In this episode, Canon Megan and Adam dive into one of the biggest theological questions out there: *what actually happens when we die?* And yes—we go there about pets, too.
From ancient Christian beliefs to how the plague reshaped everyone’s ideas about heaven and hell, we trace how our understanding of the afterlife got so complicated. Along the way, we talk about purgatory, limbo, grace, and how the church has tried (sometimes not so helpfully) to make sense of it all.
It’s a surprisingly compassionate conversation that reminds us theology isn’t about fear—it’s about love, hope, and trust in a God who isn’t finished with us yet.
What You’ll Walk Away With:
* The question “do animals go to heaven?” has been debated for centuries—and there’s no one answer.
* Classical thinkers like Thomas Aquinas said no, because animals don’t have immortal souls.
* In early Christianity, people weren’t fixated on the afterlife—the focus was on redeeming the world here and now.
* After the plague devastated Europe, people became much more concerned with individual salvation and what comes next.
* A lot of what we imagine about hell comes not from Scripture, but from Dante’s *Inferno* and Milton’s *Paradise Lost.*
* Purgatory was understood not as punishment, but as a place of growth and transformation in God’s love.
* The Episcopal Church doesn’t have a rigid stance on the afterlife, and leans into grace rather than certainty.
* There’s an important difference between theology (exploring big ideas) and doctrine (official teaching).
* Theology should be pastoral—it should help people, not scare them.
* Talking about salvation and the afterlife should always come from a place of compassion.
If you’ve ever wrestled with questions about heaven, hell, or whether your dog will greet you at the pearly gates, this one’s for you.
AI Disclosure: To support our staff in their limited time, many of our episode summaries are first generated by AI and then edited by the Communications Director to accurately reflect and preview our podcast episodes.