The first major disagreement of the episode emerges as the guys debate the true ranking of a Columbus Blue Jackets sniper.

Mark and Justin find common ground in the mid-tier, agreeing on three players in the exact same order, including a dynamic duo from the Utah Mammoth.

The debates heat up as the hosts discuss players on the cusp of the top 10, including a Canadiens star with 50-goal potential and a uniquely physical Capitals forward.

The lists diverge significantly as the hosts make their cases for who belongs in the elite top 10.

The hosts discuss the same group of elite players but shuffle the order based on playoff performance versus regular-season dominance.

Mark and Justin align perfectly for the pinnacle of the right winger position, crowning the undisputed king and wrapping up the series.

In this episode of Overtime Hockey Talk, we dive into our much-anticipated list of the top 25 left wingers for the upcoming NHL season. We discuss our criteria for player rankings, the challenges of positional designations, and how recent performances and potential future impacts have influenced our choices. Key players like Clayton Keller, Alexander Ovechkin, Jason Robertson, and Kirill Kaprizov are analyzed in-depth, with arguments for their rankings in our lists. Join us for a thorough breakdown of elite talent and hockey insights.

01:51 Ranking the Top 25 Left Wingers

In this episode of Overtime Hockey Talk, we dive into our ranking of the top 25 centers in the NHL. We recap our recent lists of top goalies and defenders, and then debate the criteria for ranking centers, considering positions and fantasy value. We discuss notable players who just missed the cut, including Robert Thomas and Mika Zibanejad, and then count down our top 25 centers. Discussions include analysis of Sidney Crosby’s potential trade value, Auston Matthews' health concerns, and the breakout potential of Connor Bedard and Jack Hughes. We also preview our upcoming episodes focusing on right and left wingers.

Follow us on X! @OTHockeyTalk

00:00 Introduction and Overview

We discuss their top 25 NHL defensemen for the upcoming 2025-2026 season. The episode dives into various criteria for ranking, including fantasy value, team talent, and overall skill. We examine players like Chris Tanev, Lane Hudson, and Thomas Harley, debating their placement based on past performance and future potential. The episode concludes with the top 10 defensemen, highlighting notable names such as Adam Fox, Victor Hedman, and Rasmus Dahlin.

01:45 Criteria for Ranking Defensemen

Ranking NHL Goalies: Top 20 Breakdown

We dive into their offseason rankings of the top 20 goaltenders in the NHL. We review past rankings from 2019 and discuss the significant shifts in their evaluations. We share our methods for determining their rankings, considering factors like team defense changes, individual performance, and fantasy implications. Key debates include the performances and potential of goalies like John Gibson, Juuse Saros, and Ilya Sorokin. We also highlight the influence of team dynamics and playoff performances on their rankings.

00:00 Introduction and Hosts

We discuss the recent developments in the NHL playoffs, specifically focusing on the Toronto Maple Leafs vs. Florida Panthers game. They analyze the thrilling match, discuss the players' performances, and speculate on the potential outcomes of the series. We also delve into other playoff series, including Winnipeg vs. Dallas, Edmonton Oilers vs. Vegas Golden Knights, and Carolina Hurricanes vs. Washington Capitals. We examine key players, strategies, and possible game outcomes. Additionally, the episode touches on the recent NHL draft lottery results, the implications for the New York Islanders and Detroit Red Wings, and the mutual parting of ways between the Los Angeles Kings and their GM, Rob Blake.

00:23 Leafs vs Panthers: A Thrilling Game Recap

Brad joins us from the Undrafted Hockey Podcast for an in-depth discussion on the ongoing NHL Playoffs.

You can find the Undrafted Hockey Podcast here!

⏰⏰Chapters⏰⏰

01:03 Edmonton vs LA Analysis

We jump into the opening games of the NHL playoffs. We discuss player performances, potential series outcomes, and key player injuries. We also touch on recent NHL coaching changes, firings, and potential hires, including the Seattle Kraken, Anaheim Ducks, and New York Islanders' search for new leadership.

We dive into detailed previews and predictions for the 2025 NHL Stanley Cup Playoff series. This episode focuses on the remaining four series: Winnipeg Jets vs. St. Louis Blues, Vegas Golden Knights vs. Minnesota Wild, Tampa Bay Lightning vs. Florida Panthers, and Toronto Maple Leafs vs. Ottawa Senators. We analyze team performances, key players, and potential outcomes as they predict which teams will advance. Special attention is given to notable players, strategic elements, and how previous playoff experiences may influence this year’s results. The episode also briefly discusses notable injuries and player impacts, and the goalkeeping challenges that teams might face.

03:18 Winnipeg Jets vs. St. Louis Blues

We dive deep into the first round of the NHL playoffs. We preview the three series that we know will happen plus we throw in Washington Capitals vs Montreal Canadiens because we like to predict the future.

03:14 Los Angeles Kings vs. Edmonton Oilers