If you went trick-or-treating today, would your favorite 90s candy still make it into your pumpkin pail — or is it haunting the candy cemetery? In this sweet and spooky minisode, Michael digs up some long-lost treats from the decade of neon and Nickelodeon, including the Nestlé Quik Bar, Ouch! Bubble Gum, Butterfinger BB’s, Fruit String Thing, and more. Grab your flashlights and your sweet tooth — we’re unwrapping memories, one discontinued candy at a time.

🕯️ Because not every 90s snack had a happy ending.