Sunday's Sermon
1 Peter 2:9
“A Distinction with a Difference” Series: “Do You Count?” August 25, 2019
The Susan B. Anthony dollar coin was minted by the United States Department of Treasury in 1991 as a replacement for what they thought was the more cumbersome and therefore underutilized Eisenhower coin. Their reasoning was that the American public would jump all over the more manageable Anthony coin and begin using it instead of having to pull out dollar bills from their purses or wallets. It was instead a big bust, one of the biggest busts in the history of the U.S. Mint. The public refused to embrace the dollar coin, but not so much because of its metallic content or its odd eleven-sided edge, or even because it bore the likeness of a woman who was a social activist in her day, a century earlier. The overwhelming majority of American consumers refused to use the Susan B. Anthony dollar mainly because it just looked too much like a quarter. It was a distinct coin; but it wasn’t distinct enough to make a difference. You might have thought you were giving someone a quarter, when in fact, you were forking over to them a coin that carried a much larger value. I think you see the problem. It was just too confusing.
When I think about how we Christians today are, generally speaking, less respected and considered less relevant than our tribe was in past years, I wonder if it’s not for similar reasons. Yes, we are in so many ways distinct from those around us who do not claim to follow Jesus. We forego certain behaviors. We support certain causes. We spend our time on Sundays in a place like this instead of some other place. I could preach a sermon series on the distinctions (and at some point in my ministry, I probably have). But in spite of all of these distinctions, at the end of the day we fail to make a real difference. We fail to “move the needle” as far as our society goes, and more times than not, we are influenced more by our prevailing culture than we are able to exert upon it.
None of this, of course, is what God intended when He sent His Son to redeem us. When God sent Jesus to form a people unto Himself, God’s intent was that we, in the words of Peter in his first epistle, “declare the praises of Him who called you out of darkness into His wonderful light.”
This morning we have before us this verse of Scripture from 1 Peter. Peter is a name familiar to you if you’ve spent a day of your life in Sunday School. He was one of Jesus’ closest disciples. He was the one disciple who after the resurrection was instructed by Jesus to “feed my sheep” (John 21:15-19).
This letter represents Simon Peter’s efforts to show obedience to Jesus’ command. Written later in Peter’s life, this first letter is taken up with important words of instructions Peter gives to new Christians, believers who have come to faith in Jesus Christ out of a pagan Roman setting. They’re Gentiles, not Jews. They’ve never been instructed in the ways of Abraham, Moses, David, or the prophets. They’ve been brought up instead with names like Jupiter, Minerva, Venus, and Mercury. But Peter, of course, was Jewish, and was therefore brought up with the belief that God had always had a people who would be about His business in this world. Thus Peter saw the need to help these new Christians comprehend both the privilege and the responsibility of what remarkable salvation God had made possible for them through Jesus Christ.
Drawing upon Old Testament passages in Exodus (19:6) and Malachi (3:17), Peter impresses upon his readers that they, too, are special people in God’s sight. Note the words Peter uses and imagine how these words would have swelled the souls of those new believers, who were no doubt being ostracized and ridiculed for their newfound faith in Jesus. “You are a chosen people. You are a royal priesthood. You are a holy nation. You are God’s special possession.” How these words must have come as a breath of fresh air after all the invectives and insults that had been hurled against them by the prevailing culture.
But note as well how Peter leverages this litany of acclamation to inspire these new believers to make something out of their distinct calling. “Yes, you are special. But God has set you apart so that you may declare His praises to your neighbors because of the changes He has brought about by bringing you out of your old darkness into the marvelous light in which you are now living.” What Peter wants his readers to understand and embrace is that their life is now marked just as much by responsibility as it is privilege. Their distinction is for a difference, that difference being their faithful service in representing God’s presence and extending God’s mercy in every place in their world where God might choose to put them.
Come to think of it, that’s also what God expects of us, is it not? You and I must, in the same way, take seriously our responsibility to illumine, as it were, the places we live, work, study, and play, with the light of Jesus Christ; for if we do not, who then will?
This is a delicate subject, but I’m going to go there anyway. Let’s think about tattoos for a moment. Some twenty-five years ago, when I left the Huntsville area to assume the pastorate of a church in Tallahassee, Florida, there was a lot I wasn’t prepared for. Tallahassee was a different culture; it had a different “vibe,” if you please, from anything I had ever known. One difference was the number of people who sported tattoos, not the henna-type wannabe tattoos. I’m talking about the real thing – with needles and dyes and side street shops in the shady side of town.
I remember thinking to myself, “What makes a person go through such a painful experience?” My assumption was that those persons with tattoos just wanted to be different. It was a novelty (though that certainly is not the case any longer, at least not in the Florida Panhandle). I figured that most of them had made an impulsive decision that they’d probably later regret. (Indeed, the statistics say that a quarter of Americans who get tattooed will later have it surgically removed. If you’re looking for an investment opportunity, then that might be a good one.) That was my assumption, and it was not entirely correct.
I learned that for some people a tattoo was their way of declaring something to the world – something personally important and purposeful. Certainly, I ran across more than my share of people who were just acting out with their tattoo or trying to prove their bravado. But just as often I’d come across someone who saw their tattoo as a means of remembering something significant or commemorating something transformative. I met people who saw their tattoos as a way of expressing control over their bodies after having suffered some form of assault or trauma. I met people whose tattoos even served as a kind of visual timeline for life-changing events. I discovered that for many their tattoo had become a means by which they could express themselves and their stories, not just in a different way, but also in a distinct one.
Now, you can rest easy, parents. I’m not suggesting that you should allow your children to run down to the local tattoo parlor on the Southside and come back with their bodies covered in ink. Remember, my wife and I raised two children during our days in the Panhandle, one of whom was the freest of spirits. And listen carefully, young people, especially those who parents may not be here this morning. Don’t go home and beg for permission to get a tattoo because “Dr. Dortch said it was OK.” That’s a conversation you have to have with your parents on your own merits.
But what I do want to mark your heart with this morning is a reminder of that one whom I trust you have met who laid bare his holy arm and was pierced for our transgressions and bruised for our iniquities, that one who on Calvary’s cross took up our infirmities and carried all our sorrows, that one whom on the third day God raised from the dead to a place of power and glory so that through our faith in him we have been called out of darkness into God’s marvelous light.
God has called each of us to a place where He wants us at this time. Our task is in those places to display not just the different but the distinct mark of a Christian whose life is a shining example of something that can only be explained in terms of God. Otherwise, our life and our witness aren’t worth a plugged nickel, much less a Susan B. Anthony dollar. But when we are faithful, Christ’s light shines in the darkness and the darkness, no matter how great, will be turned into God’s new day.
1 Peter 2:9