Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they attend the state basketball championship in Raleigh!

Don’t forget to subscribe and rate the podcast on itunes or any of your favorite podcatchers!  Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, Twitter, and TikTok at @onwednesdayspod, follow us on Spotify at Nostalgic Millennials, or email us at [email protected].

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they try to figure out their date situation for the basketball banquet.  Highlights include: don’t mess with Whitey’s legacy, don’t go to college kids, we should write a book, workshopping new ship names, Tim welfare updates, the most confident sophomore on the planet, this show is messy and stupid but somehow we’re still here, THIS IS GOD’S STRIP CLUB!,  and more!

Don’t forget to subscribe and rate the podcast on itunes or any of your favorite podcatchers!  Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, Twitter, and TikTok at @onwednesdayspod, follow us on Spotify at Nostalgic Millennials, or email us at [email protected].

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they wonder how all these high schoolers managed to get out of school to be at the TART fashion show. Highlights include: The Killers don't get enough credit for how good they are, being aggressively millennial, ANTM peaked in cycle 7, good saves by 18 year-old fathers-to-be, derek is doing all of the home security tasks we've been wishing peyton and larry would do, and more! 

Don’t forget to subscribe and rate the podcast on itunes or any of your favorite podcatchers!  Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, Twitter, and TikTok at @onwednesdayspod, follow us on Spotify at Nostalgic Millennials, or email us at [email protected].

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they make dubious life choices with teachers and strange men in Cadillacs.  Highlights include: Nirvana was not a regular on Sesame Street, the door is shut and locked for the first time in Peyton’s life, I didn’t hate it because I like it…, how much is Tree Hill paying their teachers?, how has no one called Larry yet?, Gigi and Mouth are here to remind us we’re still in high school, Jessi guesses stuff too early in the season, Dan got rid of his mental breakdown hair, Whitey’s only purpose it to torture Dan Scott, it’s finally a car crash that doesn’t involve the Scott brothers…, and more!

Don’t forget to subscribe and rate the podcast on itunes or any of your favorite podcatchers!  Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, Twitter, and TikTok at @onwednesdayspod, follow us on Spotify at Nostalgic Millennials, or email us at [email protected].

Trigger Warning: Stalking, Assault

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they create the definitive Scary Derek threat-o-meter.  Highlights include: they absolutely played Warp Tour, leave me alone you aren’t my husband!, no time for Gavin we’ve got shit to do, being reminded that these are teenagers who got married, going from zero to Scary Derek in 2 episodes, the pregnancy news knocked the psychopath out of Rachel real quick, using old headshots for new props, we can finally verify someone’s age on this show, red flags with Jessi, imitating real human feelings, the return of the Voldemort hug, thank you Rizzoli and/or Isles, the levels of Scary Derek, the best day of Dan’s life was signing a basketball paper, John Tucker is more of a model than this guy, it is a scene in this TV show…, she’s a literal sour patch kid, if only this change of heart had killed Dan, Whitey’s gonna be a grandpa!, we are at level 4 Scary Derek, THAT BOY HAS A HEART CONDITION!!, the kind of brother energy that Peyton deserves, this is a lot of trauma for a teenager without a therapist, speaking of Everwood…, the tangent to end all tangents, LIZZO FOR ALL FIVE MUSES, and more!

Don’t forget to subscribe and rate the podcast on itunes or any of your favorite podcatchers!  Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, Twitter, and TikTok at @onwednesdayspod, follow us on Spotify at Nostalgic Millennials, or email us at [email protected].

Trigger Warning: discussion of abortion

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they try to stay friends while talking about the timeline of a 17 year old TV show.  Highlights include:  mmm runny ketchup, evil Deb is here in full force, ill advised intervention guest lists, Hayley learns so much information in 30 seconds, an unwelcome reminder that Maxim exists, the early 2000’s were bad guys…, his final project is all over his hotel wall, Lion King logistics, no one with the last name Scott gets a motorcycle, that’s not how patient-doctor confidentiality works Danny!, not Dan Scott’s son thinking he’s invicible, …and I’m going to quote myself here…, uncomfortably timely plot points, the first selfie to ever exist, Rachel’s gonna Rachel, scary Derek intensifies, Chris Keller is getting thrown under the bus for a man who’s work is done, sorry dad!, you can’t bullshit a bullshitter, too many sociopaths live in this town, we think this lady might be a bad therapist, in what world is that wig PERFECT?, Brody revolts against the time line talk, and more!

Don’t forget to subscribe and rate the podcast on itunes or any of your favorite podcatchers!  Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, Twitter, and TikTok at @onwednesdayspod, follow us on Spotify at Nostalgic Millennials, or email us at [email protected].

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they call Ben out for not listening to their podcast.  Highlights include:  Jessi doesn’t trust this mother fucker, he doesn’t stay great, everyone has fully transitioned into their season 4 hair, some might say she’s glowing, this is why Hayley is the smart one, they had to up their banter game to keep things light, Daniel Marjorie Scott listen up!, and the best part is he’ll never know, Whitey gives his crappiest pep talk, Gigi is THRILLED, she’s made it to senior year of Dan Scott’s villainy school, Mouth just needs to slowly back away from the hot mess, god forbid Whitey keep you down, it was the exact same moment but different, who is fucking up royally and why will it be Lucas?, a troublingly sincere moment from Dan, Bevin needs you to keep it on the BLT, YOU CAN’T KILL GHOSTS DANNY, a fun episode despite how it ends, Jessi had no help from Buzzfeed past, A+ trash talk, they need a sharknado to bridge the gap between air and water based killings, he’s hot in a sickly early 2000’s way, Brody’s escape route plans, and more!

Don’t forget to subscribe and rate the podcast on itunes or any of your favorite podcatchers!  Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, Twitter, and TikTok at @onwednesdayspod, follow us on Spotify at Nostalgic Millennials, or email us at [email protected].

Join Caitlin, Brody, and Jessi as they use their precious in-person friend time to watch and discuss the 2006 teen rom-com classic John Tucker Must Die, starring Sophia Bush, Arielle Kebbel, Ashanti, Brittany Snow, Jesse Metcalfe, and Penn Badgely.  Highlights include: live from Minnesota it’s Saturday afternoon!, it doesn’t get more early 2000’s than this cast, Jessi fails at spelling words wrong, Taylor Kitsch has cookies!, the MILF-iest of movie MILFs, narc means narcolepsy right?, Jesse Metcalf aka season 1 Nathan Scott aka brunette basketball boy, the hottest thing on two legs in 2006, she must be important because she has lines, wink wink nudge nudge PENIS JOKE, this movie turned me us into bored goth girls, this is not Harry Styles fanfiction, Pam’s here!, half naked and nervous, no Maria Menounos pre-movie trivia, the 2006 hotness will protect her from chemical burns, the soundtrack is the best part of this movie, it was an airborne teabagging, the return of the hallmark significant look, chaotic bisexual Brooke Davis, slut is stuck on truck, is John Tucker Dan Scott??, the most 2006 sentence ever committed to the internet, and more!

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they try to weasel their way back into Brooke Davis’s life.  Highlights include: we don’t know them, the universe interrupting Peyton’s bad decisions, spending a 2nd season being completely stressed out, welcome to watching One Tree Hill, just Brooke and an ugly Posh Spice mug, bombarding a man that has been lucid for 3 minutes, enjoying every minute of watching Dan’s downfall, interior design opinions from Skills, everything sounds like white girl drama, committed to the mystery, high Deb is so mean, Lucas learned well from his Daddy Uncle Keith, we don’t talk about the timeline BUUUUUUT…, leaving the wedding planning to jesus, know what this town doesn’t need? More firearms, murderer is the new Sunkist, Peyton’s podcast walked so we could run, the longest 48 hours ever, a quick shot of Dan Scott be creepin’, everyone in this town is a stalker, she needs a back hoe to burry these feelings, the metaphor stands, writing an Anna-Peyton-Jake love triangle for the HBO remake, level 10 brood, is it wild prediction time?, and more!

Don’t forget to subscribe and rate the podcast on itunes or any of your favorite podcatchers!  Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, Twitter, and TikTok at @onwednesdayspod, follow us on Spotify at Nostalgic Millennials, or email us at [email protected].

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they try to wash dry paint off their living room wall.  Highlights include: trying new things for the new season, blub-blub-blub, getting a second chance to watch the season 3 finale, everyone gets to jump in the hepatitis filled water!, Nathan was NOT doggy paddling just fine, we understand the metaphor but that doesn’t make it smart, ghost baby Keith got a haircut, Dan seems super chill and fine, Skills is here to keep things light, scared him to death!, Tree Hill ER needs to step it up, just a little sprinkle of PTSD, not dead yet, Luke is on thin fucking ice, thus endeth Brucus part deux, onlyfans is officially back, lol what restraining order?, even more questions about what 2006 money was like, no one who ended up in that hospital is okay, maybe it’s a TV show?, and more!

Don’t forget to subscribe and rate the podcast on itunes or any of your favorite podcatchers!  Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, Twitter, and TikTok at @onwednesdayspod, follow us on Spotify at Nostalgic Millennials, or email us at [email protected].