I often fantasize about owning an island paradise. No taxes, zero traffic and I make all the laws? Sign me up! Unless it's Gaiola Island. This idyllic island off the coast of Naples, Italy kills, maims or otherwise destroys the lives of anyone who lives there for too long. From nameless hermits to the world's richest men, the island spares no one. What caused this powerful curse? Listen and learn before you book that trip to Italy!

Support the show

A little more history than haunt today, though this chick is responsible for more than her fair share of haunts. Locusta of Gaul was an ancient Roman poisoner whose body count ranged in the hundreds or possibly thousands. She was a weapon of mass destruction in her own right and is believed to be the world's first serial killer. Listen and learn how she did it and why.

Support the show

Everyone knows about the Bates Motel but way before that, Morse Mill Hotel made murderous innkeepers fashionable. You may never have heard of the place, or of Bertha Gifford but both hold an honored place in America's haunted history. Bertha was one of America's first female serial killers and the Morse Mill Hotel was where she committed her crimes...with chocolate.

Support the show

The name Edgar Allan Poe is synonymous with darkness and horror. Dude invented the detective novel, after all. If he were alive, he might have written and solved his own death. As it stands, the mystery remains unsolved. Though multiple theories exist, the one that's most likely responsible for the death of one of the most influential writers in American history happened on Election Day of 1849. Listen and decide how you think it all went down.

Support the show

Do you enjoy a good Halloween haunted house? You know, the kind that's super scary but that you know you'll actually be safe in? But how do you know for sure that you're safe? Today we look at some Halloween haunted houses that people have died your been injured in, including the most famous of all, McKamey Manor!

Listen on: Apple Podcasts   Spotify

Support the show

One October day 128 years ago, Zona Heaster fell in love at first sight with a strapping blacksmith named Trout Shue. Their whirlwind romance would end in murder. The twist? The case was solved by the ghost of the victim. Or was it?

Listen on: Apple Podcasts   Spotify

Support the show

Listen on: Apple Podcasts   Spotify

Support the show

For years, detached human feet have been washing up on the shores of the Salish Sea, grossing everyone out and ruining their vacations. Why does this keep happening and where are all those feet coming from? Scientists have and (unsatisfying) answer.

Support the show

Since it first opened to the public in 1971, Round Valley Reservoir has claimed dozens of lives...and kept many of the bodies. Why is this lake so bloodthirsty and why won't it return the dead to their loved ones? Some believe it's nature, while others believe its vengeful spirits to blame. Listen and decide for yourself!

Listen on: Apple Podcasts   Spotify

Support the show

Some things are worse than death. And sometimes Buffalo Bill is a real guy with a doctor's title. Learn about the atrocities that occurred at the Wyoming Frontier Prison and the dude who turned an inmate into his own macabre version of high fashion.

Listen on: Apple Podcasts   Spotify

Support the show