
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


In the panic age, nothing offends like optimism
Narrated by Jared Moore
Art by Daniel Medina
Text published 10/29/25:
Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts
The House Oversight Committee’s report, “The Biden Autopen Presidency,” can be broken down into two basic parts:
Biden’s inner circle — or “politburo,” as the report characterizes it — worked like the two guys in Weekend at Bernie’s, constantly propping up the president to hide his declining cognitive condition from the public.
As a result, Biden was often not in charge, thus the need for the administration to use the autopen multiple times.
The report reaches a conclusion that reads like a judicial ruling: Absent evidence that Biden made executive decisions, “the Committee deems those actions taken through use of the autopen as void.” The report continues:
Barring evidence of executive actions taken during the Biden presidency showing that President Biden indeed took a particular executive action, the Committee deems those actions taken through use of the autopen as void. The validity of the executive actions allegedly approved and signed (largely by autopen) by President Biden must be reviewed to determine whether legal action is necessary to ameliorate consequences of any illegitimate pardons granted, or executive actions implemented, throughout the Biden Autopen Presidency. The Committee finds numerous executive actions—particularly clemency actions—taken during the Biden Administration were illegitimate.
Attorney General Pam Bondi responded the morning the report was released, saying her team was reviewing Biden’s use of the autopen for pardons.
The Oversight Committee’s report focuses on “executive actions,” particularly Biden’s last-minute pre-emptive pardons of family members and characters such as Anthony Fauci.
A federal appeals court said in a 2024 ruling that a pardon or commutation doesn’t require a president’s signature as long as it can be demonstrated that the president made the decision. The Oversight Committee’s report tries to make the case that proof of Biden’s executive actions is missing.
The Biden White House’s executive decision-making procedures were so lax that the chain of custody for a given decision is difficult or impossible to establish. Documents that were used to predicate executive actions should be sufficiently traceable to ensure they reflect the will of the president. Instead, the Biden White House’s flimsy procedure appears to have been extremely vulnerable to abuse.
Interestingly, the committee’s report does not address legislation that was signed by autopen, even though the U.S. Constitution says presidents “shall” sign bills they approve. Still, courts have not ruled whether it’s legal to sign legislation with an autopen. In 2011, President Obama became the first president to “sign” legislation by autopen. The administration relied on a 2005 Justice Department opinion for its legal justification.
You can read more about that opinion below as part of Racket News’ timeline of events, controversies and key documents concerning the autopen.
Subscribe now
March 27, 1929Acting Solicitor General Alfred Wheat writes a memorandum that says presidential pardons do not require an “autograph,” but that “custom and propriety require that the pardoned man be given some token to show that he has been pardoned.”
1929 Acting Solicitor General Memo4.44MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadJuly 7, 2005The Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel issue an opinion that concludes:
The President need not personally perform the physical act of affixing his signature to a bill he approves and decides to sign in order for the bill to become law. Rather, the President may sign a bill within the meaning of Article I, Section 7 by directing a subordinate to affix the President’s signature to such a bill, for example by autopen.”
Although the Justice Department researched the topic at the request of the White House, President Bush never signed legislation with the autopen.
Memorandum 2005 Bush DoJ371KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadMay 26, 2011President Obama becomes the first president to sign legislation with the autopen. The president was in Deauville, France, for the G8 Summit while Congress voted to extend provisions in the Patriot Act. They would have expired without his immediate signature.
May 27, 2011Georgia Congressman Tom Graves expresses concerns about the autopen in a letter to Obama. Graves notes the U.S. Constitution says the president “shall” sign legislation he approves, and seeks clarity that Obama was fully informed of what he had the autopen sign.
Mr. President, I write to request your confirmation that S. 990, as passed by Congress, was presented to you prior to the autopen signing, as well as a detailed, written explanation of your Constitutional authority to assign a surrogate the responsibility of signing bills passed by Congress into law.
Tom Graves Letter35.7KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadGraves follows up in a June 17, 2011 letter to Obama that asks him to re-sign the legislation with his real signature. This time, 20 Republican colleagues also sign the letter.
Autopenletter061711128KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadJanuary 2, 2013The Obama administration for the second time uses an autopen to sign legislation while the president is on vacation in Hawaii. The autopen was used to sign high-profile “fiscal cliff” legislation to avoid spending cuts that would have taken effect if tax breaks were not extended.
February 13, 2024The Fourth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals references the 1929 Wheat memo in a ruling that says pardons don’t require a president’s signature as long as it’s clear the president made the clemency decision.
“…nothing in the Constitution restricts the President’s exercise of the clemency power to commutations that have been rendered through a documented writing…But such a clemency warrant or, indeed, any writing, is not required for the President to exercise this authority under the Constitution. Hypothetically, the President could proclaim at a press conference in the Rose Garden that he has pardoned a particular individual, and that would be a valid act…even absent a writing.”
021324 Rosemond Decision204KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadMarch 14-17, 2025President Trump posts on Truth Social that whoever controlled the autopen was the real president during the Biden Administration. He also declares the Biden’s pardons are “VOID, VACANT, AND OF NO FURTHER FORCE OR EFFECT” because they were signed by an autopen.
The conservative Heritage Foundation’s “Oversight Project” determines that 32 of Biden’s 51 clemency warrants (affecting 4,245 people) were signed by two different autopen signatures. This finding was cited in the House Oversight Committee’s report.
The Oversight Project also argues the 2005 legal opinion on the autopen was wrong, and “the Biden Administration’s apparent rampant use of the autopen reveals the very reason that OLC’s 2005 Opinion is erroneous at its core. Once the requirement for a wet signature is dispensed with, an important safeguard against fraud is removed, and an historical lawless Administration combined with a cognitively impaired President leads to the exact situation we are in—no one can be sure what actions President Biden actually authorized.”
Oversight Project Heritage Foundation Memorandum2.44MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadJune 4, 2025Trump writes a memo that directs his White House counsel to work with the Attorney General to investigate Biden’s use of the autopen. From the memo:
Given clear indications that President Biden lacked the capacity to exercise his Presidential authority, if his advisors secretly used the mechanical signature pen to conceal this incapacity, while taking radical executive actions all in his name, that would constitute an unconstitutional wielding of the power of the Presidency, a circumstance that would have implications for the legality and validity of numerous executive actions undertaken in Biden’s name.
A formal report in response to this directive has not been released.
July 13, 2025Biden defends his administration’s use of the autopen, telling the New York Times that “I made every decision” in regard to the pardons and commutations he made at the end of his term. The Times also posted excerpts of its 10-minute phone interview with him.
September 24, 2025A new display of presidential portraits debuts outside the West Wing, but in place of Biden’s face is a framed picture of an autopen signing Biden’s name.
October 28, 2025Republicans on the House Oversight Committee release a 91-page report that alleges Biden’s “loyal senior staff” engaged in a cover-up of his declining health and “numerous instances in which the president’s approval for an executive action or the chief of staff’s approval of signature by autopen was not memorialized.”
The report includes testimony of a Biden administration official, Anthony Bernal, who served as an assistant to the president and as chief of staff to first lady Jill Biden.
In the video above, Bernal is asked if “any unelected official or family member of President Joe Biden execute[d] the duties of the Presidency?”
Bernal answers by exercising his Fifth Amendment rights.
Meanwhile Democrats on the Oversight Committee release a 14-page rebuttal. That report gives examples of Biden Administration officials testifying that Biden “managed complex policy discussions.”
Moreover, the autopen “scandal” manufactured by Chairman Comer and House Republicans proved to be nothing more than a feeble attempt to attack the legitimacy of President Biden’s policies—a pretext to invalidate executive actions by President Biden, including valid pardons issued pursuant to his constitutional authority. After extensive witness interviews and numerous media appearances, the Majority has produced no credible evidence to substantiate his assertions, demonstrating once again his preference for partisanship over genuine oversight.
Republican House Oversight Report 1028258.5MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadDemocratic Rebuttal 1028251020KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadRacket News is a reader-supported publication. Consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Watch Episode 156
Matt Taibbi: All right. Welcome to America This Week. I’m an exhausted Matt Taibbi.
Walter Kirn: And I’m not just an exhausted Walter Kirn. I’m daft to use the British term. So, Walter Kirn just got, who’s speaking of himself in the third person. I’d speak of myself in the fourth person if it was possible, because I’m that detached from my own being.
Matt Taibbi: You are the Ricky Henderson of novelists right now.
Walter Kirn: Yeah. So, yeah, I got back from my cabin yesterday after three weeks of no human contact other than over the internet and on speakerphone. I was speaking to everybody in real life as though I were on speakerphone very loudly and not really looking them in the eye. Also, I had lost track of my own level of fatigue, and it turns out that you are able to be tired beyond tired without knowing it until you get back and have to do normal things. Also, I was writing many thousands of words a day, and so the normal speed at which people spoke to me wasn’t enough. And I went into several stores hoping to conclude really complicated transactions like shopping for clothes within three minutes. And when that couldn’t be done and there were other customers, I made myself one of the most unwelcome people on earth. So, how I’ll behave here, I really have no idea. I might be uncharacteristically quiet and monosyllabic.
Matt Taibbi: We both might be for different reasons.
Walter Kirn: But this is all in the service of a book for people who haven’t kept up with the sad narrative. And the book is within a quarter of a chapter of being finished.
Matt Taibbi: You’re in the Zeno’s paradox stage of the book being done.
Walter Kirn: Yes.
Matt Taibbi: Which is where the ending is so close that you can’t even measure the distance to it. But no matter how hard you work, you never get closer than half the distance to finishing it in a day.
Walter Kirn: And the thing about endings, I should tell future reviewers of the book so that they can pretend to discern something themselves that I actually told them. The thing about endings is they grow more and more important as you approach them. So, every word becomes double, triple, quadruple important. And that puts more pressure on your completely exhausted mind. And not only is it hard to finish, you’re afraid to finish. The last word of a book, I remember when James Joyce was taught to me and they said the last word of Ulysses, after all those words, after all that complexity is yes. And that-
Matt Taibbi: That’s right.
Walter Kirn: That affirms life, and it affirms mankind’s spirit and saying yes to destiny and so on. Because remember, he comes home and he finds out his wife has been fooling around, but he doesn’t care. It’s still a yes. And I thought, wow, that really puts a lot of pressure on the rest of us. They used one of the main words, actually, not a word that you would ever put at the end of a book and never really, except in dialogue or something. Now what’s going to be my yes, what are we down to?
Matt Taibbi: Yeah, how do you get to yes, also, right?
Walter Kirn: Well, I think we’re down to salamander and other rather esoteric and uncommon words as our last words, but which will mine be, I don’t know.
Matt Taibbi: You don’t know yet. Yeah, it’s funny. So, I was actually spared this agony that you’re going through now with the book, The Divide. I had a hard deadline for that book, and my wife was due to give birth a week after it, but went into labor on the day. So, we get to the hospital and we’re trying to get her comfortable and get the anesthesia going and everything, and the phone rings and they’re like, “We need it now.” I’m like, “I’m a little busy.” And that wasn’t an exception. This is Random House. So, I had to finish the book on my phone and while my wife waited to go into labor with my first child, for her first child.
Walter Kirn: These are the war stories of literature that need to be told to young people. First of all-
Matt Taibbi: You have to be willing to, yes.
Walter Kirn: To do that, you have to be willing to finish your book on your phone while your wife is giving birth otherwise-
Matt Taibbi: And glaring at you.
Walter Kirn: And glaring, yeah. And hating you, of course.
Matt Taibbi: I’ll be right with you.
Walter Kirn: Otherwise, dentistry, always an option.
Matt Taibbi: Oh, man.
Walter Kirn: Okay.
Matt Taibbi: All right. So, you’ve been going down the home stretch of writing a book. I’m still recovering from a brain injury and ill on top of that. And it’s been kind of a difficult week as you say, you learn that you can build up exhaustion and not realize it until-
Walter Kirn: Yes.
Matt Taibbi: Yeah. And so when I had the thing happen with my head, I slept for five days now. I guess that must’ve been the deficit I was operating under.
Walter Kirn: Right, exactly.
Matt Taibbi: I’m still a little fuzzy, but a lot of stuff happened in this week, and a lot of it is the kind of stuff that I normally love, like arcane sort of …
Walter Kirn: Corruption.
Matt Taibbi: Minutiae in documents. I love those kinds of stories, but now I’m having a little trouble with it. But let’s start with a couple of, and also there’s some things with, we’re reading Animal Farm and we’ll get to this later, but there is a new movie of this book that has an interesting twist on …
Walter Kirn: On Marxism, that it’s really capitalism.
Matt Taibbi: It’s so funny. I can’t wait to get to that. But let’s start with something petty because why not? I believe it’s eight. This is Lawrence O’Donnell up in arms, up in arms, angry that CNN continues to hire keep in its employee ... Well, let’s just watch.
Link Here: Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the Free Previews of America This Week:
Watch ATW on YouTube below:
In the process of writing “Bill Gates Says We’ll Survive Climate Change, World Furious” the other day, I was forced down an interesting rhetorical rabbit hole, but it was too much of a mouthful for that article. The issue however came up again in the new America This Week, as Walter and I discussed Animal Farm. A sign from above! So, returning to the theme:
First, I misused the word “optimism” in describing Gates’s conversion on climate. As the Microsoft co-founder is a monopolistic reptile-whore of the highest order who smells money through his flickering tongue, never budging except in the direction of more profits, my guess is Gates reached a real “tipping point,” in which his climate advocacy had finally become too large of a pimple on the chin of Microsoft’s business model. Amid efforts to lock down the AI-generation equivalent of OS, his old firm will need the energy footprint of a small star. “It turns out humans will survive!” in that sense just feels like a follow up to other cheery posts about next-gen nuke plants.
Nonetheless, Gates and other climate activists have always issued caveats in fine print suggesting warnings like “We have 12 years to live!” weren’t meant to be taken literally, because (as the New York Times just put it) “even the most dire forecasts don’t predict… the end of civilization anytime soon.” As was the case with Covid, tariff catastrophe and other issues, a lot of modern press rhetoric is designed to inspire unmitigated terror. This eliminates phrases like, “Very bad, but…” Things are either total disasters or not.
One fascinating way of doing that has been to reverse the concept of “conspiracy theory.” Once, you were a socially unacceptable kook if you believed in invisible connections between the Bildeburgs, Rothschilds, the CIA, and whatever else you’d read about. You know, like Michael Moore being the Bush administration’s bullhorn:
Ironically, Moore would get a taste of the new conspiracy theory concept when he later produced a movie that questioned the environmentalist movement. He became an exemplar of a new word, one which rendered Gibson-style kookdom upon those who didn’t absolutely believe in things:
DENIALISM: Barely used until this century, it spiked in the middle 2010s.Denialism’s ascent was due almost entirely to the global warming issue. If you look at the graph above you’ll see a spike in the early 2000s, which appears related to a handful of books and articles, mostly about denial of the Holocaust. But the term really took off with the 2009 publication of Denialism: How Irrational Thinking Hinders Scientific Progress, Harms the Planet, and Threatens Our Lives, by New York Times author Michael Specter:
Future themes not just of media campaigns but efforts to tackle “science denialism” through censorship were present in this book, which Specter explained grew in part out of a dinner party encounter:
Subscribe now
Specter, with whom I crossed paths occasionally in Russia, described being invited to dinner by a “prominent, well-read, and worldly woman” who asked what he was working on. He mentioned being “mystified” that so many Americans “seemed to question the fundamental truths of science and their value to society,” examples being “anxiety about agricultural biotechnology, opposition to vaccinations, and the growing power of the alternative health movement.”
The woman “became animated,” saying it was about time somebody “writes the truth about these pharmaceutical companies.” The government, she said, was “no better,” as it’s “destroying our food supply and poisoning our water.” Taken aback, Specter wrote:
The woman didn’t actually say, “It’s all a conspiracy,” but she didn’t have to. Denialism couldn’t exist without the common belief that scientists are linked, often with the government, in an intricate web of lies.
This thesis, that “denialism” is just the flip side of conspiracy theory, is what would soon send the word rocketing into mass use. It’s a perfect twist on Orwell. If the “conspiracy theorist” is the person who too easily accepts an implausible story, the “denialist” is the person who refuses to accept the pronouncements of authority, implicitly because they believe someone else’s crackpot story. Just like that, a skeptic can be repackaged as a conspiracy theorist, even though they’re usually opposites.
Specter’s book went on to posit that scandals like the implosion of Vioxx, a supposed anti-inflammatory wonder drug removed from shelves in the early 2000s over concerns about heart attack and stroke, dealt a death blow to the “cloak of invincibility” citizens previously ascribed to big science and government regulators. But the book featured a fascinating twist.
Because I’ve been living for so long in a world where media insists “the science” is unanimous about climate change, I expected Denialism to argue that the Vioxx mess led straight to people failing to accept scientific pronouncements on the warming planet. I forgot scientists once saw their roles as being gung-ho about fixing problems, not preaching about how we should “recognize our failure,” as UN Secretary General António Guterres put it this week.
Denialism — a book that came out in the first year of Barack Obama’s presidency — turned to the story of Thomas Malthus, the English economist who in 1798 wrote a book arguing that population was already rising at a pace beyond the planet’s ability to feed itself. His error was so historic it garnered a name, the Malthusian Trap. Specter saw the backlash against Big Pharma, government, and genetic engineering as similar flawed thinking, as evidenced by our shopping habits.
“It would be hard to argue with Dostoyevsky’s assertion that a society’s level of civilization can best be judged from its prisons,” he said, but that now, “a supermarket might be a better place to look—and in America today that supermarket would have to be Whole Foods.”
What’s wrong with Whole Foods? To Specter, its “shared fate” slogan, which “would require a sensible effort to keep destructive growth in check, and to find harmony in a world that is rapidly becoming depleted.” Specter thought the belief in “destructive growth” was a Malthusian trap. He wrote about running into a woman in Whole Foods who sounded much like his dinner guest. “What kind of society kills itself by eating?” she said. He concluded:
Calls for sustainability are no longer sales pitches or countercultural affectations; they have become a governing mantra of the progressive mind.
In 2009, it was still possible for a New York Times writer to suggest the world can MacGyver its way out of population problems. Within six years, that would change. The 2008 financial crisis was Vioxx times a billion in its damage to “expertise,” and the election of Donald Trump ended positive pop-culture portrayals of the free market. The old-school Thomas Friedman take on global capitalism — that it was wrapping earth in a “Golden Straitjacket” of irrepressible wealth accumulation — was gone. Soon the only companies that got high marks were those that went out of their way to solve social problems like racism and global warming, like… Whole Foods:
Still, Specter nailed the formula for future propaganda. The real sin was lack of trust in experts, which Specter also identified as coming from fear of “ceding control of our lives to technology,” particularly “highly sophisticated technology we can barely understand.” Denialism, he said, “is at least partly a defense against that sense of helplessness.”
Trumpism was marketed as a similar kind of fear, of ceding control not just to science, but all experts. His election in 2016 was largely explained as a bad case of “truth decay,” with voters losing faith in NATO, the Fed, the mass media, and other institutions. As the Harvard Gazette put it in 2020, “Republicans have successfully seized upon a larger cultural trend of diminished faith in experts around issues like climate change.”
There was probably a lot of truth in the idea that Trump won votes because people lost faith in expertise. The part usually left out is that this distrust was earned. Before the 2008 financial crisis the ultimate “expert,” Alan Greenspan, urged the public to use home equity as ATMs. Ben Bernanke and Timothy Geithner assured us massive intervention to save Wall Street was necessary. The CIA, Pentagon, and Specter’s own New York Times promised us we’d find WMDs in Iraq. Whistleblowers like Ed Snowden and Julian Assange came forward to tell the public it had been lied to a grand scale about whole ranges of things.
By 2016, there was a lot that was rational in rejecting expert pronouncements. This is where Specter’s term, denialism, became a handy way of implying irrationality when there often was none:
“Denialism” now can refer to anything from refusing to accept Russiagate to denying climate change (the most common use) to denying Covid dictates to election results to the October 7th massacre (or Gaza atrocities). Many of those topics are genuinely controversial, but two in particular — climate change and 2020 “election denial” — have been used over and over to argue against “both-sidesism,” and for “moral clarity” reporting. If there’s only one legitimate “side” to report, then why bother to look for other opinions?
The rise of denialism is a classic case of the tail wagging the dog. The word was rare before because only a handful of things were considered beyond the realm of argument. In the Internet age, however, people were presented with more alternative information than ever before, which meant an explosion of skepticism in part of the population. Another part of the population, however, saw that skepticism as dangerous. Unfortunately, a fair chunk of those people worked in media, where skepticism used to be a job prerequisite. Now they’ve became inquisitors, looking for “denialists” to denounce and expose.
Orwell would have admired the elegance of “denialism.” Unfortunately, he’ll be too busy spinning in his grave for all eternity thanks to the coming remake of Animal Farm-as-capitalist-critique Walter and I just discussed. You can’t have everything! Have a good weekend, folks, and apologies for the technical delays with America This Week…
Note to Listeners: Our apologies for the delay with today’s podcast, we’re experiencing an issue uploading the video to Substack.
In the meantime, subscribers can watch the episode on YouTube using the link below.
We’ll send out a new post with the Substack version as soon as it’s available.
Thanks for your patience and we hope you enjoy the episode!
— Racket
From the “You can’t make this up” file:
Billionaire Bill Gates yesterday gave an interview on CNBC and released an essay called “Three Tough Truths About Climate.” One of the “tough truths” was — this is not a joke — “Climate change is a serious problem, but it will not be the end of civilization.” Gates put his “truth” in a box under a field, probably the most humorously grasping use of green imagery since the UNorth commercial in Michael Clayton.
Why survival should be “tough” news wasn’t clarified, but Gates offered a summary of his thesis:
There’s a doomsday view of climate change that goes like this:
In a few decades, cataclysmic climate change will decimate civilization. The evidence is all around us—just look at all the heat waves and storms caused by rising global temperatures. Nothing matters more than limiting the rise in temperature.
Fortunately for all of us, this view is wrong. Although climate change will have serious consequences—particularly for people in the poorest countries—it will not lead to humanity’s demise. People will be able to live and thrive in most places on Earth for the foreseeable future. Emissions projections have gone down, and with the right policies and investments, innovation will allow us to drive emissions down much further.
Reaction was swift and furious. In the words of the immortal Greta Thunberg, “HOW DARE YOU!” The New York Times rushed a piece out titled, “Bill Gates Says Climate Change ‘Will Not Lead To Humanity’s Demise.’” The paper linked to Gates’s net worth on the Bloomberg Billionaires’ Index, to his prior comments about irreversible ecological damage, and to the Gates Foundation’s $1.4 billion commitment to climate change research. It didn’t link to Gates’s new essay, though, instead quoting the editor of Inside Philanthropy, who said “one could imagine” this was Gates’s way of “not wanting to be a target of the Trump administration.” Social media is still burning with theories about Gates betraying the climate cause to get out from under an investigation into his foundation’s alleged funding of Chinese entities. The imminent extinction dream is dying hard.
On the eve of the the COP30 climate summit in Brazil, Gates’s downshift from “We’re gonna die!” to “A serious but survivable problem” was ripped as a grievous affront. The climate story has been reported as an extinction panic for decades, in the process becoming one of the most influential news stories ever. Its impact reached far beyond energy policy to realms like mental health, family planning, even journalism and academic freedom. Ostensible uniformity of climate consensus was used as an argument against both “viewpoint diversity” on campuses and objective “both sides” reporting.
Global warming and the certainty of a “sixth mass extinction” became this century’s End-Times religion, replete with the Millerite pattern of repeat “final” warnings and failed predictions or “tipping points” (we reportedly just passed one two weeks ago, missing a chance to prevent “widespread dieback”). Even when warnings were scientifically accurate, the concept of unsurvivable catastrophe was still treated as an article of faith, and refusal to panic could be a cancelable offense. Denial of climate emergency was even listed in Twitter’s Files as the company’s “canonical” (!) example of “unhealthy content,” i.e. speech that should be shadow-banned even if it doesn’t violate rules:
Climate denial, the “canonical” speech offenseNow one of the most influential figures in the fight against global warming, a man who just a few years ago wrote a book called How to Avoid a Climate Disaster, essentially just mumbled “never mind,” in a memo that reads like an admission of strategic overreach.
“To use the British expression, they over-egged the custard,” says Professor Steven Koonin, former Undersecretary for Science in Barack Obama’s Department of Energy and author of Unsettled.
Just when you thought the world had exhausted the reasons for hating Gates, people on all sides of the climate issue are seething. The Microsoft titan will go down in history as God’s own proof that no amount of money can buy likeability:
Subscribe now
Scientist James Hansen’s testimony to Congress in 1988 is generally credited as the beginning of climate change as a popular news phenomenon, but voices ranging from Al Gore to Bill McKibben to Stephen Hawking have been sounding alarms ever since. As Gore described it, global warming was a “planetary emergency” that was “beyond politics.” I remember reading the environmentalist McKibben’s pucker-inducing book The End of Nature, in which he warned readers not to think of slow, “geologic” time anymore, but to realize “we have already stepped over the threshold” of irreversible change, being “at the end of nature” already.
Man, I remember thinking, that’s harsh. There was no reason to doubt it, especially since my work at the time had led me on a tour of some of the world’s grimmest ecological disasters (seeing the vanished Aral Sea in person was a reality check). Still, my generation’s cautionary horror tale was nuclear war, not warming, so I never had the experience of growing up saturated in apocalyptic climate messaging. Members of the next generations weren’t so lucky, served those scare stories constantly, almost as a prophylactic against relaxation and happiness. It worked. By October of last year, an astonished 62.9% of people between the ages of 16 and 25 agreed with the statement, “Humanity is doomed.” Over half of respondents, 52%, agreed with the statement, “I’m hesitant to have children.”
Climate fear soared in 2018, when the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change issued a report warning of “severe consequences” for humanity if action was not taken to keep temperatures from rising more than 1.5 degrees Celsius by 2030 (this is the “tipping point” we reportedly failed to avoid two weeks ago). This birthed the “We have 12 years to act” catch-phrase, which in turn birthed even darker predictions and led to the elevation of the aforementioned Swedish super-celebrity Thunberg, who earned repeat Nobel Peace Prize nominations for scaring the crap out of me via a speech demanding, “How dare you watch your Patriots game! You have stolen my childhood!”
The impact climate messaging (or education, if you prefer) had on Thunberg’s generation was described in a strange way. Harvard researchers in 2023 wrote semi-approvingly about “climate anxiety,” with one adolescent psychiatrist explaining that while some see generalized anxiety as a “pathological response that needs to be treated,” climate anxiety was different: “A healthy response to a real threat.” Other academics agreed that youths feeling a “chronic fear of environmental doom” and experiencing “panic attacks, loss of appetite, irritability, weakness and sleeplessness” were behaving more healthily than those who turned away “in denial or disavowal.” Climate anxiety was not pathological but “adaptive,” according to Cambridge researchers. No one thought the idea of a society that believes in “adaptive anxiety” was odd.
Some celebrated the success older generations had in freaking out the world’s youth, with people like Thunberg celebrated for expressing feelings of “intergenerational injustice,” having been “invalidated, betrayed, and abandoned” by old-heads who failed to fix the planet. This always seemed strange. Again, even if warnings were accurate, why foster anxiety on purpose? Would we teach young people to embrace being panicked and irritable before sending them to deal with war, pestilence, invading aliens, or any other serious challenge? If older voices were wrong to instill these fears they were doing terrible psychological damage, but even if warnings were right they were prematurely signaling failure, weakening the country through a campaign that was like the opposite of “Nothing to fear but fear itself.” We split the atom on a clock and went to the moon, but can’t fix this? What’s been the utility in thinking this way?
These constant invocations of disaster haven’t even had their intended effect. CNN poll guru Harry Enten went on air this summer to complain that it “boggles the mind” that Americans aren’t more “afraid of climate change,” given “everything that we see on our television screens… the hurricanes, the tornadoes, the flooding”:
Enten’s boggled mind offered a hint into why the “doomsday” approach might have failed. In Unsettled, Koonin wrote about a “disconnect” that’s produced in “the long game of telephone that starts with the research literature and runs through the assessment reports to the summaries of the assessment reports and on to the media coverage.” An example of such telephone “disconnect” is simple confusion of weather and climate, a constant feature of coverage. Should the public be worried about climate change because they see pictures of storms, tornadoes, and floods on CNN? Many political figures and scientists (like “Science Guy” Bill Nye) say yes. Joe Biden traveled to my home state of New Jersey in 2021 and declared a “code red” warning, saying Hurricane Ida was evidence of an “existential threat” of climate change.
Other scientists however contest claims of worsening weather data, while still others (like Koonin) insist individual weather events aren’t as important, and the crucial issue is their frequency over time. Around the same time Biden was declaring his existential code red, bodies like the American Meterological Society were declaring a slight decrease in the quantity of hurricanes over time, echoing findings by a number of other bodies (even the Washington Post in 2015 ran a story saying, “Global Warming Fueling Fewer But Stronger Hurricanes”). The climate consensus constantly referred to seems to involve most scientists agreeing that the earth is warming and agreeing this is due (or “very likely” or “extremely likely” due, according to a common caveat) to human activity. There are controversies about almost everything else, though, many of which the public never hears about because of algorithmic suppression and other factors.
There are few headlines telling the public people NASA satellite imagery shows the earth has actually gotten greener over the last 100 years. The celebrated late physicist Freeman Dyson, known to Star Trek fans as the creator of the “Dyson Sphere” idea featured in a Next Generation edisode, told an interviewer at Princeton that this was caused by carbon dioxide, leading to an increased food supply, as one would expect in any greenhouse. Obviously, not everyone agrees with him, but the intense media emphasis on drowning out such alternative views seems to have contributed to a public that has been freaked out, but not always well-informed, being hyper-focused on only certain facts:
I’m not at all saying climate change isn’t a problem, just that reinventing coverage to downplay alternative theories or ambiguous data to facilitate the amping of social concern (read: fear) has been a disaster, one that Gates played a huge role in creating. It’s helped create a population that tends to catastrophize everything, not just news about the environment.
Because the press in the last century hyped everything from “Africanized bees” to Dungeons and Dragons as civilization-imperiling threats, young reporters were once warned against over-selling fear. That ended with climate coverage, one of the first stories to fit seamlessly with the new dynamics of digital media. Being both terrifying and “not debatable,” as Gore put it, global warming was a prototypical early fixation in the Manichean hellscape of doom-scrolling zealotry that quickly came to characterize 21st century thought.
PR campaigns to spread climate awareness stressed that mere reporting wasn’t enough to effect change. Shaming campaigns were employed (“climate denialism” eventually became a mark of shame on the order of Holocaust denialism), and some of the earliest efforts to enlist Internet platforms to “moderate” controversial speech involved climate discussions. Along with suppression, algorithms were created to amplify and/or defend certain voices in the movement, especially Gates himself, whom companies like Blackbird.AI described as victims of “conspiratorial” hashtags like #gates and #WEF. The now-defunct Global Engagement Center devoted State Department resources to warnings about pretty damn small accounts that criticized Gates:
Left, a GEC report on an account “critical of Bill Gates.” Right, a since-deleted tweetInstead of finding ways to stimulate discussion, the climate “debate” over time became framed as anti-discussion, where hunting “denial” became as important as awareness. This became the template for coverage of a range of other social-emergency stories, from Covid to the 2020 racism health crisis to last year’s “end of democracy” election. These and other “doomsday” stories all had one thing in common: people became so used to having their “adaptive” anxieties stoked via maximalist scare headlines that they became genuinely unreceptive to suggestions that life might not be so bad.
In the last day and a half, for instance, most papers rejected the Gates claim that “we’ve made great progress” and that climate change “will not lead to humanity’s demise.” The Guardian fumed that this was “at odds” with the pronouncements of UN Secretary General António Guterres, who said it was instead time to “recognize our failure” with regard to the climate crisis. The New York Times, while conceding there’s “some truth” to the Gates pronouncements, because “even the most dire forecasts don’t predict that rising temperatures will mean the end of civilization anytime soon” — a startling passage on its own — still insisted the billionaire’s decision to focus on other poverty issues fed into rhetoric “usually propagated by climate skeptics” that “pits efforts to tackle climate change against foreign aid for the poor.” I could not find a single mainstream report that suggested any of the optimism in the memo should be taken seriously.
This is similar to how audiences reacted throughout Covid to studies suggesting mortality rates were lower than initially reported, or that natural immunity was effective, or that healthy children had a low risk of death, or other encouraging news. We even saw this phenomenon with Russiagate, when news outlets had to brace audiences to be “disappointed” that Donald Trump might not turn out to be a Russian agent. Panic über alles!
Creating a population that wants to stay in a constant state of “adaptive” terror, to the point where it can’t tell the difference between a fixable problem and the end of the world seems to have been a conscious aim of decades of Gates-ian propaganda. Has it worked? Have “anti-disinformation” programs designed to prevent people from seeing the “canonical” sin of denialism increased public concern? Polls show they haven’t. It’s infurating that it will probably take a comment from Gates himself to make it socially acceptable for people to pull back from the ledge.
“Climate ain’t nothing,” says Koonin, “but it ain’t everything.”
The new left movement in America is taking off mostly with the very wealthy, which isn’t an accident
Narrated by Jared Moore
Art by Daniel Medina
Text published 10/27/25:
Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts
Thank you , , , , , and many others for tuning into my live video! Join me for my next live video in the app.
Get more from Matt Taibbi in the Substack appAvailable for iOS and AndroidGet the appReader Paul Edwards, on today’s Mamdani/Platner piece:
Are you a card-carrying Exceptionalist, Matt, that you believe this Capitalist whorehouse of a country to be the most benign system for its citizens? Do you really believe the vitriol you pour on Marxism and its tenets and how terrible its effects have been in the world, never mind that it has never once been implemented anywhere. Do you believe America has been a great force for good in the world? If so, where?
Let’s see: defeating the Nazis and Imperial Japan, accepting more refugees from Nazi Germany than any other country, inventing polio vaccine, chemotherapy, the Internet, nuclear power, cars, airplanes, movies, radio, electric light, frozen food, the phonograph, both the telephone and cell phones, rock n’ roll, jazz, and hip-hop, TV, the transistor, the pill, basketball and volleyball, Star Trek and Star Wars, 425 Nobel laureates, free speech, free press, and freedom of religion, The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, Moby-Dick, The Invisible Man, and Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas, the Panama Canal, trans-oceanic communication, the poems of Frost, Poe, MacLeish, and Emily Dickinson, personal computers, the assembly line, landing on the moon, and rebuilding Europe, off the top of my head. I also like Mounds bars, Cheerios, and football, but what do I know?
I get it, you read Howard Zinn once, but if we did “what has America done for the world, besides X?” for real, the remaining Monty Python members would die of old age before it ended. Are people really this crazy?