In this discussion, we talk about redemption (in the secular sense). What do we really believe about redemption after misdeeds? We all love a good redemption story, but what is the path to get there? How long does it take and what does it entail? How do we know when someone has walked it? We use three real-life scenarios for this tough conversation: Friends disagree on reconciling with a man after he serves a ten-year prison term for killing his wife; Retired NFL player Michael Vick's involvement in a dog fighting and gambling ring; and the controversies surrounding the charity known as the Wounded Warrior Project.