A mother insists her child already called.
At first, Jamie assumes it’s memory loss. Dementia. Stress. Maybe exhaustion.
Then the conversations start containing things Jamie never told anyone.
Private details. Events that haven’t happened yet. Memories Jamie doesn’t have.
And after their mother dies, the family finally admits something they’ve known since Jamie was five:
There may have always been two of them.
“She Said I Already Called” is a psychological supernatural horror story about memory, identity, family secrets, and the terrifying possibility that the person living your life may not be the original.
Pagan’s Scary Stories — Season 5, Episode 2.
Written and created by Robert Jerome Pagan.
Featuring Dr. J.
Listener discretion advised.


Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/pagan-s-scary-stories--6784124/support.

Pagan’s Scary Stories is an original scripted horror anthology created and written by Robert Jerome Pagan. Produced by RJPC Studios LLC and RJPC Studios Audio. Stories featured on this program are works of fiction unless otherwise noted. Names, characters, places, events, and incidents may be fictionalized. This program may contain strong language, disturbing themes, violence, death, psychological horror, and other material intended for mature audiences. Listener discretion is advised. © 2026 RJPC Studios LLC. All Rights Reserved. Pagan’s Scary Stories
Some stories follow you home.

Season Five of Pagan’s Scary Stories begins.
Some things follow you no matter how many times you move.
“The Man Who Kept Moving” is narrated by Jean-Paul Boucher, presented by The Story Keeper, and written and directed by Robert Jerome Pagan.
A new season of original scary stories begins here.

Author / creator: Robert Jerome Pagan
Narrator: Jean-Paul Boucher
Presented by: The Story Keeper
Copyright: © 2026 RJPC Studios LLC


Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/pagan-s-scary-stories--6784124/support.

Pagan’s Scary Stories is an original scripted horror anthology created and written by Robert Jerome Pagan. Produced by RJPC Studios LLC and RJPC Studios Audio. Stories featured on this program are works of fiction unless otherwise noted. Names, characters, places, events, and incidents may be fictionalized. This program may contain strong language, disturbing themes, violence, death, psychological horror, and other material intended for mature audiences. Listener discretion is advised. © 2026 RJPC Studios LLC. All Rights Reserved. Pagan’s Scary Stories
Some stories follow you home.

Mariah Carey can wait. 🎃The Story Keeper has returned.Pagan’s Scary Stories — Season 5 begins TONIGHT at 9 PM Pacific / Midnight Eastern with an all-new original story.New nightmares. New voices. And we’re not stopping until the end of the year.🎧 Listen on Spreaker and all major podcast platforms.#PagansScaryStories #HorrorPodcast #ScaryStories #Horror #Podcast #StoryKeeper

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/pagan-s-scary-stories--6784124/support.

Pagan’s Scary Stories is an original scripted horror anthology created and written by Robert Jerome Pagan. Produced by RJPC Studios LLC and RJPC Studios Audio. Stories featured on this program are works of fiction unless otherwise noted. Names, characters, places, events, and incidents may be fictionalized. This program may contain strong language, disturbing themes, violence, death, psychological horror, and other material intended for mature audiences. Listener discretion is advised. © 2026 RJPC Studios LLC. All Rights Reserved. Pagan’s Scary Stories
Some stories follow you home.

Turn off the lights… and turn on the dark. Tonight’s episode of Pagan’s Scary Stories explores a fear we all remember: Checking under the bed. But what happens…
when something is already there? This story dives into the quiet dread of being watched, the weight of silence in a dark room, and the moment you realize— 👉 You were never alone. 🕯️ Listener discretion advised.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/pagan-s-scary-stories--6784124/support.

Pagan’s Scary Stories is an original scripted horror anthology created and written by Robert Jerome Pagan. Produced by RJPC Studios LLC and RJPC Studios Audio. Stories featured on this program are works of fiction unless otherwise noted. Names, characters, places, events, and incidents may be fictionalized. This program may contain strong language, disturbing themes, violence, death, psychological horror, and other material intended for mature audiences. Listener discretion is advised. © 2026 RJPC Studios LLC. All Rights Reserved. Pagan’s Scary Stories
Some stories follow you home.

Turn off the lights… and turn on the dark. We reached the Spires expecting ruins.
What we found was breathing metal. The structures pulsed at 18 Hz — an infrasonic rhythm that vibrated vision, warped gravity, and turned the air into ionized static. The jungle stopped behaving like nature and started acting like circuitry. Copper-veined fungi wired themselves into obsidian altars. Rain levitated. Dinosaurs flickered in and out of existence. Then the Abelisaur performed the ritual. Its sonic bursts ignited the bio-metallic pillars in ghost-blue light. The frequency intensified. Half the team dissolved into grey mist. The rest began humming in perfect unison — no longer explorers… but antennas. The Spires weren’t ruins.
They were a motherboard.
And we were the sacrifice. This is Entry: The Ritual. Pagan Scary Stories
A Paranormal Salad Sorbet Stay safe. Stay sane. And keep the lights on.
www.paranormalsalad.com

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/pagan-s-scary-stories--6784124/support.

Pagan’s Scary Stories is an original scripted horror anthology created and written by Robert Jerome Pagan. Produced by RJPC Studios LLC and RJPC Studios Audio. Stories featured on this program are works of fiction unless otherwise noted. Names, characters, places, events, and incidents may be fictionalized. This program may contain strong language, disturbing themes, violence, death, psychological horror, and other material intended for mature audiences. Listener discretion is advised. © 2026 RJPC Studios LLC. All Rights Reserved. Pagan’s Scary Stories
Some stories follow you home.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/pagan-s-scary-stories--6784124/support.

Pagan’s Scary Stories is an original scripted horror anthology created and written by Robert Jerome Pagan. Produced by RJPC Studios LLC and RJPC Studios Audio. Stories featured on this program are works of fiction unless otherwise noted. Names, characters, places, events, and incidents may be fictionalized. This program may contain strong language, disturbing themes, violence, death, psychological horror, and other material intended for mature audiences. Listener discretion is advised. © 2026 RJPC Studios LLC. All Rights Reserved. Pagan’s Scary Stories
Some stories follow you home.

Four years ago, Pagan Scary Stories began with one mission: to tell the stories that linger in the dark… the ones people whisper about, but rarely say out loud. Three years later, that mission grew into something bigger—
an entire universe of audio dramas, voices, and worlds. To celebrate both milestones, we’re bringing you a special crossover event from RJPC Audio: Magdalene: Part 3 — The Revolution. Three days changed the world.
Two legacies tore it apart. Before the cathedrals, before the gold, before the laws of Rome—there was a garden… and a secret. This immersive audio drama explores the explosive collision between Mary Magdalene, the visionary “Apostle to the Apostles,” and Peter—the man who would build the Church in stone. While one fought to preserve a revolution of the heart…
the other began shaping a system that would echo for two thousand years. This isn’t just a story.
It’s a question: What if something sacred was buried… on purpose? Featuring a global cast of voice actors and cinematic sound design, this is one of the most powerful chapters in the RJPC Audio catalog. 🎧 If you enjoy this episode, listen to Parts 1 and 2 of Magdalene.
📡 Explore more at RJPCTV.com
🔥 And stay tuned—because the story doesn’t end here.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/pagan-s-scary-stories--6784124/support.

Pagan’s Scary Stories is an original scripted horror anthology created and written by Robert Jerome Pagan. Produced by RJPC Studios LLC and RJPC Studios Audio. Stories featured on this program are works of fiction unless otherwise noted. Names, characters, places, events, and incidents may be fictionalized. This program may contain strong language, disturbing themes, violence, death, psychological horror, and other material intended for mature audiences. Listener discretion is advised. © 2026 RJPC Studios LLC. All Rights Reserved. Pagan’s Scary Stories
Some stories follow you home.

"THEY WERE HARVESTING THE GOD NOTE." 🦖🔊We’ve crossed into the "Dead Zone" of the Amazon, and reality is officially breaking. In Part 3 of our Pagan Scary Stories special, we uncover the Basalt Canyons—Chloe’s team is no longer human; they are "vibrating meat." Between the Abelisaurid ghost that cracks glass with a growl and the discovery of ancient acoustic chambers shaped like giant ears, the "Sonic Magic" is taking hold. Why were ancient priests using obsidian tuning forks on prehistoric beasts? And why is Chloe seeing a version of herself dressed in "Singing Bone" watching from the ridges?Your digital sensors will lie to you. Your water tastes like electronics. The vibration is shaking the atoms of our being into a higher state of entropy. We aren't just exploring the canyon—we’re being refined by it.



Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/pagan-s-scary-stories--6784124/support.

Pagan’s Scary Stories is an original scripted horror anthology created and written by Robert Jerome Pagan. Produced by RJPC Studios LLC and RJPC Studios Audio. Stories featured on this program are works of fiction unless otherwise noted. Names, characters, places, events, and incidents may be fictionalized. This program may contain strong language, disturbing themes, violence, death, psychological horror, and other material intended for mature audiences. Listener discretion is advised. © 2026 RJPC Studios LLC. All Rights Reserved. Pagan’s Scary Stories
Some stories follow you home.

The story wasn’t buried.
It was waiting. After the discovery beneath the Welsh mountain, the truth begins to surface—and it’s far worse than legend ever warned. The gold was never treasure. The book was never meant to be read. And the thing tied to it… does not forget. In this final chapter, the counting continues.
And once it starts… it doesn’t stop. This is not folklore.
This is not luck. This is a reckoning.

Follow Pagan’s Scary Stories for weekly drops of dark folklore and original horror. Part 1 is available now if you haven’t heard how it began…

🎧 Listen with headphones. Lights off recommended. 

🔑 TAGS leprechaun, dark folklore, welsh mythology, horror podcast, scary stories, paranormal podcast, cursed objects, ancient legends, creepy stories, pagan scary stories, paranormal salad, irish folklore dark, supernatural horror, audio horror, storytelling podcast

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/pagan-s-scary-stories--6784124/support.

Pagan’s Scary Stories is an original scripted horror anthology created and written by Robert Jerome Pagan. Produced by RJPC Studios LLC and RJPC Studios Audio. Stories featured on this program are works of fiction unless otherwise noted. Names, characters, places, events, and incidents may be fictionalized. This program may contain strong language, disturbing themes, violence, death, psychological horror, and other material intended for mature audiences. Listener discretion is advised. © 2026 RJPC Studios LLC. All Rights Reserved. Pagan’s Scary Stories
Some stories follow you home.

There are hills in Wales that do not like to be disturbed. When a forgotten tomb is uncovered beneath Moel Hebog, Professor Gareth Vaughan believes he’s about to rewrite history. Instead, he opens something far older than folklore… and far less forgiving. Inside the chamber: no bones. No relics.
Only a book. Its pages are gold.
Its markings are not written—but pressed.
And every page carries a thumbprint. As night falls, the artifact begins to hum. And somewhere beneath the mountain… something begins to count.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/pagan-s-scary-stories--6784124/support.

Pagan’s Scary Stories is an original scripted horror anthology created and written by Robert Jerome Pagan. Produced by RJPC Studios LLC and RJPC Studios Audio. Stories featured on this program are works of fiction unless otherwise noted. Names, characters, places, events, and incidents may be fictionalized. This program may contain strong language, disturbing themes, violence, death, psychological horror, and other material intended for mature audiences. Listener discretion is advised. © 2026 RJPC Studios LLC. All Rights Reserved. Pagan’s Scary Stories
Some stories follow you home.