Erin and Hailey interview hosts Ryan and Erik by asking them questions about the podcast.

Social media manager Erin discusses the crazy events of the 1904 Olympic marathon. Ryan review the funny but highly implausible story of a pit known as "Mel's Hole."

Erik explains the story of the infamous "Watcher House" that supposedly had a stalker eyeing the house. Guest star Hailey revisits her topic from Season 2, and gives an update on the newly identified "Boy in the Box."

Ryan reviews three funny festivals held each year in the United States. Returning guest speaker Erin discusses the odd history of swallowing goldfish.

Ryan discusses the urban legend known as Slenderman. Erik reviews the grisly murders committed in London by the infamous Jack the Ripper.

Ryan explains the story behind the Virginia-based urban legend known as Bunny Man.  Erik discusses the canine mysteries of the Overton Bridge.

Erik explains the story of the threatening anonymous letters sent to a couple in Circleville.  Ryan reviews the strange circumstances behind the death of Edgar Allan Poe.

Ryan reviews the history of the underground mine fire that is responsible for the end of Centralia.  Erik explains the strange story of the disappearance of Walter Collins, and the reappearance of a boy falsely claiming to be Walter.

Erik explains the origins of the famous mysterious rock monument known as Stonehenge.  Ryan discusses the story and explanations of Nisaeg, a Scottish monster known much more commonly by a different name.

Ryan kicks off Season 3 by explaining the puzzles posted online by an unknown user known as "3301."  Erik discusses the odd and unexplained giant rock heads on Easter Island.