This week was set to be an intensive breakdown of the unreleased Philip Seymour Hoffman pilot for "Happyish"... until they pulled it from YouTube. Your Hoff-man hosts, Kyle and Brian, try to break it down anyway as they play the "what if" game in regards to PSH's television career, and what could have come to pass if Phil didn't leave us too early. Also, find out what won the poll for the April re-watch in a battle between two very personal projects: Love Liza and Jack Goes Boating.

Lots of Charlie Kaufman talk as the Hoff-Bros rewatch one of the most unique and PSH-centric films in the entire Hoffman catalog: Synecdoche, New York. Is the film pretentious? Self-indulgent? Overrated? Underrated? A little above their pay grade? Better or worse this time around? Kyle and Brian try to answer these questions while coming to the sad realization that they will never get to see Phil grow old like he does in this film. Enjoy!

After their surprise Valentine's Day episode of Along Came Polly, Kyle and Brian are back to choose the winner between A Late Quartet and Synecdoche, New York for the P.S. I Still Love Hoffman March 1 rewatch. Stay tuned after the episode for some earth-shattering and very happy-ish Hoffman news!

Surprise! Since Along Came Polly never gets enough love (or votes) from the Hoff-fans, Kyle and Brian decided to take matters into their own hands and rewatch it for Valentine's Day! Light those candles, draw the bubble bath, press that play button, and spend your February 14th letting it rain and rewatching Philip Seymour Hoffman's greatest comedic performance with your favorite Hoff-bros.

Despite Kyle campaigning that Along Came Polly be the rewatch for February, the Hoff-fans have spoken as Kyle and Brian will be rewatching Capote. Not a bad consolation prize, though, considering it features Philip Seymour Hoffman in his Academy Award-winning turn as Truman Capote. The guys discuss true crime, twin movies, and -- of course -- all things P.S.H.

In a heavyweight battle between two very different Philip Seymour Hoffman films, find out who the Hoff-Fans voted for in our next rewatch: Capote or Along Came Polly. There's a lot of Hoffman news this month, too, as we discuss year-end and decade-end lists that mention our main man, as well as some obligatory Oscars talk.

Brian and Kyle watch The Savages, a film they enjoyed on their first run, starring the great Laura Linney and of course, our main man Philip Seymour Hoffman (in one of his greatest performances). The pair play a brother and sister dealing with their new and sobering reality as caretakers of their father's failing health.

On the final installment of P.S. I Still Love Hoffman this decade, Kyle and Brian talk about a Hoffman film-themed restaurant, a big change in the show for next year and, of course, announce who won the monthly rewatch poll: Cold Mountain or The Savages.

Kyle and Brian end their first year of Hoffman rewatches with a stop-motion animation film -- and Philip Seymour Hoffman's only voiceover feature role -- in Mary and Max. The guys chat about the less-than-sunny subject matter and the intricate details of the animation, all the while sharing some laughs and sighs. Don't forget to listen for which movies will open our poll for our January 1 rewatch at the end of the episode!

Find out what the Hoff-bros think about movie studios using CGI to bring dead actors back to life on the screen, what Kyle's been watching on Disney+, and everything else that's going on in their lives, both related to Philip Seymour Hoffman and beyond. The guys also announce the winner of the Hoff-fan voting for their December 1 rewatch: Mary and Max or The Hunger Games: Catching Fire.