dicta – law in audio

Prof. Sewrattan – November 20 – Ipeelee, 2012 SCC


Listen Later

Reasons for Judgment: LeBel J. (McLachlin C.J. and Binnie, Deschamps, Fish and Abella JJ. concurring
I. – Introduction – 1 – (00:00:29)
II. – Manasie Ipeelee – 2 – (00:00:58)
A. – Background and Criminal History – 2 – (00:01:00)
B. – The Current Offence – 11 – (00:07:12)
C. – Judicial History – 14 – (00:08:52)
(1) – Ontario Court of Justice – 14 – (00:08:54)
(2) – Ontario Court of Appeal – 16 – (00:10:33)
III. – Frank Ralph Ladue – 19 – (00:12:21)
A. – Background and Criminal History – 19 – (00:12:23)
B. – The Current Offence – 26 – (00:17:53)
C. – Judicial History – 28 – (00:20:24)
(1) – Provincial Court of British Columbia – 28 – (00:20:27)
(2) – Court of Appeal for British Columbia – 29 – (00:21:35)
IV. – Issues – 33 – (00:24:40)
V. – Analysis – 34 – (00:25:16)
A. – The Principles of Sentencing – 34 – (00:25:18)
B. – The Offence — Sentencing for Breach of a Long-Term Supervision Order – 40 – (00:30:14)
C. – The Offender — Sentencing Aboriginal Offenders – 56 – (00:44:48)
(1) – Making Sense of Aboriginal Sentencing – 64 – (00:54:40)
(2) – Evaluating Aboriginal Sentencing Post-Gladue – 80 – (01:13:24)
VI. – Application – 88 – (01:20:50)
A. – Manasie Ipeelee – 88 – (01:20:53)
B. – Frank Ralph Ladue – 94 – (01:24:44)
VII. – Conclusion – 98 – (01:28:47)

Reasons Dissenting in Part: Rothstein J.
I. – Introduction – 99 – (01:28:59)
II. – Facts – 102 – (01:29:05)
A. – Manasie Ipeelee – 102 – (01:31:00)
B. – Frank Ralph Ladue – 108 – (01:31:01)
III. – General Principles of Sentencing – 113 – (01:34:25)
IV. – Long-Term Offenders – 115 – (01:38:54)
V. – Long-Term Supervision Orders – 117 – (01:39:38)
VI. – Breaches of Long-Term Supervision Orders – 121 – (01:41:02)
VII. – Sentencing Principles Applicable to Aboriginal Offenders – 126 – (01:44:21)
VIII. – The Application of Section 718.2(e) and Gladue to Long-Term Offenders – 129 – (01:47:37)
IX. – Application – 132 – (01:49:40)
A. – Ipeelee – 132 – (01:52:22)
B. – Ladue – 141 – (01:52:24)
...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

dicta – law in audioBy dicta