#RaceClass

#RaceClass

By #RaceClassEducation
Download on the App Store

#RaceClass episodes

  • Ep. 25 | When it Comes to DEI, The Left Keeps Feeding the Trolls
    Rightwing personalities are blaming DEI (“diversity, equity, inclusion”) for everything from broken Boeings and bankrupt banks to a flaccid military and train derailments. These are facially unserious claims. Yet they resonate with much of the public. One might say they enjoy a common-sense logic that pits diversity against excellence.
    We explore two factors that feed rightwing DEI smears: (1) engrained racial narratives that rationalize inequality and (2) the Left--specifically, liberal institutions that also rationalize inequality—even when doing so undermines their own DEI policies. To concretize the latter dynamic, we highlight Harvard’s failure to acknowledge all the ways its admissions process functions as preferential treatment for white (often wealthy) applicants.
    27 min
  • Ep. 24 | The Anti-Zionism = Antisemitism Power Play
    On Dec. 5, the U.S. House passed HR 894, which states that “anti-Zionism is antisemitism.” On the same day, House Republicans charged the presidents’ of Harvard, Penn and MIT with institutional “cultures” that “foster [antisemitism] because you have faculty and students who hate Jews, hate Israel and are comfortable apologizing for terror.” As Noah Zatz recently observed, both claims rely on a logical leap that requires “conflating the Israeli state with its Jewish residents in conjunction with metaphors of destruction.”
    Building on Zatz’s analysis, we interrogate the claim that anti-Zionism is anti-Semitism. Even recognizing that criticism targeting Israel can be antisemitic, the now-bipartisan claim that anti-Zionism equals anti-Semitism raises at least three serious concerns: (1) it is analytically fraught; (2) it is potentially dangerous for Jews and others (in part because it foments social division and can feed white supremacist ideologies like great replacement theory) and (c) it is a predictable and strategic effort to silence dissent and discredit antiracist movements in the United States and beyond and abroad.
    58 min
  • Ep. 23 | Why We Can't Talk About Israel-Palestine; A Conversation w/ Prof. Sahar Aziz
    On October 7, Hamas launched horrifying and unprecedented attacks targeting Israeli civilians and continues to hold Israeli hostages. Israel responded within an ongoing assault on Gaza that includes airstrikes and a blockade on humanitarian aid. Current estimates suggest that over 1,400 people have died in Israel and nearly 6,000 in Gaza. The conflict remains agonizing front-page news. And yet it feels as if we—the public, media, politicians—are incapable of really talking about what’s happening in Israel and Gaza. One reason is that this conflict, like many others, is racialized. This dynamic shapes how we process, perceive, and engage with the conflict—often in ways we do not see. Professor Sahar Aziz, an expert on authoritarianism, terrorism, and rule of law in the Middle East, joins #RaceClass to help us explore how the world continues to racialize the conflict in Israel and Gaza.
    #RaceClass Recs: The Racial Muslim (Aziz); Teach-In on Gaza (CSRR); Traces of the Master Narrative (Ikemoto)
    30 min
  • Ep. 21 | Why Ask Students About Race?
    In SFFA v. Harvard, the Supreme Court narrowed a university’s ability to consider the racial identity of individual students during admissions. Justice Roberts also emphasized that universities may consider each student’s personal experiences with race or racism. Many schools have responded by adding admissions essays that prompt students to share how race or racism affects their lives.
    In this episode of #RaceClass, we explore a basic question: Why ask about race? (Full disclosure: We're concerned that many schools are spending more time wordsmithing their essay prompt than thinking hard about why the question matters.) To help, we explore three answers: (1) academic “merit” includes racial literacy; (2) holistic review requires a full picture of each student’s lived experience; and (3) enrolling students with diverse experiences with racism means more learning for all.
    27 min
  • Ep. 20 | Our Free Speech Crisis. Don't Blame the Students.
    For our 20th Episode, we circle back to the beginning. In Episode 1, we asked why the mainstream press struggled so mightily to call the GOP’s campaign of discriminatory censorship what it is: an unapologetic assault on free speech. Unfortunately, little has changed. 18 months later, and much of the press remains mired in a dysfunctional and dangerous “free speech debate.” To correct that narrative, we dive into a Newsweek op-ed that Prof. Feingold published with renown critical theorists Professors Athena Mutua and Angela Harris, all members of the Critical (Legal) Collective. They identify four troubling dynamics that continue to distort our national “free speech” conversations: (1) misdiagnosing the crisis; (2) presuming universities can’t take sides; (3) selective sympathy for conservative viewpoints; (4) disdain for students. The upshot: there is a free speech crisis. Unless we see it or name it, we shouldn’t expect to survive it.
    #RaceClass Reqs: The Real Threat to Free Speech is Coming from the Right
    26 min
  • Ep. 19 | Some Affirmative Action Myths
    The opinion dropped. As we expected, conservative Justices invoked the claim that race-conscious policies stigmatize and mismatch their beneficiaries. Both claims have attracted sustained critique. But they still enjoy traction in the popular press and shape our national affirmative action conversations. In this episode of #RaceClass, we explore the racialized presumptions that anchor both claims.
    Consider the following. White men are routinely admitted to Harvard and other elite schools with lower mean test scores than their Asian American counterparts. Per stigma theory, all white men on campus should face a presumption of intellectual inferiority. Per the "mismatch" hypothesis, all those white men with lower scores would better off at "less competitive" schools. It’s hard to imagine anyone buying that. So why do parallel claims about stigma and mismatch, when directed at affirmative action and Black students, appear intuitive and obvious to so many?
    #RaceClass Reqs: Mismatched or Counted Out (Hawkins), Empirical Scholars Brief (Thaxton et al.); Cracking the Egg (Onwuachi-Willig et al.)
    27 min
  • Ep. 18 | Class Can't do the Work of Race
    Next month, the Supreme Court will likely ban universities from considering the racial identity of individual applicants. Many schools will seek “race-neutral alternatives” to retain a racially diverse student body. One likely alternative will be to consider each student’s class status (but not their racial identity)—or what Prof. Cheryl Harris has termed “class-NOT-race” admissions policies.
    If we want fair admissions, we should consider a student’s class status. But it’s a mistake to think class-based policies do the work of race-based policies. We would never think middle-class status insulates women from sexism. So why would we think middle-class status insulates people of color from racism. And here’s the kicker. The ultimate beneficiaries of class-NOT-race policies are not poor white students. Rather, they are wealthy white applicants and elite institutions, the individuals and entities who the status quo already favors.
    27 min
  • Ep. 17 | Why Are White Guys Exempt from Racial Profiling?
    Recent events have sparked well-worn debates about racial profiling. When these conversations arise, we often hear the claim that racial profiling is “rational.” We’re skeptical. Why? Because this claim rests on two faulty assumptions: (1) that we have accurate information in our heads & (2) that accurate information rationally shapes our behavior.
    Even were those assumptions correct, racial profiling also raises critical moral questions that rarely enter our national dialogue. What numbers justify profiling? Do we apply the same standard to different groups? What’s the proper unit of analysis? Are white men exempt?
    Racial profiling is not rational. Nor does racial profiling make us safer. But here's one clear consequence: racial profiling signals who is an insider worthy of America’s protection, and who is an outside that America will sacrifice for the “greater good.”
    #RaceClass Reqs: American Islamophobia (Beydoun) & Seeing Through Colorblindness (Kang & Lane)
    28 min
  • Ep. 16 | How to Talk About Race without Reproducing Racism; A conversation with Dr. Deadric Williams
    Consider the following two sentences:
    “White students are often over-represented on elite college campuses.”
    “Students racialized as white are often over-represented on elite college campuses.”
    The first might seem unobjectionable. The second might seem awkward and jargony. The challenge is, the phrase “white students” implies that “white” is some natural (perhaps even biological) trait that some people inherently possess. This contradicts the basic insight that race isn’t biological—to the contrary, people created “race” to rationalize social inequality and acts of extreme violence (including enslavement and conquest). Even if we know race is socially constructed, when our language treats racial categories as natural, it invites the conclusion that group-based inequality is also natural. So shifting language isn’t just about the words. It’s also the meaning those words convey. Thankfully, Dr. Deadric Williams, an Assistant Professor of Sociology at the University of Tennessee, joined #RaceClass to make it all make sense. For more insight from Dr. Williams, visit his website or follow him on Twitter.
    #RaceClass Reqs: (1) A Call to Focus on Racial Domination and Oppression (Williams); (2) Family Structure, Risks, and Racial Stratification in Poverty (Williams & Baker)
    28 min

About #RaceClass

From the publisher's feed

An award-winning series about race and racism with Boston University law professor Jonathan Feingold & WNHN host Arnie Arnesen.