Power Structuralism in Ancient Ontologies

Positionalism Revisited


Listen Later

Maureen Donnelly (SUNY at Buffalo) gives a talk for the Metaphysics of Relations Conference, held on 3rd-5th October 2012 in University of London. In some relational claims- e.g., 'Abelard loves Eloise'-the order of the individual terms determines what relational fact is posited in the claim. In other relational claims- 'Abelard is next to Eloise' the order of the terms seems irrelevant to the underlying relational fact. Whereas there seems to be only one possible fact involving Abelard and Eloise in the relation at issue in the latter claim, there seem to be two possible relational facts involving Abelard and Eloise in the relation at issue in the former claim. I assume that there must be some difference among relations which explains why (and how) some, but not all, relations may return distinct relational facts when combined with fixed relata. I take positionalism to be the view that each argument place of a relational predicate is associated with a particular position or role. On this view, the argument place occupied by a term in a relational claim determines what role its referent plays in the corresponding relational fact. A relation R may generate distinct relational facts involving the same relata if fixed objects may play different roles in R-facts. In this paper, I develop a version of positionalism which assumes that certain properties and relations are instantiated only relative a particular object. I show how object-relative properties can explain differences in relational facts involving the same relata and answer objections to positionalism raised by Fine and MacBride.
...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Power Structuralism in Ancient OntologiesBy Oxford University

  • 3.1
  • 3.1
  • 3.1
  • 3.1
  • 3.1

3.1

7 ratings


More shows like Power Structuralism in Ancient Ontologies

View all
Philosophy for Beginners by Oxford University

Philosophy for Beginners

328 Listeners

Approaching Shakespeare by Oxford University

Approaching Shakespeare

330 Listeners

General Philosophy by Oxford University

General Philosophy

73 Listeners

Aesthetics and Philosophy of Art lectures by Oxford University

Aesthetics and Philosophy of Art lectures

75 Listeners

Theoretical Physics - From Outer Space to Plasma by Oxford University

Theoretical Physics - From Outer Space to Plasma

56 Listeners

Critical Reasoning: A Romp Through the Foothills of Logic by Oxford University

Critical Reasoning: A Romp Through the Foothills of Logic

38 Listeners

The Secrets of Mathematics by Oxford University

The Secrets of Mathematics

42 Listeners

Critical Reasoning for Beginners by Oxford University

Critical Reasoning for Beginners

30 Listeners

CortexCast - A Neuroscience Podcast by Oxford University

CortexCast - A Neuroscience Podcast

4 Listeners

Poetry with Alice Oswald by Oxford University

Poetry with Alice Oswald

25 Listeners