Oakland

Oakland

By CivicFMGovernment
Download on the App Store

All Oakland episodes

  • 911 outage questions, ShotSpotter advances, contractors' pay disputed

    The Public Safety Committee heard how cut lines left 911 calls unanswered for 69 minutes in October and sent ShotSpotter's reports and policy changes to the council. Business groups also disputed the city's 96% on-time payment figure.

    Life Enrichment Committee, Tuesday, November 17

    • $800,000 more for substitute teachers in the city's Head Start program (ChildCare Careers, LLC) (00:10:12)
      • City staff said the item raises the contract by $800,000 for its final year. (00:11:09)
      • City staff said the division is opening a new five-year request for proposals to find more vendors, and that the root problem is the need to hire and pay staff properly so the program depends less on substitutes. (00:11:09)
      • City staff said the amendment lets the program meet community care licensing, state and federal rules and keep its doors open while the root causes are addressed. (00:11:09)
      • City staff said the funding is already identified and no new money is requested or appropriated. (00:12:17)
      • A councilmember asked staff to explain for the public why this is the third waiver and why the small local business competitive bidding requirement was waived. (00:16:49)
      • City staff said the waiver was removed from this amendment, and that the original contract had one because there were no qualified bidders then. (00:17:15)
      • City staff said no small local business could meet the background check, health, credential and training requirements at the time, and that the new request for proposals includes outreach with that priority in mind. (00:17:15)
      • A councilmember asked for the current vacancy rate in the Head Start program. (00:18:25)
      • City staff said 24 teaching positions at different levels are vacant today. (00:18:34)
      • City staff said long-serving teachers are retiring faster than they can be replaced, and the city isn't competitive in a region with a teacher shortage. (00:18:51)
      • City staff said applicants are turning down job offers because the pay is too low. (00:18:51)
      • A councilmember asked whether the HR requisition process was the problem, and staff said it was not. (00:19:25)
      • City staff said the problem is a lack of interest at the wage the city pays. (00:19:43)
      • A councilmember said the city should fix the pay problem, and seconded the motion. (00:19:48)
      • The committee chair responded to a public speaker's concern about the requirements, saying that as a former registered child care provider she knows how important full training is for people who care for children. (00:19:52)
      • The committee chair noted that the federal government has cut resources, and asked what the city's long-term plan is to address funding and offer competitive pay. (00:20:53)
      • City staff said the program has been on an under-enrollment plan since 2024 and has used mechanisms in the labor agreement, such as premium pay for higher permits, to raise teacher pay. (00:21:30)
      • City staff said a 2024 change-in-scope request to the federal Office of Head Start, which included a plan to address teacher pay, sat with federal officials for over a year, and the program then lost the funding the plan needed. (00:22:31)
      • City staff said the pay gap was not addressed in labor negotiations, that a 2024 wage compensation study is included in the report, and that, as staff understand it, the council has authority to adjust pay for certain job classifications. (00:22:31)
      • The committee chair asked whether the council could take this up in the coming budget cycle. (00:23:38)
      • City staff said pay could be discussed in the budget, that other Head Start programs face the same problem, and that a coalition is looking at local workforce dollars to help recruit Head Start staff. (00:23:50)
      • City staff said the program hires fully qualified staff and has Oakland Children's Initiative funding for a new pathway that brings teachers in through an online CDA credential program while they finish their degrees. (00:24:38)
      • The committee chair said she would like to move away from outsourcing, and cited the staff report as saying the city pays the contractor $38 to $46 an hour for substitutes. (00:25:38)
      • City staff clarified that the $38 to $46 an hour is what the city pays the company. (00:25:55)
      • The committee chair asked what the contractor pays its workers and, when staff said the company has declined to share that, questioned that it won't say what it pays the workers the city is ultimately paying for. (00:25:58)
      • City staff said the contract ends June 30, 2027. (00:26:14)
      • Documents: Agenda

        Finance and Management Committee, Tuesday, November 17

        • How well the city pays its contractors on time (00:53:38)
          • The committee chair said she brought the report because many city contractors, including small businesses and nonprofits, are not paid on time (00:53:48)
          • The committee chair said the reported compliance rate of over 90% doesn't match what she hears on the ground (00:53:48)
          • Bradley Johnson (Director of Finance) said average compliance over the last three or four years is 96% and that the policy applies to Oakland vendors (00:55:37)
          • Bradley Johnson (Director of Finance) said much of the delay vendors experience comes from work starting before a contract exists, which falls outside the prompt payment timelines (00:55:37)
          • A councilmember said his office has been working with the city administration on contracting and prompt payment reform and will bring legislation (01:16:11)
          • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) said her office spent months of her first year in office tracking down payments for small businesses and nonprofits (01:16:33)
          • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked who has taken over the work an assistant city administrator who has since left had been leading (01:17:35)
          • City staff said another assistant city administrator will lead the city's Disparity Study response, supported by an interim department director (01:18:17)
          • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked why late-payment interest payments rose sharply after 2022, when there were 167 (01:19:36)
          • City staff said finance sees no clear data-driven reason for the swings and could only speculate about staff turnover or contract cycles (01:19:54)
          • City staff said the city's financial system has no comprehensive contract management to track subcontractors, and that finance is working on electronic checks to cut delays (01:21:06)
          • City staff said the administration is exploring a system that can track payments to subcontractors in the small and local business program (01:22:03)
          • City staff said the report has no comparisons with other jurisdictions and offered to look into them (01:22:40)
          • The committee chair said she would move to hold the item in committee because much more work remains, and asked for coordination with her office on legislation (01:22:55)
          • A councilmember called for a work plan to fix the problems public speakers raised, and said a requested breakdown of payments to disadvantaged businesses was missing (01:24:17)
          • A councilmember asked how capital improvement projects can have a 54% compliance rate yet only about $29,000 in interest penalties (01:25:20)
          • City staff suggested many capital payments may run only a day or two late, which drives noncompliance without much interest, though he wasn't sure (01:26:32)
          • City staff agreed to break down the list of noncompliant vendors by local, small local, and other businesses in the next supplemental report (01:27:32)
          • Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee) asked whether the city should be responsible for subcontractors being paid promptly or should put that duty on prime contractors (01:27:48)
          • City staff recommended exploring changes to contract templates and rules to require primes to pay subcontractors, with a way to track their compliance (01:28:09)
          • Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee) raised vendors who start work without a signed contract or don't understand how to get paid (01:28:57)
          • City staff said departments directing work without a contract is unacceptable, puts the city and vendors at risk, and is being stopped (01:29:28)
          • City staff said the city needs to make it easier for vendors to get under contract, including simpler insurance requirements and fewer separate forms to sign (01:30:24)
          • A councilmember spoke during the special meeting, drawing on experience as a contractor to say primes should be required to pay subcontractors within fifteen to twenty days, and that some subcontractors waited a year to be paid (01:31:59)
          • The committee chair asked the update to cover what the administration and finance are doing to manage compliance now, including software purchases (01:34:21)
          • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked for the legislative timeline and implementation as part of the update (01:34:53)
          • Update on city-owned parking garages (00:11:29)
            • City staff reported that garage revenues remain about 17% below pre-pandemic levels and that citation revenue is only a small share of garage revenue (00:11:55)
            • City staff said staff recommends returning to a gated system, estimated at about $1.5 million in one-time capital costs for the six garages plus about $1.12 million a year for attendants (00:12:57)
            • The committee chair said she was very concerned that the city doesn't make money off its garages, though Oakland isn't alone in that (00:14:27)
            • City staff estimated that a gated system could bring in $2 million to $3 million more a year in gross revenue, assuming full compliance and pre-pandemic usage (00:16:57)
            • City staff said the garages netted roughly $880,000 on about $8.5 million gross last fiscal year, and that after the gating and staffing costs the added net would be about $1 million or less (00:17:23)
            • The committee chair complained that garages are closed on key dates, including weekends, citing a closed garage during the Black Joy Parade, and asked when staff would bring specific budget requests (00:19:19)
            • City staff said the city is issuing a request for proposals for a long-term operator contract and expects it to be done within the next year (00:19:59)
            • City staff said staff plans to put options for each garage, with their funding, into a budget proposal for the council's biennial budget, and to extend the current contract a calendar year to allow the transition (00:21:11)
            • City staff noted that the garages need significant capital investment and life-safety work if the city keeps operating them (00:22:18)
            • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) recommended making license plate readers one of the deferred-maintenance priorities so non-payers are caught (00:23:59)
            • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked staff to look at what a full-day rate goes for in Bay Area garages, since not all city garages have a daily rate (00:24:42)
            • City staff said most garage rates haven't been updated in several years, and that staff plans a market analysis and fee update in this year's master fee schedule amendment (00:25:33)
            • City staff said the city already uses automatic license plate readers but they work poorly inside enclosed concrete garages (00:25:33)
            • A councilmember asked whether the city is behind on paying the garage operator, and whether the money owed is already budgeted (00:26:49)
            • City staff said the operator has been paid through the end of July and staff is finalizing the steps to issue the pending check (00:26:29)
            • City staff said the city has budget authority but needs the contract extension on the next item for contract authority to cut checks (00:27:03)
            • A councilmember noted that a couple of garages stood out for losing revenue in an earlier report, and asked why the city doesn't simply use gates (00:27:32)
            • City staff explained that gates are the surest way to make everyone pay but cost more to run because of attendant staff, and that staff is also looking at systems that read every plate on entry and exit, chosen garage by garage (00:28:49)
            • A councilmember asked why EV chargers installed in many garages are not working (00:30:49)
            • City staff said the city is contractually obligated to provide EV charging in various garages, that he hadn't known they weren't working, and that he would look into it (00:31:12)
            • City staff said the current timeline would bring a recommendation for a new vendor to the committee around March, in the spring (00:32:37)
            • The committee chair asked whether WiFi problems at the Dalzell and City Center West garages have been fixed so that citations can be issued (00:32:59)
            • City staff said connectivity is being worked on inside the city as a safety issue, whichever vendor operates the garages (00:34:33)
            • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) pointed to EV chargers at what she believed was the 12th Street garage, financed by an outside energy provider, as a model to expand to other garages (00:39:12)
            • One-year extension of the parking garage operator contract (00:40:10)
              • City staff said the original agreement dates to 2014 and, after three extensions, expires December 31, 2026 (00:40:54)
              • City staff said the amendment adds one year with no change to the current payment rate while the city completes its request for proposals (00:41:56)
              • The committee chair said she would support the extension even though a couple of months ago she wanted the contract to end this year, because a thorough procurement takes time (00:42:09)
              • The committee chair asked staff to work with the current operator during the extension on enforcement, access, and safety capital improvements (00:42:09)
              • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) urged that easier maintenance and garage upgrades go ahead during the procurement rather than pause (00:42:53)
              • City staff said staff is looking for prior-year savings to carry forward for repairs and won't wait for a new contract to start needed improvements (00:43:34)
              • A councilmember pointed to several lots that showed zero revenue in the earlier report and asked that they be fixed (00:44:29)
              • City staff explained that some lots were donated on the condition that parking stays free for commuters, and that others collect through parking meters, so that money is counted as meter revenue rather than garage revenue (00:45:09)
              • City staff said City of Oakland Parking Partners is a joint venture of two companies, and that the city got its partnership filings (00:52:15)
              • The committee chair noted that rate changes to draw more volume have been considered over the years (00:52:49)
              • Documents: Agenda

                Community and Economic Development Committee, Tuesday, November 17

                • Oakport Field license with Oakland United and regional park zoning designation (01:16:41)
                  • City staff said the parks department has few playable athletic fields and decided in 2024 to put out a request for proposals for Oakport Field, then conditionally awarded it in 2025 to the Oakland Soccer Club, now under Oakland United. (01:17:57)
                  • City staff described the site as two fields in poor condition, with a rundown fence and bathroom, behind the EBMUD facility near the Coliseum. (01:19:19)
                  • City staff said the license covers only the athletic fields, not the surrounding wetlands or trail. (01:19:19)
                  • City staff said the Parks and Recreation Advisory Commission voted on October 14 to support the license agreement. (01:20:31)
                  • City staff said the field would have to be available for free public use at least 55% of the time, through drop-in play, free youth programs, or the city's own allotment. (01:21:40)
                  • City staff said an advisory council with a city seat and an unaffiliated community member would inform the access policy, which the city must approve. (01:21:40)
                  • City staff said fees would be set in the city's master fee schedule and the city could take back scheduling if the operator breaches the agreement. (01:22:41)
                  • City staff said sponsorship and advertising revenue would first pay off an initial capital project of about $4 million, after which the city gets 15% and the rest goes back into the field. (01:23:41)
                  • City staff said the deal would bring in a little over $9 million in private capital over the term, and that the low rent reflects these in-kind benefits rather than a market rate. (01:24:46)
                  • City staff said the area's open space zoning never received a required category, that the advisory commission recommended the regional-serving park designation the previous night, and that the change keeps existing uses as they are. (01:24:46)
                  • The committee chair asked which community organizations Oakland United works with and who would have access to the field. (01:26:40)
                  • A guest presenter said Oakland United serves as the infrastructure backbone of a coalition of more than 40 free or affordable youth sports programs serving over 27,000 youth. (01:27:25)
                  • A guest presenter said the group spent more than a year engaging existing users, local programs, and schools around Oakport. (01:28:30)
                  • A guest presenter said some program partners who wanted to speak on Zoom couldn't register because of an error. (01:29:34)
                  • A guest presenter said Oakland United has raised over $7 million in five-year commitments, mostly from individual philanthropy, and is fiscally sponsored while it waits for IRS nonprofit status. (01:30:34)
                  • A guest presenter said the group is applying for a State Parks Program grant together with supplybank.org, which is doing shoreline restoration nearby. (01:31:58)
                  • Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) called the project an opportunity for East Oakland and asked how other youth soccer groups would get to use the field. (01:32:37)
                  • A guest presenter said Oakland United won't field its own teams, and that the field would be a multi-sport surface lined for several sports. (01:33:41)
                  • A guest presenter said spectator seating is still being decided through community engagement, possibly with movable bleachers. (01:35:30)
                  • A councilmember's aide conveyed Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7)'s support for both ordinances on his behalf. (01:36:35)
                  • City staff confirmed that each of the two ordinances requires two readings at the council. (01:36:50)
                  • Documents: Agenda

                    Public Works and Transportation Committee, Tuesday, November 17

                    • $15.2 million construction contract for Embarcadero West rail safety, Phase 1 (00:25:40)
                      • City staff said about 65 trains use the corridor each day and incidents are reported about once every five days (00:26:27)
                      • City staff said the project modernizes the Market Street and Oak Street crossings with new gate arms and high-visibility crosswalks (00:26:27)
                      • City staff said the upgraded overweight-truck route will eliminate the current overweight route on 7th Street through West Oakland (00:27:33)
                      • City staff said the project adds protected bike lanes on Embarcadero West between Oak and Alice Streets, and on Oak Street (00:27:33)
                      • City staff said construction would start in spring 2027 and finish in 2029, and that state Trade Corridor Enhancement Program grants fully fund the project (00:28:38)
                      • City staff said the city received five bids, and after local-business bid discounts the Oakland-based O.C. Jones came in about 35 percent below the engineer's estimate (00:29:40)
                      • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) asked where the money would come from if change orders reached the full 25 percent, and whether it would take funds from other city projects (00:30:05)
                      • City staff said change orders would also be paid entirely from state grants, so no other city project would lose money (00:31:52)
                      • Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) said the project is in District 2 and District 3, and asked whether staff had worked with the Port and rail stakeholders so the bike lanes don't conflict with freight traffic (00:32:12)
                      • City staff said staff coordinated with the Port of Oakland, Union Pacific and the California Public Utilities Commission, and the designs let vehicles and emergency vehicles get through (00:33:22)
                      • Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) relayed concerns from a dialysis center and from wheelchair users that the area needs an ADA-accessible loading zone (00:34:35)
                      • City staff said that area is covered by a separate project, the 2nd Street Transportation Hub, which adds paratransit and accessible passenger loading and new curb ramps on 2nd Street between Harrison and Alice (00:35:39)
                      • A councilmember asked about the role of the Bay Conservation and Development Commission (BCDC) and where the Bay Trail connection would lead (00:36:35)
                      • City staff said the protected bike lanes connect people to the existing Bay Trail along the Water Street segment (00:36:44)
                      • A councilmember asked that some of this kind of money go to District 7 next time, citing long-underserved infrastructure there (00:41:48)
                      • Collision repair contracts for city vehicles, amended to shift money to local shops (01:04:22)
                        • City staff said the item returns after a July presentation and covers about $7 million in estimated value over three years (01:06:11)
                        • City staff said the contract used to go to a single vendor, and staff split it into multiple awards to engage more Oakland businesses (01:07:13)
                        • City staff said the July round awarded Oakland-based Quality $1,050,000 and the incumbent Moeller Brothers $1,750,000 for heavy-duty work (01:07:13)
                        • City staff said purchasing reached out to 23 more light-duty shops, 15 of them in Oakland, and 19 heavy-duty shops, 7 of them in Oakland (01:08:15)
                        • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) thanked staff for responding to the council's push for Oakland businesses, and moved to cut Ron Dupratt Ford's share from 40 to 20 percent so local participation reaches 80 percent (01:10:46)
                        • City staff said the change was doable, explaining that most of the fleet is Ford and needs a Ford dealer to calibrate driver-assist safety systems (01:11:29)
                        • City staff said they didn't expect the reduction to affect operations (01:11:29)
                        • City staff restated the amendment: Ron Dupratt Ford drops to $700,000, and that $700,000 is split equally among the remaining local businesses (01:12:33)
                        • A councilmember asked whether the work would still get done under the change, and seconded after staff said it would (01:14:11)
                        • City staff said staff will get the work done, and noted that staff and procurement are struggling with contracts and will be back often (01:13:51)
                        • Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) thanked staff for listening, noted the body shops in District 2, and stressed that the quality of service must hold (01:14:53)
                        • $1.1 million consultant to help negotiate Oakland's next garbage and recycling contracts (00:42:49)
                          • City staff recommended awarding the agreement to HF&H Consultants (00:43:32)
                          • City staff said the three franchise agreements are the largest the city enters into, with annual revenue of around $200 million (00:44:33)
                          • City staff said the city used one of two five-year extensions on the Waste Management collection contract, which now expires June 30, 2030 (00:44:33)
                          • City staff listed the city's priorities as rate affordability, transparency, a clean Oakland, state compliance, and competitive procurement (00:45:33)
                          • City staff said a review panel picked HF&H as the most qualified and lowest-cost consultant, and that it has worked for the city for more than ten years (00:46:36)
                          • City staff said subconsultant R3 Consulting Group is a certified local small business in Oakland (00:47:38)
                          • City staff argued outside help levels the playing field, because the city negotiates these deals rarely while haulers negotiate all the time (00:47:38)
                          • A councilmember asked that comments stay on the consultant hire, not the broader contracts with Waste Management or California Waste Solutions (00:49:27)
                          • A councilmember asked whether HF&H handled the prior negotiation (00:49:49)
                          • City staff said HF&H did not handle the prior negotiation, but has helped with annual rate increases, a performance evaluation of Waste Management, and hauler performance issues (00:50:21)
                          • A councilmember asked whether reducing illegal dumping would be written into the new framework, and whether the consultant had talked with councilmembers in hard-hit districts (00:51:04)
                          • City staff said the scope includes outreach to the public, to councilmembers, and to current and other service providers (00:51:41)
                          • A councilmember questioned approving the consultant before it has talked to councilmembers (00:52:05)
                          • City staff said the consultant is being hired to help define what a future franchise agreement should look like (00:52:12)
                          • City staff said starting early gives other companies time to build the infrastructure they would need to bid (00:53:25)
                          • A councilmember objected that Oakland collects a garbage franchise fee voters never approved, and asked how that money is used (00:54:38)
                          • City staff said use of the franchise fee is shown in the city's adopted budget and offered to provide that information (00:55:42)
                          • A councilmember said illegal dumping and blight have never been worse since the contract was signed, and that his own garbage bill went up to $300 (00:56:00)
                          • City staff responded that every California city they know of charges franchise fees through solid waste rates (00:57:12)
                          • Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) asked which firm advised the city in the last negotiation, and whether this firm would bring the expertise to avoid repeating past mistakes (00:58:04)
                          • City staff said they would follow up on the prior firm's name, noting that negotiation was around 2012, and that avoiding past mistakes is the intention (00:58:41)
                          • City staff said the consultant will interview other haulers about what would make them willing to bid, so the procurement is more competitive (01:00:13)
                          • Documents: Agenda

                            Public Safety Committee, Tuesday, November 17

                            • October 2026 911 system outage (01:48:27)
                              • The committee chair said she agendized the report out of concern that the way to shut down the city's 911 system has now been publicized. (01:49:00)
                              • City staff said the outage began at 8:37 PM on Wednesday, October 21, taking both 911 calls and the police dispatch system offline. (01:49:41)
                              • City staff said calls were rerouted to the Alameda County Sheriff at 9:46 PM because the usual police-fire failover failed: the cut took down both centers' 911 lines. (01:50:41)
                              • City staff said fiber was restored at 8:44 PM the next day, copper lines about 7:13 AM the following morning, and police returned to their center at about 8:30 AM Friday. (01:51:42)
                              • City staff said the public impact was 69 minutes between the lines going dark and calls being restored through the county. (01:52:43)
                              • City staff said the cut happened in the public right-of-way outside the center, is under active criminal investigation, and is widely believed to be theft. (01:54:52)
                              • City staff said there was no network backup because AT&T is the only fiber provider at the site, and 911 lines would still have depended on copper anyway. (01:55:53)
                              • City staff said the fiber ran in plastic PVC conduit that should get metal sheathing, with tamper-proof locked boxes for the copper and surveillance in the area. (01:59:01)
                              • City staff stressed that the lines are AT&T's infrastructure, so the city depends on AT&T to do the hardening. (02:00:08)
                              • City staff said medium-term wireless redundancy may carry a budget cost, and moving 911 lines off copper requires authorization from the state Office of Emergency Services. (02:03:19)
                              • The committee chair estimated about 60 calls came in during the 69-minute window and asked what happened to them. (02:05:26)
                              • City staff said those callers very likely got a busy signal, and there is no data on whether any were major incidents. (02:06:10)
                              • The committee chair asked for concrete timelines and whether AT&T is paid by the city, questioning why the city should pay for hardening. (02:06:34)
                              • City staff said budget impacts of wireless and fiber redundancy should be clearer within weeks and will go into the budget process. (02:07:32)
                              • City staff said 911 rates are set by the state utilities commission and paid by the state, though the city pays AT&T under other telecom contracts. (02:09:30)
                              • The committee chair urged staff to play hardball with AT&T given the city funding it receives. (02:09:49)
                              • City staff cautioned that the criminal investigation is open and the city attorney's office is reviewing contractual obligations, so staff should be careful in discussion. (02:10:09)
                              • City staff said the state's NextGen 911 project has been paused and no police departments have moved to it. (02:11:18)
                              • City staff said five network hub sites, including the 911 center, emergency operations center and police administration building, are candidates for hardening and a wireless overlay. (02:12:48)
                              • City staff said AT&T has given no estimated date for the hardening work. (02:15:49)
                              • A councilmember called the theft not a victimless crime and said she has asked state representatives about legislation to curb copper theft, citing dark streetlights in West Oakland. (02:16:29)
                              • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said the response went as well as it could, recounted a person arrested in June for cutting an AT&T line on Baldwin Street, and called for law and order and full prosecution. (02:18:31)
                              • The committee chair noted sheriff's dispatchers had no access to the police dispatch system and relayed calls by cell phone, and asked for a timeline on AT&T commitments, faster rerouting and long-term upgrades. (02:24:51)
                              • City staff said staff could not provide a good timeline yet given the ongoing investigation and talks with AT&T. (02:26:57)
                              • City staff speaking for the City Attorney's office, advised forwarding the report to the council as written with the information available to date. (02:28:37)
                              • ShotSpotter annual reports, continued use, and policy changes (01:28:33)
                                • City staff said the policy now formally makes every ShotSpotter alert a priority-one call, as was already the practice. (01:29:02)
                                • City staff said the policy was updated to reflect an agreement giving Oakland Housing Authority Police access to the system. (01:29:02)
                                • City staff reported about 4,600 gunshot activations in 2025, down from about 6,000 the year before, alongside fewer shootings. (01:29:02)
                                • City staff argued fast police response speeds medical care because medics do not enter a shooting scene until officers clear it. (01:30:07)
                                • City staff described a homicide where ShotSpotter combined with license plate reader data located the shooting scene and led to three suspects being arrested and charged. (01:40:58)
                                • City staff said a March 2026 review of 18 injury shootings found three never called in, with alerts arriving within 30 seconds to a minute versus about three minutes for calls. (01:42:01)
                                • A councilmember asked whether other vendors with fewer errors could replace the ShotSpotter brand, citing Chicago moving away from that brand while still reserving money for similar technology. (01:44:26)
                                • City staff said the latest one-year extension runs from September to next September, during which police will assess other vendors, adding that a radar-based option covered less area at much higher cost. (01:45:04)
                                • City staff explained that negligent discharge is the category used when casings are found but no victim or struck object, not necessarily an accidental firing. (01:46:29)
                                • Police staffing and recruiting report (00:55:13)
                                  • City staff reported current sworn field staffing at 612, professional staff at 235.5 positions, and attrition of about six officers a month. (00:56:42)
                                  • City staff said the 197th academy graduated 15 on November 6, and the 198th academy, which began August 31, has 37 recruits and graduates March 6. (00:56:42)
                                  • The committee chair asked why so many trainees dropped from an academy that started with about 40, and whether the acceptance process is the problem, noting academies are expensive. (00:59:21)
                                  • City staff said the department uses the minimum state physical standard for entry and has recognized it is not enough, so some trainees resign once they face the physical demands. (01:00:02)
                                  • City staff said other trainees failed on academic learning domains or the driving portion. (01:01:02)
                                  • City staff said the failure rate is believed to be at the industry standard but did not have the figures. (01:02:08)
                                  • The committee chair called the staffing numbers a historic low and concerning, while noting a rise in Oakland residents among recruits. (01:02:24)
                                  • City staff said academies are budgeted for up to 50 trainees, so smaller classes produce salary savings for later academies. (01:03:13)
                                  • City staff said more than 70 people came to the latest testing, 64 passed and will begin background checks December 5. (01:04:24)
                                  • City staff said trainees who fail but keep a high enough GPA are recycled into the next academy. (01:05:54)
                                  • City staff described a weekly webinar for applicants and biweekly physical agility workshops to prepare candidates. (01:06:55)
                                  • A councilmember asked whether the report's 70 sworn employees on long-term leave had changed; police staff answered that it was 71, mostly on-duty injuries. (01:09:37)
                                  • City staff explained that officers on modified duty showing little improvement after about six months are sent home to recover or begin disability retirement, in consultation with the city's risk management. (01:12:59)
                                  • City staff said 25 sworn personnel are on transitional or modified duty, in addition to those fully off work. (01:16:02)
                                  • The committee chair questioned whether early disability retirement is any cheaper for the city than keeping officers on modified duty, and said it could be discussed offline. (01:20:05)
                                  • City staff said lateral recruitment is under way, with eight applicants meeting minimum qualifications a couple of weeks ago. (01:20:32)
                                  • City staff said one Piedmont and one BART trainee also graduated but are not counted among the 15, and promised information on reimbursement from those agencies. (01:21:04)
                                  • Documents: Agenda

                                    Rules and Legislation Committee, Thursday, November 19

                                    • Labor agreements and raises for city employees scheduled for December 1 council (00:12:01)
                                      • The clerk read the urgency reason: time sensitive for the council to approve negotiated labor agreements and give staff time to implement them (00:15:41)
                                      • Added from the dais: ratifying a local emergency for El Niño winter storm season (00:32:52)
                                        • City staff requested, for the city administration, a resolution ratifying a local emergency proclamation for the El Niño event and winter storm season (00:32:52)
                                        • City staff said the resolution would ask the governor for resources and seek a presidential emergency declaration, and asked for the December 1 council agenda on consent (00:32:57)
                                        • Documents: Agenda, Agenda (2), Agenda (3)

                                          This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

                                          Report an error · This episode's page

                                          9 min
                                        • Data center pause extended; split vote on executive search contracts

                                          Oakland's City Council extended its emergency data center moratorium by ten and a half months and split five to two, with one abstention, on executive search contracts, adding seventy-five thousand dollars for one firm. Also this week, the Rules Committee sent a public divestment proposal to the Finance Committee with no date set.

                                          City Council, Tuesday, November 10

                                          • Data center moratorium: 35-day report and ten-month extension (00:07:58)
                                            • City staff explained that state law requires a 35-day report on the work done under the 45-day moratorium (00:10:16)
                                            • City staff said the 45-day moratorium was adopted October 6 and expires November 20 (00:11:20)
                                            • City staff cited other cities with data center moratoriums, including San Francisco, Gilroy, Oakley, El Monte and Richmond, and said Richmond adopted a 22.5-month extension (00:13:26)
                                            • City staff said staff is consulting utilities and regulators, including PG&E and the air quality district, with particular concern about backup generators (00:16:34)
                                            • City staff said the city plans to hire outside consultants because of the expertise this facility type requires (00:17:37)
                                            • City staff asked for the ten-month, fifteen-day extension allowed by state law, saying it would carry the work through October 5, 2027 (00:19:43)
                                            • A councilmember said two major tech companies have leased space in West Oakland and another has shown interest in a downtown site (00:20:38)
                                            • A councilmember said the moratorium is not a rejection of technology or economic growth but guardrails on the industry (00:21:39)
                                            • A councilmember objected to companies requiring officials and landlords to sign nondisclosure agreements, which keeps the public uninformed (00:22:44)
                                            • A councilmember cited public health data showing West Oakland life expectancy six to seven and a half years below the county average (00:23:46)
                                            • A councilmember asked staff for a list of land and properties available for development in Oakland (00:26:32)
                                            • A councilmember said the city pays to lease space for police and public works, citing $4 million a year near the Coliseum, while public land goes unused (00:27:33)
                                            • The council president asked staff to send the council a supplemental list of properties that might be available (00:28:28)
                                            • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked which city departments will help with the regulatory research (00:29:08)
                                            • City staff named economic development, race and equity, and information technology, plus public works and transportation (00:29:44)
                                            • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked for an implementation timeline, such as choosing consultants within 90 days (00:30:43)
                                            • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked for a report back within 30 days on the community engagement plan, regulatory research and consultant procurement (00:32:03)
                                            • City staff offered to set up regular updates with the department (00:32:26)
                                            • City staff said the project website should be updated before the end of the year (00:33:08)
                                            • A councilmember urged that the definition of a data center not end up restricting light manufacturing and industrial uses (00:33:19)
                                            • A councilmember said massive GPU farms have no place in Oakland (00:33:19)
                                            • A councilmember suggested the threshold could rest on wattage, water use, power use or square footage (00:34:22)
                                            • City staff said staff is also considering a place-based approach, allowing some facilities in some areas and not others (00:34:39)
                                            • A councilmember thanked a community group that surveyed more than 400 West Oakland residents and shared its data (00:35:18)
                                            • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said cannabis operations in his district haven't been monitored, and asked who will enforce the moratorium and regulations (00:39:13)
                                            • City staff said Planning and Building will lead enforcement and may lean on other departments such as fire (00:40:05)
                                            • Executive recruitment firm contracts extended, with $75,000 more for one firm (01:32:20)
                                              • City staff said the city will start a new request for proposals for executive search firms and temporary services (01:35:03)
                                              • A councilmember confirmed with staff that the request reflects the committee's cut from $200,000 to $75,000, then moved approval (01:35:29)
                                              • Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) said her committee no vote is why the item was on non-consent, and that she opposes any increase to the Ralph Andersen contract (01:36:03)
                                              • Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) argued the city spends too much on headhunting firms and often gets poor results (01:36:03)
                                              • Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) said HR staff can recruit in house, and objected that the firms are not local small businesses (01:37:05)
                                              • A councilmember argued the city should train and promote its own employees into leadership instead of hiring from outside (01:38:50)
                                              • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said at first he would also vote no, citing the waiver and the firms not being local (01:42:42)
                                              • City staff said the contract is needed to finish the constitutional policing recruitment and the Mayor's priority recruitment (01:43:03)
                                              • City staff apologized for the administration for not bringing the request in a timely and transparent way (01:43:50)
                                              • City staff said the Mayor wants a professional search firm to recruit the city administrator (01:44:51)
                                              • City staff said staff will return to move some of the Hawkins contract authority to Ralph Andersen at no added cost (01:44:51)
                                              • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said the assistant city administrator's explanation led him to change his vote to yes (01:46:00)
                                              • City staff said Measure EE created a new council office whose chief would likely be recruited through a search firm (01:47:28)
                                              • City staff listed the recruitments: Head Start program director, Human Services director, Constitutional Policing administrator, and Budget administrator (01:48:46)
                                              • Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) urged the same effort and money go to entry-level hiring, such as Head Start teachers she said earn barely $18 an hour (01:50:12)
                                              • Kenilworth Road subdivision: improvement agreement, encroachment permit, parcel map (01:52:27)
                                                • City staff said the project is seven single-family homes on an unimproved stretch of Kenilworth Road, first approved in 2006 (01:53:28)
                                                • City staff said the improvements include the roadway, utilities and an emergency fire access path to Devon Way (01:53:28)
                                                • City staff said the work must be done within two years, backed by surety bonds at 175% of estimated cost, totaling $552,000 (01:54:31)
                                                • Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) supported the project and noted delays from unexpected problems, including a very large mudslide (01:55:57)
                                                • Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) said the developer plans biweekly meetings with neighbors on noise, debris and dust, and her office will monitor them (01:55:57)
                                                • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said neighbors raised air-quality concerns in committee, but he would defer to the district councilmember (02:02:28)
                                                • Consent calendar, including the Garfield Park sale to OUSD (02:03:35)
                                                  • The council president said item 6.26, honoring the Public Ethics Commission, will return in December when the commission's director and chair can attend (02:07:50)
                                                  • The council president asked the city administrator to have someone help a speaker contesting a parking ticket issued during a council meeting (02:15:32)
                                                  • City staff said they would work with the speaker and the finance department on the parking citation (02:15:44)
                                                  • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) registered a no vote on the Garfield Park sale, arguing land is more valuable than money and proposing a land swap with OUSD (02:39:15)
                                                  • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) objected that the sale trades land for money going into the general fund (02:40:00)
                                                  • The council president suggested raising city–school district land questions with the Education Partnership Committee (02:40:46)
                                                  • Council announcements (02:42:58)
                                                    • A councilmember announced a virtual community conversation on homeownership, held with the Housing and Community Development Department, on Monday the 16th from 6 to 7:30 p.m. (02:43:06)
                                                    • A councilmember announced a free holiday event at the Oakland stadium on December 13, 11 a.m. to 4 p.m., with youth baseball training and toy and food giveaways (02:43:54)
                                                    • The council president congratulated Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) and Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) on their reelection (02:46:17)
                                                    • Documents: Agenda

                                                      Rules and Legislation Committee, Thursday, November 12

                                                      • Scheduling a public proposal for an 'ethical investment' policy that would bar city investments in certain companies (00:18:09)
                                                        • The committee chair read Rule 24, section four, which says the committee shall not schedule a public member's item unless they document that they asked each councilmember to sponsor it and were refused or got no answer within 48 hours, and asked the group to forward that documentation (00:23:27)
                                                        • The committee chair stressed that the rules say the committee may schedule public members' items, not that it must (00:24:42)
                                                        • A councilmember said she had questions for the finance department about the resolution but that, because Rules is a scheduling body, detailed questions didn't belong there, and that she was fine with sending it to the Finance Committee (00:46:49)
                                                        • The committee chair said this would be the last item scheduled under Rule 24, section four, and that the rules would be changed (00:47:39)
                                                        • A councilmember asked whether anyone had talked with the Finance chair about a specific date (00:47:54)
                                                        • A councilmember's staff member said the Finance chair was ill that day and couldn't be reached about the item (00:48:16)
                                                        • A councilmember said she supported sending the item to Finance and wanted to meet with the groups to learn what the city's investment policies are and where taxpayer money is invested (00:48:24)
                                                        • A councilmember said she found it contradictory that some residents ask the city to investigate its investment policy while others say residents don't want that (00:48:24)
                                                        • A councilmember said she did not want to single out one country and wanted to look more broadly at investments that run counter to the city's values (00:48:24)
                                                        • The committee chair laid out two options, keeping the item pending in Rules or placing it pending in Finance, and noted that acting on it would mean the committee considered the Rule 24 requirements met (00:50:12)
                                                        • A councilmember said she needed to go through the legislation with the organizations and also wanted to hear from the opposing organizations (00:50:41)
                                                        • A councilmember seconded the motion, adding that members should make sure to connect with the Finance chair so the item gets scheduled there (00:52:36)
                                                        • Confirming the mayor's appointment to the City Planning Commission (00:11:43)
                                                          • The committee chair said the committee would take item five first and cut public speaking time to one minute, explaining that he had to leave by 11:20 to pick up a family member from the hospital and the committee would then lose its quorum (00:11:06)
                                                          • City staff said, for the mayor's office, that the mayor was excited to make the appointment and had coordinated it with the council president's office (00:12:10)
                                                          • City staff described the nominee, for the mayor's office, as someone with a diverse range of experience who is eager to serve (00:12:10)
                                                          • Changes to upcoming committee agendas and pending lists (00:53:18)
                                                            • A councilmember's staff member asked, for Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee), that the November 17 special Public Safety Committee meeting be moved to 5:00 (00:53:52)
                                                            • A councilmember asked to move her item honoring the WNBA's Golden State Valkyries and the team's MVP from the December 1 Council meeting to the January 19, 2027 meeting, then held the request after the clerk said the December 1 Council agenda would be in next week's packet (00:54:08)
                                                            • City staff asked, for the police department, that item five on the November 17 special Public Safety agenda be moved to the December 8 Public Safety Committee (00:54:47)
                                                            • The city clerk asked whether the item being moved was the police department's towing contract, and was told it was (00:55:20)
                                                            • City staff relayed a request from the City Administrator's office to move the cannabis informational report, item four on the November 17 CED agenda, to the January 26 CED meeting, saying a councilmember had already been asked for approval (00:55:34)
                                                            • City staff asked that the council-directives item on the November 17 Finance and Management agenda be moved to December 8, to line up with the matching report to Public Safety (00:56:00)
                                                            • A councilmember's staff member asked, for Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee)'s office, that an informational report on the city's prompt payment policy move from the pending list to the November 17 Finance and Management Committee (00:56:32)
                                                            • The committee chair read back the changes before the vote, including that CED item four would go to the pending list and that the Public Safety meeting would be a special 5 p.m. meeting (00:58:52)
                                                            • Documents: Agenda, Agenda (2)

                                                              This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

                                                              Report an error · This episode's page

                                                              9 min
                                                            • ShotSpotter, 911 outage headed to Public Safety; grants skip committee

                                                              Oakland's Rules Committee scheduled ShotSpotter's future, October's 911 outage and a new police towing contract for a November 17 Public Safety meeting. It also sent two police items and a violence-prevention grant straight to the full council, and withdrew a report on an overtime investigation at the Finance Department's request.

                                                              Rules and Legislation Committee, Thursday, November 5

                                                              • Scheduling: OPD towing contract with Auto Plus Towing (00:07:24)
                                                              • Scheduling: ShotSpotter annual reports and whether to keep using it (00:08:25)
                                                              • Scheduling: report on the October 2026 911 system outage (00:08:49)
                                                              • Review of draft agendas and pending lists: two OPD items and a violence-prevention grant sent straight to council; FLSA overtime report withdrawn (00:21:22)
                                                                • City staff asked on behalf of OPD to move two items off the November 17 Public Safety agenda to the November 10 council consent calendar (00:21:45)
                                                                • City staff identified the OPD items as the forensic examination reimbursement and payments item and the OPD NIBIN Modernization Grant (00:22:20)
                                                                • City staff gave the Rule 24 reason for those two items as the overloaded November 17 Public Safety agenda (00:23:02)
                                                                • City staff asked on behalf of the Department of Transportation to move the Safe Oakland Streets annual report to December 8, saying the Public Safety chair agreed (00:23:11)
                                                                • City staff read a revised title for the parking operator contract extension, extending it through 2027 with a new not-to-exceed total (00:24:01)
                                                                • City staff asked on behalf of the Finance Department to withdraw the FLSA overtime investigation report from the November 17 Finance and Management Committee (00:25:19)
                                                                • City staff explained that the report's contents had been discussed in closed-session labor negotiations, and offered to brief any councilmember (00:25:19)
                                                                • Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) suggested moving the November 17 Public Safety Committee up to 5 p.m. for a shorter day, saying the Life Enrichment meeting before it has one item, and asked District 2's staff to pass it to the chair (00:25:56)
                                                                • A councilmember asked, with the Safe Oakland Streets report moving to December 8, whether Public Safety had room to hear the OPD grant item instead of sending it straight to council (00:26:47)
                                                                • A council staff member said the Public Safety chair had already agreed to move the item and suggested keeping that plan (00:27:05)
                                                                • City staff asked on behalf of the Department of Violence Prevention to send a grant acceptance straight to council, saying it funds a full-time life coach and the department's life coaches are at capacity (00:27:12)
                                                                • A councilmember asked for the full scope of the grant item, beyond the life coach (00:27:57)
                                                                • City staff said the item also includes a contract with Restorative Justice for Oakland Youth for a full-time mental health clinician (00:28:16)
                                                                • A council staff member said the Public Safety chair hadn't yet been reached about the start-time suggestion (00:31:23)
                                                                • Scheduling: Embarcadero West Rail Safety Phase 1 construction contract (00:04:40)
                                                                • Scheduling: more money for homeless services provider contracts (00:10:27)
                                                                • Scheduling: tougher rules on nuisance vessels in Oakland waters (00:11:42)
                                                                  • A council staff member read a revised title that adds a definition of dock and docking to the ordinance (00:12:13)
                                                                  • Added scheduling request: travel reimbursement for League of California Cities academy (00:13:04)
                                                                    • A council staff member said the reimbursement would be capped per member and paid from the council contingency fund (00:13:04)
                                                                    • A council staff member said the item was urgent so all members could register before registration fills (00:13:04)
                                                                    • The committee chair corrected the title for the record to the 2027 Mayors and Council Members Academy, without the word new (00:14:23)
                                                                    • The city clerk asked that copies be brought for staff and colleagues in future and that the title be emailed so files can be created (00:14:37)
                                                                    • The committee chair said, when asked whether the whole council is going, that not every member may attend but all want to be on the resolution (00:14:57)
                                                                    • Documents: Agenda, Agenda (oakland.legistar1.com)

                                                                      This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

                                                                      Report an error · This episode's page

                                                                      8 min
                                                                    • Committee backs $75,000 for executive searches; Garfield Park sale advances

                                                                      The Finance and Management Committee voted 3-1 to recommend $75,000 more for executive searches, after staff cut their $300,000 request. Another committee recommended giving a long-delayed Kenilworth Road subdivision more time, over neighbors' complaints, and a third backed selling part of Garfield Park to Oakland Unified.

                                                                      Finance and Management Committee, Tuesday, October 27

                                                                      • Executive recruitment contracts: request for added money cut from $300,000 to $75,000 (01:51:47)
                                                                        • City staff said the extensions would keep the firms available while HR prepares a new request for proposals by the end of the calendar year, with departments paying the fees (01:53:44)
                                                                        • City staff listed the recruitments the added money would support (01:53:44)
                                                                        • The committee chair opposed the extensions, citing the cost of executive searches and budget uncertainty, and said the city often hires someone it picked from the start (01:54:03)
                                                                        • A councilmember called the increase too large, said a recent recruitment for a position in his office drew about 220 applications without a search firm, and noted uncertainty over Measure EE and a possible mayor's office restructuring (01:55:05)
                                                                        • A councilmember asked why the city doesn't promote more from within instead of hiring outside recruiters (01:56:02)
                                                                        • City staff said only about $14,000 remains on the contract, not enough for the City Administrator recruitment and others in progress (01:58:49)
                                                                        • City staff said the mayor's office knew about the item and supported at least the Ralph Andersen increase (01:59:11)
                                                                        • A councilmember invited the mayor's office to come back with a proposal for a smaller amount (02:00:09)
                                                                        • City staff asked whether the committee would approve extending only the contract terms, through August 2027 (02:04:57)
                                                                        • City staff asked whether a smaller increase would be acceptable so staff can finish current recruitments and pay their bills (02:06:02)
                                                                        • The committee chair said she would not support any increase but was open to extending the term to August 2027 (02:06:53)
                                                                        • City staff said money already spent on the contracts went to earlier recruitments, not the ones now listed (02:07:18)
                                                                        • City staff said Ralph Andersen bid on the City Administrator recruitment, and that staff believed the mayor's office had selected it (02:08:45)
                                                                        • City staff reduced the request to $75,000 for Ralph Andersen, for the City Administrator recruitment and the rest of the constitutional policing administrator recruitment (02:09:28)
                                                                        • City Administrator contract authority report, FY 2023-24 through 2025-26 (00:06:49)
                                                                          • City staff explained that the report covers construction, professional services, grant agreements and purchase orders under the City Administrator's authority up to $250,000 (00:07:16)
                                                                          • City staff said the FY 2023-24 and 2024-25 reports were delayed by a change in leadership and in who handled compliance oversight in Finance, and committed to bringing the report every fall (00:09:19)
                                                                          • The committee chair disputed the explanation that a cancelled June meeting caused the delay, noting the committee did meet in June and the gap covered three years (00:11:01)
                                                                          • City staff said the 2024-25 report was delayed partly by budget rebalancing at the end of 2025 and was overlooked (00:13:00)
                                                                          • City staff said the report is more comprehensive than earlier versions, adding grant and cooperative agreements that had not been included before (00:13:00)
                                                                          • A councilmember asked whether $250,000 is the right threshold for the City Administrator's contract authority (00:15:34)
                                                                          • City staff said the limit was raised from $100,000 to $250,000 around 2013, has not kept up with inflation since, and suggested a more nuanced limit that accounts for contract length (00:15:49)
                                                                          • A councilmember asked that future reports show which fund pays for each contract, citing a $26,000 police traffic-control contract for Juneteenth 2026 (00:18:33)
                                                                          • A councilmember called it a red flag that one vendor can receive more than $250,000 in a year without council review, and said such cases should come to council automatically (00:19:33)
                                                                          • City staff said one vendor can hold several contracts for different services, but if one service goes over $250,000 the department must bring it to council (00:20:08)
                                                                          • A councilmember pointed to a $400,000 information technology contract in the report that exceeds the threshold and asked what decides which contracts skip council (00:22:20)
                                                                          • City staff explained that contracts under $250,000 often still come to council because the City Administrator cannot waive small local business requirements, which apply above $50,000 (00:23:10)
                                                                          • City staff cautioned that the amounts listed are contract awards, not spending, and that the city's systems cannot easily trace spending and funding sources by contract (00:23:44)
                                                                          • City staff agreed to provide spending and fund information in future, probably in a different format, and warned that Oracle data tracks vendors, not contract awards (00:25:55)
                                                                          • Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) said other departments describe procurement as a bottleneck, and asked what is being done about racial disparities in small contracts that a disparity study had flagged (00:27:25)
                                                                          • City staff described a small staff serving the whole city, with a purchasing side of one supervisor and four buyers, against an industry minimum of 12 to 15 (00:30:55)
                                                                          • City staff said some delays happen because the city now enforces council's rules without exceptions, and called this a culture change (00:31:40)
                                                                          • The committee chair asked about a $244,000 polling contract with EMC Research and whether council authorized it (00:33:30)
                                                                          • City staff said the polling contract was for possible revenue ballot measures and had not been used (00:34:15)
                                                                          • City staff said nothing had been spent on the polling contract, it was not used for Measure E, and having a vendor ready in advance is good practice (00:34:44)
                                                                          • The committee chair asked why only one Laurel safety ambassador grant appears in the report when she knows of several over the years (00:36:15)
                                                                          • City staff said a contract recorded in the work order portal may not show in Oracle until a purchase order is issued, and promised follow-up (00:38:10)
                                                                          • The committee chair asked why contracts under the City Administrator's authority totaled about $24 million in each of the first two years but about half that in 2025-26 (00:38:33)
                                                                          • City staff noted that grants the council approved by its own resolution would not appear in this report (00:39:23)
                                                                          • Citywide staffing and vacancy report, September 2026 (00:48:49)
                                                                            • City staff reported the citywide vacancy rate fell from 19.69% in February to 17.89% (00:53:32)
                                                                            • City staff said the September rate is the lowest of the periods shown, just under a previous low of 17.94% in April 2025 (00:53:32)
                                                                            • City staff reported 368 vacancies with no recruitment activity, down from 431 in February (00:52:31)
                                                                            • City staff explained that added budgeted positions raised some departments' rates, such as the City Auditor's office, now at 33% (00:54:33)
                                                                            • City staff said IBEW has the highest vacancy rate of the city's unions, partly because its budgeted positions grew from 17 to 21 (00:55:35)
                                                                            • City staff reported separations fell from 380 in FY 2024-25 to 322 in FY 2025-26 (00:56:37)
                                                                            • City staff said that since FY 2023-24 the city recorded 1,693 new hires and 1,697 separations (00:57:37)
                                                                            • City staff said in-person new employee orientation will return in 2027 (00:58:41)
                                                                            • City staff said the public safety recruitment team had just filled its last assistant HR analyst position (00:59:26)
                                                                            • City staff named the departments' own hiring process as the biggest obstacle to faster hiring (01:00:40)
                                                                            • City staff proposed expanded certification rules, since departments now get only four referrals per position at a time (01:01:35)
                                                                            • Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) noted the HR department's own vacancy rate fell from 44% to 34%, and asked which positions remain open (01:02:26)
                                                                            • City staff said departments cancelled requisitions they no longer needed, so the count now reflects real need (01:03:50)
                                                                            • Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) raised concern about the IBEW hiring timeline of about 287 days and the shortage of electricians for streetlight repair (01:04:47)
                                                                            • City staff said that figure came from one electrician recruitment, slowed by trouble finding outside assessors to give the exam (01:05:05)
                                                                            • The committee chair asked why so few jobs are posted on the city website given the number of vacancies (01:05:34)
                                                                            • City staff said one eligible list can fill multiple positions and that recruitments are opened in priority order (01:06:11)
                                                                            • City staff said no career fair at City Hall is currently planned, though two staff now coordinate outside career fairs (01:08:15)
                                                                            • City staff said candidates can now name the departments they want, so referrals are not wasted (01:11:29)
                                                                            • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked what share of applicants fail to meet minimum qualifications (01:12:39)
                                                                            • City staff said staff review minimum qualifications at the start of each recruitment to remove artificial barriers, and could provide the requested data (01:13:07)
                                                                            • Authorizing the remaining Measure DD, KK and U bonds (01:38:41)
                                                                              • City staff said the ordinance authorizes the rest of the bonds across all three measures, with each sale still coming to council (01:38:58)
                                                                              • City staff said the next sale is planned for March at up to $275 million, and bond counsel advised the first reading be at the December 1 regular meeting, not the November 10 special meeting (01:38:58)
                                                                              • City staff said sale sizes depend on department needs, the last sale was about $334 million, and tax-exempt bond money must be spent within three years (01:40:20)
                                                                              • The committee chair cited the remaining amounts under each measure and asked about the plan for the rest (01:40:47)
                                                                              • City staff said the rest would likely be sold within another year to year and a half, depending on how fast departments can spend (01:41:16)
                                                                              • City staff expected transportation, housing and parks money to be fully used by the next two-year budget, but not the full authorization for police facilities (01:41:56)
                                                                              • The committee chair said Measure KK money should be spent down first before the city asks voters for a successor measure (01:43:27)
                                                                              • A councilmember asked why only $6 million of the remaining Measure DD money would be sold, citing community questions about Estuary Park redevelopment in her district (01:49:40)
                                                                              • City staff said parks projects under KK and U are fully allocated, and bonds won't be sold until projects are ready to start because of the three-year spending window (01:50:29)
                                                                              • Documents: Agenda

                                                                                Public Works and Transportation Committee, Tuesday, October 27

                                                                                • Kenilworth Road subdivision: improvement agreement, encroachment permit and Parcel Map 8228 (00:06:38)
                                                                                  • City staff presented the project as seven single-family homes on vacant downhill parcels along an unpaved part of Kenilworth Road (00:08:30)
                                                                                  • City staff said the project was first approved in 2010, with later extensions from the Planning Commission and Planning Bureau (00:08:30)
                                                                                  • City staff said the agreement requires a secondary emergency fire access route to Devon Way and financial security of 175 percent of estimated construction cost (00:09:30)
                                                                                  • City staff said the private infrastructure would pass to a Geologic Hazard Abatement District and a homeowners association once they are formed (00:10:38)
                                                                                  • City staff said the resolutions have no fiscal impact, because the subdivider pays permit fees that cover staff costs (00:11:38)
                                                                                  • The committee chair said he generally supports new homes but they must follow all applicable codes, and that his staffer would follow up with the neighbors (00:22:02)
                                                                                  • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said the project isn't in his district and he would abstain until he could talk with the District 4 councilmember (00:22:30)
                                                                                  • Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) said she had seconded the motion before hearing public comment and realizing the item was controversial, and asked what the deferral request meant (00:23:10)
                                                                                  • City staff explained that the agreement lets the developer record the final map before finishing public improvements, backed by bonds the city can call if the work isn't done (00:25:13)
                                                                                  • City staff said the agreement sets a deadline for the improvements, which he believed was two years with possible extensions by the city engineer (00:25:13)
                                                                                  • City staff confirmed the agreement gives the developer more time, and said that without it the map would expire and entitlements would start over (00:26:01)
                                                                                  • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) asked what community meetings the contractor had held with residents (00:26:37)
                                                                                  • City staff said community engagement normally happens during planning entitlements, and the transportation department did none for the permitting or the map (00:27:47)
                                                                                  • An applicant representative blamed the delays on an ancient landslide more than 40 feet deep, which forced a redesign about six years ago (00:30:21)
                                                                                  • An applicant representative said COVID-era inspection delays let the permits expire, and renewing them took about two years (00:30:21)
                                                                                  • An applicant representative said the project was approved in 2006 with about eight pages of conditions, including on dust and noise, and offered to meet with neighbors (00:34:51)
                                                                                  • An applicant representative argued that retaining walls and grading are already in place, so the project won't go away if it isn't approved (00:35:57)
                                                                                  • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) asked to see the contractor's dust control plan, from both the city and the contractor (00:37:19)
                                                                                  • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) asked the neighbors whether they had reported problems to the city or code compliance in writing (00:37:19)
                                                                                  • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) urged the parties to meet and try to resolve the issues before the next meeting (00:38:43)
                                                                                  • The committee chair proposed sending the item to the full council on non-consent so the District 4 councilmember can meet both sides and weigh in, and offered to help mediate (00:39:37)
                                                                                  • $5 million construction management contract for Broadway Streetscape project (00:41:04)
                                                                                    • City staff said the council awarded the construction contract for the project to McGuire and Hester in July 2026 (00:41:38)
                                                                                    • City staff described the project limits as Broadway from 2nd to 11th Street and from 20th Street to Grand Avenue (00:41:38)
                                                                                    • City staff said VSCE will do 60 percent of the work itself, and the $5 million contract is fully funded by state and local grants (00:42:39)
                                                                                    • City staff said the city issued its request for proposals on July 31 and received two proposals in mid-August, with VSCE scoring highest (00:42:39)
                                                                                    • The committee chair said this is the second large outside engineering contract recently, hoped to bring the work in-house, and said the city contracts out because it has trouble hiring (00:43:31)
                                                                                    • City staff said he did not have the exact breakdown of the remaining 40 percent, which goes to specialty subconsultants (00:44:30)
                                                                                    • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) praised the local small-business selection and asked whether the remaining 40 percent would also go to Oakland small businesses (00:44:51)
                                                                                    • Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) noted the project is in District 2, questioned the cost of oversight work, and asked how many staff the firm would assign (00:45:35)
                                                                                    • Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) asked whether it is typical for construction management to cost about a quarter of construction costs (00:46:52)
                                                                                    • City staff said the contract covers resident engineers, office engineers, inspectors, special inspections, materials testing and environmental monitoring for federal requirements (00:47:00)
                                                                                    • City staff explained that firms are ranked on qualifications first and fee proposals are opened afterward, with no budget set by the city (00:49:07)
                                                                                    • City staff answering a councilmember, said the engineer's estimate for the management services was about $4 million (00:49:34)
                                                                                    • Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) said she would vote yes but called the documentation too thin for a contract this size and asked for more information before the full council (00:54:30)
                                                                                    • Documents: Agenda

                                                                                      Community and Economic Development Committee, Tuesday, October 27

                                                                                      • State Prop 64 (BSCC Cohort 4) grant for illicit cannabis enforcement (00:29:41)
                                                                                        • City staff said the bulk of the grant would cover staff costs for public safety operations and coordinated enforcement, with the rest for equipment, technology and grant administration including an evaluator (00:31:30)
                                                                                        • City staff said the city's earlier Cohort 3 grant, awarded in 2022, allocated $2,260,000 for security improvements and overnight security at licensed cannabis businesses (00:32:33)
                                                                                        • City staff said cannabis-related public nuisance cases rose from about 21 in 2025 to 39 in 2026, an estimated 86% increase in workload (00:33:35)
                                                                                        • City staff said the division currently has one inspector, will bring on four, and has about 74 locations needing more enforcement (00:34:36)
                                                                                        • City staff said most funding goes to a task force and overtime because the current city budget does not allow regular overtime (00:34:36)
                                                                                        • City staff said about $450,000 a year would go to staff and unspent funds roll over to the following year (00:36:37)
                                                                                        • The committee chair said her biggest concern was the money going to police overtime (00:38:01)
                                                                                        • The committee chair noted other jurisdictions, including San Francisco and Berkeley, use the funds for youth development and mentorship (00:39:01)
                                                                                        • The committee chair asked whether the city had a report back on how Cohort 3 funds were used, including a promised audit (00:39:01)
                                                                                        • City staff said the division runs no youth development programs and lacks staff to manage outside partners, so enforcement was the best fit (00:41:21)
                                                                                        • City staff argued enforcement spending is easier to track and report than results from nongovernmental partners (00:41:21)
                                                                                        • The committee chair pointed out that the 2021 Cohort 2 grant funded youth-focused work with OUSD, East Oakland Youth Development Center and the Public Health Institute (00:42:54)
                                                                                        • City staff said Cohort 3 is still being spent through 2028, with a lot of it going to security grants, and that the city reports quarterly to the state (00:43:39)
                                                                                        • A councilmember asked how the grant would work with the police overtime system, calling that her biggest concern given checks and balances on overtime (00:46:42)
                                                                                        • City staff explained that one jurisdiction can hold multiple grants from the program at once, so Cohorts 3 and 4 run concurrently under different lead agencies (00:48:33)
                                                                                        • City staff said the grant period dates to July 1 and the city will try to bill retroactively for enforcement already done (00:48:33)
                                                                                        • City staff said the first report to the state is due November 15 (00:49:39)
                                                                                        • City staff said enforcement would be citywide, including parks, streets, unlicensed dispensaries, smoke shops and other stores (00:50:19)
                                                                                        • City staff said one police officer is embedded with the division and ABAT may assist, especially in parks (00:55:21)
                                                                                        • Documents: Agenda

                                                                                          Life Enrichment Committee, Tuesday, October 27

                                                                                          • Sale of part of Garfield Park to Oakland Unified (00:24:56)
                                                                                            • City staff said OUSD needs the city's parcel to expand the new school, which is why the sale was negotiated (00:26:57)
                                                                                            • City staff said the city would get money for general fund purposes (00:26:57)
                                                                                            • City staff said the existing field would be replaced by a new, higher-quality turf field on the campus that the community could use (00:27:59)
                                                                                            • City staff said that without a sale, OUSD would build up to its current property line and cut the park in half (00:27:59)
                                                                                            • City staff said the OUSD board has already approved the deal and only council approval remains (00:28:59)
                                                                                            • A councilmember called the deal long overdue and said the city hasn't maintained this park like its others (00:30:21)
                                                                                            • A councilmember said Bay Tech High School a block away could one day lease and use the field (00:30:21)
                                                                                            • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) asked why the city would sell instead of granting a long-term lease, such as 100 years (00:31:10)
                                                                                            • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) asked why the city didn't swap the land for OUSD property that could be used for housing (00:31:10)
                                                                                            • City staff said the city's lease-over-sale policy applies to sites disposed of for permanent development, and here a public agency partner asked to buy (00:32:59)
                                                                                            • City staff said the current property line runs through the middle of the park, so moving it and being paid was the more rational outcome (00:32:59)
                                                                                            • City staff said the open-space zoning greatly lowers the site's value, so a swap would get the city little (00:34:38)
                                                                                            • City staff said the city already has better surplus sites waiting in line for affordable housing, and this one would sit behind them (00:34:38)
                                                                                            • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) asked whether OUSD has unused school buildings that could help with housing (00:35:42)
                                                                                            • The committee chair urged sticking to the transaction on the agenda and told the questioner to weigh his vote if he disagreed (00:36:40)
                                                                                            • City staff said Garfield Park is in poor condition and the project would improve it (00:38:31)
                                                                                            • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said he would vote for the item and only wanted an open public discussion (00:38:58)
                                                                                            • A councilmember said the campus is badly cramped and called the deal a win-win (00:39:58)
                                                                                            • A councilmember described the park as poorly maintained, with needles, and said the neighborhood needs the investment (00:39:58)
                                                                                            • A councilmember asked to be added as a co-sponsor of the ordinance (00:40:58)
                                                                                            • The clerk said the clerk's office noted the request in the item history but doesn't add co-sponsors to department-originated items (00:41:32)
                                                                                            • A councilmember noted that earlier talks had considered spending the proceeds on a new baseball field, but they now go to the general fund (00:42:31)
                                                                                            • City staff said staff tried to direct the money to Parks and Rec but were advised the consolidated fiscal policy requires the general fund (00:42:42)
                                                                                            • Update on carrying out the 2024 Disparity Study recommendations (01:06:46)
                                                                                              • The committee chair said she brought the item because the public doesn't regularly hear the outcomes of disparity study work (01:07:12)
                                                                                              • City staff said the 2024 Mason Tillman study found disparities in the city's use of prime contractors and subcontractors (01:08:32)
                                                                                              • City staff said a citywide improvement plan set up in October covers 17 projects and 50 deliverables, each with an owner and deadline (01:09:33)
                                                                                              • City staff said that as of October 26, 16 deliverables were done, eight were in progress, and 30 were scheduled through spring 2027 (01:10:33)
                                                                                              • City staff said a revised administrative instruction on waiver reform is in final draft and goes to staff next week (01:10:33)
                                                                                              • City staff described a beta online portal that lets prime contractors browse subcontractors by trade and certification (01:11:34)
                                                                                              • City staff said all 240 firms that sought certification through the B2Gnow platform were certified, and processing time fell from weeks to days (01:12:35)
                                                                                              • City staff said departments identified over 600 upcoming contracts, which should help avoid urgent waiver requests (01:13:37)
                                                                                              • City staff said the first consolidated report found 151 contracts worth about $56 million in the pipeline, 563 active contracts, and 58 future solicitations (01:13:37)
                                                                                              • City staff said the capital forecast first found 31 projects worth about $174 million, a figure that has since grown (01:13:37)
                                                                                              • City staff said a written report would come in January, by which time completion should be closer to 60% (01:16:30)
                                                                                              • Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore) said contractors tell him city payments are far behind, which hurts their workers, and asked what the city is doing (01:17:27)
                                                                                              • City staff said staff are studying root causes across three payment types, including bond-funded contracts where the city has less control (01:18:16)
                                                                                              • City staff said the city is supposed to pay primes within 20 days, and asked how it can know whether primes then pay their subcontractors (01:19:27)
                                                                                              • City staff said staff are working with Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee) on a prompt payment ordinance and don't want a system that acts only on complaints (01:20:32)
                                                                                              • Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore) raised staff vacancies across departments and slow permits as causes of delays for contractors (01:21:16)
                                                                                              • A councilmember noted the study found the steepest disparities in small, informal contracts the council never reviews, and asked how those will be handled (01:23:18)
                                                                                              • City staff said the City Administrator's office now reviews agreements under $250,000 and waiver requests more closely until formal oversight exists (01:24:05)
                                                                                              • A councilmember cited a recent auto body contract where the published invite list showed no minority-owned shops were invited, and said such transparency matters (01:25:16)
                                                                                              • City staff said a contracting triage help desk promising fixes within five business days will roll out in the next couple of weeks (01:26:08)
                                                                                              • The committee chair asked a public speaker to send her the information about a $20 million contract he described (01:39:36)
                                                                                              • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) called it unjust that 25 years after the small local business program passed, local contractors are still left out (01:47:26)
                                                                                              • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said he had urged colleagues to reject the auto body contract that sent money outside Oakland, and they did (01:48:31)
                                                                                              • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) urged acting on contracting equity now without relying on the disparity study as justification (01:49:31)
                                                                                              • The committee chair moved to continue the item to the first January 2027 meeting for a written update, and urged progress before then (01:51:24)
                                                                                              • Summer internship agreement with Oakland Unified (00:11:38)
                                                                                                • City staff said the agreement would give city departments one consistent framework for hosting OUSD students in the summer (00:12:32)
                                                                                                • City staff said OUSD's ECHO internship program began in 2010 and has grown from about 150 students a year to more than 500 (00:13:32)
                                                                                                • City staff said the report describes participation as costing the city nothing (00:13:32)
                                                                                                • City staff said stipends are paid from Oakland Fund for Children and Youth grant money through OUSD's program (00:14:34)
                                                                                                • A councilmember asked how big the stipends are and whether students get financial training on saving and spending (00:15:21)
                                                                                                • City staff said past stipends ran about $1,000 to $1,500 for a five-week program (00:15:54)
                                                                                                • City staff said OUSD manages the funds and provides job-readiness workshops, including on saving money (00:16:37)
                                                                                                • A councilmember asked how many East Oakland residents receive the stipends (00:16:51)
                                                                                                • City staff said OUSD's work-based learning program runs it and students from across the city take part (00:17:07)
                                                                                                • City staff said students apply through the ECHO internship portal with help from work-based learning staff at each campus (00:17:47)
                                                                                                • City staff said the fire department has more administrative jobs than firefighting jobs, and OUSD proposed making the arrangement citywide for all departments (00:18:33)
                                                                                                • A councilmember asked whether students could intern across city departments, not only the fire department (00:20:00)
                                                                                                • City staff said the fire department is the first phase, and the next phase would coordinate other departments that want to take part (00:20:31)
                                                                                                • A councilmember said the program used to run at Fremont High School when he was on the school board (00:24:21)
                                                                                                • Documents: Agenda

                                                                                                  Public Safety Committee, Tuesday, October 27

                                                                                                  • OPD Part 2 crime data report (00:48:13)
                                                                                                    • The committee chair said she sought the report after learning human trafficking is not counted as a Part 1 crime, and that Part 2 reporting will become regular at the committee (00:48:24)
                                                                                                    • Police department staff cautioned that Part 2 figures are ballpark numbers because these crimes are reported with delays and are finalized only at year end (00:49:07)
                                                                                                    • Police department staff said year-to-date Part 1 crime was down 10%, with reductions in almost all violent Part 1 categories (00:50:18)
                                                                                                    • Police department staff said drunkenness reports rose sharply, attributing it to enforcement at First Fridays and downtown, and said simple assault was up 1%, in preliminary figures (00:51:26)
                                                                                                    • Police department staff said human trafficking cases rose 127%, from 45 to 102 in preliminary figures, reflecting a new focus on pimps and buyers (00:51:26)
                                                                                                    • Police department staff said vandalism was up 4% and overall Part 2 crimes citywide up 2%, in preliminary figures, and a slide label reading Part 1 was an error (00:52:26)
                                                                                                    • Police department staff explained the family and children category covers child abuse and welfare cases where a child is removed from a home (00:53:42)
                                                                                                    • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked about the 321 runaway juvenile reports and how they are tracked (00:54:02)
                                                                                                    • Police department staff said the runaway category includes missing persons and rose 143% in preliminary figures, and that repeat runaways from group homes are counted each time (00:56:22)
                                                                                                    • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) argued the increases in trafficking and runaway numbers can reflect stronger enforcement and more public confidence in reporting (00:58:10)
                                                                                                    • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said he was appointed by the governor two days earlier to the state advisory group on youth justice and wants to work with OPD on bringing state funds to Oakland (00:58:40)
                                                                                                    • Police department staff said OPD does not separately track how many runaways are recovered; alerts are removed from a national system when a person is located (01:00:09)
                                                                                                    • The committee chair said the committee should look more deeply at runaways later, tying it to county child welfare issues (01:01:01)
                                                                                                    • The committee chair asked whether identity theft stemming from mail theft is captured in the data (01:01:01)
                                                                                                    • Police department staff said identity theft may fall under embezzlement and mail theft is a federal crime often not counted in OPD's statistics (01:02:03)
                                                                                                    • The committee chair said public commenters raised useful ideas for improving crime reporting, noting limits on crime analysis capacity (01:08:51)
                                                                                                    • Community Police Review Agency bi-annual report (01:09:45)
                                                                                                      • The committee chair said these reports are required but had not been delivered for years until a staff member flagged it, and this is the second one (01:10:01)
                                                                                                      • The Community Police Review Agency's director said the agency hired three people in the past year: a director of investigations, a project manager and a complaint investigator (01:11:42)
                                                                                                      • The Community Police Review Agency's director said over 90% of complaints come through OPD, usually within 24 hours, and go to three intake technicians (01:13:55)
                                                                                                      • The Community Police Review Agency's director explained that if the CPRA and police chief disagree on findings or discipline, the case goes to a Police Commission discipline committee, all within one year (01:17:05)
                                                                                                      • The Community Police Review Agency's director said the agency tracks cases in Excel and an antiquated database that IT will discontinue, so it needs a new case management system, hoped for early next year (01:19:08)
                                                                                                      • The Community Police Review Agency's director said none of its three investigators are attorneys, so it wants two attorney investigators and has an RFP out for outside law firms through about November 17 (01:21:14)
                                                                                                      • The Community Police Review Agency's director reported 808 allegations reviewed January through September, led by physical force (327) and performance of duty (331) (01:24:29)
                                                                                                      • The Community Police Review Agency's director reported 240 completed and 62 ongoing investigations (01:25:30)
                                                                                                      • The Community Police Review Agency's director said cases with sustained findings typically take about ten months, with 26 sustained findings and 51 administrative closures since January (01:26:30)
                                                                                                      • The Community Police Review Agency's director said the report's figure of four cases missing the 180-day goal is likely only since the last report, and argued rushing serious cases compromises due process (01:27:35)
                                                                                                      • The Community Police Review Agency's director said council district data had to be compiled by hand, using two high school summer interns (01:29:41)
                                                                                                      • The Community Police Review Agency's director said an expanded agency would need 21 full-time positions and promised a budget comparison next week (01:31:01)
                                                                                                      • The Community Police Review Agency's director compared database vendors: the most comprehensive costs $660,000 over three years, while his preferred option would cost roughly $100,000 a year (01:32:05)
                                                                                                      • The Community Police Review Agency's director said the charter requires one investigator per 100 officers, meaning about six, while the agency has three (01:34:09)
                                                                                                      • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) questioned whether 50-page investigation reports are an excessive use of staff time (01:37:18)
                                                                                                      • The Community Police Review Agency's director said the outside counsel budget is approximately $200,000 (01:38:26)
                                                                                                      • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) suggested asking OPD to include the council district on complaints sent to the CPRA as a low-cost fix (01:39:39)
                                                                                                      • The Community Police Review Agency's director said OPD provides area numbers, not districts, and agreed to ask (01:40:28)
                                                                                                      • The Community Police Review Agency's director clarified that the 808 figure is all complaints received and promised a separate count of charter-mandated cases in future (01:42:31)
                                                                                                      • The Community Police Review Agency's director said the charter defines mandatory case types and also allows the agency to investigate others (01:43:51)
                                                                                                      • The committee chair expressed concern about recent officer-involved shootings, citing the fatal shooting of a man in apparent mental health crisis, and asked how such cases are assessed (01:44:10)
                                                                                                      • The Community Police Review Agency's director said shootings are first reviewed by the district attorney, pausing the agency's deadline, and that the case cited would likely go to outside counsel (01:45:06)
                                                                                                      • The Community Police Review Agency's director said recent disagreements have mostly been with internal affairs, while the agency has largely agreed with the police chief in the past six to eight months (01:47:17)
                                                                                                      • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) cited the state penal code standard for deadly force and suggested the shooting raised by the chair may have met it (01:55:05)
                                                                                                      • The committee chair responded that they would agree to disagree (01:55:38)
                                                                                                      • The Community Police Review Agency's director responded to public comment that the agency investigates all the complaint categories raised, not only the mandated ones (01:55:59)
                                                                                                      • Documents: Agenda

                                                                                                        Rules and Legislation Committee, Thursday, October 29

                                                                                                        Documents: Agenda, Agenda (oakland.legistar1.com)

                                                                                                        This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

                                                                                                        Report an error · This episode's page

                                                                                                        10 min
                                                                                                      • Council rejects Police Commission slate, advances higher nuisance fines

                                                                                                        The Oakland City Council sent a Police Commission slate back to its selection panel, gave first approval to higher nuisance fines, and heard an audit of how the city manages capital project money. Plus: a $30 minimum wage initiative heads to the council.

                                                                                                        City Council, Tuesday, October 20

                                                                                                        • Police Commission slate rejected and sent back to selection panel (00:22:15)
                                                                                                          • City staff reported for staff that one nominee withdrew because his law firm represents parties suing the city, later asked to rescind the withdrawal, and that staff had no recommendation (00:22:56)
                                                                                                          • An official explained that under the charter the council must accept or reject the entire slate, and a slate not acted on within sixty days is deemed accepted (00:24:38)
                                                                                                          • A councilmember asked why the council could not vote on a slate of just one person (00:25:09)
                                                                                                          • A councilmember asked whether the law could be changed so nominees are taken one at a time (00:26:07)
                                                                                                          • An official said the slate requirement is in the charter, so changing it would take a charter amendment (00:26:45)
                                                                                                          • A councilmember said she hoped the former-mayor nominee would still be on the slate that comes back (00:27:12)
                                                                                                          • A councilmember said one candidate withdrew after questions from a news outlet and that rejecting the slate had nothing to do with either candidate (00:27:25)
                                                                                                          • An official clarified that the attorney's office was not saying either candidate was or wasn't qualified, and that rejecting the slate simply resets the process (00:27:53)
                                                                                                          • A councilmember asked whether the selection panel had alternates ready, and the answer was that it has a reserve pool (00:29:44)
                                                                                                          • An invited speaker said, as the former-mayor nominee, that the mayor asked her to serve on the commission at a critical time for the city (00:49:26)
                                                                                                          • An invited speaker said she will never run for office again and so cannot be pressured by the police officers union (00:51:28)
                                                                                                          • An invited speaker said she supported the commission's work this year on an immigration policy and on a drone policy (00:54:38)
                                                                                                          • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) pressed the nominee on the commission's revised vehicle pursuit policy, which he tied to smash-and-grab crime in his district (00:55:37)
                                                                                                          • An invited speaker said she wanted to see data before taking a strong position on the pursuit policy change (00:56:37)
                                                                                                          • An invited speaker said she would push to change the pursuit policy if data showed it harmed the community, and stressed officer training (01:07:16)
                                                                                                          • Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) praised the nominee's past work on Ceasefire and sex trafficking and said the commission needs AAPI representation (01:00:48)
                                                                                                          • Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) said she will support the former mayor's appointment (01:04:42)
                                                                                                          • A councilmember asked colleagues to save detailed questioning for when the slate returns and to move the agenda (01:05:48)
                                                                                                          • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said it took about a year and a half, and a letter from the governor, for the commission to revise the pursuit policy (01:08:40)
                                                                                                          • Higher maximum fines for unabated nuisances introduced (01:28:09)
                                                                                                            • A councilmember said the city's maximum penalty of $1,000 a day was set in 1968 and no longer deters the worst offenders (01:29:52)
                                                                                                            • A councilmember said the ordinance raises the cap from $1,000 to $10,000 a day, aimed at chronic offenders such as owners of rotting buildings and unpermitted builders (01:29:52)
                                                                                                            • A councilmember said the ordinance still lets people fix problems in good faith, with escalating fines before the maximum (01:30:55)
                                                                                                            • A councilmember said the goal is compliance, not revenue (01:30:55)
                                                                                                            • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said he signed Measure RR, which he said changed the 1968 law, and has fought illegal dumping for years (01:32:14)
                                                                                                            • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said illegal dumpers should face jail, not just fines, and asked for trained staff to gather evidence for the district attorney (01:33:17)
                                                                                                            • Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) asked whether the ordinance only sets an overall cap, and was told it raises the ceiling for anything now capped at $1,000 (01:34:50)
                                                                                                            • A councilmember questioned who will enforce and collect higher fines when current fines are not enforced (01:36:00)
                                                                                                            • A councilmember said code enforcement imposes the fines, is short-staffed, and he wants more officers in the next budget (01:37:29)
                                                                                                            • A councilmember said the cap was raised to $5,000 in 2020 and that did not stop dumping (01:38:53)
                                                                                                            • A councilmember asked whether automatic inflation adjustments could legally be built into civil penalties (01:42:12)
                                                                                                            • An official explained for the City Attorney's Office that the city administrator sets a schedule of fines under the $10,000 maximum, and that it applies to all departments that enforce nuisance rules (01:42:54)
                                                                                                            • A councilmember added that higher fines make it easier for the city to put liens on properties (01:44:22)
                                                                                                            • An official advised that adding enforcement-staff requirements was outside the scope of the item as noticed and would need a separate item (01:53:36)
                                                                                                            • City auditor's audit of capital project financial management (02:09:13)
                                                                                                              • The city auditor's office said the city spent about $300 million on capital projects over three years, with Measure KK the largest single source (02:12:37)
                                                                                                              • The city auditor's office said change orders took far longer than the manual's two-week standard, and that neither department has adopted the manual (02:13:38)
                                                                                                              • The city auditor's office said 41% of contracted capital spending went through on-call contracts, which the city has no general guidance on (02:17:13)
                                                                                                              • The city auditor's office said on-call contracts were extended an average of two years, the longest by four years (02:17:13)
                                                                                                              • The city auditor's office reported that more than half of sampled orders to proceed did not follow requirements (02:18:34)
                                                                                                              • The city auditor's office said about half of construction management civil engineer positions were vacant, which slowed paving and street repair (02:19:44)
                                                                                                              • The city auditor's office found inadequate oversight of bond funds, including payments charged to the wrong funds (02:22:58)
                                                                                                              • The city auditor's office said the required annual audits of bond fund use have not been done (02:22:58)
                                                                                                              • The city auditor's office said bidding out projects before designs were finished led to avoidable change orders (02:23:59)
                                                                                                              • The city auditor's office said the city has had no multiyear capital plan since fiscal 2023 and recommended one, plus annual progress reports to council (02:25:00)
                                                                                                              • A councilmember pointed out conflicting implementation dates for the on-call contract recommendations in the city's response (02:28:44)
                                                                                                              • City staff said the November 2026 date was overly ambitious and January 2027 is the accurate target (02:29:56)
                                                                                                              • Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) called alarming the audit's finding that one on-call task order reached $8.4 million, against a $730,000 limit in San Jose (02:30:20)
                                                                                                              • The city auditor's office explained that qualifications-based selection has firms compete on experience and expertise rather than lowest bid (02:37:18)
                                                                                                              • A councilmember asked what consequences follow when projects exceed approved amounts without returning to council, citing one in her district (02:37:57)
                                                                                                              • The city auditor's office said there generally were not consequences in those cases, but they could be built into policy or legislation (02:41:24)
                                                                                                              • A councilmember asked how much remains in Measures U and KK, saying he wants to explore a possible new bond in 2028 for facilities (02:41:44)
                                                                                                              • City staff said parks funds in the bond are largely committed, while the citywide facilities category has more room (02:42:39)
                                                                                                              • City staff said for finance that most Measure KK money will likely be spent by 2028, with transportation and affordable housing funds likely fully used (02:44:19)
                                                                                                              • City staff said some approved projects lack full funding, sometimes on purpose while seeking matching grants (02:45:20)
                                                                                                              • A councilmember asked who is responsible for making sure audit recommendations are carried out, given staffing shortages (02:48:19)
                                                                                                              • City staff said as interim city administrator she is focused on having departments act on the auditor's follow-up reports (02:49:12)
                                                                                                              • The city auditor's office said his office tracks recommendations twice a year, with a new dashboard, and that more than 300 remain outstanding (02:49:45)
                                                                                                              • A councilmember asked the administration when it would report back to council with a timeline for the work (02:51:39)
                                                                                                              • Love Life acknowledgment and opening program (00:05:00)
                                                                                                                • A councilmember announced the council would acknowledge the city motto with a Love Life anthem, a performance and remarks from the foundation's founder (00:05:00)
                                                                                                                • A councilmember said she was bringing legislation recognizing October 19 through 25 as Love Life Week in Oakland (00:05:56)
                                                                                                                • A councilmember read the Love Life acknowledgment, which commits participants to lead with love and denounce violence (00:07:59)
                                                                                                                • An invited speaker said the day was the anniversary of his daughter's killing and that the foundation in her name is mostly volunteer-run (00:11:08)
                                                                                                                • An invited speaker cited an impact report saying the foundation has reached 30,000 young people in twenty-nine years and asked for ongoing support (00:13:12)
                                                                                                                • A councilmember urged that the meeting keep to the acknowledgment's call for inspiration instead of insults (00:19:17)
                                                                                                                • Consent calendar, with SAVE grant urgency vote and amendment (02:56:28)
                                                                                                                  • Police department staff gave the urgency reasons for the vessel grant: the grant term began October 1, the governor declared a state of emergency, and boats cost more to remove once they sink (03:02:16)
                                                                                                                  • Police department staff said removing vessels quickly matters because costs rise once they sink (03:02:16)
                                                                                                                  • An official clarified as parliamentarian that the change removes the request to waive small and local business requirements, making it an amendment, not a title change (03:04:31)
                                                                                                                  • Police department staff listed the struck language: the sixth whereas clause, part of the twelfth, and the fifth further resolved clause (03:20:49)
                                                                                                                  • A councilmember spoke on the United Against Hate Week resolution, noting the movement was cofounded in Oakland in 2017 (03:21:22)
                                                                                                                  • A councilmember registered a no vote on item 6.26 over its waivers of the city's sanctuary city contracting policies (03:22:58)
                                                                                                                  • Mayor's appointee confirmed to Planning Commission (01:55:02)
                                                                                                                    • City staff presented the appointment for the mayor's office, citing the appointee's prior service as commission chair and his legal and land use experience (01:55:37)
                                                                                                                    • A Planning Commission appointee said today's planning challenges, such as economic development and work with the port, differ from those of the 1990s (01:56:46)
                                                                                                                    • A Planning Commission appointee said the commission can play a role in discussing displacement even though it is not the commission's primary jurisdiction (01:57:43)
                                                                                                                    • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) asked how the planning process could be streamlined, citing a constituent who lost loans to delays (01:58:32)
                                                                                                                    • A Planning Commission appointee said well-intentioned laws have become procedural traps, and the commission can push staff to bring matters forward faster (01:59:22)
                                                                                                                    • A Planning Commission appointee said long-range planning will be part of the general plan update coming next spring (02:00:21)
                                                                                                                    • A councilmember asked the appointee to be a strong advocate for more housing, citing rising rents (02:01:22)
                                                                                                                    • A Planning Commission appointee pointed to inclusionary zoning and zoning bonuses as ways to add housing, including affordable housing (02:01:41)
                                                                                                                    • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) corrected his earlier remark, saying the Claremont Hotel is listed in Berkeley but part of its parking lot is on an Oakland parcel (02:07:53)
                                                                                                                    • Public hearing: World Cup hotel-tax sharing deal with Oakland Roots and Soul (01:09:11)
                                                                                                                      • City staff reported the club met all performance targets, bringing Australia's team to its facility and hosting watch parties and local events (01:12:53)
                                                                                                                      • City staff said the city collected about $1.7 million in hotel tax in June 2026 (01:14:02)
                                                                                                                      • City staff said the club received the $300,000 and the city kept about $80,000 above that (01:15:04)
                                                                                                                      • City staff noted hotel tax rose 28% even with five fewer hotels and 360 fewer rooms than a year earlier (01:15:04)
                                                                                                                      • City staff said the Claremont Hotel has a Berkeley address but all of its hotel tax goes to Oakland (01:15:04)
                                                                                                                      • City staff said the hearing is required by state law for economic development subsidies and that no action was needed (01:16:06)
                                                                                                                      • A councilmember said most of the Claremont Hotel's property is in Oakland and its hotel tax goes to the city (01:17:27)
                                                                                                                      • A councilmember urged staff to study Miami's stadium-centered development as a model for the Coliseum and sports development (01:18:16)
                                                                                                                      • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) asked why the team stayed at the Claremont rather than in Districts 6 and 7, where it played (01:20:30)
                                                                                                                      • Agenda changes: three ordinances continued, police commission item moved up (00:20:16)
                                                                                                                        • The city clerk asked that items 6.5, 6.6 and 6.7 be continued because the newspaper did not publish the city's notices (00:20:16)
                                                                                                                        • A councilmember moved the Police Commission selection panel item to the top of the agenda, ahead of the public hearings (00:21:30)
                                                                                                                        • Documents: Agenda

                                                                                                                          Rules and Legislation Committee, Thursday, October 22

                                                                                                                          • Scheduling the 'Oakland Living Wage for All Act of 2026' minimum wage initiative for the full council (00:04:19)
                                                                                                                            • The city clerk explained that the Elections Code requires the council to pick one of the three options, which is why the item goes straight to the council (00:06:24)
                                                                                                                            • Scheduling the data center moratorium report and proposed extension (00:06:24)
                                                                                                                              • The city clerk read the reason for skipping committee review: state law requires the council to hear a written report 35 days after the moratorium was adopted, and the report would let the council consider an extension (00:07:28)
                                                                                                                              • The city clerk stated that to meet state deadlines, the item must be on the November 10 council agenda as a public hearing (00:08:34)
                                                                                                                              • Documents: Agenda

                                                                                                                                This episode was produced with AI from the public recording of the meeting. Links to the source are in the show notes.

                                                                                                                                Report an error · This episode's page

                                                                                                                                10 min
                                                                                                                              • Committee backs shorter parking contract extension; capital audit and housing bonds head to council

                                                                                                                                A city committee votes to shorten Oakland's parking citation contract extension, to June 30, 2027, over a thirty percent collection fee, the City Auditor reports on how the city manages capital project money, and a committee lines up up to $50 million in Measure U housing funds.

                                                                                                                                Finance and Management Committee, Tuesday, October 13

                                                                                                                                • Parking citation system contract with Modaxo, shortened (00:23:13)
                                                                                                                                  • A speaker presented the request as the fourth and final amendment to the agreement with Modaxo, extending it 24 months from April 2026 through March 2028 (00:24:23)
                                                                                                                                  • A speaker said the system supports collection of about $29.7 million in budgeted parking revenue for the current fiscal year (00:25:25)
                                                                                                                                  • A speaker said the agreement expired in April 2026, and that after the program moved from the Department of Transportation to Finance, Finance reviewed its contracts and practices (00:25:25)
                                                                                                                                  • A speaker said negotiations produced an agreement that collection fees will not apply to citations under the state-mandated indigent payment plan (00:26:26)
                                                                                                                                  • A speaker described the extension as a temporary bridge to allow a competitive procurement for a long-term parking management system (00:26:26)
                                                                                                                                  • A speaker said staff is also exploring gated entry and exit at city-owned parking garages (00:27:27)
                                                                                                                                  • A councilmember said they were very concerned that 30% goes to a company that does not do the collections, called it a blow to public trust, and said they could not support extending the contract (00:28:28)
                                                                                                                                  • A councilmember asked why the contract came to Finance so many months after it expired (00:29:29)
                                                                                                                                  • A speaker said no one from the Department of Transportation was present to explain, that Finance aims to bring the contract into compliance and pay the vendor for services since April, and that procurement staff are short-handed (00:29:48)
                                                                                                                                  • A councilmember asked why a private company gets 30% for collections work done by the DMV, the city, or state programs (00:31:12)
                                                                                                                                  • A speaker said the fee is part of the vendor's pay for specialized services and depends on collecting delinquent balances, and that the DMV and Franchise Tax Board portions are under negotiation (00:31:34)
                                                                                                                                  • City staff pointed to a cost breakdown on page four of the report showing options with and without the special collection services (00:32:11)
                                                                                                                                  • A councilmember said the two options differ by only about $300,000 and that dropping the service would shift the cost from ticket payers to the city, so neither was acceptable (00:32:23)
                                                                                                                                  • A councilmember noted six months of the 24 had already passed and asked whether staff needs the remaining 18 months for a full RFP (00:32:54)
                                                                                                                                  • A speaker said a request for information goes out this month and a request for proposals in November (00:33:24)
                                                                                                                                  • A speaker said switching vendors would require moving terabytes of historical data, and recommended the full term (00:34:24)
                                                                                                                                  • A councilmember said the problem is the contract terms, not the vendor, and asked whether a shorter term would be workable (00:34:55)
                                                                                                                                  • A speaker said a shorter term would put staff in a crunch (00:35:38)
                                                                                                                                  • City staff said a shorter timeline could mean staff returns with another extension (00:35:54)
                                                                                                                                  • A councilmember raised privacy concerns about the license plate data the company collects and noted that Los Angeles's transportation department added privacy protections (00:36:25)
                                                                                                                                  • A councilmember said the outstanding invoices must be paid, the city could get better terms, and she wanted to know what other vendors are available (00:37:28)
                                                                                                                                  • A councilmember asked whether a 30% fee is typical for this kind of company (00:37:52)
                                                                                                                                  • A speaker said such fees typically range from 20 to 30 percent in the industry (00:38:35)
                                                                                                                                  • City staff said the 30% rate is not unusual, but the arrangement of charging it on money sent through the DMV or Franchise Tax Board is something they had not seen before (00:38:47)
                                                                                                                                  • A speaker explained the 30% is added to a ticket on day 61, an internal business decision inherited from the Department of Transportation that will be revisited with an equity lens in the new RFP (00:39:43)
                                                                                                                                  • A councilmember moved to extend the contract only to the end of this fiscal year, June 30, and to have staff return with an alternative (00:42:34)
                                                                                                                                  • City staff said staff can bring back options under a shorter term, that the committee would hear back in December or January, and that this may affect the procurement process (00:43:15)
                                                                                                                                  • City staff said the department is working citywide to stop paying contracts in arrears and will not pay any contract until the council authorizes it (00:45:23)
                                                                                                                                  • City staff recommended that a short extension keep the current collection process, including the special collection services, so staff can focus on the new procurement (00:46:16)
                                                                                                                                  • A councilmember restated the motion: extend to June 30, 2027 on the same terms, with direction to return quickly with other options and to include privacy protections on license plate reader data (00:48:05)
                                                                                                                                  • Documents: Agenda

                                                                                                                                    Public Works and Transportation Committee, Tuesday, October 13

                                                                                                                                    • City Auditor's audit of capital project financial management (00:49:32)
                                                                                                                                      • A speaker said the audit was requested by the transportation director and covers fiscal years 2023 through 2025 (00:50:36)
                                                                                                                                      • A speaker said the city spent about $300 million on capital projects over the three fiscal years, with bond measures the largest funding source (00:53:47)
                                                                                                                                      • A speaker said change orders took an average of 79 days and a median of 35 days to issue, versus the manual's two weeks (00:54:48)
                                                                                                                                      • A speaker said neither Public Works nor Transportation has formally adopted the construction management manual (00:55:52)
                                                                                                                                      • A speaker said change orders on a paving project raised its cost by over 25% without council approval (00:57:55)
                                                                                                                                      • A speaker said $105 million, or 41% of contracted capital spending, went to on-call contracts with no guidance on their use or extensions (00:59:02)
                                                                                                                                      • A speaker said staff often did not follow the manual, including 34 of 65 sampled orders to proceed (01:00:04)
                                                                                                                                      • A speaker said vacancies have been persistently high, with about half of construction management engineer positions vacant (01:01:06)
                                                                                                                                      • A speaker said project information is scattered across several systems with no central project management system (01:02:15)
                                                                                                                                      • A speaker said the city overpaid about $35,000 on seven of 46 projects reviewed, mostly from misapplied markup rates (01:03:19)
                                                                                                                                      • A speaker said invoices took an average of 47 days to pay, though local primes must be paid within 20 days (01:05:21)
                                                                                                                                      • A speaker said late payments on one project cost the city $66,000 in interest (01:06:27)
                                                                                                                                      • A speaker said the city has not adequately overseen Measure KK and Measure U bond funds or done the required annual audits of them (01:07:31)
                                                                                                                                      • A speaker said projects sometimes go to bid before designs are complete because of funding deadlines, and five of 92 change orders could have been avoided (01:08:40)
                                                                                                                                      • A speaker recommended a 10-year capital improvement plan and at least annual progress reports to the council (01:10:35)
                                                                                                                                      • City staff said management agreed or partly agreed with all 17 recommendations and has an implementation plan with target dates (01:12:13)
                                                                                                                                      • City staff said seven recommendations will be addressed by updating the construction management manual by February 2027 (01:13:13)
                                                                                                                                      • City staff said some fixes are done already, including updated payment forms (01:13:13)
                                                                                                                                      • A councilmember asked why capital projects are paid late so often, citing a Finance Committee report of about 55% on time versus 90% for other work (01:15:04)
                                                                                                                                      • City staff said bond-funded payments require an extra independent Treasury Bureau check, which lengthens the process (01:15:35)
                                                                                                                                      • City staff said internal payment timelines might be adjusted once processes improve (01:16:42)
                                                                                                                                      • A councilmember asked whether primes could be required to document payments to subcontractors without undue burden (01:17:32)
                                                                                                                                      • A speaker said an invoice exhibit lists subcontractor payments, and the city is looking at amending its prime contracts to strengthen requirements (01:18:16)
                                                                                                                                      • A councilmember called for one easily accessible place showing the status of each capital project (01:19:10)
                                                                                                                                      • A councilmember asked why the city does not use design-build contracts, arguing they save money and reduce change orders (01:20:08)
                                                                                                                                      • A speaker said Public Works is open to design-build, especially for facilities like fire stations and recreation centers, but it must be chosen at a project's start (01:21:07)
                                                                                                                                      • A speaker warned that bringing every change order to committee would slow projects considerably (01:22:56)
                                                                                                                                      • A councilmember suggested change orders above a dollar threshold, such as $200,000, come back to the council (01:23:09)
                                                                                                                                      • Ready-mix concrete purchases, with sanctuary and border wall waivers (00:34:56)
                                                                                                                                        • City staff said the resolution also covers up to $70,000 for concrete delivered after the prior purchase authority expired (00:36:44)
                                                                                                                                        • City staff said the Oakland market has only two to three providers and a 2025 request for quotes drew none (00:36:44)
                                                                                                                                        • City staff said CalPortland and CEMEX accepted the city's terms, including prevailing wage, but declined the certifications barring ICE detention services and border wall work (00:37:47)
                                                                                                                                        • City staff said the municipal code lets the council waive the two requirements when no reasonable alternatives exist, which staff believe is the case (00:37:47)
                                                                                                                                        • City staff said crews now mix concrete by hand and the in-house ADA curb ramp program is suspended, affecting the capital program and consent decree obligations (00:38:48)
                                                                                                                                        • A councilmember asked what is being done to bring on a third supplier and how many of the suppliers' workers live in Oakland (00:39:58)
                                                                                                                                        • City staff said Sierra Pacific had no plans to reopen its Wood Street plant, and the third-supplier slot keeps the option open (00:40:26)
                                                                                                                                        • City staff said CalPortland could not estimate its Oakland employees, and two limited-duration city concrete finishers would likely be let go in February without concrete (00:41:27)
                                                                                                                                        • A councilmember requested the concrete mix designs for curb and gutter work to see whether a small local company could supply it (00:41:53)
                                                                                                                                        • A councilmember asked why the city adopts sanctuary city and border wall rules if it waives them so often (00:42:25)
                                                                                                                                        • A councilmember said a large contracting reform package being prepared would address those questions (00:42:25)
                                                                                                                                        • A speaker said the city has one concrete mixing truck (00:48:17)
                                                                                                                                        • City staff said the equipment backlog exceeds $50 million, so upgrading the fleet will take a long time (00:48:38)
                                                                                                                                        • East 12th Street Bikeway construction contract (00:08:22)
                                                                                                                                          • City staff said the project closes a one-mile gap in the bikeway network, routing cyclists off International Boulevard at 54th Avenue to Fruitvale BART via East 12th Street (00:10:06)
                                                                                                                                          • City staff listed the improvements, including protected bike lanes, restriping, paving, ADA curb ramps, wayfinding, signal upgrades and traffic calming (00:10:06)
                                                                                                                                          • City staff said four bids came in and McGuire and Hester was the lowest responsible and responsive bidder (00:10:06)
                                                                                                                                          • City staff said the project is funded by an Alameda County Transportation Commission grant, Measure U and gas tax revenue (00:11:09)
                                                                                                                                          • City staff said staff do not expect to use the full 25% change order authority, which helps keep schedule and control costs (00:11:09)
                                                                                                                                          • A speaker asked for the project timeline (00:12:13)
                                                                                                                                          • City staff said construction would likely start in spring 2027, after contracting, and take about a year (00:12:44)
                                                                                                                                          • A councilmember asked staff to explain the contract's local business participation and credited percentages (00:13:02)
                                                                                                                                          • A councilmember asked staff to track and report back on the money that small local businesses receive under the contract (00:14:41)
                                                                                                                                          • A councilmember said the extra cost compared with a lower, non-compliant bid was worth it for local small businesses (00:15:10)
                                                                                                                                          • City staff said change orders are evaluated case by case and typically go to the same subcontractor when existing work must be redone (00:19:35)
                                                                                                                                          • City staff clarified that the whole project, including change orders, must meet the minimum small and local business requirements (00:20:28)
                                                                                                                                          • A speaker said the city has paperwork certifying payments to small local businesses but no oversight function yet, and is piloting tracking software with the housing department (00:20:59)
                                                                                                                                          • A councilmember asked that results of the payment tracking come back to the council (00:22:00)
                                                                                                                                          • Documents: Agenda

                                                                                                                                            Community and Economic Development Committee, Tuesday, October 13

                                                                                                                                            • $50 million in Measure U bond money for affordable housing (01:11:48)
                                                                                                                                              • A speaker read in an amendment making the allocation contingent on the sale of the tranche three bonds and on final project funding legislation (01:14:01)
                                                                                                                                              • A speaker said the request only grants authority to allocate money already approved and appropriated, so it has no new fiscal impact (01:16:06)
                                                                                                                                              • A speaker said the new construction program has committed $180 million, creating more than 1,300 units and helping 468 people out of homelessness (01:17:06)
                                                                                                                                              • City staff said a survey of residents in Homekey and R2H2 housing found that most reported lower stress and better mental health (01:18:47)
                                                                                                                                              • City staff said 10 youth at the Friendly Manor transition-age youth housing, which has 26 units and 52 beds, have found full-time jobs since July (01:20:58)
                                                                                                                                              • A speaker said the last new construction funding round drew 24 applications asking for $424 million, of which the city could fund $144 million (01:22:12)
                                                                                                                                              • A speaker said the pipeline has grown to about 15 to 20 projects with about 1,200 units, needing roughly $350 million (01:22:12)
                                                                                                                                              • A speaker laid out the timeline: the funding round opens in January, awards are expected in March, and projects apply to the state's first round in April (01:23:15)
                                                                                                                                              • A speaker said the health and safety loan fund, which offers interest-free emergency repair loans of up to $250,000 per project, is out of money (01:24:15)
                                                                                                                                              • A speaker gave the expected split of the $50 million: about $35 million for new construction, $5 million each for R2H2 and ACAH, and $2.5 million for administration (01:25:16)
                                                                                                                                              • A councilmember said running out of this money feels like a crisis because affordable housing has not been solved (01:29:23)
                                                                                                                                              • City staff said about another $50 million could follow in a fourth tranche, depending on the biennial budget (01:28:25)
                                                                                                                                              • City staff acknowledged the city will need additional funding sources (01:29:40)
                                                                                                                                              • City staff said tranches one and two spent $248 million out of a Measure U housing figure she gave as $350 million (01:30:09)
                                                                                                                                              • City staff confirmed that both this tranche and a fourth would require bond sales (01:30:38)
                                                                                                                                              • City staff said $30 million of the second tranche went to the acquisition program, run with the Housing Accelerator Fund (01:31:09)
                                                                                                                                              • City staff said buildings bought through the acquisition program get deed restrictions keeping them affordable for 55 years (01:31:09)
                                                                                                                                              • City staff said $7 million is set aside for the next rehabilitation funding round, likely with more in a fourth tranche (01:32:43)
                                                                                                                                              • A councilmember pointed to gaps in East Oakland, with few or no funded projects in Districts 6 and 7 in several programs (01:34:42)
                                                                                                                                              • City staff said the state's high opportunity maps put Oakland at a disadvantage when competing for funding (01:34:58)
                                                                                                                                              • City staff said city money must be leveraged about five to one with state funds and tax credits (01:34:58)
                                                                                                                                              • Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) asked whether developers get extra points for building in certain districts or high-need areas (01:37:20)
                                                                                                                                              • City staff said projects in areas with high displacement pressure get additional points (01:38:37)
                                                                                                                                              • City staff said a racial equity impact analysis was done on the new construction scoring criteria (01:39:36)
                                                                                                                                              • Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) credited the acquisition program, formerly called PATH, with helping East Oakland renters stay in their homes (01:40:02)
                                                                                                                                              • Higher fines for unabated nuisances (02:04:49)
                                                                                                                                                • A councilmember said the $1,000-a-day maximum for many code violations was set in 1968 and no longer deters the worst offenders (02:05:43)
                                                                                                                                                • A councilmember said the target is repeat offenders such as absentee owners of decaying vacant buildings, not people with minor lapses (02:05:43)
                                                                                                                                                • A councilmember said the ordinance keeps an escalating ladder of fines and leaves the City Administrator room to work with offenders (02:06:56)
                                                                                                                                                • Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) asked whether the ordinance covers graffiti, noting that businesses are often the victims of it (02:09:25)
                                                                                                                                                • Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) said some business owners in her district, which has many entertainment venues, have petitioned over enforcement they see as racialized, and asked for case-by-case review (02:10:17)
                                                                                                                                                • A councilmember said the ordinance changes neither the petition process nor enforcement discretion, only the fine amounts (02:10:58)
                                                                                                                                                • A councilmember asked for a comprehensive list of examples of public nuisances before the item reaches the council (02:11:16)
                                                                                                                                                • A councilmember said code enforcement usually gives written notice first, and the goal is to fix problems rather than collect money (02:12:15)
                                                                                                                                                • A councilmember said several chambers of commerce were consulted and support the change (02:13:14)
                                                                                                                                                • Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) asked that council district offices be told when businesses are fined, to stay aware rather than to intervene (02:15:49)
                                                                                                                                                • A speaker said the change gives the city more administrative tools against repeat offenders where court judgments are slow and ineffective (02:17:30)
                                                                                                                                                • A speaker read the amended penalty language, including an annual cap per parcel or structure (02:19:11)
                                                                                                                                                • Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) asked whether the penalty range could be struck down as grossly disproportional under the California constitution (02:20:13)
                                                                                                                                                • A speaker said staff must weigh factors listed in the ordinance, including newly added ones on commercial activity and equity (02:21:29)
                                                                                                                                                • A speaker said a $10,000 penalty for minor blight would be open to legal challenge (02:21:29)
                                                                                                                                                • A councilmember said that adjusted for inflation, $1,000 in 1968 equals about $9,700 today (02:22:40)
                                                                                                                                                • A councilmember urged the administration to publicize the new fines widely, through memos and city social media (02:22:55)
                                                                                                                                                • A speaker said code enforcement has moved this year toward proactive inspections, not only responding to complaints, and has added inspectors (02:24:02)
                                                                                                                                                • City staff clarified that the first amendment read was wrong and only the last two amendments stand (02:26:55)
                                                                                                                                                • Results of the hotel-tax sharing deal with Oakland Roots and Soul (00:50:42)
                                                                                                                                                  • Ashleigh Kanat (Director, Economic & Workforce Development Department) said the agreement shares up to $300,000 of general fund hotel tax collected above the June 2025 level (00:52:36)
                                                                                                                                                  • Ashleigh Kanat (Director, Economic & Workforce Development Department) gave the June 2025 baseline as $1,350,000, to be compared against June 2026 (00:52:36)
                                                                                                                                                  • Ashleigh Kanat (Director, Economic & Workforce Development Department) said the club met all its targets, including landing an official World Cup team base camp (00:53:37)
                                                                                                                                                  • Ashleigh Kanat (Director, Economic & Workforce Development Department) reported about $1,735,000 in hotel tax collected in June 2026 (00:54:41)
                                                                                                                                                  • Ashleigh Kanat (Director, Economic & Workforce Development Department) said the club received $300,000 and the city kept about $80,000 more on top of the baseline (00:55:41)
                                                                                                                                                  • Ashleigh Kanat (Director, Economic & Workforce Development Department) said hotel tax rose 28 percent that month even though the city had five fewer hotels and 360 fewer rooms than a year earlier (00:55:41)
                                                                                                                                                  • Ashleigh Kanat (Director, Economic & Workforce Development Department) cited Visit Oakland figures showing hotel occupancy rose from about 67 percent to 73.6 percent (00:55:41)
                                                                                                                                                  • Ashleigh Kanat (Director, Economic & Workforce Development Department) said the report must be heard by the full council as a public hearing (00:56:52)
                                                                                                                                                  • Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) thanked the club for activating the whole city (00:57:45)
                                                                                                                                                  • Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) noted that larger cities also brought in less revenue than expected because of ticket prices and FIFA policy (00:58:48)
                                                                                                                                                  • Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) asked whether Alameda County and the City of Alameda had similar agreements with the club (00:58:48)
                                                                                                                                                  • City staff said she believed the City of Alameda offered up to $150,000 and the county's role was mainly sheriff and security services (00:59:24)
                                                                                                                                                  • A speaker said the club expects the City of Alameda to share its hotel tax revenue but has not yet received it (00:59:55)
                                                                                                                                                  • A speaker said the county had no similar arrangement and did not help fund the effort (00:59:55)
                                                                                                                                                  • Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) asked whether Oakland has to split hotel tax from the Claremont Hotel with Berkeley (01:01:12)
                                                                                                                                                  • City staff said she believed Oakland receives all of the Claremont's hotel tax despite its Berkeley mailing address, and that she would confirm (01:01:27)
                                                                                                                                                  • A councilmember said the Claremont is legally entirely within Oakland and District 4, though a small part physically falls in Berkeley (01:02:18)
                                                                                                                                                  • A councilmember asked for a breakdown of how District 7 hotels benefited, noting five hotels there have closed (01:03:15)
                                                                                                                                                  • A councilmember raised concern that the club's training facility is in Alameda, so nearby Alameda hotels benefit rather than District 7 (01:03:15)
                                                                                                                                                  • A councilmember said he remained concerned about $700,000 he described as owed to the city and $700,000 owed to Alameda County (01:04:40)
                                                                                                                                                  • City staff said the city has completed the agreement's terms and offered to follow up separately with district-by-district hotel data she had not prepared (01:05:37)
                                                                                                                                                  • Documents: Agenda

                                                                                                                                                    Public Safety Committee, Tuesday, October 13

                                                                                                                                                    • Schedule of outstanding committee items (00:13:32)
                                                                                                                                                      • A councilmember praised an assistant city administrator for leading the work that got the city out of the NSA (00:18:57)
                                                                                                                                                      • A councilmember thanked the same assistant city administrator and joked that she shouldn't answer the phone at 11 PM (00:19:26)
                                                                                                                                                      • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said he had told the Mayor in person that the assistant city administrator was doing a phenomenal job and that the city should keep her (00:19:40)
                                                                                                                                                      • A councilmember agreed with the praise, urged the assistant city administrator not to leave, and moved the item (00:20:16)
                                                                                                                                                      • Police firearm relinquishment grant from Alameda County Superior Court (00:25:11)
                                                                                                                                                        • A speaker said the money traces back to $40 million that the state Judicial Council received in 2022 for firearm relinquishment work, part of which went to the Alameda County Superior Court (00:26:01)
                                                                                                                                                        • A speaker said the program was meant to start in January 2025 but was pushed to July 2025 for lack of resources (00:27:01)
                                                                                                                                                        • A speaker explained that when the department went to invoice, it found the MOU had not been fully executed because it needed City Council approval (00:27:01)
                                                                                                                                                        • A speaker explained that a GVRO is a court order letting law enforcement temporarily remove guns from someone who poses a significant danger to themselves or others, and that people other than police can seek one (00:28:03)
                                                                                                                                                        • A speaker said 65 of Oakland's 67 homicides in 2025 involved a firearm (00:30:03)
                                                                                                                                                        • A speaker said the department dropped the idea of buying a technology integration platform, finding it works better to have staff connect the existing systems themselves (00:31:08)
                                                                                                                                                        • A speaker said the grant covers up to four sworn officers and one professional staff member already in the unit, and requires no added city spending (00:31:08)
                                                                                                                                                        • A speaker said the funding will be used only for GVRO work and for recovering unlawfully held guns, not for broad operations (00:32:18)
                                                                                                                                                        • A councilmember in a video played for the committee, described being alerted to a stash of high-impact weapons and calling James Beere (Chief, Police Department), who came right out; he said the guns were headed for District 3 or 7 (00:33:30)
                                                                                                                                                        • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked staff to explain in public how the funds will be allocated and used, and what the work has accomplished so far (00:34:25)
                                                                                                                                                        • A speaker said part of the funding pays overtime for teams that serve GVROs and remove guns, and that much of that field work hasn't started yet because the department was waiting for the funding to be secured (00:35:22)
                                                                                                                                                        • A speaker said he believed 54 firearms had been recovered so far through the team's work under the initiative (00:36:24)
                                                                                                                                                        • A speaker said the plan is to train officers first and then build an online portal explaining how GVROs work and how to seek one (00:38:11)
                                                                                                                                                        • A councilmember said GVROs can be sought by family members, roommates, employers, coworkers and teachers but are underused, and asked about educating the public and training civilian police staff (00:38:59)
                                                                                                                                                        • A speaker said he didn't have an exact count of GVROs filed, but that usually two or three are in progress at once and each can take months (00:40:29)
                                                                                                                                                        • A councilmember asked about staffing in the department's Ceasefire section, saying her understanding was that it had dropped (00:41:05)
                                                                                                                                                        • A speaker said Ceasefire has about 16 officers, probably half or less of past levels, and that other specialized units are even lower (00:41:23)
                                                                                                                                                        • A councilmember asked whether the reimbursable work is something the department would be doing anyway (00:42:01)
                                                                                                                                                        • A speaker said the reimbursement covers a designated set of staff already in the operations center, while overtime brings in patrol or specialized officers on their days off for field work (00:44:01)
                                                                                                                                                        • A councilmember asked whether the grant is being billed at overtime rates rather than straight time (00:44:23)
                                                                                                                                                        • A speaker said the officers in the office are full-time, and that only field work, such as serving GVROs and enforcement against people barred from having guns, is done on overtime (00:44:35)
                                                                                                                                                        • A speaker said field operations take more resources but less time, for example ten-hour operations with six or eight officers and a sergeant (00:45:04)
                                                                                                                                                        • A councilmember asked whether any of the staff doing this work are civilians or whether all are sworn (00:45:41)
                                                                                                                                                        • A speaker said the grant reimburses one professional staff member and four sworn officers, and that an earlier plan to fully cover one civilian's salary was dropped to leave room for adding more civilian staff (00:45:54)
                                                                                                                                                        • A speaker answered a public speaker by saying the department never resells guns, so forfeited guns are stored and then destroyed, and that it charges no storage fees (00:48:07)
                                                                                                                                                        • Twice-yearly report from the Community Police Review Agency (continued) (00:20:27)
                                                                                                                                                          • A speaker said he had a slide presentation ready, but the City Attorney's office told him that day he couldn't present it because it hadn't been attached to the agenda in writing, and offered to give it aloud or reschedule (00:21:20)
                                                                                                                                                          • A councilmember proposed rescheduling to the next committee meeting, since the director had lost his voice, with materials due by the 17th (00:21:54)
                                                                                                                                                          • A speaker said he had earlier given the committee a draft of the agency's 2025 annual report and had brought copies of the final report to share (00:22:20)
                                                                                                                                                          • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked whether the annual report is available digitally and could be added to the agenda report; the reply was that it is on the agency's website and can be added (00:23:37)
                                                                                                                                                          • Documents: Agenda

                                                                                                                                                            Rules and Legislation Committee, Thursday, October 15

                                                                                                                                                            • Committee recommendations sent to the October 20 City Council (00:12:56)
                                                                                                                                                              • The city clerk read the committee's amendments to the parking citation contract, which limit the extension to June 30, 2027 and call for other vendor options (00:12:56)
                                                                                                                                                              • The city clerk noted the capital improvement program audit goes to the October 20 Council as a non-consent item (00:15:03)
                                                                                                                                                              • The city clerk noted the Roots and Soul hotel-tax sharing report goes to the October 20 Council as a public hearing (00:16:08)
                                                                                                                                                              • The city clerk read the Measure U amendment making the housing funding contingent on the sale of Tranche 3 bonds (00:16:08)
                                                                                                                                                              • The city clerk read the nuisance penalty amendment replacing $1,000 with $2,500 (00:18:11)
                                                                                                                                                              • The city clerk noted the police review agency report was continued to the October 27 Public Safety Committee (00:18:11)
                                                                                                                                                              • A councilmember summarized the changes to item 3 before the vote: title changes on 3.3 and 3.4, and a co-sponsor added to 3.10 (00:19:43)
                                                                                                                                                              • Documents: Agenda

                                                                                                                                                                This episode was produced with AI from the public recording of the meeting. Links to the source are in the show notes.

                                                                                                                                                                Report an error · This episode's page

                                                                                                                                                                12 min