Fluff up your favorite holiday blanket—it’s time for another cheerful romp through the Predictability Scorecard! We start by revisiting last week’s festive double feature, Hallmark’s: Three Wisest Men and Tidings for the Season. Did our predictions hold up like sturdy Christmas stockings, or did they sag a little under the weight of unexpected plot twists? We unwrap the tropes, celebrate the hits, and lovingly laugh at the misses, all in the spirit of good holiday fun.

Then we suit up for this week’s newcomers: Hallmark’s Holiday Touchdown: A Bills Love Story and Melt My Heart This Christmas. With only the titles as our playbook, we call the boldest holiday audibles—expect wild theories, rom-com Hail Marys, and at least one pun that will make someone in Buffalo groan audibly. Will romance score on the first down? Will hearts melt faster than a snowman in a sauna? And just how many plot points will fall from the sky like perfectly timed, emotionally supportive snowflakes?

Join us for another episode of festive folly, where the stories may be predictable, but our confidence is downright unfrosted. It’s cozy, it’s chaotic, and it’s exactly the kind of holiday cheer Hallmark keeps throwing our way—whether we asked for it or not.

Rate, review, and subscribe — or risk being out-wised by three men with perfect hair and swept into tidings you didn’t ask for but will absolutely cry over by minute eighty-seven.

Download on your favorite podcast platform or find us here:

https://predictablyunexpected.buzzsprout.com

Send us a text

Follow us on Instagram!

https://www.instagram.com/predictablyunexpectedpodcast/

The tinsel is twinkling, the snow is suspiciously foam-like, and our Predictability Scorecard is ready for another test. This week, we’re checking in on Hallmark's Christmas Above the Clouds and A Keller Christmas Vacation to see if our predictions soared or totally crash-landed in a snowbank. 

Then we turn our merry gaze toward Hallmark's Three Wisest Men (yes, they made a third one!) and Tidings for the Season, which sounds like it’ll deliver exactly what it promises: tidings, twinkle lights, and two people who definitely weren’t looking for love.

So cozy up by the fire (or the metaphorical streaming queue) as we test our theory that Hallmark’s greatest gift isn’t love… it’s predictability.

Rate, review, and subscribe — or risk being out-wised by three men with perfect hair and swept into tidings you didn’t ask for but will absolutely cry over by minute eighty-seven.

Download on your favorite podcast platform or find us here:

https://predictablyunexpected.buzzsprout.com

Send us a text

Follow us on Instagram!

https://www.instagram.com/predictablyunexpectedpodcast/

The Hallmark machine keeps cranking out Christmas cheer — and we’re here to decode it one predictable plot at a time. This week, we revisit our predictions for Christmas on Duty to see if we nailed the tropes, misread the mistletoe, or underestimated Hallmark’s ability to recycle its own storylines.

In true holiday fashion, we forgot something on our list — Hallmark’s A Newport Christmas! This Hallmark title won’t get the full Predictability Scorecard treatment, but we did watch it and we’ll review whether it was smooth sailing or if it had stormy seas….

Then we take flight with Christmas Above the Clouds and buckle up for A Keller Christmas Vacation, two titles that sound full of holiday chaos and emotional baggage (literally). We’ll debate which movie will earn us the highest Predictability Score, which character will learn “the true meaning of Christmas,” and which one will definitely fall in love after a snowball fight.

Hallmark’s holiday formula might be set in stone, but we’re here to see how closely it sticks to the blueprint — and maybe, just maybe, find a new favorite in the process.

Rate, review, and subscribe — or you’ll end up spending your next Christmas vacation stuck in matching pajamas, mediating family drama, and realizing that love was snowed in next door all along.

Download on your favorite podcast platform or find us here:

https://predictablyunexpected.buzzsprout.com

Send us a text

Follow us on Instagram!

https://www.instagram.com/predictablyunexpectedpodcast/

The countdown continues, and we’re back on the front lines of Hallmark's Countdown to Christmas movie predictions! This week, we’re reviewing our battlefield results from A Christmas Angel Match and Merry Christmas, Ted Cooper! —two festive missions full of angels, a weatherman, and more small-town charm than a snow globe factory. How accurate were our guesses? Let’s just say our Predictability Scorecard is seeing both victories and tactical errors.

Then, it’s time to salute our next challenge: Christmas on Duty. With a military backdrop and a guaranteed dose of mistletoe, will this one bring a soldier home for the holidays, or maybe pair a disciplined officer with a free-spirited hometown hero? One thing’s for sure—love and duty are about to go head-to-head, and we’ll be here to predict every salute, snowflake, and soft-focus kiss along the way.

So polish your ornaments, stand at ease, and join us as we predict Christmas on Duty—because when it comes to Hallmark movies, we never retreat from a good holiday romance.

Rate, review, and subscribe — or you’ll find yourself accidentally engaged to a rugged soldier who just came home for Christmas and only knows two things: honor... and holiday proposals.

Send us a text

Follow us on Instagram!

https://www.instagram.com/predictablyunexpectedpodcast/

Buckle your sleigh belts and grab your glitter glue — we’re back with another tinsel-covered episode of holiday hot takes! First, we saddle up and spill the eggnog on our Predictability Scorecard for Hallmark’s A Royal Montana Christmas, where tiaras meet tractors and we answer one of life’s most important questions: How many royal secrets can one ranch handle?

Next we flap our metaphorical angel wings and float into the clouds of speculation as we preview Hallmark’s A Christmas Angel Match — a film that promises divine intervention, romantic tension, and possibly a harp solo. Will it be predictably precious or just heavenly nonsense? Either way, our scorecards are ready and our jingle bells are on high alert.

Then we try to predict the plot of Hallmark’s: Merry Christmas, Ted Cooper! Who is Ted Cooper? A big-time actor with a secret love of woodworking or a warm-hearted weatherman returning to his hometown for the holidays? 

Join us for punny predictions, and enough Hallmark holiday magic to light up a Christmas tree farm. Because when it comes to Hallmark movies, we don’t just watch — we sleigh.

Rate, review, and subscribe — or risk a surprise engagement in a snow covered gazebo.

Send us a text

Follow us on Instagram!

https://www.instagram.com/predictablyunexpectedpodcast/

In this special Halloween episode, we temporarily ghost our traditional Predictability Scorecard (don't worry, it'll haunt us again soon) to simply discuss Hallmark's spooky-season offering: Haul Out the Halloween.

Join us as we unwrap this cinematic candy corn of a film — complete with autumn clichés, supernatural small-town charm, and romantic misunderstandings.

We’re not here to judge. Okay, we are — but only in the most festive, flannel-wrapped way.

Is it scary? No.
Is it logical? Also no.
Is there a baking competition judged by overzealous HOA members? You bet your cinnamon broomstick there is.

No scorecards. No predictions. Just pumpkin-scented opinions.

Download on your favorite podcast platform or find us here:

https://predictablyunexpected.buzzsprout.com

Send us a text

Follow us on Instagram!

https://www.instagram.com/predictablyunexpectedpodcast/

Mount up and curtsy, cowpokes — this week we’re blindly predicting A Royal Montana Christmas, the latest Hallmark holiday export straight from the wild blue yonder. We don’t know the plot, but we’re pretty sure it involves royalty, horses, a flannel-loving local, and at least three montages involving hay, cocoa, and unresolved emotional baggage.

PLUS: We saddle back up to see how our wildly confident predictions panned out for Home Turf. Who took the lead after week one of our seasonal showdown? Did we throw the ultimate Hail Mary... or were we sacked behind the line?

Grab your cocoa and your crown — it’s time to get predictably festive.

Send us a text

Follow us on Instagram!

https://www.instagram.com/predictablyunexpectedpodcast/

Surprise! It’s a bonus episode—because our hearts (and DVRs) just couldn’t wait. The Hallmark Christmas Movie Season has arrived like a surprise snowstorm on Christmas Eve, and we’re here with your essential preview of Hallmark’s Countdown to Christmas holiday movie calendar.

In this festive frolic, we sleigh through Hallmark’s upcoming lineup of snow-glazed love stories, magical misunderstandings, and aggressively cozy small towns that only exist in Canada and our dreams. We’ll sprinkle a little preview prediction magic to speculate about plotlines based on nothing but the titles and our deep, shameful expertise.

So grab your peppermint mocha, mute your expectations, and enjoy this cozy little bonus treat. It’s not just a podcast episode—it’s a peppermint-scented gift you didn’t ask for but will pretend to love anyway. 

Send us a text

Follow us on Instagram!

https://www.instagram.com/predictablyunexpectedpodcast/

In this week’s episode, we’re revealing the final results of our Predictability Scorecard for Adventures in Love and Birding — where romance meets the great outdoors. We’ll recap the film, share our honest review, and break down how we scored to reveal who owns the tiebreaker! (**potential spoilers**)

What’s awaiting us this week? Fall leaves, football season, and maybe… a campus romance? We’re raking the leaves as well as the clues as we preview the upcoming Hallmark fall movie Home Turf! We don’t know much, but we’ve got theories — and we’re putting our Predictability Scorecard to work.

Grab your cider and tune in.

Send us a text

Follow us on Instagram!

https://www.instagram.com/predictablyunexpectedpodcast/

Grab your pumpkin spice latte and settle in for a cozy, leaf-crunching episode as we dive into our latest Hallmark fall movie obsession: Adventures in Love and Birding. Love and birds, what else do you need? Tune in as we break down our predictions that will serve as the tiebreaker that could determine who wins our Hallmark movie face-off at the end of the season. Does birdwatching lead to true love? Let’s find out!

Send us a text

Follow us on Instagram!

https://www.instagram.com/predictablyunexpectedpodcast/