SUPPORT THE SHOW AT ko-fi.com/prollyshoulda

After six months of forgetting to do the podcast, Tony and Nadia reunite to discuss Nadia's recent panel appearance at Comic-Con, where she represented the show and figured out how to process poorly-aged media in front of a large audience of dorks. The two hosts continue to try and figure out how to be people in the world that grow and learn while consuming art but also still overthink everything. Tony also does a deep assessment on AI and the threat it poses to his job as a podcaster. Today's theme music is "SKrAm" by Jeff Rosenstock; Jeff's music is distributed under a Creative Commons license and available at quoteunquoterecords.com

SUPPORT THE SHOW AT ko-fi.com/prollyshoulda

Nadia unearths a John Cusack favorite from her adolescence, which Tony has never heard of and is completely baffled by. Come for the competitive skiing, stay for the claymation hamburger musical number (?). Our theme song is "Yr Throat" by Jeff Rosenstock; Jeff's music is distributed under a Creative Commons license and available at quoteunquoterecords.com . This week's outro music is My Chemical Romance’s “I Don’t Love You” as covered by Xena Aqila.

SUPPORT THE SHOW AT ko-fi.com/prollyshoulda

Nadia and Tony watch one of the funniest movies ever made from one of the funniest comedy teams ever, starring one of the best comedic actors of all time and featuring multiple contenders for the greatest gag of all time. And now, to take a big sip of water and make sure there aren’t any world-famous murderers in the cast list. Our theme song is "Yr Throat" by Jeff Rosenstock; Jeff's music is distributed under a Creative Commons license and available at quoteunquoterecords.com . This week's outro music is My Chemical Romance’s “Thank You For the Venom” as covered by kiy music.

SUPPORT THE SHOW AT ko-fi.com/prollyshoulda

Tony and Nadia decide to take the podcast seriously for once and definitely don’t spend 90 minutes talking about which of their friends ended up on Wikifeet or which tags show up in the Bluey fanfics on AO3 or how hot Winona Ryder is in this early-2000s era hidden gem from the Adam Sandler catalogue, featuring an Oscar-nominated (not really, but we wish) turn from John Turturro. Our theme song is "Yr Throat" by Jeff Rosenstock; Jeff's music is distributed under a Creative Commons license and available at quoteunquoterecords.com . This week's outro music is My Chemical Romance’s “House of Wolves” as covered by emmanoodle.

SUPPORT THE SHOW AT ko-fi.com/prollyshoulda

In 2016, Disney threw every member of phylum chordata into a bizarre and baffling allegory (for children?) on 2010s prejudice, policing, and urban unrest, but don’t worry, they made all of the animals in it really sexy. Nadia and Tony investigate the strangest movie to ever gross over a billion dollars. Our theme song is "Yr Throat" by Jeff Rosenstock; Jeff's music is distributed under a Creative Commons license and available at quoteunquoterecords.com . This week's outro music is My Chemical Romance’s “Famous Last Words” as covered by PeppermintOllie.

SUPPORT THE SHOW AT ko-fi.com/prollyshoulda

In 2018, Tony bet a friend that he could get his pal Nadia to co-host a podcast and then drive her away by being the worst podcast co-host ever. At the same time, Nadia bet a friend that she could co-host a podcast for at least seven seasons no matter what. The simultaneous bets reach a head this week as they review the classic McConaughey/Hudson rom-com. Our theme song is "Yr Throat" by Jeff Rosenstock; Jeff's music is distributed under a Creative Commons license and available at quoteunquoterecords.com . This week's outro music is My Chemical Romance’s “Blood” as covered by VloggyOllie.

SUPPORT THE SHOW AT ko-fi.com/prollyshoulda

In 2000, two big-ticket high-profile Oscar-nominated stars helmed a sweet romcom that nobody saw and nobody remembers, only because everything that happens in the movie is completely insane and the main plotline is David Duchovny’s wife dying and her heart being transplanted into Minnie Driver, who then falls in love with David Duchovny separately. Nadia enters her David Duchovny phase. Tony brings back the podcast’s best segment, Aishwarya Rai Update. Our theme song is "Yr Throat" by Jeff Rosenstock; Jeff's music is distributed under a Creative Commons license and available at quoteunquoterecords.com . This week's outro music is My Chemical Romance’s “Dead!" as covered by lizzietupman.

SUPPORT THE SHOW AT ko-fi.com/prollyshoulda

A cameo from Michael Bloomberg. Ashton Kutcher learning the true meaning of New Year’s Eve. Bon Jovi playing Bon Jovi in a movie where they didn’t pay for the rights to any Bon Jovi songs. Could this be…the greatest movie of all time? Nadia and Tony celebrate the holidays with the most jaw-dropping all-star cast of 2011. Our theme song is "Yr Throat" by Jeff Rosenstock; Jeff's music is distributed under a Creative Commons license and available at quoteunquoterecords.com . This week's outro music is My Chemical Romance’s “Helena" as covered by Jessica Chi.

SUPPORT THE SHOW AT ko-fi.com/prollyshoulda

Tony and Nadia watch one of the most enduring teen movies of all time, and it’s actually pretty good so this one is more about how much Tony and Nadia have aged, and whether they themselves have aged poorly. Nadia investigates Paul Rudd’s parents. Tony discovers the most powerful ska song of all time. Our theme song is "Yr Throat" by Jeff Rosenstock; Jeff's music is distributed under a Creative Commons license and available at quoteunquoterecords.com . This week's outro music is My Chemical Romance’s “Welcome to the Black Parade" as covered by Sophie Scarlette.

SUPPORT THE SHOW AT ko-fi.com/prollyshoulda

Nadia and Tony tackle another classic high school rom-com, which is very pleasant and delightful if you can get past like six different adult characters becoming horny for high school students. Tony invents a new game. Nadia revisits her high school blog. Our theme song is "Yr Throat" by Jeff Rosenstock; Jeff's music is distributed under a Creative Commons license and available at quoteunquoterecords.com . This week's outro music is My Chemical Romance’s “Teenagers" as covered by Elise Ecklund.