Christmas isn’t all sugarplums and reindeer. Nick and Mike dive into the chilling tales of Krampus, the goat-demon, and Iceland’s Yule Cat, the fashion-policing feline. Spoiler: Both are terrifying.

Join Nick and special guest Rich, host of The Wampa Diaries, as they dive into the Amityville Horror—a story so full of creepy vibes and questionable decisions that it's basically a DIY guide to ruining your life in 28 days. From haunted houses and creepy priests to poltergeist-style slime and glowing pig demons, this episode covers all the supernatural drama you didn’t ask for but totally deserve. Buckle up for a deep dive into one of the most famous ghost stories in American history—because why not?

Dive into the chilling tale of history’s most infamous “vampire,” Elizabeth Bathory, as Nick and Anya dissect the blood-soaked legend behind the countess who put Transylvania on the map for all the wrong reasons.

This week Nick and Anya team up with Dave Prescott from Cryptid Cocktail Party to dive into the legend of the Skinwalker, the Southwest’s favorite nightmare fuel. If you’ve ever wondered what lurks in the desert (hint: it’s not just coyotes), this episode’s got you covered. From shape-shifting witches with attitude problems to the notoriously creepy Skinwalker Ranch, we break down why your next road trip through Utah might come with an unwanted, uh...tour guide. Grab a drink and get ready to question every rustle in the bushes.

Today, we’re looking at a ghost who didn't just make an appearance but held full-on conversations. Nick and Anya recount the strange, often disturbing voice that haunted the Bell family, unraveling whether the infamous Bell Witch was a curse, a local legend, or an elaborate hoax.

Join Nick and Anya, along with returning friend of the show Jack, as we dive into the bizarre love life of David Huggins. From his first encounter with extraterrestrial beings at age 8 to his ongoing relationship with a cosmic companion named Crescent, Huggins’ story is equal parts wild and weird. We’ll explore his claims of hybrid children, his haunting paintings, and the cultural impact of his life’s work—plus, we’ll unpack the skeptics and believers in the world of UFOs. Buckle up for a journey that’s out of this world!