A West Australian council spent an estimated $180,000 a year on disputes it never actually resolved.

One ratepayer was prosecuted for pulling weeds and planting native trees — then billed for his own prosecution.

Gavin Waugh is the founder of the Melville Shadow Council, a volunteer-run "council in waiting" set up to hold the City of Melville accountable between elections.

In this conversation, Gavin walks Nirmal through what pushed him to act after more than a decade of unresolved disputes, how local government oversight bodies actually work, and what he calls "crimes of participation" — the pattern he says councils use against residents who speak up.

A candid, occasionally uncomfortable look at how one of Perth's local councils operates, and what genuine community engagement could look like instead.

🔗 Melville Shadow Council: melville.shadowcouncil.org

Timestamps:

00:00 Cold Open: "I Pay for My Own Prosecution"

00:28 Welcome: Gavin Waugh, Melville Shadow Council

01:07 What Is Local Government Actually For?

03:00 Enter the Shadow Council: Bridging the Gap

04:26 One Volunteer, No Pay, No Access — How Does He Cope?

06:01 Are the Watchdogs Actually Independent?

07:12 12 Years in the Making: Why He Finally Acted

08:30 Answering the Mayor's "We're Already Transparent" Claim

11:04 The "Double Whammy": Paying to Be Prosecuted

12:09 Prosecuted for Planting Native Trees

14:02 What Is a Shadow Council, in Plain English?

14:59 Charged for Information the Law Says Is Free

15:43 What Does "Council in Waiting" Mean?

16:42 Why He Launched on April Fools' Day

17:19 Staying Motivated With Zero Funding

20:16 The "Revolving Door" of Local Government Oversight

22:38 Auditing the Auditors: Conflicts on the ARIC Committee

23:59 50+ "Council Failures" — and Counting

26:29 Volunteers: 1% on the Books, 30% in Reality

31:12 What New Migrants Should Know About Local Councils

33:06 What Real Community Engagement Should Look Like

36:49 Are Decisions Already Made Before You Speak?

37:46 What Are "Crimes of Participation"?

39:11 Is This Just Melville — or Every Council?

40:47 Why State Government Reforms Keep Failing

44:31 Two Changes He Wants to See in Two Years

45:57 The Personal Cost of Fighting City Hall

48:06 You're Convinced. Where Do You Start?

51:06 How to Contact the Melville Shadow Council

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Join and Subscribe to Perth Dialogues on our channels 👇

Support us Here: https://perthdialogues.au/

Join on YouTube: https://tinyurl.com/PD-Youtube

Listen on Spotify: https://tinyurl.com/PD-Spotify

Apple Podcasts: https://tinyurl.com/PD-ApplePodcasts

Amazon Music: https://tinyurl.com/PD-AmazonMusic

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Follow our host, Nirmal Singh, at

Website: https://nirmalsingh.au/

X (Twitter): https://x.com/nirmalsingh

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/nirmalsingh.au

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/nirmalsingh.au

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/psknirmal/