pplpod

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

In December 1864, Union Major General George H. Thomas held Nashville, Tennessee, with about 55,000 troops behind seven miles of trenches, while Ulysses S. Grant boarded a train to relieve him for not attacking. This episode lays out how the two armies got there: Sherman cut loose for the sea, John Schofield slipped past John Bell Hood's sleeping army at Spring Hill, and Hood's frontal assault at Franklin cost over 6,000 men. Hood then dug a four-mile line south of Nashville and waited, and an ice storm on December 8 froze both sides in place while Lincoln complained of a strategy of do nothing.

When the ice thawed, Thomas struck on December 15 with a feint against the Confederate right by United States Colored Troops, then a wheeling attack by James Wilson's cavalry and A.J. Smith's infantry that overran the redoubts on the left. On December 16 he ran the same play. At Shy's Hill, Confederate trenches dug on the geographic crest left a blind slope, and General John McArthur attacked without waiting for orders. Hood's line collapsed, and a misrouted pontoon train let the remnants escape across the Tennessee River.

• A Confederate soldier wrote that the shallow, muddy winter trenches gave him a graveyard feeling.
• Hood sent Nathan Bedford Forrest's cavalry to Murfreesboro before the battle, leaving his army without its scouts.
• The 13th USCT lost 40 percent of its men in one charge on Peach Orchard Hill under enfilading fire.
• McArthur sent word that unless ordered otherwise, he would attack in five minutes.
• The Army of Tennessee fell from about 38,000 men to fewer than 15,000, and Hood resigned weeks later.

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

In the spring of 1862, the Army of the Potomac, more than 100,000 strong, halted on the Virginia Peninsula before logs painted black to look like cannon. This episode traces how George B. McClellan, its commander, came to that moment. Born into a Philadelphia medical family, he entered the University of Pennsylvania at 14 and West Point at 15, graduated second in his class, and learned slow, methodical siege warfare under Winfield Scott in Mexico. Friendships with Southern cadets shaped his opposition to abolition. As an Illinois Central Railroad executive he mastered telegraph dispatching and large-scale freight, the skills he used to rebuild the army after Bull Run at age 34.

The episode follows his insults toward Lincoln, his reliance on Allan Pinkerton's inflated enemy counts, and his retreat to the gunboat USS Galena during Malvern Hill. Handed Lee's lost Special Order 191, he waited about 18 hours to move, then fought Antietam in piecemeal attacks while holding Fitz John Porter's V Corps in reserve. That narrow result gave Lincoln the opening for the preliminary Emancipation Proclamation, a policy McClellan opposed. He lost the 1864 election to Lincoln and later served as governor of New Jersey.

• Ellen Marcy turned down McClellan's proposals nine times and had once been engaged to A.P. Hill before accepting him.
• McClellan once came home to find Lincoln waiting in his parlor and went upstairs to bed.
• The lost Confederate orders were found in a field wrapped around three cigars.
• In 1864 McClellan ran on a Democratic peace platform he personally disagreed with, and his own soldiers voted heavily for Lincoln.
• Asked years later to name the best general he faced, Robert E. Lee named McClellan.

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

On the afternoon of November 30, 1864, about 20,000 Confederate soldiers stepped off across two miles of open ground toward Union earthworks at Franklin, Tennessee, twice the distance of Pickett's Charge. This episode explains how General John Bell Hood got there. With William T. Sherman marching to the sea, Hood invaded Tennessee hoping to crush John Schofield's force before it reached Nashville. At Spring Hill he got ahead of Schofield and blocked the turnpike on paper, but his exhausted army never closed the road, and the entire Union column, wagons and artillery included, passed the Confederate campfires in the dark.

Trapped against the Harpeth River without pontoons, Schofield dug in behind trenches, head logs and a thorny Osage orange abatis while engineers planked a railroad bridge. Hood rejected Nathan Bedford Forrest's flanking proposal, and the episode frames his decision as a calm, calculated gamble shaped by the sunk cost fallacy rather than blind rage. The Confederates broke the center when two exposed Union brigades under George Wagner fled down the turnpike, shielding the attackers from fire. Close fighting around the Carter House followed, and the Army of Tennessee never recovered.

• Patrick Cleburne told a fellow officer that if they were to die, they should die like men, and he was killed in the assault.
• Union regiments near the Carter House carried Henry and Spencer repeaters, firing about 16 rounds a minute against three from a muzzleloader.
• Captain Todd Carter was mortally wounded yards from his family's home and died there the next day.
• The Confederates lost roughly 6,000 men, 55 regimental commanders and 14 generals, six of them killed.
• General John Adams died after his horse was shot as it crested the Union earthworks.

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

Ambrose Powell Hill Jr. was born in 1825 in Culpeper, Virginia, into a planter family whose wealth rested on enslaved labor. At West Point he clashed with his rigid classmate Thomas Jackson, and on an 1844 furlough he contracted gonorrhea, forcing him to repeat a year. The infection was never cured and left him with chronic prostatitis, urethral strictures and kidney damage that shadowed his career. This episode follows Hill from a broken engagement to Ellen Marcy, who later married his roommate George McClellan, to command of the Light Division, which marched without coats, knapsacks or wagons to move faster than any other Confederate force.

Hill challenged James Longstreet to a duel, was arrested repeatedly by Stonewall Jackson, and saved Lee's army at Antietam after a 17-mile forced march from Harpers Ferry. As a corps commander his record faltered at Fredericksburg, Gettysburg and the Wilderness, and the episode weighs the Peter Principle against the effects of uremia. Killed at Petersburg on April 2, 1865, he left a will asking to be buried standing up. His remains sat beneath a Richmond statue in a traffic intersection for over 130 years until they were moved to Culpeper in 2023.

• Soldiers who saw Hill pull on his red calico shirt said Little Powell had his battle shirt on and began fixing bayonets.
• After Antietam, Hill joked that Ambrose Burnside owed him $8,000 for making his men march so fast.
• At Fredericksburg he left a 600-yard gap in a swampy wood, and George Meade's troops broke through it.
• Corporal John W. Mauk of the 138th Pennsylvania fired the shot that killed Hill at age 39, one week before Appomattox.
• Fort A.P. Hill was renamed Fort Walker in 2023 under a Defense Department directive on Confederate base names.

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

This episode follows a single melody across more than two centuries. It began as a call and response tune at frontier camp meetings, built to be learned by ear and sung by huge crowds. In 1861, soldiers of the Tiger Battalion at Fort Warren in Massachusetts set it to morbid verses mocking a Scottish comrade named John Brown, who shared his name with the executed abolitionist. Officers hated the song, but it spread through the Union ranks.

In November 1861, Julia Ward Howe, whose husband Samuel Gridley Howe belonged to the Secret Six, heard troops sing it near Washington. At the urging of James Freeman Clarke she wrote new verses before dawn at the Willard Hotel and sold the poem to the Atlantic Monthly for $4. Her longer lines forced singers into the dotted rhythms that give the hymn its drive. The tune later reached Marian Anderson's 1953 broadcast, a Grammy winning Mormon Tabernacle Choir record, the funerals and tributes of the 1960s, Martin Luther King Jr.'s final speech, and soccer stadiums.

• The Mormon Tabernacle Choir's 1960 recording reached number 13 on the Billboard Hot 100.
• Barred by CBS from naming John F. Kennedy after his assassination, Judy Garland sang the hymn on her show instead.
• Andy Williams' a cappella version from Robert F. Kennedy's funeral also reached the charts.
• Tottenham Hotspur fans dressed as angels and sang its chorus in 1961 after a Polish paper called their players no angels.
• Parodies include labor union marches, a Finnish hockey chant, and a Swedish drinking song about pub prices in Gothenburg.

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

By August 1864, Mobile, Alabama, was the last major Confederate port on the eastern Gulf. Its narrow entrance was covered by Fort Morgan's 46 guns, Forts Gaines and Powell, and 67 mines that left only a 500 yard gap beneath Fort Morgan. Rear Admiral David Farragut brought 14 wooden ships, lashed in pairs so a disabled ship could be towed, and four monitors. Admiral Franklin Buchanan waited with three gunboats and the ironclad ram CSS Tennessee, floated over the sandbar on wooden camels.

On August 5, the monitor Tecumseh under Tunis Craven veered into the minefield and sank in under three minutes with over 90 men. The Brooklyn stopped, jamming the column under the fort's guns, and Farragut, tied in the Hartford's rigging, led the fleet through the mines, whose primers could be heard clicking against the hulls. Buchanan then attacked the whole fleet alone; heavy shot from Union monitors disabled the Tennessee and he surrendered. Fort Morgan held out under siege until General Richard L. Page surrendered on August 23.

• Farragut kept steam pressure low so a hit boiler would scald fewer men.
• Army Signal Corps men aboard the ships relayed orders with wigwag flags through the smoke.
• The famous line damn the torpedoes did not appear in print until years later.
• Page was tried for spiking his guns under a flag of truce and was found not guilty.
• 115 Medals of Honor were awarded for the battle, four of them to African American sailors.

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

In August 1846, during the Mexican-American War, President James K. Polk asked Congress for $2 million to negotiate with Mexico. Northern Democrats known as Barnburners, angry over lower tariffs, a vetoed internal improvements bill, and the Oregon compromise, had David Wilmot of Pennsylvania add a rider banning slavery in any territory taken from Mexico. The House passed it on a sectional vote that ignored party lines, breaking the unwritten rule against national debate over slavery.

In the Senate, Massachusetts Whig John Davis talked to run out the session, but the House clock was eight minutes ahead and the House adjourned first, killing both the money and the proviso. In 1847 Preston King reintroduced a broader version, and after the Senate stripped it out, 22 Northern Democrats switched under patronage pressure. The fight produced popular sovereignty, the Free Soil Party, and William L. Yancey's Alabama Platform. The episode ends with the irony that the 1860 census counted 29 enslaved people in Utah and none in New Mexico.

• The Missouri Compromise of 1820 had drawn the 36-30 line between free and slave territory.
• Henry David Thoreau refused to pay his poll tax over the war and wrote Civil Disobedience.
• The proviso's key clause ran to just 14 words.
• Lewis Cass proposed popular sovereignty in 1848, letting territorial settlers decide on slavery.
• California's gold rush led it to write a constitution banning slavery and skip the territorial stage.

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

Dorothea Dix was born in Maine in 1802 to an abusive, alcoholic preacher father and an ailing mother, and at 12 was sent to her wealthy grandmother in Boston. She began teaching at 14, ran a charity school in her grandmother's barn, and wrote children's books and a dictionary of flowers before a breakdown in 1836 sent her to England, where Quaker reformers introduced her to the data driven lunacy reform movement.

In 1841, teaching Sunday school at the East Cambridge jail, she found mentally ill women in a freezing basement. She spent 18 months documenting conditions across Massachusetts, then traveled more than 10,000 miles by stagecoach lobbying states, using a former New Jersey lawmaker found in a basement to win the New Jersey State Hospital. Her bill to fund care with 10 million acres of federal land passed Congress but was vetoed by Franklin Pierce in 1854. As superintendent of Army nurses in the Civil War she clashed with doctors and lost her authority, but she is credited with founding 32 mental hospitals.

• Many towns auctioned the care of mentally ill residents to the lowest bidder, rewarding neglect.
• In North Carolina, a legislator's dying wife asked lawmakers to reconsider Dix's bill, and it passed.
• In Rome, her findings led Pope Pius IX to inspect local asylums and order reforms.
• On Sable Island she helped rescue 180 people from a shipwreck and later secured new lifesaving equipment.
• She required nurses to be 35 to 50 and plain looking, and distrusted the Catholic sisters serving as nurses.

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

David Farragut was born James Glasgow Farragut in Tennessee in 1801, son of Jorge Farragut, a Menorcan who fought in the American Revolution. After his mother died of yellow fever in New Orleans, he was taken in by naval officer David Porter, adopted the name David, became a midshipman at nine, and at 11 served as prize master of a captured ship in the War of 1812. He fought in the Marquesas and was wounded and captured at Valparaiso.

This episode follows his long middle career hunting pirates in the West Indies, blockading Mexico, founding the Mare Island Navy Yard in California, and testing guns in Virginia, along with his 11 years caring for his ill first wife. When Virginia seceded he moved his family north, took command of the West Gulf Blockading Squadron, and ran past Forts Jackson and St. Philip to capture New Orleans, earning the new rank of rear admiral. The episode also covers his costly impatience at Port Hudson in 1863 and his choice at Mobile Bay in 1864 to drive on through the mines.

• Congress created the rank of rear admiral for him after New Orleans, having avoided the title as too aristocratic.
• At Port Hudson he moved his attack up by nearly 12 hours, and only his flagship and one other ship got past the batteries.
• At Mobile Bay a quartermaster tied him to the rigging of the Hartford to keep him from falling.
• In 1866 he became the first full admiral in U.S. history and commanded the European Squadron.
• Jules Verne named a character in Twenty Thousand Leagues Under the Sea after him.

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

David Dixon Porter, born in 1813 into a naval family, grew up alongside his adoptive brother David Farragut. When his father, Commodore David Porter, left the U.S. Navy to command Mexico's navy, young David followed, survived yellow fever, and at 14 fought Spanish ships off Cuba, where his cousin was killed and he was held prisoner in Havana. Back in the U.S. Navy his arrogance nearly got him dismissed, but his family name and real skill kept him in.

Porter surveyed a Dominican bay on a secret State Department mission in 1846, mapped a channel by rowboat under the guns of Veracruz and ignored Matthew Perry's signal to withdraw, and shipped camels from the Middle East to Texas for Jefferson Davis. In 1861 he took the USS Powhatan to Fort Pickens on William Seward's orders without telling Gideon Welles, leaving the Fort Sumter relief mission without it. He later led mortar boats at New Orleans, ran the Vicksburg batteries for Grant, helped take Fort Fisher, and walked through Richmond with Lincoln.

• Welles promoted him from commander to acting rear admiral, skipping two ranks, despite calling him a gas bag in his diary.
• His mortar schooners were disguised with tree branches and lobbed heavy shells over fort walls.
• The Red River Expedition with Nathaniel Banks nearly stranded his fleet in falling water.
• A ship packed with gunpowder failed to damage Fort Fisher, and Porter pushed Grant to replace Benjamin Butler.
• He felt lifelong guilt over Lincoln's assassination and later modernized the Naval Academy at Annapolis.