Was Nero really a disaster from day one? In this episode, Lucas and Luna explore the controversial 'Quinquennium Neronis' — the first five years of Nero's reign, which ancient sources like Trajan and Aurelius Victor praised as a golden age. They delve into the roles of Seneca and Burrus, the reform of the permanent courts (quaestiones perpetuae), the suppression of forgery, the crackdown on corrupt governors, and the Emperor Claudius's poison mushroom. They also examine the shift from the Stoic ideal of the philosopher-king to the tyranny of the artist-emperor, and the lingering question: was the early promise real or just the work of capable ministers? Along the way, they discuss the Piso conspiracy, the Praetorian Guard, Tacitus, Suetonius, and Cassius Dio, and how the burning of Rome and the construction of the Golden House transformed Nero from a beloved ruler into a monster. A nuanced look at one of history's greatest what-ifs.