5 Star Tossers

One Babel After Another: Walter Benjamin Finds Meme-ing


Listen Later

Dear, surviving, audient: how is it hanging?

We\I sympathize.

If you were looking to art as an answer, hoping for some revolutionary frameworks, or just plain ol' solace inside --

            -- I'm afraid most of the pod's going to tell you to keep looking.

In this one we watched 2 "political" movies released this year: Ari Aster's Eddington and Paul Thomas Anderson's One Battle After Another.

More generally, the 2 movies raised the question of what it means to involve politics in a movie. Jake took this as an excuse to geek out on Grad school vibes and do a deep dive into Walter Benjamin's attempts to save aesthetics from the khaki schmattes of Communism.

Who said Marx Grudge?

Benjamin does brandish an interesting, rather Derridian, analytic tool in the distinction between allegory and the symbol; which I will anger Jake and summarize here as analogous (allegorical?!) to a movie whose special effects are shot on set with actual props, and the one where the effects are all programmed in (as CGI). Like shooting props, the allegory foregrounds its technicity, while the symbol will claim the harmony of form-function and content. 

Except the symbol doesn't work anymore. Like the pathetic attempt poor Andy had to suffer through, where the reinvented "Superman" is called-upon to white-wash the Gaza genocide (still a western debacle). The symbol rang so hollow it gave Andy bowel issues. 

(Editor's note:) We will NOT be getting into that.

Of course, the allegory's very apparatus makes it susceptible to Capitalist manipulations. This is where we take a more specific tack on Anderson's film: shot and directed, deliberately, in my opinion, as a post-fascist account of how pathetic and hopeless revolutions are, how revolutionaries are either posers or self-deceiving cucks.

And here is Anderson's genius, in recognizing the capitalist tentacles have already infiltrated all discourse -- which is a panicked, exhausted discourse these days (on "the left") -- "over-technicizing" allegory into social media reels and internet memes. His account gives the melancholia of a post-fascist winner looking back at history: disjointed, often accompanied by a (never happy or energetic or really calm) soundtrack, the characters are mostly isolated with superficial thoughts and relationships... it is the sad sigh of a fulfilled Sklavenmoral.

There was more tossed around, of course. Fair warning.

STARS: Marx Grudge (grudgingly); Beast & Sovereign... but really, all the Stars were there: the Il vaut mieux with differance; the Pervs R' Us with melancholy, the WWJD with 'Manifest Destiny'...

P.S. 

We have an official email address ([email protected]), for you, dear audient, to vent; a kind of a complaint/feedback box. We will collect the complaints (/corrections/disputes) to an episode where we address your mirror of our stupidities. 

5ST



...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

5 Star TossersBy 5 Star Tossers

  • 4.4
  • 4.4
  • 4.4
  • 4.4
  • 4.4

4.4

7 ratings


More shows like 5 Star Tossers

View all
The Joe Rogan Experience by Joe Rogan

The Joe Rogan Experience

229,657 Listeners

Real Time with Bill Maher by HBO Podcasts

Real Time with Bill Maher

16,359 Listeners

Matt and Shane's Secret Podcast by Matt McCusker & Shane Gillis

Matt and Shane's Secret Podcast

11,532 Listeners

The Tim Dillon Show by The Tim Dillon Show

The Tim Dillon Show

12,993 Listeners

The Adam Friedland Show by The Adam Friedland Show

The Adam Friedland Show

10,562 Listeners

This Past Weekend w/ Theo Von by Theo Von

This Past Weekend w/ Theo Von

28,039 Listeners

The Daily by The New York Times

The Daily

113,035 Listeners

Why Theory by Why Theory

Why Theory

582 Listeners

Bad Friends by Bobby Lee & Andrew Santino

Bad Friends

14,544 Listeners

Fly on the Wall with Dana Carvey and David Spade by Audacy

Fly on the Wall with Dana Carvey and David Spade

12,881 Listeners