In 1983, four-year-old Nyleen Kay Marshall was playing with other children during a family outing in the Helena National Forest when she vanished without a trace. Despite an immediate search, no clues were found until years later, when anonymous letters and phone calls began arriving, claiming Nyleen was alive and living with her abductor. Were they cruel hoaxes or genuine messages from the person who took her?

Thanks for listening to Threads of Truth, where real-life mysteries meet internet speculation.