Having discussed the Hitler Dilemma for Annihilationism, Rajat and I move on to discuss various philosophical questions pertaining to annihilationism as well as what constitutes a meaningful afterlife. By way of clarification, I should point out that Rajat is a theist but does not subscribe to any one religious tradition. Accordingly, his questions and answers tend to come from an uncorrelated philosophical point of view, while mine are largely within the Christian frame.