It was 5 years ago this month that the first episode of Mystery Movie Night came out. 50 episodes later, Michael, Dave, David, Erik, and Evan are still making connections between movies: this time about pirates, privates, and puddle-booted primates. And there's a special announcement about the future of the show.

00:02:15 - Review of Treasure Island (1950) 00:15:40 - Review of Kelly's Heroes (1970) 00:32:46 - Review of Dora and the Lost City of Gold (2019) 00:50:22 - Guessing the Connection

David, Erik, Evan, Michael, and Dave talk about feelings, firearms, and fleet feet and the secret that connects them.

Dave, David, Erik, Evan, and Michael converse about cavemen, claw hands, and Cliffjumper and the cryptic component that connects them.

00:02:09 - Review of Halloween (1978) 00:16:29 - Review of Brazil (1985) 00:29:26 - Review of Planes, Trains & Automobiles (1987) 00:52:33 - Guessing the Connection

Evan picked the movies; Michael, Dave, David, and Erik tried to guess the secret connection. See if you can too in this episode about tipis, tap dance, and towels.

It'll take the detective skills of Batman, the persistence of RoboCop, and the endurance of a Terminator to figure out the connection in this episode. Join David, Erik, Evan, Michael, and Dave for sensational repartee about sinister riddles, savage robots, and sassy ragamuffins. 00:01:28 - Review of Batman (1966) 00:15:34 - Review of RoboCop (1987) 00:26:09 - Terminator 2: Judgment Day (1991) 00:46:38 - Guessing the Connection

Dave, David, Erik, Evan, and Michael muse about metal, machines, and metahumans and the mysterious matter that melds them together.

00:02:12 - Review of This Is Spinal Tap 00:19:28 - Review of Maximum Overdrive 00:31:01 - Review of Mystery Men 00:45:59 - Guessing the Connection

Erik picks some creepy house movies that also have another, mysterious connection. We got clowns, cul-de-sacs, and cameos in this episode. 00:01:45 - Review of Poltergeist (1982) 00:21:28 - Review of The 'Burbs (1989) 00:33:20 - Review of Casper (1995) 00:53:03 - Guessing the Connection

Michael, Dave, David, Erik, and Evan muse about manipulation, money, and manuscripts, but mostly... murder! 00:02:01 - Review of Gaslight (1944) 00:15:24 - Review of Dial M for Murder (1954) 00:32:22 - Review of Deathtrap (1982) 00:48:33 - Guessing the Connection

Evan, Dave, David, Michael, and Erik are joined by blogger and podcaster extraordinaire Siskoid to pontificate on paper cuts, police detectives, postage stamps, and what could possibly connect them. 00:02:56 - Review of 36 Hours (1964) 00:19:36 - Review of Dark City (1998) 00:36:01 - Review of Paycheck (2003) 00:54:46 - Guessing the Connection