"Wherefore art thou Romeo!??" Today we are tackling the 90's Shakespearean retelling of ROMEO + JULIET with the help of our special guest witness, Eric Peterson. Shawn as the judge. Pilson as the defense. Reynolds as the prosecution.

Danger! Danger! Danger! Today we are tackling a movie that most likely takes place inside of the Friends universe, "LOST IN SPACE" with the help of our special guest witness Alex Galbate! Reynolds as the judge. Shawn as the defense. Pilson as the prosecution.

Who is the sexiest slasher?? There's only one way to find out. By listening to this episode of Movies on Trial where we bring 2003's "The Texas Chainsaw Massacre" to the stand with the help of our resident slasher witness Jess Defanti! Pilson as the judge. Shawn as the prosecution. Reynolds as the defense.

Jackie Chan! Owen Wilson! Walton Goggins??? It's time to put this classic buddy comedy film on trial! Today we tackle Shanghai Noon with our special guest witness Trey Callaway. Pilson as the judge. Shawn as the defense. Reynolds as the prosecution.

Get your head in the game everybody! It's time to go back to the Disney Channel! Today we are putting "High School Musical" on trial with the help of our special guest witness Branson Nejame. And yes, he brings his keyboard. And yes, there will be singing in this episode. This episode brought to you by mashed potatoes. Reynolds as the judge. Shawn as the prosecution. Pilson as the defense. We're all in this together.

A thrilling movie becomes an even more thrilling trial!! Today we are tackling the classic mystery of "Identity" with the help of our witness, Steve Rommevaux.

In honor of the release of Freakier Friday, we are tackling the original Jamie Lee Curtis and Lindsay Lohan classic, Freaky Friday with the help of our special guest witness, Isabel Galupo! Shawn as the judge. Pilson as the prosecution. Reynolds as the defense.

It's time for a wicked awesome episode. Today we are putting the classic adventure film, The Perfect Storm on trial with our local Massachusetts native, Sean Brogan! Reynolds as the judge. Shawn as the defense. Pilson as the prosecution.

Get ready for a (healthy?) dose of Darren Aronofsky. Today we are tackling "The Fountain" with our special guest witness, editor Steve Markowitz. As expected, things will become UNHINGED. Pilson as the judge. Reynolds as the defense. Shawn as the prosecution.

Here we go. Our first movie musical...? The music of The Beatles mixed with a small amount of plot and sprinkled with a little bit of Bono. What's not to love? Find out for yourself. With our special guest witness Danny Gendron. Pilson as the judge. Shawn as the defense. Reynolds as the prosecution.