On February 5, 2015 members of the Tice Fire Department and Central District Deputies responded to a trailer fire located  in the Tice area of Fort Myers. Fire Department personnel met with the complainant Peter Matthew Albritton, who resided in the trailer with Donna Chatterton. Albritton claimed Chatterton was not in the trailer when he returned home earlier nor could he confirm if she was in the trailer when the fire occurred.

 
On February 6, 2015 Central District Deputies responded to the residence of Diane Bisram who requested to file a missing person’s report for her daughter Donna Chatterton. Bisram was obviously concerned for the safety of Donna following the fire at her residence. Deputies completed a preliminary report and entered Chatterton as a missing person.

This is Seeking Closure: Episode 4 -  Where's Donna?