Racket News

Racket News

By Matt Taibbi
Download on the App Store

All Racket News episodes

  • At Last: John Brennan and James Comey Under Criminal Investigation for Russiagate
    Above, former FBI Director James Comey testifies to the Senate Intelligence Committee in June, 2017. Below, former CIA chief John Brennan testifies to the same committee in January, 2017. Both figures are now being investigated for perjury

    What a roller-coaster the last week has been.

    On the heels of the devastating, embarrassing announcement by Donald Trump’s Justice Department that there would be no new document releases in the Jeffrey Epstein case, there is real — if confusing — progress in an equally explosive investigation. In a story first broken by Fox News, reported further by Margot Cleveland at The Federalist, Miranda Devine at the New York Post, and Paul Sperry at RealClear Investigations, and bolstered now by our own sources at Racket, it’s confirmed: FBI Director Kash Patel has opened criminal investigations into former CIA chief John Brennan and former FBI Director James Comey, for offenses related to the Trump-Russia scandal colloquially known as “Russiagate.”

    The opening of criminal probes into two of the most powerful enforcement chiefs of the Trump era marks the first steps toward consequences for the elaborate and historically unprecedented intelligence fraud that for years consumed American politics. The Bureau will look at possible perjury and conspiracy offenses for both, focusing initially on how Brennan’s CIA and Comey’s FBI worked to produce the infamous “Intelligence Community Assessment” of January 6th, 2017.

    The public portion of that report included a summary that said that the agencies assessed that “[Vladimir] Putin and the Russian Government aspired to help President-elect Trump’s election chances when possible by discrediting Secretary Clinton.” This narrative — that Russia not only “influenced” the 2016 election but “aspired” to help Donald Trump at Hillary Clinton’s expense — quickly became conventional wisdom in media, then snowballed into a political scandal and a Special Counsel investigation that for some time seemed destined to topple the first Trump presidency:

    The crucial “key judgments” section of the 2017 Intelligence Community Assessment

    As ambitious as that caper was, the scope of the new Brennan-Comey probes appears limited to process issues raised in an 8-page report on Russiagate’s origins released by CIA director John Ratcliffe. This has been a source of concern to some who were hoping for a heavier wallop. House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence (HPSCI) chair Rick Crawford, for instance, sent Trump an angry letter last week expressing disappointment that Ratcliffe’s CIA was “permitted to whitewash” the Intelligence Community’s role in manufacturing Russiagate.

    Crawford’s letter reflected intramural GOP strife about the investigations into Brennan and Comey. While the predicate for the new FBI probes technically is a criminal referral from Ratcliffe and the CIA, most of the actual digging into the origins of what Crawford calls the “Russia collusion hoax” was performed across an exhaustive, 3,000-hour investigation conducted by teams working under former HPSCI chief Devin Nunes in the 115th congress, in 2017 and 2018. Racket and Public reported on the details of that investigation last February. Those HPSCI investigators were led by current FBI chief Kash Patel and split into two teams, one of which worked out of a “small office in Langley.” That team working at CIA headquarters had wide access to raw intelligence surrounding the Trump-Russia investigation, including dissenting analyses and emails from officials questioning the 2017 ICA.

    Unsurprisingly, that final HPSCI report was “significantly worse” and described far more corruption than Ratcliffe’s 8-page brief, as The Federalist’s Cleveland put it. We described some of what was “worse” in Racket and Public last February:

    Brennan and the ICA authors “embellished” their conclusion by upgrading unreliable sources to reliable. Investigators found “3-4 instances” in which they couldn’t find a “credible historic reporting line” for sources in the ICA report, and found the “source rating” had been changed. Dissent, even within Brennan’s group of 24 “hand-picked” analysts — not from 17 agencies but just three — was overruled… The HPSCI investigators “looked at the report and the sourcing they used to evaluate the sourcing… When we dug further to look at the data available to them that they didn’t use, and it overwhelmingly contradicted their conclusions that Russia supported Trump.”

    The HPSCI report has remained classified and “in a vault at the CIA” for seven long years. This followed the same pattern as the WMD episode, where the CIA did not release its full 93-page National Intelligence Estimate* on Iraq until 2015, thirteen years after a redacted version was released to the public to sell the invasion. The full document, hidden from the American public before the war, determined there was no operational tie between Saddam Hussein and al Qaeda.

    HPSCI investigators who hoped the new Trump administration would aggressively pursue the leads Kash Patel’s team dug up in 2017 and 2018 were both puzzled by the release of Ratcliffe’s relatively tamer report last week, and upset that their more hard-hitting work remained locked up. After Crawford sent his letter, however, Trump interceded and Ratcliffe returned the original HPSCI report to Crawford on the Hill. The HPSCI material remains classified, but at least it’s no longer being “held hostage” at Langley, as Crawford put it, in a public note of thanks tweeted last Thursday.

    The news that the FBI is now opening criminal investigations into Brennan and Comey seems to have mollified some of those close to the original HPSCI investigation. “I don’t know how the fuck they got here, but I’m happy they did,” laughed one source familiar with the full HPSCI report.

    The same source was not disappointed that the FBI is “only” looking at charges like perjury or conspiracy. “You have to understand, there’s no statute that really fits what these people did,” the source said. “But there is one against lying to Congress, and given that that’s what they have to work with, the Ratcliffe report makes more sense to me now.”

    Although some had concerns about statutes of limitations (for perjury, six years) and others worried about the prospects of obtaining convictions against prominent, blue-leaning politicians in the District of Columbia, sources I spoke with believe the evidence for perjury is compelling in the cases of both Brennan and Comey. To wit:

    Subscribe now

    Read more

    0 min
  • ATW Livestream Today at 4 PM ET/3 PM CT

    Join Walter and Matt for another episode of ATW Live. They’ll dive into the events from over the weekend and begin reading their next book club pick, Evelyn Waugh’s Scoop.

    Tune in at 4:00 PM ET on Substack, Rumble, and YouTube:

    Or visit Matt or Walter on X.

    See you soon!

    0 min
  • Activism, Uncensored: Alligator Alcatraz

    A note from Managing Editor Greg Collard:

    It took eight days for Florida officials to convert an old airstrip in the Everglades into what is now Alligator Alcatraz. And yes, that’s the official name of the detention center that’s expected to hold 3,000-plus illegal immigrants arrested in Florida and held for potential deportation in cooperation with the federal government under its 287(g) program.

    Unlike most — if any — immigration detention centers, Alligator Alcatraz is a source of political fundraising revenue. Florida Republicans are selling Alligator Alcatraz merch. The facility has also attracted a lot of disgust. In collaboration with Racket, Ford Fischer and David Decker of News2Share capture the debate surrounding Alligator Alcatraz in this segment of Activism, Uncensored.

    Subscribe now

    0 min
  • Transcript - America This Week, July 4, 2025: "The Great American Intelligence Scam"

    Listen to Episode 140

    Matt Taibbi: All right. Welcome to America This Week. I’m Matt Taibbi.

    Walter Kirn: And I’m Walter Kirn.

    Matt Taibbi: And Walter and I, as you can see, are no longer together. That was a fleeting moment in history, Walter.

    Walter Kirn: Yeah, it really was. Yeah. Sun Valley, the place that brings all the world’s important people together in a strange funnel. I felt like briefly, we were among maybe the class that runs things. I saw private jets flying over gigantic parties, and I had a feeling that I was among not just oligarchs, but just secretly influential people from the past. Yeah.

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah. We may have met the Great Gatsby.

    Walter Kirn: We may have met the Great Gatsby. Yeah. The Deep State Gatsby. But it was interesting to be up there, and it was interesting to do the show live and not be assaulted by abusive comments the way we are when we do a live stream on X.

    Matt Taibbi: We’re not assaulted by abusive comments. It’s just those are the ones that I notice.

    Walter Kirn: Right. But we had zero in Sun Valley.

    Matt Taibbi: Right.

    Walter Kirn: See, that’s the nice thing being among the upper classes. They comport themselves a little bit more politely than do the commenters on the right side of my screen during our live streams.

    Matt Taibbi: I got a Sun Valley souvenir that you didn’t get though, Walter. I took a selfie in front of the Cuts and Mutts van from Dumb and Dumber...

    Walter Kirn: Whoa.

    Matt Taibbi: ... Which is warehoused in Sun Valley because the Farrelly brothers have a place there and there’s an auto center near the airport that is packed with unbelievable vehicles, including some of the most beautiful Porsches in the world. But the Cuts and Mutts van, the dog car is there. So, I’ll post that at some point. It was pretty cool.

    Walter Kirn: But didn’t it end up in Aspen in the movies? Sun Valley’s competition, remember?

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah, but maybe Aspen was like a stand-in for where they really hang out. I don’t know.

    Walter Kirn: Interesting.

    Matt Taibbi: But anyway, cool place. I went up on the ride, the Gondola ride. It’s unbelievably gorgeous at Sun Valley if anybody ever has a chance to go that place.

    Walter Kirn: The truth is I want to thank our hosts for showing us a good time, putting us up in a nice place and being instinctively courteous, helpful, and delightful. So, thank you Sun Valley Policy Forum.

    Matt Taibbi: Absolutely. Yeah. And I can see why Papa Hemingway moved there. I was always a mystery, but now, I’m no longer one. So, we’re now in different places. I’m in Denver. Walter, it looks like you’re back, Livingston.

    Walter Kirn: Yeah. I drove six hours through the night last night from Sun Valley, which takes you past one of the spookiest places in the American Defense Archipelago, which is called the Idaho National Laboratory. It’s a big empty part of Idaho. That’s where they build nuclear reactors for submarines and things like that, and where they’re now doing the research to build the small nuclear reactors that are going to power our AI future.

    Matt Taibbi: Wow.

    Walter Kirn: Yeah, so I could feel its glow. I stopped in Arco, Idaho, which was the first nuclear-powered town in the world.

    Matt Taibbi: Wow.

    Walter Kirn: Yeah.

    Matt Taibbi: Wow.

    Walter Kirn: Stands for Advanced Research Corporation. And I had-

    Matt Taibbi: The town is a nuclear acronym?

    Walter Kirn: Yes. The town is a nuclear acronym.

    Matt Taibbi: I love it.

    Walter Kirn: And I had the worst hamburger I think I’ve had in 50 years.

    Matt Taibbi: I had the worst hamburger I think I’ve ever had. Anyway, we’ll compare our notes later.

    Walter Kirn: Okay, okay.

    Matt Taibbi: But anyway, great trip. Today, for people watching, this is the 4th of July for you, so happy 4th of July everybody. Happy 4th, America.

    Walter Kirn: Also known as No King’s Day.

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah, No King’s Day. Exactly. Are they doing that tomorrow?

    Walter Kirn: Yeah, they’re doing No King’s Day again.

    Matt Taibbi: Oh, my God. Give it a rest for the day. I get it. But come on. All right. So, there’s been significant news. It’s funny, as the week progressed, Walter and I, Walter sent me a story by Miranda Devine of the New York Post, who is probably famous to the audience, most famous for breaking the Hunter Biden laptop story. But this time, she scooped everybody on a new CIA report about Russiagate, and it should be leading the news everywhere, but isn’t because of another story that is everywhere at the moment. And that is the acquittal of Sean Puff Daddy Combs. And this is a story I haven’t followed terribly closely, but we’re going to talk about it a little bit. People may not notice, but there is actually a link between these two stories, which is the Comey family. The Russiagate report was very nasty to James Comey, though nastier to someone else. And the losing prosecutor in the Puffy case was his daughter. What’s her name again? What’s the daughter’s name?

    Walter Kirn: Can’t remember.

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah.

    Walter Kirn: Her last name is so conspicuous that her first name is overshadowed by it.

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah. Just casts a glow over the whole thing. So, we’ll have, take a look.

    Walter Kirn: Could they remake the Addams family as the Comey family?

    Matt Taibbi: Oh, my God.

    Walter Kirn: And they’re spooky.

    Matt Taibbi: He’s tall enough.

    Walter Kirn: Yeah, exactly, lurch.

    Matt Taibbi: Right? Yeah, he’s lurch. If you’ve ever seen the guy, most people who are that big are physically intimidating. He’s like one of the only six-foot-eight people who I thought was a wimp looking at.

    Walter Kirn: Oh, great dude.

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah. But anyway, so it’s a significant story on a number of levels. I’ve seen a lot of people comparing it to the OJ verdict. It’s not the OJ verdict. We’ll get into why it’s not the OJ verdict. So, P Diddy got off on the most important charges for which he could have served a life sentence. And these were basically RICO charges racketeering and-

    Walter Kirn: My wife asked me this morning, “What’s racketeering, Walter?” And because I don’t use Grok, I probably gave her an insufficiently detailed answer, but what does it mean, racketeering?

    Matt Taibbi: Well, racketeering is just, that’s what our site is named after, a racket, if you have a criminal enterprise. Classically, racketeering is a criminal organization where all the people who are in your organization, in some way, are helping commit a crime even if they didn’t, themselves, commit the crime, if the organization does that crime, and you’re a part of the organization, you’re a racketeering, you’re in a racket. So, the classic thing is like a protection racket. So, if you’re a mobster and every business for a 10 block area has to pay protection money to you, that’s a racketeering enterprise. If you’re just the accounting accountant for them, and you don’t actually go to the places and threaten people, that’s the theory of how RICO works. RICO allows the government to prosecute people for crimes, even if they weren’t present for the predicate.

    Walter Kirn: They didn’t pull the trigger, so to speak.

    Matt Taibbi: Right. Yeah, exactly. Yeah. So, Diddy was massively overcharged. Obviously, there were individual offenses specifically against, is it three women? Three women, who I think were the main complainants in the case and some of those are pretty messed up. If you read those accounts, you can see how, look, the whole story bites is horrifying and off-putting. But the government’s theory of this case was that not only did these bad things happen, but that the entire, his company was a criminal enterprise whose purpose was sex trafficking and sexual offenses, which is a goofy theory of how it all went down. And most of the lawyers who were reacting to what happened, and we’ll get to their reactions, are heavily criticizing the prosecutors for going there instead of going for something a little less sexy. He did get convicted of the Mann Act. Walter, when was the last time you heard the Mann Act mentioned?

    Walter Kirn: I don’t know, like Dukes of Hazzard or something, maybe. The Mann Act is transporting an underage person across state lines for the purposes of prostitution. It’s one of the few that I’ve never committed accidentally, and I think it’s unfair to people who live close to state lines. I grew up on a state line, and it means that if I’d gone from Taylors Falls, Minnesota to St. Croix Falls, Wisconsin with weird intent, I would’ve been charged with a federal crime. But if I’d gone the other direction, five miles, I wouldn’t have been.

    Matt Taibbi: Right. Right. Yeah. This is a law that was very much in the news often in the early days of the FBI and in the early days of federal criminal enforcement. A lot of very famous people have been charged with the Mann Act, Charlie Chaplin, Frank Lloyd Wright, Jack Johnson, the heavyweight boxer.

    Walter Kirn: And interestingly, in the parlance-

    Matt Taibbi: Chuck Berry.

    Walter Kirn: In the parlance, it used to be called white slavery. As opposed to black slavery, white slavery was prostitution and pimping and carrying people from place to place for purposes of it.

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah. It was often used to bust somebody who may have just had a consensual relationship but brought a girlfriend across state lines and was politically an enemy of the state in some way. We know how the FBI operated back in those days. But I don’t know. Walter, what’s your initial take on the Diddy verdict? Because there are a couple of interesting angles on it that maybe some people aren’t getting into.

    Walter Kirn: Well, the merits of overcharging is that when you finally get a conviction on something that would be serious otherwise, if it were the main charge, it looks by comparison that you got off. Technically, Puff Diddy didn’t get off. He was convicted of some very serious federal crime, but he was not convicted of more serious federal crimes. Therefore, relatively speaking, he did well. So, in other words, it’s a little bit of a trick of optics or point of view. And what I think, in general, from a cloud-down perspective, a bird’s-eye view, a god’s-eye view is that Puffy has friends somewhere because there were many lawyer friends of mine and lawyer sources, and one particular who follows this kind of thing follows government scandals and corruption and so on, and has a jaundiced view of how things work in America was able to predict to the charge back before a whole other slate of charges were dropped, which one he’d be convicted on.

    And her theory of why this was was that he was, in some fashion, a protected figure. This is just pure speculation on her part, but it’s slightly weightier because it led to such an accurate forecast.

    Read more

    0 min
  • In Spite of Everything, Celebrate this Fourth of July

    Canadian author Stephen Marche, in The Guardian, writes “This Fourth of July, the world declares its independence from America”:

    As the United States retreats from the world, it is reshaping the lives of its former trading partners and allies, leaving huge holes in its wake… The Canadian strategy, undertaken with vigor by the newly elected government of Mark Carney, has been clear in spirit at least: a polite “go fuck yourself.” After you’ve told America to fuck off, though, the real work starts. You have to figure out how to live without them.

    This Fourth of July, the consensus around the world and in our still-humming (despite distress calls about a fascist takeover) mainstream press, is that 2025 America is lost, a reject, the pig of the world. We’re delinquents, no longer fit to sit at the grownup table, much less lead. Pundits like Mr. Marche (is there anything in the world less believable than a Canadian saying “Go fuck yourself”?) imagine they’re insulting us by saying we no longer deserve titles like “responsible” or “dignified,” forgetting who Americans are and always have been: screwups, losers, earth’s trash. Mutants, as Bill Murray put it in Stripes, whose “forefathers were kicked out of every decent country in the world.”

    Independence Day is when we embrace being sneered at and dismissed as lowlifes by the civilized world. At least, that’s what I’m choosing to do today:

    Subscribe now

    There are reasons for mixed feelings. On one hand, the images of ICE agents tossing people out of the country sting and contrast with my idea of what this country is about. Even knowing that a lot of what we’re looking at is media manipulation (on both sides, incidentally) doesn’t make it feel right. These raids have always gone on and as even the New York Times points out today, Donald Trump has a long way to go before he catches up with the number of “repatriations” in George W. Bush’s second term, or Barack Obama’s, for that matter. Still, the image of the America that took in everyone’s tired, their poor, their huddled masses is gone for now, and that’s something to be mourned, no matter what your politics.

    On the other hand, we’re now about a decade into a relentless campaign by consensus-makers in academia, media, and politics to rewrite history in a way that describes even aspirational America as flawed, racist, and vicious. There’s something bizarre and suspicious about this campaign. The New York Times today, for instance, ran a Frankensteinian editorial by Yale professor Greg Grandin that stitched George Washington to Trump, then negatively compared both with South American revolutionaries:

    George Washington was among the first to appropriate America exclusively for the United States: “The name of American,” he told U.S. citizens in his 1796 Farewell Address, “belongs to you.” In contrast, the revolutionaries who sought to throw off Spanish rule did not claim the name America as their own.

    For them, America symbolized not nationalism but internationalism. The Colombian political leader Francisco de Paula Santander wrote in 1818 that it mattered little where, exactly, he was born, for he “is nothing less than an American, and my country is any corner of America that isn’t ruled by the Spanish.” Simón Bolívar, the Venezuelan revolutionary who liberated much of South America from Spanish rule, hoped that a free America — all of it — would lead humanity into a future ruled by law and justice.

    Grandin went on to decry “a bellicose nationalism, the kind today represented by MAGA,” as being responsible for slavery, Indian removal, and “westward expanasion.” That “America” he contrasted with the later concept of Latin America, which was more “humanist, spiritual and attuned to the social interdependence of human existence than their grubbing, individualistic, egotistic, conquering, enslaving ‘Saxon’ neighbors to the north.”

    I read this in shock. Are we supposed to be embarrassed to be Americans instead of Colombians or Venezuelans? Was “Go west, young man” canceled while I was on a flight this week? Is a United States that codified religious freedom really not “spiritual”? And is a professor from Yale really arguing on Independence Day that America’s problem is that it’s insufficiently tuned in to the “interdependence of human existence”? The Fourth of July has its silly side and obviously is no sacred cow, but how pathological does a person have to be to chide America for its lack of collectivist spirit on a holiday celebrating individual liberty?

    Not long ago, the basics of American citizenship were uncontroversial and the challenge for all of us was living up to the ideal. As Martin Luther King put it, “All we say to America is be true to what you said on paper.” Now it’s as if our historians look back and see massacres and misery, but no Edison, Elvis, Chuck Berry, or Muhammad Ali. I don’t love the parody version of patriotism touted by Trump, but it shines through in the writings of people like Professor Grandin that they’re not proud to be Americans at all. Who can sign up for that? Why are we continually asked to choose between too much pride, and none?

    We should be encouraged on this of all days to remember the good things about this country that have nothing to do with politics, from baseball to airplanes to most of the Rocky movies to just-departed George Foreman, Roberta Flack, Val Kilmer, and Brian Wilson. That’s who we are, not this dumb argument. To hell with the sourpusses. Happy Birthday, America.

    0 min
  • Explosive New CIA Report Details Russiagate Fraud

    Miranda Devine of the New York Post, who broke the fateful story about Hunter Biden’s laptop, has struck again with an exposé on the origins of Russiagate that implicates former intelligence chiefs John Brennan, James Comey, and Jim Clapper in an elaborate fraud. From the story, which is centered on a new CIA report commissioned by John Ratcliffe:

    Brennan handpicked the CIA analysts to compile the ICA and involved only the ODNI, CIA, FBI and NSA, excluding 13 of the then-17 intelligence agencies.

    He sidelined the National Intelligence Council and forced the inclusion of the discredited Steele dossier despite objections of the authors and senior CIA Russia experts, so as to push a false narrative that Russia secured Trump’s 2016 victory.

    “This was Obama, Comey, Clapper and Brennan deciding ‘We’re going to screw Trump,’” said Ratcliffe in an exclusive interview. “It was, ‘We’re going to create this and put the imprimatur of an IC assessment in a way that nobody can question it.’”

    The CIA report is focused mainly on the publication of the infamous Intelligence Community Assessment of January 6th, 2017, which concluded that Russian President Vladimir Putin sought “to undermine public faith in the US democratic process, denigrate Secretary Clinton, and harm her electability” while maintaining a “clear preference for President-elect Trump.” Publication of that Intelligence Assessment, which was ordered by Barack Obama on December 6th, 2016 and included material from the infamous Steele dossier, set in motion a series of events that led to Special Counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation. It was the trigger for years of Russiagate lunacy that consumed Trump’s first term.

    Racket readers may remember reports I co-authored with Michael Shellenberger and Alexandra Gutentag last February, describing how Brennan, Comey, and Clapper “cooked the intelligence” in that 2017 ICA. For instance, the chiefs suppressed junior analysts’ belief that Russia may not have preferred Trump, seeing him as “mercurial,” “unreliable,” and “not steady,” while viewing a possible Clinton presidency as “manageable and reflecting continuity.” The notion that the ICA was manipulated isn’t new, as Aaron Mate at RealClearInvestigations reported the ICA’s preparation “deviated from standard CIA practice,” and similar reports came out via former CIA analyst Ray McGovern, current deputy FBI director Dan Bongino, and others.

    However, this new report contains a wealth of new details. It’s not clear what this may or may not mean for any possible future criminal investigation, but Ratcliffe’s CIA investigation fills in a lot of blanks. Some key conclusions:

    Subscribe now

    CIA chief was warned not to include the Steele Dossier

    The new CIA report criticizes the intel chiefs for including the Steele Dossier in the report, saying that “ran counter to fundamental tradecraft principles” and “undermined the credibility” of his key conclusions. That isn’t just a post-factum conclusion, however. The report reveals:

    CIA’s Deputy Director for Analysis (DDA) warned in an email to Brennan on 29 December that including it in any form risked “the credibility of the entire paper.”

    Thanks to previous reports (including material from John Brennan’s own book Undaunted), it was already known that Brennan not only overruled NSA chief Mike Rogers but “two senior managers for the CIA mission center for Russia” to reach the much-disputed conclusion that Putin “aspired” to help Donald Trump win the election. The new CIA report’s inclusion of an email from a senior CIA official specifically warning against use of the Steele Dossier is damning.

    Regarding the objections of those two “senior managers,” Ratcliffe had more detail:

    The two senior leaders of the CIA mission center responsible for Russia argued jointly against including the “aspire” judgment. In an email to Brennan on 30 December, they stated the judgment should be removed because it was both weakly supported and unnecessary, given the strength and logic of the paper’s other findings on intent. They warned that including it would only “open up a line of very politicized inquiry.”

    It’s one thing for Ratcliffe to criticize the ICA, but these specific email warnings add significantly to the pile of evidence that the key pillar of Russiagate was manipulated.

    NSA considered “alternative” conclusion

    Without an Intelligence Assessment saying Russia hoped to harm Hillary Clinton’s chances and help Trump, the American public likely wouldn’t have gone through years of Russiagate scandal. The three agencies that put the ICA together — the CIA, FBI, and NSA — all started out with differing views on that key question of whether or not Russia specifically wanted to help Trump. Of the three agencies, the NSA and its chief Mike Rogers were the least enthusiastic about endorsing that conclusion. From the new report:

    NSA and a few other participants were not comfortable with ascribing “high confidence” to the “aspired” judgment. They cited the limited source base, lack of corroborating intelligence, and “the possibility for an alternative judgment” as driving their discomfort.

    It was bad enough that the NSA would only say publicly it had “moderate” confidence in the ICA. As the Ratcliffe report explains, “moderate confidence generally means that the information is credibly sourced and plausible but not... corroborated sufficiently.” Moderate was “equivalent to no,” as one source told me last year.

    That the NSA believed there was room from the available intelligence to come up with an “alternative judgment” undermines the ICA conclusion even more.

    Why the FBI endorsed the ICA

    According to the report:

    FBI leadership made it clear that their participation in the ICA hinged on the Dossier’s inclusion and, over the next few days, repeatedly pushed to weave references to it throughout the main body of the ICA.

    This is a significant revelation, because while the NSA expressed only “moderate” confidence in the Intelligence Assessment, the FBI appeared to change its mind.

    On October 31, 2016, a week before Obama ordered the ICA written, senior FBI officials told the New York Times in a much-criticized piece called “Investigating Donald Trump, F.B.I. Sees No Clear Link to Russia” that “even the hacking into Democratic emails, F.B.I. and intelligence officials now believe, was aimed at disrupting the presidential election rather than electing Mr. Trump.” In the first week of December 2016, the FBI and CIA reportedly gave conflicting briefings to Congress on the question. Shortly after, the FBI publicly backed the CIA’s interpretation.

    The reason for the FBI’s turnaround has always been a mystery. If the FBI’s participation in the Intelligence Community Assessment was contingent on the CIA publicly backing the Steele Dossier, it might answer that question. The FBI by December 2016 already knew it had an issue with its use of the Steele Dossier to obtain FISA surveillance on Carter Page, and the FBI’s lead Trump-Russia investigator Peter Strzok had privately questioned Steele’s reliability. By inducing the CIA to throw its weight behind the flawed document (one the CIA itself had pooh-poohed as “internet rumor”), the FBI and Comey gained crucial bureaucratic cover.

    It was Brennan all along

    From the report:

    One business day before IC analysts convened for the only coordination session on the ICA, Brennan sent a note to the CIA workforce stating he had met with the DNI and FBI Director and that “there is strong consensus among us on the scope, nature, and intent of Russian interference in our recent Presidential election.” While officers involved in drafting the ICA consistently said they did not feel pressured …Brennan’s premature signaling… risked stifling analytic debate.

    As has been made clear, there was no “strong consensus” about Russia’s intentions among the three agencies. The NSA was lukewarm at best, the FBI gave public statements contradicting the ICA conclusions, and even within the CIA — even within Brennan’s hand-picked group of CIA analysts — there was serious dissent. Brennan steamrolled that dissent in a number of ways, beginning with this “premature signaling” effort, and moving on to override his own team.

    Ratcliffe wrote that “Brennan showed a preference for narrative consistency over analytical soundness,” describing a scene in which he overrode the objections to the Steele Dossier by those two CIA “mission center for Russia” analysts. When confronted, Brennan reportedly said, “My bottom line is that I believe that the information warrants inclusion in the report.”

    Overall, the report looks very bad for the intelligence chiefs Brennan, Comey, and Clapper, who submitted the flawed ICA to the National Intelligence Council just “hours before it was due to be published,” as Devine wrote. Those same figures then briefed President-Elect Trump about the ICA’s contents, ostensibly to warn him about the possibility of Russian efforts to compromise him. Shortly after, the details of that briefing were leaked to the press. In this manner, the otherwise classified issue of “blackmail” and the pee tape and so on became public, leading to years of the Russiagate circus.

    Much like the WMD episode, where it later came out that analysts who worked on a National Intelligence Assessment about Iraq had wildly differing beliefs about whether or not Saddam Hussein was pursuing a weapon of mass destruction, Russiagate and the 2017 ICA now look like an episode that will be infamous because of the way dissenting opinions were suppressed. We’ll have more on what this report means as information comes in.

    0 min