In this episode, I dive into the yuletide cringe-fest that is Merry Gentlemen, Netflix’s latest attempt to mix holiday cheer with rom-com clichés. Starring none other than 00’s dreamboat Chad Michael Murray and the cool rider from Grease 2. This movie has it all: improbable meet-cutes, dialogue cheesier than a fondue fountain, and enough forced holiday spirit to power a small Christmas village.

Join me as I break down the plot and lovingly observe Murray’s transformation from brooding high school heartthrob to sweater-wearing small-town charmer. Is it so bad it’s good? Tune in to find out.