
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Link Here: How to Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Automated transcripts can be found on the web browser or app version below the byline.
Share the Free Episodes of Get Lit:
Watch Get Lit on YouTube below:
From Mother Jones yesterday:
The science is far from settled about whether trans girls who have received gender-affirming treatment actually have a competitive advantage or pose a greater risk of injuring other players. But the majority opinion, by Justice Brett Kavanaugh, glosses over those unknowns—reasoning that “biological sex” is a good enough proxy for athletic ability for states to categorically ban trans girls from girls’ sports.
It was once uncontroversial to observe that testosterone gives athletes advantages. Baseball’s steroid scandals were only a tick of the historical clock ago, and the number of people in the continental United States willing to stand up and say Mark McGwire and Raffy Palmeiro hit their own homers would have fit in a dentist’s waiting room. Every working comedian in the country made at least one joke about balloon-headed liar Barry Bonds:
This was universal, but once the trans issue with its myriad lifestyle and political considerations came along, the general public was suddenly asked to accept one factual absurdity after another about the same thing. “Far from settled!” Really, Mother Jones?
The Supreme Court Tuesday handed down a landmark 6-3 ruling in West Virginia v. BPJ and Little v. Hecox, upholding two state bans on the participation of transgender athletes on women’s and girls’ sports teams. Justice Brett Kavanaugh, who wrote the majority opinion, used strong language in upholding West Virginia and Idaho statutes, saying the court disagreed that “schools must allow biological males… to compete on girls’ sports teams.” Kavanaugh even used a hated term, asking, “May schools determine eligibility for women’s and girls’ sports based on biological sex? The answer is yes,” upsetting pundits who want officials to stick to activist-approved phrases like “sex assigned at birth.”
“It’s a good decision for women and girls,” said Kara Dansky, who wrote an amicus brief supporting the states for the U.S. chapter of the Women’s Declaration International.
Dansky was once senior counsel for the ACLU Center of Justice. In this case she was on the other side of the ACLU, whose attorneys (including co-director of LGBTQ and HIV rights, Chase Strangio) argued against the state bans. The ACLU has also split with former feminist allies by arguing for the housing of biological men in women’s prisons, including those with records of violent sex offenses. These efforts in trying to force society to reimagine biology are clearly failing, but the outraged reaction yesterday shows the fight isn’t over. NBC described the decision as a “major blow to LGBTQ rights,” and former VP contender Tim Walz claimed the “Supreme Court says schools can be cruel to trans kids”:
Cruel is an extraordinary word to describe the act of allowing states to object to a radical social program that was implemented virtually everywhere ahead of both scientific and (especially) political consensus. The numbers aren’t close. A New York Times/Ipsos poll last year found 79% of Americans, including 67% of Democrats, are opposed to “athletes who were male at birth” participating in women’s sports. The same poll found 71% of all Americans, including 54% of Democrats, believe no one under 18 should have access to puberty blockers. This was after exposure to years of movement messaging.
Strangio and the ACLU don’t see that they’re asking for something people can’t give them, even if they wanted to, namely the honest belief that people who’ve transitioned have literally changed sexes. The gambit failed for the same reason Spanish speakers rejected “Latinx.”
Like politics, language has a democratic dynamic. If people don’t use Latinx because Spanish (like 38% of all languages) is a gendered tongue with its own distinct sonic system that Spanish speakers love, they won’t use it, and you can’t make them. The ostensible logic behind Latinx was to “challenge the gender binary” and “remove gender from Spanish,” in part because a handful of intellectuals claim gendered language causes unequal economic outcomes. A rational person finds this absurd, unless you believe the early French schemed to consign bananas to girlhood while making boys out of tuna as a weirdly subtle means of oppressing women in future centuries.
As with Latinx, activists tried to lobby “sex assigned at birth” into reality, only to have the population spit it back out as “biological sex.” The court just recognized another thing that was uncontroversial until ten minutes ago. Yes, a small percentage of human beings have intersex characterstics, but most of the world’s population can’t be forced to unlearn what it intrinsically knows. Knowing which gametes your body cranks out is another form of “lived experience,” one is irrelevant to activists, apparently, because it’s “normative.” People know they weren’t “assigned” a sex by hospital clerks. Some people tried to think that way. It just didn’t take.
Activists could have started with a proposition: given that sex is binary, what can society do to accomodate people who experience dysphoria and wish to live under a new identity? The same Americans who accepted gay marriage fairly quickly after Obergefell v. Hodges 11 years ago likely would have extended as far as they could without jumping into a factual or scientific abyss, on issues ranging from expanded insurance to easier routes to housing or identification. Instead, activists treated access for biological males to women’s locker rooms, sports rosters, even prisons as settled rights matters, against which only right-wing Christian patriarchal bigots could possibly object. Unless 80% of Americans are bigots, a lot of apologies are owed:
Subscribe now
Today is a big day at Racket, for Brad Pearce and are starting our Get Lit dive into Fyodor Dostoyevsky’s Demons, a book suppressed by the Soviets for much of the 20th century that’s never been more relevant to the West, especially after last week’s big victory by the DSA in the New York primary. Anyone puzzled by the iron humorlessness and defiant impracticality of characters like Hasan Piker, Zohran Mamdani, and Darializa Chevalier, to say nothing of the gushing welcome they’ve received by aging Boomers with glue-factory reservations on MSNOW, need only read this book.
Sometimes translated as The Devils or The Possessed, Demons to American readers will present as a predictive epic about wokism, told through a blistering satire of political activism that starts off as comedy and ends in the place no one described better than this author — hell. There’s more to say about this book, but first, here’s where you can find Brad and me this afternoon at 4:30 ET:
Substack
Rumble
YouTube
You can also find us on X, @mtaibbi or @waywardrabbler.
Now for a brief cheat sheet on Demons, which is based on a real murder conspiracy but starts with an observation about family:
Subscribe now
New York’s Mayor proved he’s a generational political talent this week, re-shaping the Democratic Party and setting America up for a referendum on its founding principles
Narrated by Jared Moore
Art by Daniel Medina
Text published 06/25/26:
Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts
Ahead of America’s 250th, the beautiful people have brought anti-patriotism fully back into style
Narrated by Jared Moore
Art by Daniel Medina
Original Text published 06/23/26:
Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts
The days of dismissing the Democratic Socialists of America and New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani as lightweights are over, after Mamdani-endorsed congressional candidates Brad Lander, Claire Valdez, and Darializa Chevalier obliterated traditional Democrats in this week’s New York primary.
Traditional Democrats are finished. Their card is punched. They will be replaced, or more likely absorbed, by a Mamdani-led Democratic Socialist bureaucracy in short order. Though Mayor Zohran is even more overrated as an orator than Barack Obama or Ronald Reagan, he’s now proven that he possesses their same transformational political skill, as his gambit backing three shaky DSA candidates and easily winning all three hands was a masterstroke, one that did mark “a new era for the Democratic Party,” as CNN analyst Van Jones put it.
It’s not Bernie redux. Vermont’s scruffy Senator Sanders will still be trotted out as a totem, a symbol of the insufficiently ruthless old days, tolerated by the DSA’s humorless young leadership in the same way poor old Stepya Verkhovensky was by the young radicals in Dostoyevsky’s Demons. But Tuesday was not about advancing Bernie’s cause.
What happened this week is being described in many places as a big win for populist or “anti-elite” politics, but it’s the opposite. This was simulteneously a wipeout of Clintonian party hacks and Bernie’s staid F.D.R.-style big tent politics, in favor of a slickly marketed revolution with a young ethnic vibe. The Zohran movement is an obvious elite fixation, built atop the exotically batshit boutique ideas that America’s nitwit rich find thrilling, like publicly funded “gender-affirming care,” “humanity has no borders,” and my personal favorite, “the institution of the family acts as part of the carceral system.”
If the Sanders campaign was a referendum on the presidency of Barack Obama, the Zohran/DSA revolution is a referendum on America itself, led by people who aren’t the least bit embarrassed to tell you they hate this place, to point of viewing our government as an extension of the Israeli state, whose people deserved 9/11. There’s a smorgasbord of statements by DSA folk along those lines, led by charming Mamdani pal Hasan Piker:
That’s the difference between the Sanders movement and this new tidal wave. Sanders loved every inch of Vermont and was desperate to implement ameliorative social reforms he sincerely believed would turn around a country and a government he revered, borders and all. His platform was designed to fit in the American system, only with government acting as a tougher negotiator for the ordinary person.
The Zohran revolution, meanwhile, is a whole-hog, fuck-it, real-thing version of Marxian socialism, instantly recognizable to anyone who’s ever lived in a socialist country. Boy, is it selling with our beautiful people, who’ve never met a bad idea they didn’t love:
Subscribe now
Link Here: Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Automated transcripts can be found on the web browser or app version below the byline.
Share the Free Episodes of Get Lit:
Watch Get Lit on YouTube below:
Brad and Matt’s last live-cast on “Discourses of Livy” has lessons for both Democrats and Republicans
Get more from Matt Taibbi in the Substack appAvailable for iOS and AndroidGet the appIn 1986 the New York Times celebrated the 100th year of the Statue of Liberty with a series of paeans to its hometown heroine-of-steel, who’d stood at the harbor and welcomed so many of the city’s immigrant families.
“Miss Liberty… represents tolerance and acceptance, a generosity of spirit, the America that lives in the words of Walt Whitman and William Saroyan, the films of Frank Capra, the music of Aaron Copland,” the paper wrote. “And when… a nation falls short of the ideals she represents, she towers in silent reproach.”
Forty years later the same Times, ahead of a new national milestone, is running a series of features called AMERICA AT 250. One of the latest is “These 8 Americans Shaped History. We Just Don’t Agree on How.”
What eight Americans would you put on a list of history-shapers?
From Elvis to Muhammad Ali to Michael Jackson to Barack Obama, the most famous people on earth for the last seventy-plus years have almost all been Americans, but being known isn’t everything. If the question is who shaped world history, one could make cases for Edison, Ford, Whitney, Salk, Disney, Deere, Gates, Jobs, Rockefeller, Colt, or the Wright Brothers; you might think of shadow villains like Dulles or Lansdale, or activists like Samuel Gompers, Betty Friedan, Susan B. Anthony, or Martin Luther King, Jr. It would be hard to write a modern history book without sections on Washington, Jefferson, Lincoln, Eisenhower, and both Roosevelts.
Which eight did the Times choose? Let’s dig in:
Subscribe now
From the publisher's feed