
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Join Walter and Matt for today’s livestream of America This Week at 4 p.m. ET. We’ll be joined by News2Share’s Ford Fischer, who you know as the producer of our “Activism, Uncensored” series. Ford has been filming demonstrations in Minneapolis since Friday. He’ll tell us what he’s observed from activists and law enforcement.
Tune in on Substack, Rumble and YouTube:
Expressing support for a loony housing appointee, New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani became the latest politician to ratify a truly evil set of academic race theories
Narrated by Jared Moore
Art by Daniel Medina
Text published 01/07/25:
Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts
Listen to Episode 163
Matt Taibbi: All right. Welcome to American This Week. I’m Matt Taibbi.
Walter Kirn: And I’m Walter Kirn, talking at twice the speed because you did. Well, we’re trying to cram a lot of content in here. We’re trying to deliver more value to people. So the news of the day is that there is another shooting, not the first one that has taken place in Minnesota. And let’s get into some video. Let’s look at the first clip.
Matt Taibbi: Okay. So there’s that. That can be interpreted in a number of ways or it can’t. Why was
Walter Kirn: She parked Crosswise on the road?
Matt Taibbi: Well, this is part of the insight that I’m going to try to impart in a moment, but
Walter Kirn: It- Then I’ll just note that she was parked Crosswise on the road. On the icy road of Minnesota, which I’ve driven all through my youth, those
Matt Taibbi: Icy roads. So we’re basically consuming this as people do on the media, on social media. We’re getting disembodied bits of things and we don’t know what lots of things mean.
Walter Kirn: But we do know there was someone there with a camera ready to film it.
Matt Taibbi: Right. That was true. Yes. But why was she parked that way? Why was she being stopped? What’s the operation? Okay. All right. Let’s look at a slowed down version, which a lot of people have done. There’s been lots of meta analyses of this.
Walter Kirn: The guy in front got hit.
Matt Taibbi: The guy in front ... So that’s one of the problems with the video is that you don’t see the whole thing now. The third one, I think, shows that.
Walter Kirn: Well, that guy got brushed off the front
Matt Taibbi: Side bumper. On that side, you can sort of see that there’s a person in front of the car, right?
Walter Kirn: Yeah, I can see it clearly.
Matt Taibbi: Yeah. Okay. So everybody walls up off into different camps immediately about this. Let’s look at Jacob Frey. This is the mayor of Minneapolis who has stern words to say.
Jacob Frey: There’s little I can say again that’ll make this situation better, but I do have a message for our community, for our city, and I have a message for ICE. To ICE, get the fuck out of Minneapolis. We do not want you here. Your stated reason for being in this city is to create some kind of safety and you are doing exactly the opposite. People are being hurt. Families are being ripped apart. Long-term Minneapolis residents that have contributed so greatly to our city, to our culture, to our economy are being terrorized, and now somebody is dead.
Speaker 6: I’ve seen a lot of Republicans here in Washington criticizing those comments, saying that you’re escalating tensions with that. Can you respond to them? And what do you say to them tonight? People who criticize those comments.
Jacob Frey: I’m so sorry if I offended their Disney princess ears, but here’s the thing. If we’re talking about what’s inflammatory, on the one hand, you got someone who dropped an F-bomb, and on the other hand, you got someone who killed somebody else. F-bomb, killing somebody. I think the more inflammatory action is killing somebody. And so once again, let’s be real and just honest and straight up about what’s happening here. This is not okay.
Walter Kirn: This is idiocracy. That whole appeal to kind of basic locker room rhetoric, as far as I’m concerned, what an actor he is.
Matt Taibbi: Well, we’ll get to that in a second. Let’s get through all the different actors. Let’s see Kristi Noem
Kristi Noem: At 10:25 AM Central Time, immigration and customs enforcement were carrying out lawful operations here in Minneapolis. Because of the adverse weather that Minneapolis has seen in recent snow, one of the vehicles became stuck and ensnared in the snow. Law enforcement were attempting to push out this vehicle and when a mob of agitators that were harassing them all day began blocking them in, shouting at them and impeding law enforcement operations. ICE officers and agents approached the vehicle of the individual in question who was blocking the officers in with her vehicle, and she had been stalking and impeding their work all throughout the day. ICE agents repeatedly ordered her to get out of the car and to stop obstructing law enforcement, but she refused to obey their commands. She then proceeded to weaponize her vehicle, and she attempted to run a law enforcement officer over. This appears as an attempt to kill or to cause bodily harm to agents, an act of domestic terrorism.
The ICE officer fearing for his life and the other officers around him, and the safety of the public fired defensive shots. He used his training to save his own life and that of his colleagues. In fact, the very same officer who was attacked today had previously been dragged by an anti-ice rioter who had rammed him with a car and drug him back in June. He sustained injuries at that time as well. It’s very clear that this individual was harassing and impeding law enforcement operations. Our officer followed his training, did exactly what he’s been taught to do in that situation and took actions to defend himself and defend his fellow law enforcement officers. The officer was hit by the vehicle. She hit him. He went to the hospital. A doctor did treat him. He has been released, but he’s going to spend some time with his family.
Matt Taibbi: Okay. And then lastly, a tweet from Trump, I think this is number eight. This is Trump saying, “I’ve just viewed the clip of the event, which took place in Minneapolis, Minnesota. It is a horrible thing to watch. The woman screaming was obviously a professional agitator and the woman driving the car was very disorderly, obstructing and resisting, who then violently, willfully, and viciously ran over the ICE officer who seems to have shot her in self-defense. Based on the attached clip, it is hard to believe he is alive.”
Walter Kirn: That’s a bit of an exaggeration. He didn’t look like someone who had been maybe fatally injured.
Matt Taibbi: Yes. Right. It’s an exaggeration. It’s the President of the United States looking at a clip and responding to it. It’s to a degree, I think a lot of the other folks are doing the same thing. And I spent years of my life covering police brutality, incidents, shootings, stranglings. I don’t think there was a vehicular homicide or a vehicular attack incident, but there was such a wide range of these incidents. And the one constant in all of them is that the end picture never accords with what you think in the first moments.
Walter Kirn: What do you mean the end picture? You mean the results of an investigation never?
Matt Taibbi: When you finally get all the different facts in about what you’re looking at, which is usually a disembodied piece of video that circulates often because somebody on social media has got it, and in many cases, the actual media is only reporting on something that they’ve grabbed from social media. So you don’t always know what you’re looking at. You don’t always know what the person who filmed the scene was doing.
Walter Kirn: You don’t know what the expression on the face of the victim was, or it’s hard to know what was being screamed
Matt Taibbi: Either. What was being screamed, what was being said, what the situation was, but we’re in this world where everybody sort of goes to the mattresses immediately and takes sides and often they’re arguing about different things. So Jacob Frey talking about ICE, get the fuck out of Minneapolis. Now, if you want to argue about the ICE program, you can, but if you want to talk about the specific shooting, I think it’s prudent to wait a couple of days at least, or maybe even until there’s an indictment to find out all the different relevant
Walter Kirn: Matt, that’s so 1986.
America is exploding in protests in the wake of the ICE shooting of Renee Good, with people mostly falling into two camps. One side stresses Good’s reported role as an “ICE Watch” activist whose car blocked a road and appeared to hit the gas with an officer in front of her. Another stresses Good’s unarmed status and the fact that the ICE officer appeared to fire even after the threat passed, with many politicians already declaring the shooting a “murder” in “cold blood.”
The history of cases involving law enforcement shooting at moving cars is remarkably varied. A review of them, guided by interviews with experts and police, suggests a truth nobody wants to hear: both parties were not just in the wrong, but obviously so.
Pedro Serrano, now retired, was a long-serving New York City police officer, famous for honesty. His recording of an inspector’s instruction to target “male blacks, fourteen to twenty” in random street stops helped end the “Stop and Frisk” regime in New York City. Serrano loved the job and took pride in doing good police work, and he felt Stop-and-Frisk wasn’t that. His first observation about Renee Good was blunt.
“She should not have been there,” Serrano said. “If there’s a federal convoy and you’re trying to stop it, you’re breaking the law. When a cop pulls you over and says to get out the car and you don’t, you’re breaking the law. When you try to flee from a cop, you’re breaking the law. And when you try to run a cop over, you’re breaking the law. She shouldn’t have paid for it that way. But she was not right, in my opinion.”
The ICE officer, identified in reports as Jonathan Ross, also came in for serious criticism from Serrano. New York City officers, like officers in many big cities, are trained not to shoot at moving cars at all, unless there’s a direct threat to life. The ICE officer in Serrano’s view however violated a more fundamental rule.
“Someone trained this cop wrong,” he said. “He walked in front of the car. Never should you ever stand in front of a car. You don’t walk behind the trunk, because they put it in reverse, they crush you. In front, they put it in drive and run you over. Who’s going to win, you or the car? Not you. This guy, I think he was asking for it, like, ‘I dare you to try to run me over so I can shoot you.’”
His summation was brutal:
Subscribe now
When I was a kid, one of the coolest things was that every year, a few days before Christmas, our town’s fire department would drive through all the neighborhoods in its gleaming fire engine with the lights flashing, giving short bursts of the siren. All the firemen were in full gear hanging off the sides, while Santa, sitting at the top, threw candy canes to us all. The fire department was special, especially to the kids whose dads or uncles were volunteers.
These days, that truck may not be as shiny as it once was, as there are many trucks in service that should have been retired or kept only as backups because of how prone to failure they are. That’s what happened in Camden, NJ, in March 2024. From NJ.com:
Camden Fire Capt. Will Johnson and his crew arrived within five minutes in Engine 8, a battle-scarred, 21-year-old truck. Flames roared from the second-floor windows as firefighters rushed in, spraying water to try to save Shawn, 35.
But then the hose went limp. The red-and-white truck’s pump had failed, according to incident reports. About two and a half minutes passed, Johnson estimates, before water was restored.
Shawn did not make it. The captain wrote in a report that “we could not advance quickly enough to suppress a bulk of the fire or have an adequate primary search done to locate the victim.”
We don’t know if Shawn would have lived if the pumper truck had worked. But a 21-year-old pumper truck should not be on the front lines of service. The National Fire Protection Association recommends that trucks older than 15 years be relegated to a station’s reserve fleet and completely removed after 25 years.
Subscribe now
Los Angeles is a prime example of an aging fleet. The Los Angeles Times reports that as of last June, 60% of its 210 pumper trucks and 48% of its ladder trucks were operating beyond their recommended lifespans. During the Palisades fire, roughly 40 pumper trucks were in the shop; 70 percent of them were 15 years or older, including three built in I999.
“These aging and inoperable fire trucks have certainly harmed emergency responses and cost lives,” Edward Kelly, the president of the International Association of Fire Fighters union, said during a U.S. Senate hearing in September.
He cited an incident in Chicago last summer when a ladder on a reserve truck failed during a rescue. Firefighters had to restart the truck to raise the ladder. Four people died, including a five-year-old.
What the hell is going on?Lack of competition, for one. Three manufacturers have emerged in the last two decades to control 70% to 80% of the market, according to a federal lawsuit filed by the town of Newstead, NY.
One of the companies, REV Group, was created by a private equity firm, American Industrial Partners (AIP). It got into the fire apparatus business in 2008 with the purchase of E-One, a huge player in the industry, and proceeded to purchase six more companies over the next 12 years. It’s been quite successful for investors. AIP launched an IPO for Rev Group in 2017 and sold a portion of its stake in the company for $275 million, and then got out completely in 2024 by selling its remaining shares for $127.6 million.
But before cashing out, AIP’s purchase of so many manufacturers enabled Rev Group to join the companies Oshkosh and Rosenbauer as dominant players in the industry. As a result, the lawsuit argues they gained near monopolistic pricing powers.
Kelly, the union president, says costs have doubled in the past decade. Pumper trucks cost about $1 million; ladder trucks roughly $2 million. To make matters worse, Kelly testified that the price often changes after they’re ordered.
Manufacturers wield their market power to impose surprise price hikes after order placement through “floating” price terms. These price hikes exacerbate other budget constraints. Fire departments with budget challenges have had to cancel essential training and even lay off fire fighters.
Awesome Returns Bro!In 2025, REV Group’s stock price surged 93%, while Oshkosh rose 33%. Both companies outperformed the S&P 500, which increased 16.5% for the year.
In REV’s blowout third-quarter 2025 earnings call — a day in which its stock jumped 19% — CEO Mark Skanechnie stated:
Given the inventory levels we had on hand at the start of the quarter, along with the efforts of our supply chain team, we were able to mitigate a portion of the expected inflationary impacts related to tariffs within the third quarter, which resulted in delivering a 28% incremental margin year over year as compared to our prior guidance of twenty percent to 25% incremental margin for the 2025.
The increase [in incremental margin] versus last year was related to the continued demand for fire apparatus and ambulance units as well as pricing actions, partially offset by the benefit of the increased throughput mentioned earlier.
In other words, the floating price hikes weren’t completely tied to increased costs during production, which typically takes a year to 18 months, depending on the truck. A 28% incremental margin is generally considered outstanding for vehicle manufacturers.
Antitrust ComplaintsThe Newstead Fire Department filed its class action complaint on October 31 against REV Group, Oshkosh and Rosenbauer. From the complaint:
Beginning in or about January 2016, Manufacturing Defendants entered into an agreement, combination, or conspiracy to limit the supply, and to fix, raise, maintain, or stabilize prices of Fire Trucks sold in the United States at supra-competitive levels. As a result of the unlawful conduct of Defendants, Plaintiff and Class members paid artificially inflated prices for Fire Trucks and as a result have suffered antitrust injury in violation of the federal antitrust laws.
The result, the lawsuit argues, is inflated prices with long wait times that “have forced municipalities to keep older and less reliable Fire Trucks” or forced them to redirect funding to cover the higher costs.
This complaint came on the heels of a similar antitrust complaint that La Crosse, Wisconsin, filed in August against the three companies.
Rev Group, Oshkosh, and Rosenbauer told Reuters, “the company believes the suit is meritless and intends to challenge the allegations in court.”
Additionally, In April 2025 Senators Elizabeth Warren (D) and Senator Jim Banks (R) opened an investigation into this matter, making the following statement,
While CEOs and shareholders pad their pockets, consolidation in the industry impedes fire fighters’ ability to do their jobs safely and effectively, squeezes fire departments’ budgets, and forces taxpayers to bear the consequences. We have heard from dozens of fire departments in Massachusetts, Indiana, and elsewhere about difficulties they have faced related to serial roll-ups of fire truck manufacturers, including delivery delays, defective parts, and price increases… Private equity consolidation of fire truck manufacturers has led to higher costs and a nationwide shortage of fire trucks.
In response, Mike Virnig of The Rev Group told the New York Times that the industry has had a shortage in skilled labor and that it was affected by pandemic supply chain disruptions. The Times reports he also said a backlog resulted from a flood of orders that came with federal stimulus money.
Perhaps, but jacking up prices during production and bragging about a 28% incremental margin that resulted from doing that doesn’t instill confidence that everything is aboveboard. A year-over-year stock price increase of 93% probably does not represent a company struggling to meet its customers’ needs. It represents the market perception that REV Group has its customers over a very profitable barrel.
You can also listen to Eric Salzman discuss this topic on his podcast, “Monkey Business.”
Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support our work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Link Here: Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the Free Previews of America This Week:
Watch ATW on YouTube below:
Note to readers: This is the latest in an ongoing series about the Opioid Crisis by friend-of-Racket Matt Bivens, a full-time ER doctor (and an EMS 911 medical director) who also writes his own Substack at The 100 Days. Dr. Bivens is board-certified in emergency medicine and addiction medicine.
One of America’s most infamous corporate characters just made its final curtain call. The $7 billion bankruptcy deal approved over the holidays for Purdue Pharma and its billionaire owners, the Sackler family, includes compensation for individuals harmed by OxyContin® or other prescribed opioids: from $3,500 to $16,000 (before legal fees), available to anyone who filled out the right paperwork a long time ago and who promises not to sue. The payments might begin as soon as this March.
Purdue, with a new name (Knoa Pharma) and under new management, gets to re-dedicate itself now to treating opioid addiction. As an ER doctor also board-certified in addiction medicine, I’ve spent years reviving (or failing to revive) people who’ve overdosed on fentanyl or heroin or oxycodone, and who, more often then not, first got hooked on opioids via a prescription from a doctor.
I’ve also spent years commiserating with other doctors about how, back in the day, we were set up to fail our patients, thanks to a confused mishmash of nonsense about how no one gets addicted to modern opioid therapy anymore. Yet even today — after all of the multi-billion-dollar settlements and lawsuits, after hundreds of thousands of overdose deaths, after hearings and speeches in Congress — few people seem to really understand how coldly and methodically Purdue (and other opioid manufacturers, but especially Sackler-led Purdue) worked at getting people addicted. They focused in marketing and sales trainings on the need not just to convince doctors to start patients on opioids, but to keep them on opioids, and at the highest achievable doses.
As laid out in particularly withering detail in the Massachusetts and New York state lawsuits, Purdue had an opioid sales strategy for every American identity group with good insurance. They targeted the elderly, using “profiles of fake elderly patients, complete with staged photographs” to convince doctors to prescribe opioids. They targeted veterans — who, in my state of Massachusetts, are three times more likely to die of a drug overdose than non-veterans, but until that sad day also do have great insurance!
Purdue, both directly and through front organizations like the American Pain Foundation, even came up with the idea that getting addicted to OxyContin could be a form of feminist self-actualization. Under the heading “Empowerment — women,” notes from a marketing strategy session elaborate approvingly that the “empowerment angle can be used with any program.” And that wasn’t all:
Subscribe now
Last Thursday, a longtime tenant advocate named Cea Weaver was tabbed by new New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani to head a new “Office to Protect Tenants.” Mamdani had made holding bad landlords accountable a priority, and the appointment of his confidante Weaver along with a publicized visit to crumbling rental property underscored the commitment.
Then Weaver’s social media history became an issue. While the Bryn Mawr and NYU-educated Weaver disabled her X account, she didn’t act fast enough, as “Notes From the Front” author and Substacker Michelle Tandler grabbed screenshots. Tandler, a business world vet turned aggressive citizen journalist who cut her teeth documenting corruption and decay in San Francisco, wrote she “had a hunch” this summer that Weaver might get a position in Mamdani’s government, and set about archiving her statements. “She’s Chesa Boudin times a thousand,” an incredulous Tandler said today, referencing the oft-mocked former San Francisco District Attorney.
In one clip, Weaver talked about how “we” can “take over a lot of distressed housing,” and use legal processes to tell “scofflaw” landlords, “We’re gonna take this building away from you.” A video short that went viral showed Weaver talked about moving home ownership from an “individualized good” to a “collective good,” saying that “especially white families, but some POC families” are going to have to embrace a “different relationship to property” than “the one that we currently have”:
There aren’t many things more obnoxious than a housing official threatening to take your home for the crime of owning it. But she’s one person, and merely “controversial,” according to the New York Times. Gotham’s paper of record, which has seemed split internally on how to cover Mamdani, quoted former Deputy Mayor for Housing Vicki Been as saying Weaver is “very savvy, strategic. Ideologically driven, of course, but also practical.” Even the outgoing head of the “probusiness” Partnership for New York City, Kathleen Wylde, said Weaver was “not a lunatic” and “actually quite smart.”
After blowing off reporters for days, Mamdani issued a statement doubling down on Weaver:
We made the decision to have Cea Weaver serve as our executive director for the mayor’s office to protect tenants, to build on the work that she has done to protect tenants across the city, and we were already seeing the results of that work.
Mamdani continues to ignore media requests to clarify whether or not his office is opposed to home ownership. Mamdani said in the past his goal is to “move away from a situation where most people access housing by purchasing it” toward one in which the “state guarantees high-quality housing for all.”
That’s fine. The more serious issue is the continued employment of someone with abjectly racist ideas. Weaver has a spectacular, tinfoil-level fixation on white people. Among her deleted posts is a long list of racialist lunacies, from a call to “impoverish the white middle class” to claiming “homeownership is a weapon of white supremacy.”
The story is less about one housing official and more about a booming movement of sanctioned intellectual racism, as dangerous as anything a Nick Fuentes could cook up, because this race theory has so much institutional backing. It’s not the old conservative trope of “reverse racism,” but something much more ambitious, and worse, to say nothing of likely being illegal where publicly funded. It already has the attention of federal authorities.
“We are attacking it where we find it and it’s federally funded,” Assistant Attorney General for Civil Rights Harmeet Dhillon told us Wednesday.
What’s it? What ghoulish belief system inhabits the brains of people like Weaver and Zohran Mamdani? One can already hear the objections of the online left (“Really? This is what you focus on?”), but I’d be anxious to hear a defense of this open race theory, which would also be humorously nuts, if not for the fact that so many young people on the cusp of leadership believe it. Meet Whiteness as Property:
Subscribe now
Weaver hasn’t said where she got her ideas, but both she and Mamdani echo the same familiar language.
Some older Americans were surprised to learn after the Summer of Floyd in 2020 that “Whiteness Studies” had begun to be taught in Universities, and that its ideas were spreading thanks to books like White Fragility by onetime Whiteness Studies professor Robin DiAngelo.
DiAngelo and White Fragility have since been reduced to punchlines, but a more relevant text to the Weaver/Mamdani story is the 1993 Harvard Law Review essay “Whiteness as Property” by UCLA’s Cheryl Harris. In the reigning campus pseudo-religion this is still a sacred screed, if not the sacred screed, whose publication at the start of the Bill Clinton presidency is understood as a seminal event in the Great Awokening.
As you’ll hear below, activists and advocates for marginalized peoples faced a conundrum following the sixties liberation movements. Freedom from racist laws had been won at enormous cost in effort, money, and bloodshed, and with full legal desegregation came the demand that America live up to its Constitutional promises to all. As Martin Luther King put it, “All we say to America is, ‘Be true to what you said on paper.” This was in the before-times, when the idea that people are people was still considered a progressive conviction.
However, when the laws changed and progress did not come fast enough, activists now had to ask if all that effort in taking race out of the law didn’t perhaps need to be undone, so that goals could be achieved. In the video below Kimberle Crenshaw, the hallowed black feminist academic largely credited with the invention of intersectionality, describes the “contradiction” that paralyzed activists in the early nineties. If we need to take race into account, the thinking went, we’d have to navigate a path somewhere between white and black nationalism, the Klan or the Panthers:
In Crenshaw’s telling, the problem was activists asking the wrong questions. Forget small goals like desegregating schools and hospitals and the military, creating hiring incentives, eliminating barriers. If none of it dismantled “white racial power,” what was the point? It had to be considered that the Constitution itself, the very “paper” whose promises Martin Luther King so wanted to access, was itself a racial weapon, and needed to be “interrogated.”
How, though? It was going to be tough sledding to argue the American system was inherently racist after so many people sacrificed for so long with the professed aim of gaining entry to it. Unbeknownst to Crenshaw and other activist scholars, who “didn’t know Cheryl Harris yet,” the rhetorical solution was a “twinkle” in the eye of the Assistant Professor from the Chicago-Kent School of Law. It was called whiteness.
Most Americans, particularly liberal Americans, breeze by concepts like “whiteness studies” because they assume (in part because cynical politicians and pundits reassure them of it) that these disciplines are the merely necessary teaching of harsh historical reality, about everything from slavery to colonial conquest to Jim Crow, redlining, and race-based scams like the “contract mortgage.” But Whiteness Studies isn’t that, nor is Whiteness as Property.
Whiteness as Property is an amazingly creative document. It posits an elaborate Bible-like theology, with a story that traces a slice of history (but only a slice, as Harris was careful to point out when I contacted her) to tell of mankind’s journey from innocence to domination. While the world might once have been a raceless Eden, Americans ate of an apple called whiteness, after which its citizens discovered slavery, and in turn property — after which whiteness and property became synonymous with each other, and both with the “right to exclude.” An evil trinity, if you will.
Harris wrote that although the early American settlers were “cognizant” of race, the “racial lines were neither consistently nor sharply delineated among or within all social groups” in those early prerevolutionary days. However, the divisions soon became more defined, and “the construction of white identity” became “intimately tied to the evolution and expansion of the system of chattel slavery.” With slavery came that “merger of white identity and property.” Property remained whiteness and whiteness remained property, even after the Civil Rights movement:
After legalized segregation was overturned, whiteness as property evolved into a more modern form through the law’s ratification of the settled expectations of relative white privilege as a legitimate and natural baseline.
The Harris essay is a lot of window dressing on one idea, namely that America’s history of slavery and apartheid and other horrors is tied inextricably to the skin color of the perpetrators. The academic-sounding rhetorical device is that whiteness is synonymous with property. The simpler translation is that “whiteness” is just a stand-in for “white.” There’s no question that by “whiteness” Harris means white people. Harris even writes that “differential treatment of whites is not beyond constitutional concern” (thanks!) but to seek for them “an equivalent right to a level of review designed to protect groups and peoples subordinated by white supremacy” is to seek an “usurpation.”
I wrote to Harris, trying to frame things delicately. I couldn’t be the first person, I said, to have read her paper and wondered about the fact that people were property all over the world long before America existed, in almost every racial configuration: “whites enslaving whites, Indians enslaving Indians, Africans enslaving Africans, whites enslaving Africans, whites enslaving Native Americans, Romans enslaving pirates, pirates enslaving Romans, etc.”
Even during the time period in question, a white person in Russia could not only buy another white person but mortgage him. Property rights meanwhile went back thousands of years, beginning in nonwhite societies in Mesopotamia and Egypt, and then in white societies that both did and did not include slavery. How could whiteness, slavery, and property correlate, unless you excluded all that history?
By excluding all that history, naturally.
“I’m not able to really engage at the level you ask on this timeline, as I’m traveling out of the country,” Professor Harris wrote. “What I can say is that I was not making a global, trans-historic claim about race and property; I was writing about its formation in the context of US history and American law.”
Someone might want to tell Cea Weaver that texts like Whiteness is Property are not a “claim about race.” She and a hell of a lot of other people seem to be operating under the impression that whiteness means white.
Here’s what happens when something like Whiteness is Property becomes sacred writ on liberal arts campuses. It gets gobbled up by mentally ill white intellectuals, who can’t get enough of being told how inescapably guilty they are. The Harris essay in arguing against the idea of requiring proof of present-day discrimination even puts the term “innocent” in quotes, saying: “The inability to see affirmative action as more than a search for the ‘blameworthy’ among ‘innocent’ individuals is tied to the inability to see the property interest in whiteness.” For those slow on the draw, “the property interest in whiteness” is jargon for “the inherent guilt of white people.” This is irritation with the burden of proving bigotry in individual cases, when the important concept is collective racial guilt.
All racial movements devolve into caricatures, and this one has been no different, painting both white and nonwhite people with the broadest and dumbest of brushes. The racial justice theorist Tema Okun made a “white supremacy culture” poster that warns against “breathing in” those “poisons” of white culture like the written word, objectivity, individualism, and my favorite, perfectionism. Is there a nonwhite person alive who enjoys the implication of being a half-literate, biased communitarian with an increased tolerance for mediocrity?
All this goes back to the problems expressed by Crenshaw: how to justify using bias “for good,” and how to “interrogate” the Constitution as racist? If one can argue that private property is just white dominion, it’s not a big leap to indicting the whole catalogue of Englightenment virtues, from Mamdani’s denunciation of “rugged individualism” (the first entry on an infamous Smithsonian exhibit on “White Culture”) to puncutality to “family structure” to the “Protestant work ethic” and so on. No need to worry about expropriating homes of “innocent” people, since nobody’s innocent, except maybe Weaver’s “POC families,” who’ll of course eventually welcome the “different relationship to property,” nonwhites having less of a belief in “one right way.” Oops, is that a racist caricature? It is! And you can learn it in almost any federally-subsidized school.
Dhillon notes that many of the problems at taxpayer-funded universities that drummed up “whiteness” mania were presided over by the Department of Education. “When it closes down my department will have their civil rights investigation function,” she said. “We need to end this nonsense!”
What’s depressing is that all this fundamentally misunderstands how the Founders viewed “property.” Obviously, many were rich landowners and didn’t think much beyond that. But to James Madison, the idea of government existing to protect the “property” of even the non-wealthy was essential, and symbolic of the idea that government existed to respect and safeguard private rights to opinion or religious belief. “Conscience is the most sacred of all property,” he wrote.
I understand the tragic fact that so many Americans were long denied such protections, but what sane person sees taking them away now as a solution?
Recently author Eoin Higgins took to his Substack platform to complain, “Yes, I’m Being Sued by Matt Taibbi.” He wrote a book called Owned with a cover illustration showing marionette strings controlling people like me and Glenn Greenwald, the main subjects of his book, depicted me as “bought” by “tech billionaires on the right.” Though I’ve never taken any money from “tech billionaires on the right” and am entirely dependent on subscribers to this site, the suit was something Higgins felt needed celebrating.
Racket readers went through this when a member of congress called me a “serial sexual harrasser” last summer. Not wanting to pull a late-stage Lenny Bruce on a faithful audience the original plan was not to say anything. When The Free Press asked for a response, though, I gave one, published today. You can check it out if you like. One point left out is the main reason I felt I had to go to court.
Higgins somehow dismisses as an act of self-interest the key moment in my relationship with Elon Musk, when I refused to leave Substack and move to his new Twitter subs program. Elon was angry then about Substack’s new Notes feature, which he felt was an attempt to “kill Twitter,” so he began disabling Substack links not just for me but every Substack contributor, including ironically Eoin Higgins.
I would have done just about anything to keep working on the Twitter Files, but what Elon was asking — I still don’t think he understands this — would have looked like financial ties, which was enough undercut the reporting. I had no choice but to say no. When our exchanges were made public, these dynamics came out. Elon argued that if I moved to Twitter I’d “get far more subscribers,” but I still said no, because “people would essentially say I’m an employee of Twitter” and “both of us would never hear the end of it.” Also, the optics would be “really bad, journalistic ethics-wise.” Elon replied, “Then I guess it’s goodbye,” making clear I’d cut myself off:
If I’d been the marionetted mercenary Higgins and Hachette books claim I am, I’d have accepted Elon’s offer without a thought, put myself on Twitter subs, and kept cranking out Twitter Files stories. Instead I refused the inducement of “far more subscribers” to avoid the appearance of a financial relationship, and lost a great story because I was being asked to go to a place I felt I couldn’t go, “journalistic ethics-wise.”
This was a by-the-book example of what you have to do in such a situation, about which I consulted with older journalists. According to Higgins, though, it was motivated by greed. In Owned he writes that it was a “threat to Taibbi’s bottom line that finally motivated the journalist to act,” and I only protested the treatment of Substack because Musk was “threatening [my] subscription growth.” This makes no sense. Me staying at Substack was not an option for Elon. It was made clear there was only one way I could stay on that story, and I couldn’t do it, and that was that.
No one should get a medal for following basic standards, and I didn’t ask for one. However if for ethical reasons you have to give up a big story by standing up to a billionaire, it’s not a lot to ask that a major corporate publisher not subsequently describe you as a “bought” and “owned” puppet who literally sold his soul to that same billionaire. I didn’t make a big deal of this costly move because I think people should make decisions based only on whether or not they’re right, and not for credit, which means I was originally fine with people not noticing. But if you take advantage of that instinct to sell a book accusing me of bad ethics, what can I do but sue?
Higgins is having fun with this. He’s having a grand old time, laughing about smearing someone with corporate backing, and what a big joke it is that he should have to be careful with someone who’s “made no secret” of “ideological affiliation with the Republican Party.” Proof of the latter includes — this isn’t a joke — the fact that I once wrote a column called “Thanksgiving is Awesome” that made fun of Howard Zinn. These people are so nuts, they think you need a payoff to like Thanksgiving. They also think people with the wrong politics don’t deserve even the very low level of reputational care the law requires. This kind of person doesn’t care about being wrong, so courts are the only recourse. It sucks, but what else can you do?
From the publisher's feed