Ralph McCollister joins the show to discuss his opinion column which addresses a political dispute between former Baton Rouge Mayor Sharon Weston Broome and current Mayor-elect Sid Edwards, centered on the financial and political fallout from the incorporation of the City of St. George. Broome recently criticized Edwards for blaming her administration for the city’s budget issues, calling his claims “categorically false.” McCollister challenges Broome’s narrative, arguing that her past actions as a state senator—particularly her opposition to the creation of an independent school district in Southeast Baton Rouge—contributed to the current situation.
He asserts that Broome’s resistance led parents to push for city incorporation, mirroring past efforts in Central, Zachary, and Baker.McCollister accuses Broome of ignoring historical context and failing to lead effectively, especially in managing city finances and surrounding herself with competent advisors. He contends that her administration’s spending and political decisions exacerbated the current crisis, which Edwards now inherits. The conversation also touches on broader governance issues, including the challenges of the consolidated city-parish government, underfunding of the District Attorney’s office, and the need for equitable contributions from all cities within East Baton Rouge Parish.
The discussion concludes with concerns about fragmentation, governance inefficiencies, and the need for reform. McCollister advocates for collaborative leadership, historical awareness, and implementation of best practices from other cities. He emphasizes that without unity and action, Baton Rouge risks further decline in public services, safety, and population. The column ultimately serves as a call to acknowledge past missteps and work toward a more functional and inclusive future for the region.