pplpod

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

In August 1814, British troops marched into the American capital and set fire to the Capitol and the White House. This episode unpacks how a foreign army came to burn Washington during the War of 1812, the myths that grew up around that night, and the violent storm that cut the occupation short.

We look at British motives after Napoleon's defeat and the earlier American burning of York, the rout known as the Bladensburg Races, and how gunfire on a flag of truce changed General Robert Ross's plans. We also explore how the Library of Congress fueled the Capitol fire, the British officers who ate the White House dinner, and the push in Congress to abandon the ruined city.

• Paul Jennings's account correcting the Dolley Madison portrait legend
• Admiral Cockburn's stolen ledger and his war on the letter C at the National Intelligencer
• How William Thornton shamed British troops into sparing the Patent Office
• The tornado on Constitution Avenue and the deadly Greenleaf's Point explosion
• The Old Brick Capitol and how rebuilding cemented Washington's permanence

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

On August 16, 1780, the celebrated hero of Saratoga, General Horatio Gates, fled the battlefield at Camden, South Carolina, riding 60 miles by evening while his army was destroyed. This episode dissects one of the most humiliating American defeats of the Revolutionary War and how it unexpectedly set the stage for ultimate victory.

We follow the British Southern Strategy after the fall of Charleston, Gates's march through the barren Pine Barrens, a meal of meat, cornmeal and molasses that sickened his troops, and a blind night collision with Cornwallis's army. Then we break down the fatal deployment that placed untrained militia opposite British regulars, and the heroic stand of Baron de Kalb's Maryland and Delaware Continentals.

• Why the 18th-century "place of honor" tradition doomed the American left flank
• How a British bayonet charge sent the Virginia and North Carolina militia fleeing
• Baron de Kalb's 11 wounds and General William Smallwood's disappearance
• How Nathanael Greene and Daniel Morgan rethought tactics after the defeat
• How Cornwallis learned the wrong lesson on the road to Yorktown, and the Camden 14

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

In 1775 Patriots made up only about 40 to 45 percent of the white colonial population, while 15 to 20 percent remained loyal to the British crown. This episode explores the American Revolution as America's first civil war, told from the perspective of the losing side: the Loyalists, also known as Tories, royalists and Kingsmen.

We examine why loyalists believed in parliamentary sovereignty, the diverse coalition that sided with Britain, including tenant farmers, Quakers, Highland Scots, the Iroquois and Black Loyalists, and the legal puzzle that femme covert created for loyalist wives. We then follow the Great Exodus of 65,000 to 70,000 refugees and the surprising ways it reshaped Canada, Sierra Leone and the United States.

• Benjamin Franklin and his loyalist son William Franklin on opposite sides
• Lord Dunmore's proclamation and the Ethiopian Regiment's "Liberty to Slaves" motto
• The Loyalist Claims Commission and the United Empire Loyalist title in Canada
• Birchtown, the Shelburne riots and the founding of Freetown in Sierra Leone
• How the departure of colonial elites opened the door for America's "new men"

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

At Saratoga National Historical Park stands a monument to a wounded left leg with no name carved on it. That nameless hero is Benedict Arnold. This episode is a psychological autopsy of America's most infamous traitor, tracing the financial, social and physical grievances that carried him from battlefield brilliance to treason.

We cover his family's collapse after a yellow fever outbreak and his father's public disgrace, his tactical genius at Valcour Island, his clashes with Congress and Horatio Gates, the shattered leg at Saratoga, and his court-martial while commanding Philadelphia. Then we follow the West Point plot with Peggy Shippen and John Andre, and the strange chain of events that exposed it.

• How a book cipher based on Blackstone's Commentaries hid Arnold's negotiations
• Arnold's demand for 20,000 pounds and his sabotage of West Point's defenses
• The splinter in a British captain's nose that left John Andre stranded
• Arnold's raid on New London and his bitter exile in London
• Why Arnold might be remembered as a founding martyr had he died at Saratoga

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

On September 11, 1777, the largest battle of the American Revolution by troops engaged erupted in the Pennsylvania countryside, with fighting crashing past a Quaker meeting house during worship. This episode explores how General William Howe outmaneuvered George Washington along the Brandywine River and opened the road to Philadelphia.

We trace Howe's grueling 34-day sea voyage to Head of Elk, Washington's fixation on Chadds Ford, and the 17-mile flanking march by Howe and Cornwallis across unguarded fords. We examine how confirmation bias led Washington to dismiss scouting reports, why 18th-century linear tactics made a flank attack so deadly, and how a desperate rearguard action saved the Continental Army from destruction.

• How loyalist guides led 9,000 British troops across fords Washington did not know existed
• Why Washington trusted the scouts who told him the northern roads were clear
• The Marquis de Lafayette's first combat and the musket ball through his leg
• The rearguard efforts of Nathanael Greene, Henry Knox and Casimir Pulaski
• How the Liberty Bell was hidden under the floorboards of an Allentown church

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

In late December 1776, George Washington privately wrote that "the game is pretty near up." Roughly 90 percent of the soldiers who fought at Long Island were gone, and the remaining enlistments expired on December 31. This episode unpacks how a desperate gamble across the ice-choked Delaware River became one of the most consequential victories of the American Revolution.

We look at the spy John Honeyman, who posed as a Tory butcher inside Trenton, the arrogance of Hessian commander Colonel Johann Rall, who refused to build defensive redoubts, the brutal Christmas night crossing in Durham boats, and the nine-mile march where soldiers left trails of blood in the snow. We also debunk the myth of drunken Hessians and explain why the victory mattered most as a psychological turning point.

• Why the password "victory or death" was a literal statement as enlistments ran out
• How Honeyman's double-agent cover fed Rall's confirmation bias
• Washington's order to "use the bayonet" when sleet soaked the gunpowder
• How Henry Knox's grapeshot exploited the intersections Rall left unfortified
• James Monroe's near-fatal wound and the roughly 900 Hessian prisoners taken

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

By December 1776, George Washington's army was shrinking from disease, desertion and expiring enlistments, and his generals were ignoring his orders. This episode looks past the marble-statue image to examine how a cornered commander gambled everything on a Christmas night crossing of the icy Delaware River.

We follow the retreat across New Jersey, Charles Lee's capture at a tavern, and the morale boost from Thomas Paine's words about summer soldiers. Then we cover the crossing itself, with Henry Knox directing traffic, John Glover's Marblehead mariners and Durham boats, the collapse of the three-pronged plan, the surprise attack on the Hessians at Trenton, and the pleas that kept the army together on New Year's Eve.

• Why a high-risk attack was the only logical option with enlistments ending on December 31
• The victory or death password and the storm that stopped two of the three columns
• How sleep deprivation and Colonel Johann Rall's assumptions left the Hessians unprepared
• The dangerous return trip with captured rum and nearly a thousand prisoners
• Washington's bounty offer that kept veterans for six more weeks and enabled Princeton

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

In 1794, George Washington prepared to lead nearly 13,000 troops against American citizens over a tax on whiskey. This episode explores how the Whiskey Rebellion became the first major stress test of federal power under the new Constitution.

We start with Alexander Hamilton's 1791 excise tax, the first domestic tax levied by the national government, and why it hit cash-poor frontier farmers who used whiskey as currency. Then we follow the escalating resistance in western Pennsylvania, from tarring and feathering and Tom the Tinker threats to the Battle of Bower Hill, the rally at Braddock's Field, Washington's militia call-up, and the trials that followed.

• How the flat fee versus per-gallon rates favored large Eastern distillers over small farmers
• Why subpoenas requiring trial in Philadelphia, 300 miles away, inflamed the frontier
• The death of James McFarlane at General John Neville's house and David Bradford's rise
• Washington's two-track strategy of peace commissioners and overwhelming force
• Why Washington pardoned the only two men convicted of treason, and Jefferson's repeal of the tax

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

In 2019, DNA from bones beneath a monument in Savannah, Georgia, matched the family of Casimir Pulaski, yet the skeleton appeared female. This episode follows Pulaski's journey from Polish rebel to American hero and unpacks the modern debate over his remains.

We cover Pulaski's noble birth, his role in the Bar Confederation against Russian domination, the failed plot to kidnap the Polish king, and his exile. Then we follow him to America through Benjamin Franklin's recommendation, his charge at Brandywine, the founding of Pulaski's Legion, his mortal wound at the Siege of Savannah, and the competing interpretations of the forensic evidence.

• How Franklin promoted him as Count Pulaski, a title he never actually held
• Why Washington trusted a newcomer with his bodyguard at Brandywine
• His clashes with American officers and his personal spending to equip his legion
• The Smithsonian-backed hypothesis that Pulaski may have been intersex
• A 2022 study arguing mitochondrial DNA cannot prove the remains are his

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

In May 1801, men in Tripoli chopped down the flagpole at the U.S. consulate, a formal declaration of war against a young and nearly broke United States. This episode explores how the First Barbary War pushed Thomas Jefferson into America's first overseas conflict and helped give birth to the modern U.S. Navy and Marine Corps.

We trace the crisis from the loss of French protection after the Revolution, through Jefferson and John Adams's 1786 meeting with Tripoli's ambassador and their disagreement over paying tribute, to the 1795 ransom paid to Algiers. Then we follow the war itself: Jefferson's use of his commander-in-chief role, the grounding of the USS Philadelphia, Stephen Decatur's raid, William Eaton's desert march, and the controversial peace deal.

• How the Barbary states ran a system of captures, ransoms and tribute payments
• The unusual case of captive James Leander Cathcart rising to advise the ruler of Algiers
• Decatur's night raid to burn the captured Philadelphia in Tripoli harbor
• Eaton, Presley O'Bannon, eight Marines and a mercenary army taking the city of Derna
• Why Tobias Lear's $60,000 ransom deal left Eaton furious and the war's outcome debated