Racket News

Racket News

By Matt Taibbi
Download on the App Store

All Racket News episodes

  • NPR Should Be Axed Because it's Anti-Thought, Not Anti-Trump

    After reading Madame Bovary in college I bought the unfinished novel Bouvard and Pécuchet, one of the last things Flaubert wrote. It’s a furious satire about two bourgeois clerks with no ideas of their own who come into a fortune, travel the world and live through great events, and ultimately return home having learned nothing, despite seeing everything. In American terms, it’s Dumb and Dumber for pseudo-intellectuals. I was too young to appreciate it (it was an older man’s final middle finger to the world’s unrepentant stupidity) but there was a prize at the end.

    The Dictionary of Received Ideas is often tacked to the back of the novel. It’s believed Flaubert meant to publish it either as an appendix, or as a fictional creation of the book’s two idiot-heroes, whose conversations are just exchanges of clichés (“In the long run, solitude is very sad,” or “The beautiful is the beautiful, the sublime the very beautiful”). The “dictionary” is just a monster collection of these empty sayings, sometimes written as instructions on how and what to say in society, as in:

    • AMUSING – Must be attached to all remarks: “How amusing!”

    • HEAT – Always unbearable.

    More often, entries explained what views to hold:

    • DISSECTION – An outrage against the majesty of death.

    • ICE CREAM - It is dangerous to eat it.

    • LEGALITY – Legality is killing us. With it, no proper government is possible.

    Flaubert was nearly driven mad by these ear-piercing snippets of conventional wisdom. He said he wrote Bouvard and Pecuchét to “vomit back onto my contemporaries the disgust they inspire in me.” To be trapped in a world of clichés would seem tyrannical enough to that kind of mind, but what if all those dead phrases and canned non-thoughts were mandatory? What if they were factory-produced as part of a state enterprise? What if “received ideas” were dumped on the public with military regularity, and in conjunction with prohibitions against saying anything else?

    From a Friday story about National Public Radio in the Washington Post:

    President Donald Trump signed an executive order on Thursday evening seeking to prohibit federal funding for NPR and the Public Broadcasting Service (PBS). The order, which could be subject to legal challenge, called the broadcasters’ news coverage “biased and partisan…”

    An NPR spokesperson said early Friday that “NPR’s editorial practices and decision-making are independent and free from outside influence…”

    The zany, sociology-prof-on-molly vibe at NPR is no longer the big story in America. Donald Trump’s unprecedented “assault on our most fundamental rights” is. Just ask NPR, which of course is the problem.

    Once a great American institution, NPR has become a state-sponsored version of Flaubert’s nightmare. Why it has to go:

    Subscribe now

    The station doubtless thinks it’s engaged in “public service journalism” by cranking out piles of stories with headlines like Trump nominee gives misleading testimony about ties to alleged ‘Nazi sympathizer’, Trump cuts demolish agency focused on toxic chemicals and workplace hazards, Asian American voters backed Trump in Nevada. Here’s how they feel about him now, The U.S. set the global order after WWII. Trump has other plans, A legal architect of Guantanamo questions Trump’s El Salvador plan, and on, and on. Its editors either don’t realize they’ve built an abjectly partisan political operation, or, more likely, they’ve been at this so long, they believe ideological uniformity is truth, and by extension, just “the news.”

    It would be depressingly easy to create a 2025 edition of the Dictionary of Received Ideas just by tweaking NPR texts:

    • JOURNALISM - Advances the conversation. Stands out for its thorough research, diverse sourcing, fairness, and fact-checking. George Clooney says the press has a duty to “always question authority.”

    • THIN - It’s back in, but did it ever leave? It’s easier for thin people when it comes to employment and education. With fatphobia, why are so many people comfortable saying the quiet part out loud?

    • RACISM - A public health issue. The accumulated stress from institutional racism has documented effects. Mentorship for Black medical students is crucial as they navigate a healthcare system that is not always welcoming. There’s a new computer algorithm that more accurately illustrates Black hair. If we don’t keep talking about it, whiteness becomes the default for everything.

    • AWKWARDNESS —Part of our lives whether we like it or not. But what if we put the embarrassment aside and embraced our awkward selves?

    If Flaubert had access to NPR’s search tool, he could have a sequel book in six hours. The only challenge would be figuring out how to limit the most important entry:

    • TRUMP - Poses a global threat to democracy. Conspiracy theories about Covid fueled his support among Christian nationalists. He’s a convicted felon now, but what comes next? Meet the conservative women who are keeping their votes for Harris a secret. Instead of a final plea for unity, embraced racist jokes about Latinos. Meet former Obama ethics czar Norm Eisen. His assault on the First Amendment is historic…

    About that: for every unnerving addition to the censorship toolkit that’s come out of this presidency (like the reported expansion of “anti-BDS” rules), there remain dozens of federally funded entities that exist for one of two reasons: to promote groupthink, or stamp out the absence of it. NPR is at the top of the list. Its problem isn’t that it’s anti-Trump, or that it retains its weird addiction to stories like “Bringing diversity to Maine’s nearly all-white lobster fleet” or “Fat Phobia And Its Racist Past And Present” (though that stuff is nuts), but because it’s the most visible symbol of a thought-suppressing bureaucracy that’s not really compatible with our system of media or government.

    The $535 million the Corporation for Public Broadcasting doles out to stations around the country isn’t a lot, in the scheme of overall federal spending. I’d argue the state should feel queasy about spending any amount of the taxpayer’s money on efforts to propagandize against his or her political choices, and that the CPB would properly be shut down overnight if it was as near-exact a mirror of Fox or the RNC press page as NPR is to Democrats.Org. Even if one stipulates it’s too small to need squashing, NPR has come to represent that far larger system of subsidized conformity, infused in everything from Internet search algorithms to AI to academia, whose scale is only beginning to become visible.

    Old friend Andrew Lowenthal’s non-profit liber-net recently published a database of 867 awards issued by the U.S. government related to “mis-, dis-, or malinformation,” completing a painstaking effort at mapping the anti-disinformation sector we could only start at Racket years ago. His accomplishment got significant buzz thanks to another old friend, former Washington Examiner writer Gabe Kaminsky, who along with Madeleine Rowley not only wrote up its publication at The Free Press but quoted a State Department official as saying the administration was “just getting started” on a “spree” of program cancelations. A number of high-profile figures from the anti-disinfo world expressed disgust with the project.

    As Andrew noted in a follow-up this week, those 800+ grants created a field that really hadn’t existed before 2016. Casual news consumers were told these programs supported apolitical activities like “fact-checking,” or were simple service contracts to do things like give out laptops to the disadvantaged. Even I’d have bought it once, but years spent under the hood of “media literacy,” “cyber hygiene,” and “counter-disinformation” initiatives left no doubt that whatever else these programs are about, their essence is about training populations to recoil from some narratives, while embracing others.

    Just to take a few examples: the Department of Justice gave Youngstown State University $449,897 to study “misinformation, extremism, and conspiracism,” via a study that involved scanning social media discussions about topics like QAnon and MAGA. They asked questions like, “To what extent is religious discourse turning militaristic?” and “What is hypermasculinity, and how is it influencing extremist discourse?” Findings were shared with “security-related professionals” so a discussion could begin about finding “possible responses to online radicalization.” Andrew’s list also includes a National Science Foundation grant to the University of Illinois to track the spread of “dubious” Covid-19 misinformation. Racket similarly just received FOIA documents showing DHS officials pondering some of the same issues, as well as broader questions about how to restore faith in institutions.

    NPR is the official media arm of these ideas. If you look (as I did this week), you’ll find that any ideological fixation we spent millions promoting through the State Department or Department of Commerce or National Science Foundation is virtually guaranteed to have been the subject of one or more segments on All Things Considered or Fresh Air.

    I didn’t know what “hypermasculinity” was before reading the aforementioned Youngstown grant, but NPR sure does. They’ve run essentially the same feature on the topic multiple times, profiling the gay rodeo in Colorado that’s a place to “challenge hyper-masculine expectations,” the gay wrestler who revolutionized lucha libre (which until then was sadly rooted in hyper-masculinity), and the young black photographer who used his camera as a weapon against poverty and pressures of hypermasculinity. They’ve likewise covered “online radicalization” (in a series called “Untangling Disinformation”), extremism (in a “News Literacy” series) and conspiracism (UFOs to RFKs: How conspiracy theories went mainstream).

    It’s uncanny. If a federal agency promotes awareness about “health equity,” you’ll be sure to find “health equity” experts quoted by NPR in stories like New Zealand’s Indigenous people are furious over plans to snuff out anti-smoking laws, or WHO renames monkeypox as mpox, citing racist stigma, or Heat makes health inequity worse, hitting people with risks like diabetes harder (because “marginalized communities often have fewer trees”). If there’s a federal grant to battle Covid disinfo, you’ll find NPR denounced the “dubious” messaging in Virus Researchers Cast Doubt On Theory Of Coronavirus Lab Accident, or How Vaccine Skepticism May Affect Efforts To Combat The Coronavirus Pandemic. Once I saw in FOIA documents that the DHS huddled with academics to find solutions to a “crisis of faith in key institutions,” I knew NPR had to have run a piece like ‘A Time To Build’ Author On Restoring Faith In U.S. Institutions. It never fails.

    Creepier still is the fact that not much has changed in the attitudes of affluent urbanites since the days of Flaubert. Especially since Trump arrived on the scene, America’s chattering class has begun to speak the language of the skittish 19th century Parisian bourgeoisie. There must be a gene that’s passed down across centuries to allow Flaubert’s observations to fit so perfectly. Examples include “VACCINATED - Frequent only vaccinated persons,” “POLICE - Always in the wrong,” and “COLONIES (our) - Affect a mournful countenance when they are discussed,” but I thought this was the most amazing:

    • LIBERTY – O liberty! What crimes are committed in your name! We have all the liberties that are necessary. Liberty does not mean license (phrase for conservatives).

    The theme of struggling to find the right “balance” of political or religious or academic freedom against bigotry or extremism or threats to LGBTQ rights was one of NPR’s main themes for years. The station was particularly angry about “liberty” and letting people “make their own decisions” during the pandemic, when it ran story after story with themes like America Relied On ‘Individual Decisions’ To Slow The Virus. It Didn’t Work. Until recently these discussions all tilted in one direction, but “freedom of speech” has recently re-acquired positive connotations. Either way, it’s remarkable how similar French upper-class groupthink was to ours on many fronts.

    That NPR is a wasteland of mindless convention and pseudo-intellectual gibberish isn’t a reason to kill it, though. It has to go because it’s already begun to be remade in the image of state media of the more infamous kind, in which the people running it (like CEO Kathleen Maher or COO Ryan Merkley) sound and act more like political officers than journalists. It’s a free country and media outlets can have one point of view, even relentlessly, but those places can’t be publicly funded. We’re not trying to build a monoculture. Or are we?

    0 min
  • Transcript - America This Week, May 2, 2025: "Are 'AI Friends' the Ultimate Surveillance Tool?"

    Listen to Episode 133

    Matt Taibbi: All right. Welcome to America This Week. I’m Matt Taibbi.

    Walter Kirn: And I’m Walter Kirn.

    Matt Taibbi: Walter, you are back at home base.

    Walter Kirn: Yeah, I’m back in the land of society and marriage and all the things that moderate one’s latent psychotic tendencies. And my wife has determined that I speak differently than I did when I last saw her a few weeks ago. And my mouth makes different sounds, she said. And I said, it’s because I’ve had no practice speaking for weeks. This has been the longest I’ve gone without conversations. So if people are noticing that out there, expect it to abate.

    Matt Taibbi: I mean, did it sound drastically different? Did you sound like a raccoon when you first came back?

    Walter Kirn: Well, to me, I sound no different, of course, being quite used to residence in my own mind and mouth. But to my wife who sees me at discrete intervals when she’s traveling, there’s been a marked change.

    Matt Taibbi: Well...

    Walter Kirn: That’s always disturbing to find out that you’re making different sounds, you speak differently, may have adopted a slightly different personality all through solitude, which we’re told is a good thing. But, I’m not sure. We were going to talk about AI friends today, and I’ve wondered if having them in the meantime during this sojourn in the wilderness, this Thoreau-like writing jag I’ve been on, if AI friends prancing around the room in convincing 3D would of accelerated or retarded the process of my becoming loopy.

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah, it could go either way. I think it probably depends on your underlying psychological situation. But I don’t really think it makes a difference. I think if you’re inclined to go the all work and no play makes Jack a dull boy route, you’re going there anyway sooner or later.

    Walter Kirn: Yeah.

    Matt Taibbi: But as you hinted, yeah, we’re going to talk about, we’re going to do something a little different this week and it’s not like it’s not in the news, it is in the news. It’s just not the hot button partisan topic of the week. At least not yet, it’ll get there.

    Walter Kirn: It’s trending toward partisanship. It’s acquiring a partisan coding, as everything does.

    Matt Taibbi: Everything has to.

    Walter Kirn: They just haven’t quite figured out exactly in what way it’s the current administration’s fault. Exactly in what way it will lead to a fascist autocracy, but we’re getting there.

    Matt Taibbi: Right, right. Exactly. So I guess let’s start with all our old friend and former WEF Young Leader program completer Mark Zuckerberg, who has occupied a variety of roles in American culture in the last eight years. It’s really interesting, isn’t it? He’s gone from being a villain to one side to a villain on the other to being a villain back on the other side.

    Walter Kirn: Well, for me, he’s always been a villain since I saw him. But a super-villain is one who changes form slightly in order to win different audiences’ trust so he can victimize whole new groups in new ways. And when I saw him in this latest video with his chunky SoHo art gallerist glasses.

    Matt Taibbi: I love it. I love the look. Yeah.

    Walter Kirn: Yeah. So most recently, he was an MMA fighter, a participant in sort of esoteric martial arts, a guy on a one-man mission to raise his own testosterone through natural means.

    Matt Taibbi: Just ready to go bow hunting for something.

    Walter Kirn: Right, right. Yeah, exactly. Drag home a wild pig. But now this is that plus Rachel Maddow. And I think he wants to be known as an intellectual who’s leading us somewhere, a visionary. I’m sure everyone in his position has Elon envy at this point. He can’t take us to Mars, but he can take us to virtual Mars, and he seems to indicate that may be more important.

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah, let’s just listen to what he has to say. But you’re right. I have some thoughts about that. But he’s going to talk about computers possibly as a cure for loneliness, which is very ironic considering the origin story of Facebook to begin with. But let’s listen to what he says.

    Mark Zuckerberg: I think as the personalization loop kicks in and the AI just starts to get to know you better and better, I think that will just be really compelling. One thing just from working on social media for a long time is... There’s this stat that I always think is crazy. The average American, I think has, I think it’s fewer than three friends, three people that they’d consider friends and the average person has demand for meaningfully more. I think it’s like 15 friends or something. I guess there’s probably some point where you’re like, all right, I’m just too busy. I can’t deal with more people. But the average person wants more connectivity, connection than they have. So there’s a lot of questions that people ask of stuff like, okay, is this going to replace in-person connections?

    Matt Taibbi: Can we pause for a second?

    Walter Kirn: It’ll augment it. It always augments it, right?

    Matt Taibbi: When he says this, he’s talking about AI friends.

    Walter Kirn: Now through what dark DARPA study or Johns Hopkins research, did they come up with Americans having space or demand for 15 friends.

    Matt Taibbi: Friend demand.

    Walter Kirn: Did they study people who have 13 friends and say, I’m almost there. And then with two more, they say, stop it. Stop it. People were pushing me around. I feel crowded.

    Matt Taibbi: I have unused friend capacity.

    Walter Kirn: And then they push them up to 20 and they start fighting. It does remind you of the ‘60s, 1950s MK Ultra style programs in which they made these very specific claims about the human psyche. He doesn’t seem to question at all the research, probably because it suits him. If there are, what, 12 friends per American now and Americans are in an average deficit of 12, and he can provide, well, maybe all 12, but certainly half of them from his, I don’t know, lab or on the computer. I don’t know what kind of amplitude and reality level will constitute a human-like friend. I mean, they have to be able to do sort of electro stimulation of our skin. Can they just be a cartoon? Must they be 3D, holographic? Do they need to burst into the room at random times in the manner of independent human beings?

    Because a friend really isn’t a slave, and I suspect he’s kind of talking about slave like beings. Friends are often busy, and I have a feeling that Friend-books or whatever they’re going to call them will always be available. My joke on Twitter was, can they move your couch? Which is my test of friendship. Will they move your couch?

    Matt Taibbi: Will they move your coach?

    Walter Kirn: But he’s very optimistic and I want to hear his answer about whether they’ll replace human beings because I know won’t, not in his mind. I mean, he hopes they will. It’s his unspoken, deepest desire. But he’s going to reassure us, I have a feeling.

    Read more

    0 min
  • In All-Time Loathsome Podcast, Reporters Cheerfully Admit Screwing Up Russiagate

    In late 2018 and early 2019, before the release of the Mueller report, I sometimes felt fear that if I didn’t get out of the legacy press soon, I might go on a tri-state killing spree, ending up gunned down on the Taconic Parkway. I thought those feelings were past, but a clip of Ezra Klein chuckling to former Buzzfeed chief Ben Smith about Russiagate brought them all back:

    Smith, whose decision to publish the loony Steele Dossier in full despite obvious factual problems struck me as nuts at the time, and who later doubled down on the decision multiple times (including in a long Atlantic piece in 2023), now smiles and speaks of regrets. Echoing former New York Times editor Dean Bacquet, who after the collapse of the Mueller probe complained of pressure on Russia from “our readers who want Donald Trump to go away,” Smith explained Buzzfeed’s predicament:

    A lot of our readers felt, and a lot of Democrats felt, like, there’s no way this guy was legitimately elected. There are two theories. One, it was Facebook. Two it was Russia. And lots of media energy went into chasing those two things. The White House felt totally under siege from, like, that set of questions. I think I have regrets about that in retrospect…

    Smith was speaking on his own “Mixed Signals” podcast. Guest and author Klein, whose current hit book Abundance enumerates the many things besides galactic media misses that contributed to “the rise of Trumpism,” grinned and asked:

    Subscribe now

    “Do you regret publishing the dossier? Is what you’re saying? Is that the admission here, Ben?”

    “I would say I’m more ambivalent about it than I used to be.”

    Mixed Signals co-host Max Tani playfully jumped in, ragging his partner. “We made news on our own podcast! You’re not supposed to make news. Ezra is supposed to make news.”

    Klein described his own attitude toward Trump-Russia. “I was always very hostile to the ‘Facebook did it through disinformation’ theory,” he said. “I mean, you go back to what I said then. I never thought there was evidence that Russian disinformation, or ads, or something on Facebook, had turned the election. I thought James Comey had turned the election, which I still think is true.”

    At the time I was one of just a handful of mainstream press figures expressing reservations about Trump-Russia “collusion.” Like Glenn Greenwald, who was still at The Intercept and called for an independent investigation, and Aaron Maté, who was writing for The Nation, I was neither a fan of Donald Trump (I’d just published Insane Clown President), nor had I said much beyond noting a lack of evidence and stressing caution. Still, like Glenn and Aaron, I gained leper status anyway. Any colleague who expressed similar doubts would have stood out to all of us. We’d have been glad of those private thoughts of Ezra’s. It wasn’t to be. He went on:

    The Russia stuff, I always thought that was worth investigating. I mean, I guess people can debate whether or not it got too much, and it definitely became a deus ex machina for liberals. I never believed that Russia had won the election for him, and I don’t think I ever said anything that would’ve suggested I did believe that…

    Liberals had gotten themselves into a weird place where they wanted some explanation for how it had happened. There was some view that Mueller was going to come out with some report, and that would be the end of this. And I think something very different in the liberal mind is a recognition that there’s something very authentic in Trump’s appeal, and nobody comes in and saves you on a horse. And I think that’s really important. I also think the fact that Trump lost the popular vote, and that the election was so incredibly close in the battleground states in 2016, contributed to this feeling that this guy was a fluke and should be treated as kind of an aberration.

    I’ve run into Ben maybe once or twice, don’t know Ezra, and have heard both are nice enough guys, but what the fuck? Listen to the reasoning: “Clinton’s close electoral college loss broke the brains of audiences, who to their credit have since come to accept that Donald Trump has enough authentic appeal to win elections. At the time, however, they were so incapable of believing the election had been won organically that they gobbled up any soothing explanation and were reduced to praying for rescue by divine plot intervention. And looking back, that’s what Russiagate was, right? Not that we ever believed Russia won the election for him…”

    About that: on July 13, 2017, the Center for International Studies published, “Ezra Klein: Collusion is Likely,” featuring the money quote: “I believe at this point collusion between Russia and the Trump campaign is likely. We know for a fact that Russia hacked into the Democratic National Committee files and released them in ways… designed to hurt Hillary Clinton… Given how razor-thin the final margin was for Trump, we know they might have literally decided the election.” A few days earlier, in Vox: “We know that foreign power conducted a large-scale and successful cyber-espionage effort against the Democratic Party… The election is tainted. The White House is tainted. Our foreign policy is tainted.”

    Later that year, on October 24th, 2017, the Washington Post finally broke the story that the Steele dossier was paid Clinton campaign research. That should have been the end of the story, but not to Klein, who wrote in Vox days later: “[Russia] really did conduct social media operations designed help Trump. Both their targets and their timing were extremely sophisticated for a foreign government that has traditionally shown itself to have a poor understanding of American politics… At this point, it would be a truly remarkable coincidence if two entities that had so many ties to each other… and that were working so hard toward the same goal never found a way to coordinate.”

    If you’re looking for reasons why “liberals” fell into that “weird place” of putting their faith in that “deus ex machina,” you’ll find plenty more like the above. Most interesting, though, was the caveat Klein just offered in the podcast:

    The idea that he was possibly compromised or that the people around him were, I don’t think was or is, by the way, crazy. I think that the network of corruption around Donald Trump is vast and much worse than we actually know — including now, by the way, where I think crypto has created whole new vistas of potential corruption.

    In the middle of a speech about how readers (but not him!) lost touch and went searching for magic collusion connections instead of facing electoral reality and embracing tough policy changes as Abundance recommends, Klein moves to a new set of possible conspirators, whose reach could be “much worse than we actually know.” The lesson of Trump-Russia was about the danger of speculative rumination in realms beyond what we “actually know,” but apparently we’re not in the lesson-learning mode yet. Incidentally I agree it’s worth investigating Trump’s crypto connections and schemes like the Trump meme coin, but aren’t we also still waiting for a full autopsy on the Sam Bankman-Fried episode? At least one candidate to replace Gerry Connolly as ranking member at House Oversight was supported by an SBF-bankrolled PAC.

    A last note: in that 2023 Atlantic piece, Smith talked about complaints he received from people like Jake Tapper (who worried the dossier’s publication made the Trump-Russia story “less credible”). “I’d expected that backlash, and at first welcomed it,” he wrote. “I thought we were on the right side of the decade-old conflict between the transparent new internet and a legacy media whose power came in part from the information they withheld. And, of course, I loved the traffic…”

    The reason the publication of the Steele dossier freaked out a lot of people in conventional media was because it broke a longstanding taboo on publishing material one knows to be untrue or unverifiable. Of course, taboos are made to be broken, the Internet age did usher new variables into the media business, and part of the reason the dossier could be published by Smith and not at CNN or the New York Times was because, as Smith himself has said, Buzzfeed was a “slightly fringy place.”

    Looking back, though, that “fringy” status of Buzzfeed just helped complete a complex end-run around the safeguards against fake news. Oppo researchers from Fusion-GPS tried to sell Steele’s reports to the Times, The New Yorker, ABC, and CNN. Those outlets passed, unable to verify the stuff. But the FBI, CIA, and NSA weren’t bound by journalistic ethics, and were able to stick Steele’s “blackmail” claim in an annex to an Intelligence Community Assessment in early January 2017. Jim Comey then presented that Annex with the “blackmail” material to President-elect Trump in an early January briefing, ostensibly to help make him aware it was out there. After that, news of the meeting was leaked, leading to a January 10, 2017 CNN report that Smith says helped force his hand.

    Once the dossier was published, other mainstream outlets felt like the choice was either report, or ignore a story that “lit up the Internet,” as The Guardian put it. It was all tidy: once Smith went public (and while his decision drew some fire, it was also backed by the Columbia Journalism Review) everyone had a justification for speculating about the unverifiable thing, which as Smith now notes, besieged that White House for a good long while. The smile as he speaks of “regrets” is so mischievously wry, it’s hard not to admire. He knew exactly what he was doing. It’s really a hell of a smile, a perfect nod to a brilliant maneuver. Sure, it helped blow up the credibility of a storied industry, but wasn’t it also worth it, just a little? No wonder people hate us…

    0 min
  • Timeline: The Path to Real ID Implementation
    Illustration by Daniel Medina

    The deadline for Real ID is now six days away. It’s only taken 20 years to get this far, which is bad even by government standards.

    Yes, Covid played a role, but the Real ID Act passed in May 2005. It had already taken 15 years when Covid became the excuse to extend the deadline not once, but twice more.

    The extensions were welcome news to many of us. The last thing any sane person wants to do is hang out at the DMV for a few hours. Fortunately, you don’t need a Real ID for domestic air travel if you have a passport, which is something to consider when reading figures on the percentages of state populations that are Real ID compliant.

    For example, New Jersey has the distinction of having the lowest rate of Real ID compliance at just 17%. However, it has the nation’s highest rate of passport ownership. Estimates vary, but this Center for American Progress report puts it at 80%.

    On the other end of the spectrum, Mississippi has one of the highest percentages of Real ID compliance at 97%, but also has one of the lowest percentages of passport holders.

    You can also bypass Real ID with a passport card and military ID. Here’s a list of acceptable IDs.

    Nationwide, about 60 percent of the country 18 and older have a Real ID. Seven states and Washington, D.C., have at least 99% compliance.

    You can click on your state here to see what documents your state accepts. While the requirements for Real ID are nationwide — such as proof of residence and Social Security number — the documents that are accepted vary.

    Now, on to the Real ID timeline.

    November 27, 2002

    President George W. Bush signs H.R. 4628, authorizing the launch of the National Commission on Terrorist Attacks on the United States, better known as the 9/11 Commission. The Commission investigates every dimension of the September 11 terrorist attacks and makes recommendations to prevent future attacks.

    July 22, 2004

    The 9/11 Commission Report is published. One of the recommendations made by the Commission is a national standard for driver’s licenses:

    Secure identification should begin in the United States. The federal government should set standards for the issuance of birth certificates and sources of identification, such as drivers licenses. Fraud in identification documents is no longer just a problem of theft. At many entry points to vulnerable facilities, including gates for boarding aircraft, sources of identification are the last opportunity to ensure that people are who they say they are and to check whether they are terrorists.

    911report7.22MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadDecember 17, 2004

    Bush signs the Intelligence Reform and Terrorism Prevention Act of 2004. Section 7212 of the 235-page bill requires the secretary of transportation to devise baseline standards for identification documents, including driver’s licenses, “issued by States for use by Federal agencies for identification purposes.” The bill tasks the secretary with overseeing a “negotiated rulemaking process” that includes representatives from the states and bans federal agencies from accepting state-issued identification documents that do not meet those standards two years after they are implemented.

    January 26, 2005

    Republican Congressman Jim Sensenbrenner of Wisconsin introduces H.R. 418, the purpose of which is “to establish and rapidly implement regulations for State driver’s license and identification document security standards.” (Sensenbrenner also introduced the USA PATRIOT Act in October 2001.)

    May 11, 2005

    Bush signs the Emergency Supplemental Appropriations Act for Defense, the Global War on Terror, and Tsunami Relief. The bill includes the Real ID Act and repeals Section 7212 of the IRTPA. The Act establishes a series of nine criteria for state-issued driver’s licenses and identification cards. They are:

    (1) The person’s full legal name.
    (2) The person’s date of birth.
    (3) The person’s gender.
    (4) The person’s driver’s license or identification card number.
    (5) A digital photograph of the person.
    (6) The person’s address of principle residence.
    (7) The person’s signature.
    (8) Physical security features designed to prevent tampering, counterfeiting, or duplication of the document for fraudulent purposes.
    (9) A common machine-readable technology, with defined minimum data elements.

    These standards must be met by May 11, 2008.

    Statute 119 Pg231343KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadMarch 1, 2007

    The Department of Homeland Security states that it will grant extensions for Real ID compliance to any state that requests them. This first extension would give a state until December 31, 2009, to be compliant.

    May 11, 2008

    The original deadline for Real ID implementation comes and goes without a single state complying with the Act’s criteria. All 50 states are automatically granted extensions.

    December 20, 2013

    The National Security Council establishes a timetable for states to implement Real ID. This schedule requires all state-issued driver’s licenses and identification cards to be Real ID-compliant by October 1, 2020.

    April 27, 2020

    Because of the COVID-19 pandemic, Secretary of Homeland Security Chad Wolf announces that the Oct. 1 deadline for “card-based enforcement” of Real ID will be extended to Oct. 1, 2021.

    December 5, 2022

    After several more delays, the Department of Homeland Security announces a final implementation deadline of May 7, 2025. The DHS press release emphasizes that, after the deadline, the Transportation Security Administration will be barred from accepting driver’s licenses and identification cards that are non-compliant.

    April 11, 2025

    No more extensions. Secretary of Homeland Security Kristi Noem reaffirms on X that May 7 remains the deadline.

    Starting May 7, you will need a Real ID to travel by air or to visit federal buildings in the United States. These IDs keep our country safe because they help prevent fraud and they enhance security. Please do your part to protect our country. Go today, and don’t delay.

    May 6, 2025

    Noem tells members of the House Appropriations Committee that travelers who have not obtained a Real ID will still be able to fly after the May 7 deadline. However, they will be subject to additional security screenings.

    Noem says, “If [a traveler’s ID is] not compliant, they may be diverted to a different line, have an extra step, but people will be allowed to fly.”

    She does not indicate how long this arrangement will last.

    0 min
  • New York Times: Trump Invented the Surveillance State

    The New York Times runs a jaw-dropper:

    Elon Musk may be stepping back from running the so-called Department of Government Efficiency, but his legacy there is already secured. DOGE is assembling a sprawling domestic surveillance system for the Trump administration — the likes of which we have never seen in the United States… What this amounts to is a stunningly fast reversal of our long history of siloing government data to prevent its misuse…

    They seem to be building a defining feature of many authoritarian regimes: comprehensive files on everyone so they can punish those who protest.

    The guest editorial by Pulitzer-winning investigative reporter Julia Angwin is based on a number of stories, including a whistleblower claim that Musk’s DOGE team was “exfiltrating sensitive data for unknown reasons” at the National Labor Relations Board, and possibly other agencies. If true, it would for sure be an upsetting development on the domestic surveillance front, and should of course be investigated.

    The rest of the editorial is a rewrite of American history comical enough to be the bones of a pre-Green Book Farrelly Brothers movie. The assemblage of “comprehensive files” so the state can “punish those who protest” is, openly, a proud part of the FBI’s creation story. J. Edgar Hoover was put in charge of “counter-radical activities” in 1917, and soon after began keeping sensitive information in separate files locked with his legendary assistant Helen Gandy. Hoover grew those files “exponentially” through the infamous Palmer raids and the 1924 founding of the FBI, and that famed cabinet of secrets helped him hold office until his heart stopped on May 2, 1972. The United States has been repeatedly nailed trying to build Hoover’s dream to scale, which the Times knows because it made history in 1975 publishing Sy Hersh’s report on a “Huge CIA Operation” to gather files on at least 10,000 antiwar dissidents and other Americans who fit the category of “those who protest”:

    Sy Hersh’s story of domestic surveillance in 1975 should count as something we’ve “seen before”

    As for the “sprawling domestic surveillance system… the likes of which we have never seen in the United States,” where we have a “long history” of keeping information siloed “to prevent its misuse,” I don’t know where to start. Just the admitted history of surveillance innovations in recent decades gave the United States capabilities beyond the wildest dreams of the “authoritarian regimes” Angwin references. When I called former CIA analyst Ray McGovern about the piece, he described a 2013 meeting with a former Stasi Colonel, whose eyes lit up when told about America’s post-9/11 data-collection programs. “He said, ‘Zis vould be paradise!’” Ray laughed.

    No one knows this more than the Times, which boasts decades of exposés on the topic:

    Subscribe now

    From Angwin’s piece:

    Over the past 100 days, DOGE teams have grabbed personal data about U.S. residents from dozens of federal databases and are reportedly merging it all into a master database at the Department of Homeland Security. This month, House Democratic lawmakers reported that a whistle-blower had come forward to reveal that the master database will combine data from federal agencies including the Social Security Administration, the Internal Revenue Service and the Department of Health and Human Services. The whistle-blower also alleged that DOGE workers are filling backpacks with multiple laptops, each one loaded with purloined agency data.

    Angwin, author of Dragnet Nation: A Quest for Privacy, Security, and Freedom in a World of Relentless Surveillance, obviously knows the Homeland Security Department was created with the specific aim of taking “siloed” information and merging it into a single database. She’s almost certainly familiar with the initial proposal for the DHS, which read, “The Department would fuse and analyze intelligence and other information pertaining to threats to the homeland from multiple sources, including the CIA, NSA, FBI, INS, DEA, DOE, Customs, DOT and data gleaned from other organizations.”

    She also knows that list is far from complete: Dragnet Nation is full of examples of the DHS and NSA culling info not just from databases like the Census Bureau but state auto vehicle records, foreclosure records, and private data from “giant companies such as Google, Yahoo!, Verizon and Microsoft.” She mentions the DHS sending $50 million “to state law enforcement agencies to purchase automated license plate readers that allow them to keep tabs on citizens’ movements in ways never before possible,” and even finds a DHS mailer about youth cyber activity that makes anodyne lines like “Know What Your Kids Are Doing” feel creeptastic (there’s even a suggestion about installing monitoring tools that can be used “with or without a kid’s knowledge”).

    Today’s Times editorial asserts that “the creation of a huge government database of personal information about U.S. residents is dangerous and very likely against the law,” and cites an instance in the 1960s when Lyndon Johnson was thwarted by Congress in an effort to combine federal dossiers into one “databank.” But Angwin’s 2015 book describes repeated instances in which the executive branch just grabbed whatever data it wanted. In one instance, “the Justice Department authorized the National Counterterrorism Center to copy entire government databases of information about U.S. citizens—flight records, lists of casino employees, the names of Americans hosting foreign-exchange students—and examine the files for suspicious behavior.” The example buttressed one of her main theses: that “suspicionless dragnets had become the new normal.”

    The gist of that story, which is really about the ongoing high-speed merger of public and private databases, was also reported on regularly by the Times during that period and the years preceding. They were most attentive in the Bush years when concerns over civil liberties still ran high with Times readers. A few examples:

    • 2005: Times reporters James Risen and Eric Lichtblau are criticized for disclosing a warrantless eavesdropping program approved by George W. Bush, one that included mining “vast troves of Internet and telephone communications.” It later comes out, via Times public editor Byron Calame (they still had one then) that the Times held the piece until after the results of the 2004 election;

    • 2013: Charlie Savage writes “Facial Scanning is Making Gains in Surveillance,” about testing of the Biometric Optical Surveillance System, or BOSS. Though it “alarms privacy advocates,” there had been “stabs for over a decade at building a system that would help match faces in a crowd with names on a watch list”;

    • 2014: Times publishes features on surveillance of Occupy Protests, noting the use of data from 78 “fusion centers” funded by hundreds of millions of DHS dollars. It describes the production of Homeland Intelligence Reports (HIRs), which make use of nontraditional information like local law enforcement records;

    • 2021: Times reports that the government buys “commercially available databases” containing geolocation and other data from apps like Muslim Pro, a private service showing the direction of Mecca at prayer time;

    • 2021: Times releases McKenzie Funk exposé revealing that ICE “sucks up terabytes of information from hundreds of disparate computer systems, from state and local governments, from private data brokers and from social networks” and “piggybacks on software and sharing agreements originally meant for criminal and counterterrorism investigators.”

    Even with bombshells like the 2013 releases of Edward Snowden (whom the Times editorial once praised as having done a great service for his country) leading newscasts and hitting the front pages, the expanded surveillance state has been massively undercovered, for reasons of varying stupidity and cravenness. Data “purloined” by DOGE geeks stuffing laptops into sacks is an arresting image, but we’re decades into a world in which info from your bank, credit card company, or cell phone carrier can be accessed with just a click, no backpacks needed.

    The Times at least covered abuses of the “National Security Letter” regime allowing wide-scale vacuuming of private data, though they did it in an odd way, running stories like the 2019 “Secret FBI Subpoenas Scoop up Data from Scores of Companies” where you have to read to the bottom to learn the FBI has been repeatedly chided for abuses of this USA PATRIOT Act enhancement. It was more quiet about abuses of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act that surfaced in 2015, 2016, and 2017, particularly a court report about “significant non-compliance with the NSA’s minimization procedures,” which are designed to prevent officials from intentionally accessing conversations of Americans. When reports of FISA abuse to gain access to communications of people in Trump’s circle became a major part of the Russiagate mess, the Times editorial board denounced the story as a “witch hunt,” and never apologized after Justice Inspector General Michael Horowitz issued a report documenting the FISA-abuse story in excruciating detail. Now, suddenly, the paper is back to deathly concern with the surveillance state.

    I don’t love the concept, even in theory, of an administration that’s shown a willingness to go after political enemies using state databases to “identify people who harbor anti-Musk or -Trump sentiment.” But the cascade of accusations more and more resembles the early days of Russiagate, when tales of money laundering, streams of “illicit communications,” connections with Russian spies, abuse of “emoluments,” and other accusations became de rigeur assumptions among reporters, to the point where papers would write blithely about “Trump’s money-laundering problem.”

    The story about using AI to hunt “expressions of perceived disloyalty” might be true, but: one allegation is based on “two people with knowledge of the matter,” another quotes an unnamed Veterans Affairs employee describing a movie-like “culture of fear” where “you know something out there [wants] to kill you but you never know when or how or who it is,” and a third is based on more anonymous reports from workers who “think Musk’s team is looking for signs of progressive thinking or disloyalty.”

    In the Times piece the “sprawling domestic surveillance system” turns out to be a collection of hypotheticals, e.g. “President Trump could soon have the tools to satisfy his many grievances by swiftly locating compromising information about his political opponents,” and “While [court rulings] restricted DOGE from obtaining personally identifiable data, it remains unclear what happens with data that has been already collected.” These are the journalistic equivalent of ghost stories, hushed guesses by anonymous sources about unknown horrors. There are enough whistleblower complaints about data irregularities that one can believe something is afoot, but we have so much experience with second- or third-hand tales of Trump iniquity (remember when we thought Michael Wolff books were gospel?) that we should know to pause when things still “unclear” become the basis for asserting we’re watching the installation of a surveillance state “never seen in the United States.”

    The line that threw me was this quote from longtime civil liberties lawyer Kevin Bankston: “The infrastructure for turnkey totalitarianism is there for an administration willing to break the law.” That’s true, but it’s been true for a while. It’s exactly the danger Snowden warned existed already in 2013:

    These stories are starting to have an unpleasantly familiar ring to them. If the first Trump presidency helped rehabilitate the cratered reputation of the intelligence services, the second Trump term is more and more used as a foundation for new versions of American history. We’re told that billionaires never held dominant roles in domestic politics, civil liberties never faced systematic threats, and most preposterously now, we never deployed a “sprawling domestic surveillance system” using centralized databases of “those who protest.” If like me you’ve struggled to identify the irritating new lie in the atmosphere, doesn’t this feel like it?

    0 min
  • When Genius Failed.....Again
    Illustration by Daniel Medina

    THE SCHEME: Fraud and Money Laundering

    THE COMPANY: Stenn Technologies

    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    THE NEWS: For the second time in five years, a scam involving sexing up a boring, centuries old financing business blew up in the faces of some of the world’s largest banks

    You know the old saying. Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice…

    In December, “fintech” supply chain financier Stenn Technologies and its subsidiaries Stenn Assets UK Ltd and Stenn International Ltd, collapsed, spanking investors and lenders such as Citigroup, Nexis, BNP Paribas, HSBC and private equity firm Centerbridge. Just a month prior to the blow-up, Stenn was viewed as a fintech unicorn with a robust $1 billion book of business, poised for strong growth.

    As we’ve seen time and again, a unicorn can quickly die when a company’s business model screams fraud to anyone bothering to look.

    Stenn Technologies claimed to use artificial intelligence and state of the art technology to analyze credit and money laundering risk in order to turn a low margin, supply chain financing business into an awesome, high return, low risk securitized product.

    Here’s a quick explanation of supply chain financing:

    1. A company delivers its product to a buyer and the buyer promises to pay in a few months’ time, creating an accounts receivable.

    2. The company that has the accounts receivable sends it to the supply chain financier (Greensill Capital or Stenn Technologies).

    3. The supply chain financier pays the company cash for the receivable minus a discount which is another business practice called factoring.

    4. The buyer pays the financier the full amount of the receivable on the due date.

    Supply chain financing is nothing new. It was probably around when Marco Polo set out for the Orient.

    If it sounds boring, that’s because it is, or at least is supposed to be. Lex Greensill’s Greensill Capital changed that a decade ago.

    Through fancy structuring, as well as four private jets, Greensill created a byzantine circular loop where money flowed around the world, much of it to Greensill favorites like steel maker Sanjeev Gupta and then back again. The operation was continuously funded by either GAM, Credit Suisse, SoftBank as well as Greensill’s own German bank, Greensill Bank AG. After a while, as more money poured into Greensill from eager investors, the company began to essentially just lend money out, mostly to Gupta while calling the transactions “future receivables.”

    Greensill Capital collapsed under the weight of fraud in 2021, costing its big investors mentioned above billions. Matt reported on the story here in 2021.

    Greensill’s receivable notes (the fancy structuring) were insured by a number of insurers, the biggest being Japanese insurer Tokio Marine. The insurance made investors comfortable because, if Tokio Marine insured it, the notes have to be money good, right?

    Wrong.

    At one point, Tokio had nearly $8 billion of exposure to Greensill deals. How insurers got comfortable with insuring receivables to a blizzard of shell companies that all seemed to point back to Gupta and Lex’s pockets is anyone’s guess, but when Tokio finally did a good look under the hood, they cried insurance fraud and Greensill came crashing down. Credit Suisse investors alone lost $10 billion.

    At this point, we need to hear from Lt. Commander Montgomery Scott, better known as Scotty.

    So now, we’re at the shame on you portion of the story.

    Astoundingly, Stenn Technologies was able to pull off a similar scam just a couple of years later, posing as a fintech company, supposedly using the latest in technology to do global supply chain financing faster and better than everyone else in the business.

    The victims are new, but given the high publicity of Greensill’s failure, you’d figure they would catch on.

    According to Bloomberg News, “Stenn’s main backers were Citigroup Inc., BNP Paribas SA, Natixis and HSBC Holdings Plc while Barclays Plc, M&G Plc and Goldman Sachs Group also backed the transaction.”

    Private equity firm Centerbridge invested $50 million in capital and valued the company at $900 million in 2022.

    In 2022, TechCrunch described the secret sauce that Stenn was supposedly using to bring a 13th century business into the modern age.

    Stenn — which applies big data analytics, taking a few datapoints about a business (the main two being what money it has coming in and going out based on invoices) and matching them up against an algorithm that takes some 1,000 other factors into account to determine its eligibility for a loan of up to $10 million; and on the other side taps a network of institutions and other big lenders to provide the capital for that financing.

    Perhaps this multi-factor algorithm was super cool when they showed it to investors and lending partners. The only problem was Stenn, in the words of a business crime attorney who spoke to Bloomberg, “has all the hallmarks of both fraud and money laundering.”

    Greensill might have been a bit hard to figure out with large, respected insurance companies insuring their notes.

    But anyone who took the time to investigate Stenn Technologies by simply looking at the data they pumped out to investors weekly would have seen the scheme for what it was.

    While it appears the previously mentioned institutional investors didn’t bother to investigate, Bloomberg did and the results were darkly hilarious.

    Some of Stenn’s biggest suppliers were tiny companies in Thailand and Hong Kong with little in common yet corporate filings for all of them list the same Russian name as a backer. One in Singapore was accused by the U.S. of enabling payments to Russian naval intelligence and sanctioned in August. Tracing a group owned by another Russian investor that was supposedly shipping millions of dollars of goods to corporations in Switzerland and Canada led to a derelict Prague building with boarded-up windows.

    Bloomberg contacted the largest 50 firms that were supposedly the buyers for what Stenn’s suppliers produced, and the bulk had no idea who Stenn Technologies or these suppliers were! A spokesman for Edion Corp., one of the biggest electronics retailers in Japan, told Bloomberg, “we have absolutely no knowledge of this matter. We really have no idea what it’s about.”

    Essentially, the data produced by Stenn highlighted thousands of bogus transactions on a weekly basis to investors, lying about who was paying and who was receiving billions of dollars of funds. According to Bloomberg, investors received these details with the name of the suppliers and buyers included. Therefore, at any time, investors could have done a sanity check on these obscure suppliers to see who they were, or in this case, weren’t.

    HSBC finally caught up to what Stenn was doing. Again from the Bloomberg report:

    HSBC triggered Stenn’s downfall when it lodged an application to the UK courts, alleging that its officials had uncovered ‘deeply troubling issues on a large scale.’ The
    invoices at the heart of the deal weren’t ‘genuine debts’ and payments to suppliers weren’t coming from ‘blue-chip companies’ but from bogus firms with similar names, according to the complaint filed by the London-based bank.

    Investors are facing a potential loss of $200 million, although it could be a lot more as $978 million in invoiced-financed notes are outstanding, Bloomberg reports.

    There is a bright side to Stenn’s collapse though. A senior trade finance official told The Sunday Times:

    “The saving grace here is at least it’s smaller than Greensill.”

    Well played.

    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    0 min
  • Timeline: Political Advocacy by Open Letter
    Illustration by Daniel Medina

    With research assistance from James Rushmore

    There are two primary seasons for open letters:

    1. The first few months of an administration, when aggrieved political groups (most often) voice their dissatisfaction.

    2. The last few months of election season, when the goal is to fuck with you - emphasizing how scary one candidate is or how much stronger the other is, when the truth is they both suck.

    The October 19, 2020 letter signed by 51 former senior intelligence officials is probably the most infamous example of number 2. It said email from Hunter Biden’s laptop “has all the classic earmarks of a Russian information operation.”

    We now know it was more like a Biden misinformation program. We know from the House Intelligence Select Committee that it started with Biden campaign official Anthony Blinken — who later became Secretary of State — calling former Deputy CIA Director Michael Morrell, who then organized the letter. The purpose was to provide cover and talking points for Biden to help him in a final debate with Trump, the House committee found.

    Of course there are almost always political motives behind open letters. In 2020, the Trump campaign released an open letter signed by 235 retired military leaders saying Trump was good for national security, and Biden not so good. That was released only after the progressive group Democracy Forward released a letter signed by 70 former Republican national security officials saying Trump had already failed with national security.

    It’s mostly a game. The goal is to get the attention of traditional media, and have content that takes off on social media.

    At least that’s usually the case. As Matt Taibbi notes in “Are We in a ‘Soft’ Civil War?” today, a strongly worded letter signed by 200 former diplomats and security officials titled “The Assault on American Democracy: A Call to Action” was published last Friday. It features big names former National Security Advisors Susan Rice and Anthony Lake as signatories, but received media attention in Bulgaria only. 

    An open letter signed by political scientists after the January 6 riots received more media attention in the U.S. Then again, the letter called for Trump’s removal by impeachment or by invoking the 25th Amendment.

    One of the signatories, Catawba College (NC) political science and history professor J. Michael Bitzer, says he considers the letter a “statement of principles.”

    When something in my mind reaches beyond a level of partisanship to the level of fundamental values we hope Americans stand for on principle, then statements of principles are a core responsibility for those of us who study them. There’s so much partisanship out there that people don’t need to hear from us on every political issue, but when it comes to fundamental values, if something calls that into question, it’s good to speak with a collective voice.

    The “statement of principles” is usually more honest than the “open letter,” such as one written in early 2017 by former Columbia Journalism Review editor Kyle Pope but signed “The Press Corps.”

    That piece is both hilarious and Class A Jim Acosta-level smug:

    Access is preferable, but not critical. You may decide that giving reporters access to your administration has no upside. We think that would be a mistake on your part, but again, it’s your choice. We are very good at finding alternative ways to get information; indeed, some of the best reporting during the campaign came from news organizations that were banned from your rallies. Telling reporters that they won’t get access to something isn’t what we’d prefer, but it’s a challenge we relish.

    Of course, we know that last part isn’t true. The Associated Press whined when its Oval Office access was cut off. Trump’s move was certainly silly, but democracy was not at stake.

    Here’s a list of open letters — though certainly not complete — directed at Trump in his first and second terms.

    November 29, 2016

    Following Trump’s election as the 45th president, the Union of Concerned Scientists release an open letter to Trump and Congress. The letter, signed by 2,000-plus scientists — including 22 Nobel Prize winners — informs the president-elect and Congress that:

    First, creating a strong and open culture of science begins at the top. Federal agencies should be led by officials with demonstrated track records of respecting science as a critical component of decision making. Further, recognizing that diversity makes science stronger, administration officials should welcome and encourage all scientists regardless of religious background, race, gender, or sexual orientation.

    The Washington Post’s lead on the letter says: “Call it the opening shot in a brewing war over scientific integrity in the future Trump administration.”

    The headline is a reference to this line:

    Congress and the Trump administration should adhere to high standards of scientific integrity and independence in responding to current and emerging public health and environmental threats.

    Andrew Rosenberg of The Center for Science and Democracy at the Union of Concerned Scientists tells the Post, “We need to make sure there’s not political manipulation of the science.”

    Science And The Public Interest69.8KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadJanuary 17, 2017The Press Corps/Kyle Pope

    This letter was written by Columbia Journalism Review editor Kyle Pope, but signed by “The Press Corps.” I reference this letter further up. Another excerpt:

    We decide how much airtime to give your spokespeople and surrogates. We will strive to get your point of view across, even if you seek to shut us out. But that does not mean we are required to turn our airwaves or column inches over to people who repeatedly distort or bend the truth. We will call them out when they do, and we reserve the right, in the most egregious cases, to ban them from our outlets.

    Tough stuff.

    January 22, 2017500 Women Scientists

    Forbes magazine posts an open letter from 500 Women Scientists. It reads in part:

    We are women scientists and we are members of diverse racial, ethnic, and religious groups. We are immigrants. We are people with disabilities. We are LGBTQIA. To represent us, you must embrace our inherent diversity. We will continue to contribute to the American scientific enterprise, and we invite you to do the same.

    The letter also gives Trump eight “concrete ways” to support women and their contributions to society and science, such as strengthening America’s role as a leader in climate action by “investing in clean, low carbon energy and climate research.”

    The Atlantic profiled the group as its members participated in the January 21st Women’s March on Washington, January 31, 2017 - Feb. 8, 2017

    Interfaith Immigration Coalition
    Evangelical Leaders

    Over eight days, the Interfaith Immigration Coalition, evangelical leaders, and venture capitalists write open letters to Trump over his executive order that banned refugees from seven Muslim countries for 90 days.

    From the Interfaith Immigration Coalition:

    The U.S. Refugee Resettlement program has been and should remain open to those of all nationalities and religions who face persecution on account of the reasons enumerated under U.S. law. We oppose any policy change that would prevent refugees from Syria, Iraq, Iran, Libya, Somalia, Sudan, and Yemen, or individuals who practice Islam and other faiths from accessing the U.S. refugee resettlement program.

    Interfaith Coalition Letter1.42MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload

    A Feb. 7 letter, organized by the National Venture Capital Association, says:

    We are deeply troubled by the recent Executive Order banning citizens of seven countries and refugees from entering the U.S., as well as the recently leaked draft Executive Order suggesting plans to roll back worker visa and parole programs.

    020717 NVCA Immigration Letter905KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload

    The Feb. 8 letter from evangelical leaders was in the form of a full-page ad in the Washington Post.

    As Christians, we have a historic call expressed over two thousand years, to serve the suffering. We cannot abandon this call now.

    March 2, 2017Various women’s rights groups

    As advocates for women’s rights, equality, justice and inclusion, we have come together to outline core domestic policy priorities that will help ensure that all women in the United States have the opportunity to succeed and thrive.

    That is the first line in a letter signed by about 400 progressive organizations, such as several NOW chapters. It proceeds to list six broad categories for which “we will measure your administration’s success by how women have fared during your tenure,” the letter warns.

    Womens Community Letter 2017560KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadSept. 29, 2017

    Several evangelical leaders, including pastor TD Jakes and the president of the Southern Baptist Convention, email a letter to Trump and calling for him to denounce the alt-right.

    We believe it is important for this movement to be addressed, for at its core it is a white identity movement and the majority of its members are white nationalists or white supremacists.

    May 6, 2019

    Several hundred former officials in the Justice Department issue a statement on Medium that says special counsel Robert Mueller’s report shows that Trump would be charged with obstruction of justice if he wasn’t president.

    The Mueller report describes several acts that satisfy all of the elements for an obstruction charge: conduct that obstructed or attempted to obstruct the truth-finding process, as to which the evidence of corrupt intent and connection to pending proceedings is overwhelming.

    August 21 - Sept. 14, 2020

    The tit-for-tat letters on national security mentioned at the top of this piece are released August 21 (anti-Trump) and Sept. 14 (pro-Trump)

    235 Military Leaders Endorse President Trump Final170KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadFormer Republican National Security Officials For Biden Defending Democracy Together229KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadOct. 19, 2020

    The letter from 51 former national security officials is released. Politico breaks the story.

    Statement On Hunter Biden Emails98.8KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadJanuary 6, 2021

    Following the January 6 riots, Political scientists write an open letter calling for Congress to remove President Trump from office.

    Political Scientist Open Letter700KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadJanuary 11, 2021

    Nearly 1,500 historians call for removing President Trump from office, via Medium.

    Historians And Constitutional Scholars’ Statement On The Second Impeachment Of President Donald Trump By Historians And Legal Scholars For Impeachment2.4MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadJanuary 6, 2025Global Centre for the Responsibility to Protect

    Several organizations sign on to this letter to “express grave concerns and to unequivocally oppose the use of the sanctions authority of the United States to attack the International Criminal Court (ICC), an independent judicial institution dedicated to combating impunity for the gravest crimes known to humanity.”

    Signatories include the ACLU, American Friends Service Committee, American Human Rights Council, and Amnesty International USA

    January 29, 2025American Friends Service Committee

    A coalition of groups that includes Catholic Workers and the National Association of Korean Americans ask Trump to take a “peace-first approach” with North Korea. One recommendation is to formally end the Korean War.

    Even though active hostilities between the United States and North Korea ended in 1953 with an Armistice Agreement, there was never a formal end to the war with a peace agreement. This continued state of war is the root cause of militarism and tensions that must be resolved if there is to be real progress with North Korea. A peace agreement that ends the wartime status quo would reduce tensions and foster more effective engagement on critical issues such as improved human rights and denuclearization.

    March 3, 2025Former prisoners at Guantanamo Bay

    Sixteen former prisoners of Guantanamo Bay sign an open letter to condemn an executive order to expand detention facilities for illegal immigrants there. The letter is posted on Aljazeera.

    Guantanamo is not just a prison – it is a place where law is warped, dignity is stripped, and suffering is hidden behind barbed wire. We lived it. We know the clang of metal doors, the weight of shackles, and the silence of a world that looked away. We know what it means to be caged without charge, without trial, without hope.

    March 31, 2025National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine

    More than 1,900 members sign an open letter to criticize cutbacks in the sciences and the administration investigations of universities.

    The funding cuts are forcing institutions to pause research (including studies of new disease treatments), dismiss faculty, and stop enrolling graduate students—the pipeline for the next generation’s scientists.

    The administration’s current investigations of more than 50 universities send a chilling message. Columbia University was recently notified that its federal funding would be withheld unless it adopted disciplinary policies and disabled an academic department targeted by the administration. Destabilizing dozens of universities will endanger higher education—and the research those institutions conduct.

    Public Statement On Supporting Science For The Benefit Of All Citizens Google Docs588KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadApril 24, 2025

    The Assault on American Democracy: A Call to Action letter is released, signed by 200 former diplomats and security officials.

    American global leadership has depended on many factors, including political, economic, and military power. But most important was the moral foundation for that power -- America as an example to others. Though our actions didn’t always live up to our ideals, we stood for simple but powerful ideas that people everywhere embraced: democracy, equality, individual liberty, and human rights.

    That moral foundation is now in grave danger. The challenge comes from within, as President Trump and his administration have assaulted the pillars of our democracy here at home and our strength around the world.

    Open Letter On Democracy With Signatories (1) (1)261KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadApril 22, 2025American Association of Colleges and Universities
    American Academy of Arts and Sciences

    Several hundred college presidents and deans sign on to “A Call for Constructive Engagement.” The letter was released a day after Harvard sued the government following the Trump administration’s decision to withhold funding. The letter now has 547 signatures.

    As leaders of America’s colleges, universities, and scholarly societies, we speak with one voice against the unprecedented government overreach and political interference now endangering American higher education. We are open to constructive reform and do not oppose legitimate government oversight. However, we must oppose undue government intrusion in the lives of those who learn, live, and work on our campuses. We will always seek effective and fair financial practices, but we must reject the coercive use of public research funding.

    A Call For Constructive Engagement303KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadApril 28, 2025Coalition of Nobel Peace Prize-winning groups

    Representatives of the three groups urge Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin to work toward denuclearization.

    Recent statements from your administrations have featured rhetoric about the desirability of a world without nuclear weapons and the exorbitant cost of nuclear weapons, funds that could be put to far better use. Talk about denuclearization must be matched by deeds. The world cannot continue to walk the edge of catastrophe.

    0 min
  • Are We in a "Soft" Civil War?
    A group letter signed by natsec luminaries calling for citizens to “mobilize” was released before a visit by Donald Trump, Jr. to Bulgaria

    On Sunday, April 27th, Donald J. Trump, Jr. joined an event in Bulgaria, hosted by controversial crypto firm Nexo. Nexo in 2023 was fined $45 million by the SEC and ordered to stop offering a product that was marketed as a way for investors to earn interest on crypto holdings. On Monday, it announced its “return to the United States,” quoting Trump Jr. as saying, “I think crypto is the future of finance.”

    The visit by Trump, Jr. coincided with a sharpening public relations campaign at home. Former Treasury official Steven Rattner argued in the New York Times that we’re witnessing a “new low” in corruption, after $Trump meme coin investors were offered “Special VIP Tours” at the White House. It also came days after 200 former diplomats and security officials signed a group letter titled “The Assault on American Democracy: A Call to Action.” Featuring signatories like ex-National Security Advisors Susan Rice and Anthony Lake, and impeachment witness/former Ukraine ambassador Marie Yovanovitch, the letter contained eyebrow-raising language:

    Subscribe now

    Many of us have served in countries where democratically elected leaders followed a path to autocracy, and we know this crisis requires an urgent and unified response…Waiting passively for the electoral calendar to fight back does nothing more than give the administration additional time and running room to impose its authoritarian stamp… No American… can afford to be a bystander. Each of us in different walks of life must… speak out, mobilize, defend our way of life. The moment requires nothing less. We must recognize the seriousness of what is taking place and act collectively to restore our democracy and our security.

    The word “mobilize” has been appearing in op-eds and political speeches with increasing frequency. “Mobilize, message, litigate” was a catch-phrase offered by Virginia congressman Gerry Connolly early in the Trump term, but lately mobilize seems to be carrying a different connotation, amid an often-unvoiced implication of coming revolt.

    The recent letter received no press outside of Bulgaria, making it necessary to reach out to signatories like former CIA senior intelligence officer Anne Gruner to confirm authenticity. The call for ex-officials to act now instead of “waiting passively for the electoral calendar” appears to have been organized by former Ambassador to Bulgaria Eric Rubin, who gave an interview about it on Bulgarian TV Saturday. Rubin has not responded to requests for comment.

    The first 100 days of the Trump administration have been marked by blunt offensives against political opponents, from executive orders targeting law firms like Wilmer Hale, Perkins Coie, and Jenner & Block, to the firing of career officials from the National Security Council to the Justice Department, to the stripping of security clearances for figures like Kamala Harris and Hillary Clinton. These moves prompted a cascade of news stories describing an “unprecedented assault on the constitutional order,” and those increasingly are accompanied by editorials calling for “mobilization” or revolution.

    Coming from the likes of David Brooks, a call for a “national civic uprising” felt like a joke, but we’re starting to hear the same types of arguments emanate from more serious characters. Illinois Governor J.B. Pritzker just joined in the call for “mobilization” and “mass protests” in a New Hampshire speech, comparing Republicans to Nazis, saying their names will be reserved for museums dedicated to “tyrants and traitors,” and adding that “do-nothing” Democrats need to “step out of your comfort zone and step out into the streets” and “fight, fight, fight.”

    The speech has been hailed across the pundit-o-sphere, with the Boston Globe saying Democrats “finally seem to understand the assignment,” while the Washington Post said the call to make sure Republicans “cannot know a moment of peace” has already driven 2028 “campaign buzz.” Instead of making fun of an heir to the Hyatt fortune cosplaying Lev Trotsky, Republicans have grumbled in response. Stephen Miller suggested the speech could be construed as incitement to violence, an argument ridiculed when Democrats made it about Trump’s “fight like hell” comment on January 6th. There have been growing calls for resistance beyond things like “Hands Off!” marches, but those have been marked by an ominous vagueness. Anne Applebaum of the Atlantic suggested a reason resistance hasn’t been more forceful is a divide among protesting demographics, between those playing by old rules, and those ready for obliquely-defined “new” solutions.

    “People have to understand what’s happening, and then they’ll figure out what’s the best way to resist it,” is how Applebaum put it on German television last month.

    As Greg Collard notes in today’s Timeline on “Political Advocacy by Open Letter,” the Trump era has been marked by a comically high quantity of “open letters.” Many have involved intelligence honchos, from a 2016 group letter with former CIA chief Michael Hayden and former Homeland Security head Tom Ridge to a 2018 letter protesting the removal of former CIA head John Brennan’s security clearance, to the infamous “51 spies” letter, to a 2024 letter by the mysterious “NSL4A” (National Security Leaders for America) endorsing Kamala Harris and condemning Trump’s “vengeful impulsiveness.” The NSL4A, which features a half-dozen former CIA directors, still exists, still issues statements about episodes like SignalGate, and markets itself as the voice of the exiled intelligence sector so unabashedly that one almost expects the release of a We Are The Deep State single, with Brennan playing the George Michael role and Leon Panetta as Bono.

    Since Trump’s second inauguration, these and other critics have been relentless in decrying an unprecedented “assault on norms,” which in their telling began in January and has been marked by such “dictatorial” severity as to require those “new solutions.” The White House obviously sees it differently. Current and former officials connected to the administration believe “norms” evaporated before Trump took office in 2016, with official spying via the Trump-Russia probe, the subsequent launching of multiple successful politicized investigations, the May 2017 opening of a second FBI probe into whether or not Trump was “working on behalf of Russia” after the firing of James Comey, the successful removal of Trump from Internet platforms, efforts to have lawyers who represented Trump disbarred, use of courts to try to remove Trump and other pols from the ballot, the censorship (and in cases like Steve Bannon, jailing) of media figures friendly to Trump, and countless other matters.

    We forget how comprehensively institutional America became politicized before the arrival of this new administration. Never mind the prosecutions and investigations: officials from enforcement agencies issued so many warnings about “brazen” efforts by Russia and other countries to meddle in elections on Trump’s behalf that you could set your watch by them. Imagine if Kristi Noem or John Ratcliffe not only issued regular bulletins about Chinese efforts to buy American farmland or dominate “emerging technologies,” but every election season issued warnings about China seeking to “sow division” by “boosting Democrats” and “denigrating Donald Trump.” Op-ed pages would be full of frantic denunciations of the politicization of the DHS and CIA, news pages would be full of analyses correctly pointing out that intelligence can be manipulated in a dozen different ways, and newspapers would valiantly point out that they’re duty-bound to not repeat such assertions until proven. Ten minutes ago, of course, everyone in media felt differently.

    How one views all this largely rests on whether or you believe those pre-2025 moves directed at Trump were legitimate. NBC for instance recently quoted a Washington lawyer named Dan Meyer, who called the revocation of security clearances of signatories of the “51 spies” letter as “the most politically saturated security action since the Oppenheimer case in the 1950s.” The Trump team of course sees the “51 spies” episode itself as the unprecedented action. Their executive order on the subject notes the 2020 letter, which suggested a New York Post story about Hunter Biden’s laptop was Russian disinformation, didn’t involve retired officials only. The letter was also “sent to the CIA Prepublication Classification Review Board,” and “senior CIA officials were made aware of the contents of the letter.” Add the still-underreported scandal about the FBI falsely briefing Senators Ron Johnson and Chuck Grassley that the laptop story was Russian meddling, and it’s not hard to argue that intelligence and law enforcement agencies were improperly meddling in politics for years.

    Trump is who he is. He makes outrageous statements, often means them, and has never been anybody’s idea of a tribune of Jeffersonian probity. In recent weeks he’s said and done a number of hair-raising things, from seeming to talk about deporting U.S. citizens as prisoners to El Salvador (“We have bad ones too… I’m all for it because we can do things with the president for less money”) to selling “Trump 2028” merch (classic Trump, but why do that, even as a joke?) to the aforementioned $Trump promotion, which seems like an homage to Bill Clinton’s Lincoln bedroom scandal.

    On closer examination, however, most of the the “assault on the constitutional order” stories aren’t as alarming as advertised. The main complaints seem not to be about rule-breaking but his radical policy choices: deep cuts to the budget, mass deportations, giganto-tariffs, abandoning consensus on the Ukraine war, the withholding of federal funds and/or tax-exempt status from academia or organizations like Wikipedia, and other major departures.

    Look at the allegations in the Bulgaria letter: Trump has “questioned the value of long-standing alliances in Europe and Asia,” he’s “intimidating independent media outlets with frivolous lawsuits,” he’s made “explicit threats to withdraw federal monies” from universities, and humorously, he’s undermining a “global economic order that ushered in a period of unparalleled prosperity for Americans.” (If that last line were true, he wouldn’t have been elected.) He’s also accused of “dismantling essential institutions,” which seems to be the key issue.

    Every story that looks like it might be evidence of an irrevocable decision to cross a line, a modern version of Lincoln’s defiance of the Supreme Court in Ex Parte Merryman, turns out to be something less dramatic. The much-publicized “arresting a judge” story, which the Guardian described as a local justice’s punishment for “helping an undocumented man avoid abduction,” has been presented as an example of an administration willing to lock up judges who block policies via their rulings. Forbes for instance wrote:

    They sent a chilling message: that the executive branch of government now claims the power to punish judges who stand in the way of its political priorities.

    I spent months back in the early 2010s covering cases of undocumented immigrants deported under the 287(g) program, which dates to 1996 and deputized local and federal officials to run immigration checks on everyone taken into custody. I don’t remember judges railing against the injustice of that program, or wrapping arms around undocumented court vistors back when they were being shipped out wholesale by a more socially acceptable president like Barack Obama. I get the principle that even non-citizens are theoretically entitled to habeas rights, but a judge helping an undocumented person use a back door to escape deportation is absurd in a different direction. ICE arrests aren’t “abductions” or a program of “mass kidnapping,” as the Guardian called it, unless you think there’s no such thing as illegal immigration, an even more radical concept than Trump’s deportations policy. It’s as if everyone is choosing to lose their minds.

    Since November we’ve moved a highly lawyered group of habitual rule-breakers out of office, and replaced them with a payback-seeking group that is often more interested in big results than process. Another way to view it is that we exchanged a group of officials who used executive power in an unprecedented way but didn’t admit it, for a group that is freely admitting its novel and at times unsettling use of presidential authority. It all makes for a fraught, dangerous moment and my main emotion as a voter is hoping none of this devolves into open conflict. Can we get through this with something like an intact legal system in the end?

    0 min