It's time to pack our bags and head to Vegas! Reynolds and Shawn are going to battle head to head with our guest judge, Alex Metz deciding if we should re-watch this 90's classic!

It's time for our very first re-trial! After all the backlash we received for our trial of "Hook" we thought it was only fair to give it a second go. And to help us along, we brought a guest DEFENSE! George Chammas is here to tell us why Hook should be a re-watch. But what will the verdict actually be?? Shawn as the judge. Reynolds as the prosecution.

Not to be confused with Failure to Lunch. Today we are going after a 2006 rom-com that most people seem to have completely forgotten about. Terry Bradshaw? Kathy Bates? Bradley Cooper? What IS this movie?? Shawn as the judge. Pilson as the prosecution. Reynolds as the defense.

The boys are back with a movie that most people probably forgot existed. The 2000 movie reboot of the classic television show, Charlie's Angels! Reynolds as the judge. Pilson as the defense. Shawn as the prosecution.

It's time for our very first Bond movie! We figured it was best to talk about a 90's bond film with tons of nostalgia due to it spawning one of the most popular N64 video games of all time! But does the movie hold on? Our special guest Nate Caywood helps us! Shawn as the judge. Pilson as the prosecution. Reynolds as the judge.

How well do you really remember the movie Signs? It's time to find out if this movie holds up with our special guest witness Miles Crosman! Shawn as the judge. Pilson as the defense. Reynolds as the prosecution.

Somebody stop us!! It's time we put another Jim Carey classic on trial! This week we are doing THE MASK with our special guest witness Jon Salmon. Reynolds as the judge. Shawn as the prosecution. Pilson as the defense.

Hold your horses. It's time to bring our horse expert Isabelle Bright to put the 2003 film "Seabiscuit" on trial. Pilson as the judge. Reynolds as the prosecution. Shawn as the defense.

Bigger boat. Bigger wave. We are starting the new year off right with a classic New Years Eve movie featuring...Fergie? And we can only do this movie with the help of our special guest witness, Brandon Baker. Shawn as the judge. Reynolds as the defense. Pilson as the prosecution.

Our holiday festivities continue with Adam Sandler's "Eight Crazy Nights." A Jewish Witness. A Jewish Judge. Shawn Prosecutes. Reynolds defense. What could go wrong?