Patent Pending Made Simple

Patent Pending Made Simple

By Outlier Patent AttorneysBusinessEntrepreneurship
Download on the App Store

Patent Pending Made Simple episodes

  • 12. Who's on 3rd and Who is an Inventor?

    Who is an inventor when it comes to a patent? Can there be multiple inventors? What rights do they have? These questions will be answered in this insightful episode of Patent Pending Made Simple, where our hosts, Jamie Brophy and Samar Shah, delve into the intricacies of inventorship claims and their implications in the realm of patent applications and legal protections.

    Summary
    In this episode, Jamie Brophy and Samar Shah discuss the topic of inventorship. They explain that an inventor is anyone who helped come up with the idea behind a patent and, specifically, anyone who helped come up with the idea written in the claims. They also discuss the importance of understanding inventorship from a legal perspective, as the person who came up with the invention is presumed to have ownership of the invention. They highlight the need to carefully review employment agreements, as many of them state that any inventions made during the course of employment belong to the company. They also discuss the complexities of determining inventorship and the importance of including all potential inventors to avoid future legal issues. Finally, they mention the additional obligations and paperwork that arise when multiple inventors are involved.


    Takeaways
    An inventor is anyone who helped develop the idea behind a patent, specifically the idea written in the claims.

    Understanding inventorship from a legal perspective is important, as the person who invented the invention is presumed to own it.

    Employment agreements often state that any inventions made during the course of employment belong to the company, so it is important to review these agreements carefully.

    Including all potential inventors is recommended to avoid future legal issues and ensure the patent's validity.

    When there are multiple inventors, additional obligations and paperwork regarding ownership may arise.


    Chapters
    00:00 Understanding Inventorship

    02:28 Ownership of Inventions in Different Countries

    03:54 Importance of Determining Co-Inventors' Responsibilities

    06:44 Analyzing Inventorship on a Claim-by-Claim Basis

    10:33 Including Potential Inventors to Avoid Legal Issues

    13:23 Additional Obligations and Paperwork with Multiple Inventors

    16 min
  • 11. Patent Attorney vs. Patent Agent

    What are the key differences between a patent attorney and a patent agent? 
    In this episode, Jamie and Samar dispel the myths surrounding patent attorneys and patent agents. They specify the qualifications a patent attorney and patent agent must have and what actions fall under their jurisdictions, respectively.  

    Takeaways:
    Both patent attorneys and agents are required to take the patent bar exam, which qualifies them to represent people in front of the USPTO. Patent agents are restricted strictly to the legal representation of clients in front of the patent office. However, patent attorneys can operate anywhere the law and the patent office intersect. Regarding more complex legal consultations that are not confined to the patent office, an attorney is often better equipped to handle them. Generally, attorneys charge more than agents, but this varies depending on the agent's or attorney's experience and market.

    Timestamps:
    0:00 - Introduction 
    2:11 - How do patent agents get registration numbers?
    2:49 - Patent bar exams 
    4:00 - Qualifications to take the exam
    4:45 - What can agents and attorneys do and not do?
    5:50 - Cost differences
    6:56 - Appeal Briefs 
    7:49 - At what stage do you need to get an attorney?
    8:50 - Closing thoughts

    11 min
  • 10. Is a Prototype Necessary Before Filing a Patent Application?

    In this episode of Patent Pending Made Simple, Jamie and Samar talk about the ins and outs of prototyping and whether you should have one before filing your patent application. They discuss the costs of prototyping, how it can help you in the product development process, and what you should consider before prototyping your invention.

    Summary

    The conversation discusses whether a prototype is necessary before filing a patent application. It is clarified that there is no legal requirement to have a prototype before filing a patent application as long as the invention is described in sufficient detail. However, prototyping can be beneficial in working out kinks in the invention and discovering potential changes that may need to be made. The decision of whether to prototype before filing a patent application depends on factors such as comfort level, cost, goals, and the nature of the invention.


    Takeaways
    There is no legal requirement to have a prototype before filing a patent application.
    Prototyping can help work out kinks in the invention and discover potential changes.
    The decision of whether to prototype before filing a patent application depends on factors such as comfort level, cost, goals, and the nature of the invention.

    Chapters

    00:00 Introduction and Background

    03:49 Is a Prototype Necessary Before Filing a Patent Application?

    07:34 The Benefits of Prototyping in the Patent Process

    10:17 Factors to Consider When Deciding to Prototype Before Filing a Patent Application


    17 min
  • 9. License Your Idea to a Company with Stephen Key of InventRight and One Simple Idea

    In this episode of Patent Pending Made Simple, Jamie and Samar interview Stephen Key, one of the foremost experts in the world of patent licensing.  They discuss the patent licensing process, the role of a provisional patent application in that process, steps to bringing an idea to market, prototyping, prior art searches, and so much more!

    Summary
    Stephen Key, a patent licensing expert, shares his insights on how to protect and commercialize ideas. He emphasizes the importance of focusing on the benefits of an idea rather than just the features. Key recommends starting with a Google search to see if the idea already exists and then reaching out to companies that may be interested in licensing the idea. He suggests using tools like provisional patent applications, sell sheets, and videos to test the market interest before investing in prototypes. Key also discusses the importance of teamwork with patent attorneys and agents to create a valuable patent.

    Takeaways
    Focus on the benefits of an idea rather than just the features.
    Start with a Google search to see if the idea already exists.
    Reach out to companies that may be interested in licensing the idea.
    Use tools like provisional patent applications, sell sheets, and videos to test market interest before investing in prototypes.
    Work with patent attorneys and agents as a team to create a valuable patent.


    00:00 Welcome to the Patent Pending Made Simple Podcast
    00:15 Introducing Stephen Key: The Patent Licensing Expert
    00:48 Stephen's Journey: From Ideas to Innovation
    03:16 Demystifying the Patent Process for Inventors
    04:35 The Initial Steps of Bringing an Idea to Market
    07:12 Licensing Ideas: Stephen's Strategy for Success
    08:42 Prototyping and Testing: Essential Steps Before Patenting
    11:38 The Power of Provisional Patent Applications
    14:05 Testing Your Invention in the Real World
    17:17 Stephen's Advice on Prototyping and Filing for Patents
    19:55 Navigating Patent Applications: Insights and Strategies
    20:40 The Importance of Matching Claims with Business Objectives
    22:10 Leveraging Patents as Negotiation Tools
    23:29 Crafting Patents with Manufacturing and Detail in Mind
    27:01 The Role of Prior Art in Shaping Patent Strategy
    27:28 Building a Strong Team Beyond the Patent
    28:28 A Real-World Example: Overcoming Prior Art Challenges
    33:32 The Art of Patent Writing: A Collaborative Approach
    36:55 Closing Thoughts and Appreciation

    39 min
  • 8. Patent vs. License

    What is the difference between a patent and a license?
    In this episode, Jamie and Samar discuss the differences between a patent and a license.  Topics include:

    • Key differences
    • Do you need an issued patent to get a licensing deal?
    • Are there benefits of securing a licensing deal during the patent pending phase?
    • Overcoming fears and uncertainties around licensing an invention
    • What is a license (a contract that allows someone to use your patented invention in exchange for payment)
    • Licenses can be exclusive or non-exclusive
    • Most common patent licensing deal structures (lump sum payment, royalty rate per unit sold, percentage of profits)
    • Finding potential licensing partners
    • Tips for writing a patent application with licensing in mind (understand potential partners’ portfolios, draft claims accordingly)

    Timestamps:
    0:00 - Introduction
    2:30 - Do you need an issued patent to get a licensing deal?
    5:15 - Overcoming inventor fears about licensing
    7:00 - Defining what a license agreement is
    10:30 - Exclusive vs. non-exclusive licensing
    12:45 - Typical licensing payment structures
    15:00 - Finding potential licensing partners (teaser for future episode)
    17:30 - Writing patents with licensing in mind

    16 min
  • 6. Top Provisional Mistakes

    Happy Thanksgiving to all! On today's episode, Jamie and Samar discuss the top mistakes that inventors make in writing and filing their provisional patent applications. For show notes, visit: https://outlierpatentattorneys.com/top-mistakes-provisional-applications

    ---
    Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/patentpending/message
    18 min
  • 5. Patent Deadlines

    In this episode of the Patent Pending Made Simple Podcast, Jamie and Samar discuss patent related deadlines, including:

    • The importance of patent deadlines (00:00-01:56)

    • Pre-filing Deadlines (01:57-02:55)

      • Public Disclosures and Associated Nuances (02:56-10:13)

      • Post-filing Deadlines (10:14-10:49)

      • Responding to Final and Non-Final Office Actions (10:50-19:14)

      • Other Deadlines (19:15-19:56)

      • ---
        Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/patentpending/message
        25 min
      • 4. Jamie's Kids Interview Us About Patents!

        In this podcast episode, the hosts Samar Shah and Jamie Brophy are interviewed by Jamie's two sons, Griffin and Jordan. The boys have questions about patents, which they ask during the episode.

        They learn that a patent is a legal document that gives inventors rights to protect their inventions from being made, sold, or used by others. The process of getting a patent involves writing a patent application and submitting it to the Patent Office for review. It can take several years to obtain a patent due to the backlog of applications at the Patent Office. The cost of obtaining a patent, and more.

        Once you have a patent, you need to mark your product as patented when selling it. This notifies others that you have the exclusive rights to the invention and discourages them from copying it. If someone does copy your invention, you can send them a letter asking them to stop. If they refuse, legal action can be taken by filing a lawsuit in federal court.

        Overall, patents are important for protecting inventions and preventing others from copying them without permission. And, if someone does steal your invention, patents give you the right to sue infringers.

        ---
        Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/patentpending/message
        16 min
      • 3. Patentability vs. Infringement

        For transcript and show notes, visit: https://outlierpatentattorneys.com/patent-pending-made-simple/podcast/episodes/3

        In this episode of Patent Pending Made Simple Podcast, Jamie and Samar discuss the differences between patentability opinions and patent infringement opinions. What is the difference, and when should you think about these concepts in your patent journey.


        1. Introduction to the podcast (00:02)

          • Hosted by Samar Shah and Jamie Brophy

          • Catching Up (00:08-00:50)

          • Topic: Differences between patentability and patent infringement (00:51)

            • Initial discussion of the two concepts (01:13-02:41)

            • Just because you get a patent on something does not mean that you're not infringing on something, so you could still be infringing on somebody else's patent.

            • Is having a patent a good defense to infringement? ⁠4:02⁠

              • A client has a patent and they can still infringe on somebody else's patent, both of which can happen simultaneously.

              • Having a patent is not a good defense to patent infringement. Courts may not allow you to present that kind of evidence to a jury.

              • The different types of opinions that practitioners can draft: patentability, non-infringement, and freedom to operate.

              • Patentability opinions are straightforward, while infringement opinions are more complicated.

              • The importance of a patentability opinion. 7:57

                • Patentability analysis gives a good idea of whether a patent application will be rejected or not. It also gives an idea of what elements to focus on in the application to get a patent.

                • Litigation can cost upwards of $100,000 on the search itself.

                • The patentability opinion and the infringement opinions are very very different.

                • In infringement, you have to interpret the claim language and determine what is meant by each of those terms in the claims and that is kind of complicated.

                • The importance of non-infringement opinions. 12:09

                  • When writing a non-infringement opinion letter, the quality of the opinion letter becomes very important, and the level of analysis that has been done is very important.

                  • What to recommend to clients who want to know if they are infringing on something, and how to handle it.

                  • Advice to those who want to do an initial search to see if they infringe someone else's patent before launching something.

                  • Information disclosure statements ⁠16:50⁠

                  • Software patents are written often in a way that is indecipherable to clients. It is hard for the client to make a decision on whether the disclosure is relevant to their invention.

                  • Information Disclosure Statements: The information disclosure statement is an ethical obligation to tell the patent office about references to the invention.

                    • Cost considerations and ethical obligation to disclose relevant references (17:49-18:12)

                    • Working with an attorney to establish search parameters and track references (19:01-19:23)

                    • Conclusion and Closing Remarks (19:40)

                      • Recap of key points discussed (19:49-19:57)

                      • Disclaimer about legal advice and opinions expressed (20:27-20:44)

                      • ---
                        Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/patentpending/message
                        21 min

                      About Patent Pending Made Simple

                      From the publisher's feed

                      Patent Pending Made Simple is a podcast for inventors who are looking to learn more about the patent process

                      Best of Patent Pending Made Simple

                      Ranked by our users in the last 21 days