pplpod

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

Tombstone got its name from a warning. In 1877 Army scout Ed Schieffelin set out alone to prospect in Apache country, and fellow scout Al Sieber told him the only rock he would find would be his own tombstone. He found a silver vein instead, and within a few years the mesa called Goose Flats held the most productive silver district in Arizona. The mines gave up 32 million troy ounces, and the money hauled in luxuries by mule team: four churches, a bowling alley, an ice cream parlor, imported European wine, 110 saloons, 14 gambling halls, and the Bird Cage Theatre, which reportedly never closed for eight years.

This episode treats the famous gunfight as one chapter in a larger story. It casts the feud between the Earps and the Cochise County Cowboys as a clash between Northern Republican business interests in town and Southern Democratic ranchers and rustlers outside it, sharpened when the Cowboys began robbing stagecoaches. Then it turns to the forces that really broke the town: two devastating fires, an aquifer that flooded the richest shafts, and a collapse in the price of silver. Tombstone survived as a county seat until 1929 and was revived by the Western craze of the 1950s.

• The gunfight of October 26, 1881 lasted about 30 seconds and took place in a vacant lot on Fremont Street, not inside the O.K. Corral.
• In 1880s Cochise County the word cowboy was an insult meaning outlaw. Legitimate cattlemen called themselves ranchers.
• During the fire of May 1882, townspeople dynamited their own buildings to create firebreaks because there was too little water pressure to fight the flames.
• Giant Cornish engines were pumping 576,000 gallons a day out of the mines by 1884. A fire in May of 1886 destroyed the pumps, and the mines flooded for good.
• A Chinese businesswoman known as China Mary brokered much of the town's labor until her death in 1906, and a rose cutting planted in 1885 now covers over 8,000 square feet.

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

In 1690 the danger of robbery in Hyde Park was so great that King William III had oil lamps strung along his route between St. James's Palace and Kensington Palace, creating the first artificially lit highway in Britain. The men he feared were highwaymen, a term first printed around 1617 that meant a mounted robber and nothing less. Thieves on foot were mere footpads. The golden age began around the Restoration in 1660, when disbanded soldiers with horses, weapons, and cavalry training returned to a country with no work for them and no real police, only unpaid parish constables.

This episode sets the polite rogue of legend against the record of shootings, bayonets through carriage windows, and protection rackets run on carriers. It explores why crowds cheered condemned robbers at Tyburn, how Irish tories and rapparees, Balkan hajduks, and Hungarian betyars came to be seen as rebels, and why India's Thugs offered no romance at all. It also explains what really ended the trade in England, where the last recorded mounted robbery took place in 1831, before the railways were built.

• Highwaymen worked choke points on the roads out of London, including Hounslow Heath, Bagshot Heath, and Shooters Hill, and followed wealthy travelers toward Epsom and Banstead Downs.
• Lord North wrote in 1774 that a highwayman fired at his postilion simply because the carriage did not stop quickly enough.
• Historian Roy Porter's point that violence was routine in 18th century life helps explain the ironic title gentlemen of the road.
• Mounted police patrols around London from 1805, traceable banknotes, and reliable repeating handguns such as the pepperbox all raised the cost of robbery.
• The Enclosure Act of 1773 carved open heaths into walled and fenced private fields, leaving a robber boxed in on patrolled roads with manned turnpike gates.

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

Eliot Ness spent his last years in Coudersport, Pennsylvania, telling skeptical bar patrons that he was the man who took down Al Capone. The truth was more complicated than either his boasts or the movies. Born in Chicago in 1903 to Norwegian immigrants, he studied political science and business administration, ran credit checks for the Retail Credit Company, and absorbed the scientific policing ideas of Berkeley police chief August Vollmer. At 27 he was picked by U.S. Attorney George E.Q. Johnson to lead a small squad against Capone's breweries, choosing his men by auditing personnel files for anyone who could not be bought.

This episode separates the legend from the record. The raids that began in March 1931 bled Capone's cash, but it was the IRS tax case that sent him to prison for 11 years. It then follows Ness to Cleveland, where as safety director from December 1935 he modernized the police before the torso murders in Kingsbury Run exposed the limits of his methods. Divorces, heavy drinking, a 1942 drunk driving cover-up, a failed 1947 run for mayor, and a string of bad business ventures followed. He died of a heart attack on May 16, 1957, at 54, just after approving the galleys of The Untouchables.

• Ness's squad used wiretaps to map yeast deliveries and barrel movements, destroying an estimated $500,000 in bootlegging operations within six months.
• Capone's men offered him $2,000 a week to look away. His refusal led Chicago Daily News reporter Charles Schwarz to coin the name the Untouchables.
• Ness and Capone met in person only once, in May of 1932, when Ness helped escort him from the Cook County Jail to the train bound for the Atlanta penitentiary.
• In Cleveland he personally questioned suspect Dr. Francis E. Sweeney with a polygraph, then ordered the Kingsbury Run shantytowns evacuated and burned, a move that wrecked his reputation as a reformer.
• The memoir written with Oscar Fraley sold 1.5 million copies and inspired the 1959 television series and the 1987 film. A 2014 proposal to name the ATF headquarters for him failed, though its main atrium bears his name.

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

Pat Garrett is remembered for one gunshot in a dark bedroom, but his life ran far longer and stranger than that night. Born in Alabama in 1850 and raised on a Louisiana plantation, he was orphaned as a teenager and left in 1868 with more than $30,000 of debt. He went west as a buffalo hunter, killed a fellow hunter named Joe Briscoe in a dispute, and drifted to Fort Sumner in New Mexico Territory. At his first wedding in 1879 the guests included Billy the Kid, and his bride, Juanita Martinez, died 15 days later. Elected sheriff of Lincoln County in late 1880, he was sent to hunt his former drinking companion.

This episode recounts the ambush at Fort Sumner, the siege at Stinking Springs, and the midnight shooting in Pete Maxwell's house on July 14, 1881, then follows Garrett through decades of failed reinvention. He lost a race for the Texas state Senate, quit the Texas Rangers in under a month, was forced out of his own irrigation ventures near Roswell, and squandered the favor of President Theodore Roosevelt. Broke and bitter, he was shot dead on a desert road during a quarrel over goats grazing his ranch, and no one was ever held to account.

• The press cast Billy as a romantic hero and Garrett as a coward, so he co-wrote The Authentic Life of Billy the Kid with Ash Upson. It flopped commercially yet shaped the historical record into the 1960s.
• Hired to solve the 1896 disappearance of Colonel Albert Jennings Fountain and his eight-year-old son, Garrett lost a deputy in a rooftop shootout at Wildy Well. A jury later found the suspects not guilty.
• Roosevelt made him collector of customs at El Paso in 1901, then dropped him after Garrett introduced saloon owner Tom Powers to the president as a prominent cattleman.
• When the county auctioned his possessions to satisfy judgments, the total came to $650.
• Wayne Brazel confessed and claimed self-defense, the only eyewitness never appeared, and the trial lasted one day. Garrett stood six foot five, so a custom coffin had to be shipped by train from El Paso.

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

Jack Diamond, known as Legs and sometimes as Gentleman Jack, took so many bullets and lived that the press and police called him the clay pigeon of the underworld. Born in Philadelphia in 1897 to Irish immigrants, he lost his mother as a teenager, moved to Brooklyn, and joined a Manhattan street gang called the Hudson Dusters. After deserting the Army and serving two years at Leavenworth, he came out in 1921 and went to work as muscle and then bodyguard for Arnold Rothstein. Prohibition let him build his own bootlegging operation, and a taste for Broadway nightlife put him on a collision course with Dutch Schultz.

This episode follows the unglamorous reality behind the legend: a drunken double killing at his Hotsy Totsy Club in July of 1929, witnesses who vanished, and a string of ambushes he survived on luck alone. It tracks his failed flight to Europe, where one country after another threw him out, and his slide into torturing a truck driver over a stash of hard cider. The end came in an Albany rooming house in December of 1931, hours after a jury acquitted him, and the strongest theory blames the local political machine that wanted no competition.

• Diamond had ships dump partly filled barrels of liquor offshore so the tides carried them to Long Island beaches, then paid local children a nickel a barrel to drag them out of the surf.
• In 1927 he was shot twice, once just below the heart, while guarding Little Augie Orgen on the Lower East Side. He survived and refused to name the shooters.
• In October 1930 two gunmen shot him five times at the Hotel Monticello. He walked into the hallway in his pajamas and drank two shots of whiskey.
• Sailing on the Belgenland as John Nolan in August of 1930, he was refused entry by England, seized in Belgium, arrested in Germany, and shipped back to Philadelphia on a freighter.
• On Dove Street in Albany one gunman held him down while another fired three times into the back of his head. No underworld figures attended his burial in Queens, and his widow was shot dead in Brooklyn in 1933.

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

Two men named Alfred Hinds sit on opposite sides of a single encyclopedia disambiguation page. Alfred Walton Hinds, born in 1874 and dead in 1957, was a captain in the United States Navy and the 17th naval governor of Guam, a post that made him executive, legislature, and judge of a strategic Pacific coaling station. Alfred George Hinds, born in 1917 and dead in 1991, is recorded in just two words: British criminal. For forty years, from 1917 to 1957, the two were alive at the same time, one enforcing the law and the other breaking it.

This episode uses that bare page as a case study in how history gets stored. A database treats a name as a unique key, so when one name points to both military order and criminality, the system has to build a wall between them. The conversation weighs what a naval governor really was, an unelected officer holding near absolute authority thousands of miles from Washington, and asks whether it is fair to shrink a 74-year life to a nationality and a broken law. Together the two men account for 157 years of living, compressed into dates and a short occupational tag.

• The naval governor of Guam ran no campaigns and answered to no local electorate. He managed public health, land disputes, and naval regulations as the embodiment of the law on the island.
• When the future British criminal was born in 1917, the naval officer who shared his name was 43 and well into his military career.
• The page warns readers that if a link led them there by mistake, they should repoint it to the intended article, a small sign of how costly it is to confuse the two lives.
• Before digital records, a village storyteller would have supplied the context, the sailor or the thief. A disambiguation page acts as a software patch for that lost context.
• History is framed here as a compression algorithm that records disruption: you earn an entry by enforcing the rules or by breaking them.

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

The real Peaky Blinders were not middle-aged crime lords running an empire after the First World War. They were a street gang of teenagers and young men in the slums of late Victorian Birmingham, grown out of the loose slogging gangs that fought police crackdowns on gambling and street sports. Their public debut came in March of 1890, when a gang led by Thomas Mucklow fractured the skull of George Eastwood with belt buckles as he sat drinking a ginger beer in a Small Heath pub. Then they wrote to national newspapers to claim the attack under their new name.

This episode traces how that act of branding worked, how tailored jackets, bell-bottom trousers, silk scarves, and flat caps became an armor of status in a filthy slum, and how the gang moved into protection rackets, extortion, and illegal bookmaking. It also follows their collapse, squeezed between Billy Kimber's Birmingham Boys at the racecourses, a disciplinarian police chief named Rafter who arrived in 1899, stricter sentencing, better schooling, and the First World War. By the 1920s the survivors had fled the city center, and by the 1930s the Sabini gang held the region's rackets.

• The razor blade legend fails on dates alone. Gillette introduced its replaceable safety razor in 1903, and the first British factory making them opened in 1908, years after the gang took its name in 1890.
• Peaky was common slang for a peaked flat cap, and blinder was Birmingham slang for someone strikingly well dressed.
• Arrest records show how young they were: David Taylor carried a loaded firearm at 13, and Baby-Faced Harry was arrested at 19 in 1904 for stealing a bicycle.
• A tactic called constable baiting, championed by a member known as Kevin Mooney, left officers dead in 1897 and 1901, injured hundreds more, and drove many to quit the force.
• Henry Lightfoot, the first person named in print as a Peaky Blinder, went on to fight at the Battle of the Somme in 1916.

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

Gustave is a Nile crocodile estimated at more than 20 feet long and 2,000 pounds, blamed in local legend for the deaths of up to 300 people along the Ruzizi River and the northern shores of Lake Tanganyika in Burundi. Thought to have hatched around 1955, he is the product of indeterminate growth, the reptilian trait of never fully stopping, compounded over five decades of successful hunting. Observers counted at least three bullet scars on his body and a deep gash on his right shoulder blade, evidence that his bony, plate-like scutes had already turned away more than one attempt on his life.

This episode explains how sheer size forced Gustave to give up fast prey for hippos, buffalo, and the people who fish and wash at the water's edge, and why so many of his victims were found uneaten, a detail that points to territorial defense instead of hunger. It also follows herpetologist Patrice Faye, who named the crocodile and spent two years trying to trap him alive during the Burundian Civil War, an effort recorded in the 2004 PBS film Capturing the Killer Croc. Conservative scientific estimates put the real death toll at 60 or fewer, yet the myth kept growing.

• Faye's team built a drop-door cage nearly 30 feet long and weighing 2,000 pounds, fitted with an infrared camera. Gustave ignored the bait entirely.
• Three giant snares hidden on the riverbanks caught only smaller, ordinary crocodiles.
• On the final night before a forced evacuation, a thunderstorm knocked out the camera. By morning the cage had been partly dragged underwater and the live goat inside was gone.
• Gustave was reportedly photographed again in the Ruzizi River in 2009. A 2019 piece in Travel Africa magazine relayed rumors of his death, but no body, photograph, or account of the kill ever surfaced.
• Nile crocodiles can live 70 to 100 years, and Lake Tanganyika plunges more than 4,700 feet, which leaves open the possibility that he is still alive.

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

Joseph Weil, better known as the Yellow Kid, stole an estimated eight million dollars over a career that ran from the streets of 1890s Chicago to the offices of a European dictator. Born in 1875, he left school early and by 17 was collecting debts for loan sharks, where he noticed his fellow collectors skimming cash and charged them for his silence. An apprenticeship with a veteran grifter named Doc Merriweather, selling bottled rainwater as a miracle elixir at county fairs, taught him that buyers pay for the story, never the product.

This episode follows Weil as he scales up from short cons to full stage productions: fake prize fights with paid audiences and phony police raids, rented offices staffed by actors, forged surveys and counterfeit credentials. It also examines the cynical rule he lived by, that nobody can be conned unless they are trying to get something for nothing. His marks believed they were the ones doing the cheating, and their embarrassment kept most of them away from the police. Weil served only about six years behind bars and died in Chicago in 1976 at the age of 100.

• The nickname came in 1903 from Chicago alderman Bathhouse John Coughlin, who linked Weil and his partner Frank Hogan to the comic strip Hogan's Alley. Weil later denied the legend of yellow gloves, spats, and a yellow beard.
• His staged boxing matches used hired referees, choreographed fighters, capsules of fake blood, and actors in police uniforms, so that terrified marks fled and abandoned their bets.
• Weil reportedly sold the brother of Treasury Secretary Andrew Mellon a fictitious Colorado silver mine for half a million dollars, complete with a fake office and forged core samples.
• Posing as a mining engineer with forged seals and letters of introduction, he took Benito Mussolini for two million dollars by offering secret rights to American mining lands.
• Weil argued that people are 99 percent animal and that the remaining 1 percent, the ego that thinks it can outsmart the world, is what makes a mark.

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

Henri Charriere, born in 1906 and nicknamed Papillon for the butterfly tattooed on his chest, was a figure of the Paris underworld who admitted living as a pimp. In October 1931 he was convicted of murdering a fellow pimp, a killing he always denied, and was sentenced to life imprisonment plus ten years of hard labor in the penal settlements of French Guiana. His 1969 memoir told what happened next as a string of spectacular escapes: an open boat voyage to Colombia, months with an indigenous tribe, two years in solitary confinement, and a final leap from the cliffs of Devil's Island onto a raft of coconut sacks.

This episode holds that memoir against the records of the French justice system. The files show a prisoner who spent his time as a nursing assistant in a colonial hospital, where he heard the stories of hundreds of other men. He did escape, but in 1944, by walking away from a mainland forest camp with four others and making his way to Venezuela. He was never held on Devil's Island at all. The book sold more than one and a half million copies in France regardless, and in 1970 the state that had convicted him granted a pardon.

• Devil's Island has no towering cliffs. It slopes gently into the sea, which makes the memoir's climax a geographical impossibility.
• A former Paris Match reporter alleged that Charriere had been a police informant who tried to pin the murder on his own girlfriend.
• The French Justice Ministry reported that readers should divide the book's claims by at least ten. The shark rescue of a guard's daughter was the act of another convict, who lost both legs and died.
• In 2005 a 104 year old Parisian named Charles Brunier, who had a butterfly tattoo on his arm, said he was the real Papillon.
• Confronted with his errors, Charriere replied that he had not had a typewriter with him. Steve McQueen played him in the 1973 film, the year he died of throat cancer in Madrid.