Well, the 1880’s finally has some visual media coverage. That’s the good news.
I do think it was an enjoyable series. I’m at a bit of a disadvantage being a history podcaster, as “suspension of disbelief” is kind of contrary to the mission of educating about details of history. But it is enjoyable, especially the acting performance of Matthew Macfayden.
-No, Blaine didn’t speak to Conkling casually. They did not speak.
–Blaine, Grant and Sherman were not present at the 1880 convention. Blaine was monitoring by telegraph close by, which was an endless source of material for Conkling (which would have been accurate and entertaining/funny to include).
–Arthur did not offer to resign as Vice President. If he did, it would not be up to Garfield to “accept it” he’d give that to Blaine as Secretary of State, and his letter would be the only step, as a Constitutional officer. But it didn’t happen, so why discuss, right?
-Arthur did not storm out of Conkling’s carriage.
-Arthur was not at the President’s bedside.
-Arthur did not refuse to break the deadlock as Vice President, he did break it, in his first days, casting 3 tie votes to organize the Senate.
– After that, the Senate appointed a pro tempore President and made a deal with a Virginia Independent Senator and there was no deadlock.
-Garfield did not meet Guiteau.
-Arthur did meet Guiteau, or rather, Guiteau forced himself on him. And he did give him a speaking assignment in NYC as 1880 New York campaign manager. This was common for newcomers, it was one of hundreds of little speech slots that party faithful would do. His was not good and lasted a few minutes. He did not get him into parties or drink with him.
-Blaine did not meet Guiteau at his house or the park, rather he threw him out of the State Department.
-Chauncey Depew did not replace Conkling in the Senate. elbridge Lapham did.
– More importantly, the resign plan was not Conkling’s idea. It was Platt. He wanted away out of his predicament of having to vote for Robertson as collector. He convinced Conkling, who then thought it was a good idea. Show presents it other way around.
-Conkling continued to see Kate Sprague (nee Chase) well into Arthur’s Presidency. The showdown moment with the wife in Albany did not happen. Politics, a split among the Stalwarts, not a metoo moment drove Conkling’s downfall in the Senate vote.
-A little too much “cussing” if you ask me. I’m sure though in a few moments these guys did use these words, but not this much.
Despite all this, yes you should watch.
*This would have been better to tell the accurate story- more entertaining.
The University of Aberdeen:
https://on.abdn.ac.uk/online-history-courses/