Racket News

Racket News

By Matt Taibbi
Download on the App Store

Racket News episodes

  • Listen to This Article: The Great Disappearing Trans Freakout

    The Supreme Court drives a stake in the transgender controversy, and neither party says much. Is this chapter in American politics headed for the dustbin of history?

    Narrated by Jared Moore

    Art by Daniel Medina

    Text published 06/20/25:

    Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app

    Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts

    13 min
  • Listen to This Article: Optimism, The Last Taboo

    Only in America can positivity be thoughtcrime.

    Narrated by Jared Moore

    Art by Daniel Medina

    Text published 06/18/25:

    Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app

    Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts

    Read more

    3 min
  • The SPAC is Back!
    Illustration by Daniel Medina

    Bloomberg News reported last week that Goldman Sachs, after a 2022 self-imposed ban, is getting back in the SPAC underwriting game.

    Back in 2021, as Fed monetary policy supercharged a speculative mania, SPACs were the poster children of markets gone wild. Goldman underwrote more than $16 billion of the product in 2021 as Wall Street pumped out more than $170 billion overall, led by Citigroup’s $22 billion.

    What is a SPAC?

    Our fearless leader Mr. Taibbi wrote about SPACs in 2021, and it’s a great read.

    Here’s a drier take.

    Special Purpose Acquisition Companies (SPACs), also referred to as Blank Check Companies, are registered investment products underwritten by the likes of Goldman. Managers of the SPAC raise money in an Initial Public Offering for the purpose of buying a company or companies within 18 to 24 months.

    Investors don’t know what the SPAC manager is going to buy, and sometimes they don’t even know the type of companies being sought.

    Racket News is reader-supported. Consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    One of the awesome things about SPACs in their heyday was that they were “regulatory arbitrage.

    What could possibly go wrong?

    This meant that SPACs’ sponsors and investment bankers faced far fewer disclosure requirements than a traditional IPO. After all, when the SPAC doesn’t know what it will be buying, there‘s nothing to disclose! The beauty of this was that once a target company was acquired, disclosures were still fairly light. The result was that SPACs were cheaper and faster to file and carried less liability for the underwriter.

    The Cost

    SPAC investors pay $10 a share.

    The sponsors of the SPAC pay a nominal amount, usually $25,000, to receive “founder shares,” which can be 20% of the entire deal. If the SPAC managers cannot find a company to purchase within the 18 or 24 months, the funds are returned to the investors. While the managers work on acquiring a company, investor funds are put in an interest-bearing account. If a purchase is consummated, the SPAC is “De-SPAC’d” and it becomes a new shiny public company.

    From a pure comedic standpoint, SPAC-Mania in 2020-2021 was fantastic. Everybody was sponsoring a SPAC. Such notable SPAC sponsors that the common folk could invest alongside included Alex Rodriguez, Shaq, Colin Kaepernick, Jay-Z and Serena Williams! There was even a SPAC Rap by Cassius Cuvee giving props to SPACs!

    It's ya boy Cassius Cuvée, you know I gotta give a shoutout to everybody in the SPAC game helpin’ me eat good these days, man it's crazy
    If you in the SPAC game you know what I'm talking about
    We sick of IPOs day 1 lockin’ us out
    My man Randy first told me Draft Kings would go public
    It's mergin' wit' a SPAC and the market gon' love it
    I'm like a SPAC, what's the hell's that?
    You get in on the ground floor
    It paid big, so I searched and then I found more
    Twitter put me up on game, well, at least most of it
    Then after Nikola merger hit, it was over wit’

    Feel the groove?

    I’m not sure where Cassius is these days, but if your SPAC De-SPAC’d, it probably performed horribly.

    Here is a nice chart of the now-defunct De-SPAC Index.

    Source: Bloomberg

    By far, the best SPAC attempt came in 2021 when Hong Kong investors teamed up with the owners of a small South Jersey sandwich shop, Your Hometown Deli, to launch a SPAC Deli!

    The Financial Times reported at the time that:

    Duke and Vanderbilt universities, two of the most prestigious seats of learning in the US, are among the biggest shareholders of a company that owns a single sandwich shop in New Jersey and has a stock market valuation of $100m despite recording just $13,976 in sales last year.

    The deli and the SPAC are both gone now.

    After standing by while more than $100 billion of SPACs were underwritten in less than a year, the SEC finally cracked down in late 2021 and took action to beef up disclosures and erase the “regulatory arbitrage,” driving Goldman’s public 2022 decision to exit the business.

    Why is Goldman getting back into the SPAC business?

    The first reason is relatively obvious. President Trump’s SEC has begun to roll back the stricter regulations imposed under former President Biden’s SEC chair, Gary Gensler.

    While nothing has been said regarding Gensler’s beefing up of SPAC disclosures, reversing them is probably high on Wall Street’s wishlist with the Trump administration. I would argue it is a bit discomfiting that a financial product’s production rises and falls with disclosure requirements.

    Wall Street is also eager to bring back the SPAC because the private equity deal machine is jammed up. The Wall Street Journal recently reported that private equity has about 30,000 unsold companies worth about $1.8 trillion that have been held for at least four years. PE has its own ecosystem, filled with investment bankers, lawyers, asset managers, asset lenders, structured product traders and salesmen and hedge fund managers relying on billions of dollars of fees every year. After all, the $300,000 exclusive country club fee, the beach house, ski lodge, and the kids’ ridiculous private school tuitions aren’t going to pay for themselves!

    A few weeks ago, we reported on PE’s drive to access the $12 trillion in Americans’ 401k funds to get the deal-making machine unstuck. Another way to get at retail money to buy the aforementioned PE company backlog is to bring back the SPAC. After all, this is what SPACs do. They buy private companies. Why not kill two birds with one stone? Investment banks like Goldman can start earning sorely-needed underwriting and M&A fees with SPACs while private equity companies looking to unload companies will now have an off-ramp frequented by retail investors.

    Who knows, maybe it will be different this time, but probably not.

    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support our work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    0 min
  • Divided America is Vulnerable in War

    American B-2 bombers struck three sites in Iran Saturday night, the denoument of a crisis triggered in late May, according to the New York Times:

    In late May, [Trump advisors saw] intelligence that made them concerned that Israel was going to move ahead with a major assault on Iran… And in the two weeks leading up to the Camp David meeting, Mr. Trump’s top advisers met multiple times to get on the same page about what the menu of potential options might be… Monday, June 9, Mr. Trump got on the phone with Mr. Netanyahu. The Israeli leader was unequivocal: The mission was a go.

    Mr. Netanyahu laid out his intentions at a high level, according to three people with knowledge of the call. He made clear that Israel had forces on the ground inside Iran. Mr. Trump was impressed by the ingenuity of the Israeli military planning… After he got off the call, he told advisers, “I think we might have to help him.”

    This is already a microcosmic example of everything you worry about with Donald Trump. No one boasts more about strength, and the importance of appearing strong, than Trump. Forget the cavalcade of roided-out wrestler types in his entourage, and remember what he said back in 1990 about the Chinese suppression of the Tiananmen revolt: “They were vicious, they were horrible, but they put it down with strength. That shows you the power of strength.” At times, he seems to follow his own advice, but now? When the baddest military on the block goes to war, it should go on its own timeline. We should never be blackmailed into escalation by a yapping-dog client state. Trump grasps this with Volodymyr Zelensky, an actor in a commando sweater. But he went weak in the knees around Bibi Netanyahu, and here we are.

    Realizing the situation is not about optics, the optics are nonetheless terrible. Trump last year ran on being “the only president in generations who didn’t start a war.” Along with a promise to immediately “stop all government censorship,” the idea that Trump Alone would wave off the hawks in the Pentagon and State Department who urge us into forever wars was central to his platform:

    Now the administration is acting like a coked-out version of the Bush White House, offering premature “mission accomplished” bromides after its porn-titled bomb run (“Midnight Hammer” might as well have been “Operation Throbbing Man-Shaft”). Defense chief Pete Hegseth boasted “American deterrence is back” before we had any idea if Iran planned to make good on its retaliatory threats, which Trump already promised would be “met with even greater force than what was unleashed today.” The possibility that all this will backfire and we’ll end up lashed to Israel in an “existential” forever-war of exactly the type Trump promised to reject is real.

    Trump made a tactical mistake, but the bigger problem is political. At a different time in our history (even Trump’s first term, when a decision to bomb Syria had everyone from Brian Williams to Van Jones orgasming over American military prowess), America’s consensus-building mechanisms would be working overtime to rally the population. Ostensible European allies, who have a bigger strategic interest than we do in this matter, would be doing the same. This would all add to pressure on Iran and make the gambit less likely to end in disaster. That moment is gone. Reactions to “Midnight Hammer” have been bonkers even by the standards of the Trump era. We may be a country that can no longer go to war for any reason without risking internal collapse. Is that a good thing? Maybe, maybe not:

    Subscribe now

    Read more

    0 min
  • ATW Livestream Today at 4 PM ET/3 PM CT

    Join Walter and Matt for another episode of ATW Live. They’ll dive into the events from over the weekend and continue with their book club pick, Joseph Heller’s Catch-22.

    Please tune in at 4:00 PM ET on Substack, Rumble, and YouTube:

    Or visit Matt or Walter on X.

    See you soon!

    0 min
  • Transcript - America This Week, June 20, 2025: "Israel, Iran, and Trump, by Popular Demand"

    Listen to Episode 138

    Matt Taibbi: Welcome to America this week. I’m Matt Taibbi.

    Walter Kirn: And I’m Walter Kirn.

    Matt Taibbi: Hey, Walter. How is it going? I’m sorry, I’m off. I’m in England, so my brain is on the wrong side of the road, I think is what’s going on but-

    Walter Kirn: Watch your mouth over there, man, and don’t tweet. Try not to pass on any memes. Keep your ideas to yourself.

    Matt Taibbi: Well, I was told this morning that that was a vastly exaggerated version of the situation and that I was not to harp on that.

    Walter Kirn: Oh, okay. In other words, shut up about people being shut up.

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah, exactly. Exactly.

    Walter Kirn: Okay. Well, I’m in Montana, land of the free. We’re approaching the 4th of July, which is what they call Cowboy Christmas. I live in a town which is particularly enchanted with fireworks and getting drunk and cowboys with big belt buckles and-

    Matt Taibbi: Awesome.

    Walter Kirn: Yeah. So anarchy is coming, and I am really happy about that because the world right now could use some pressure valves that don’t end in death.

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah. Maybe the whole world just needs a weekend of beer, fireworks and bare sex maybe. I don’t know. I’ve been trying to ... I heard that would chill everybody out. But Walter, you know what? We, on Monday, promised the audience that we would just do a deep dive. We would go all the way in. We would crawl up the very anus of the Iran-Iraq situation.

    Walter Kirn: No, Israel. Israel.

    Matt Taibbi: Right. Sorry. Israel-Iran situation.

    Walter Kirn: Right.

    Matt Taibbi: And so we will. We will leave no corpuscle unturned in this situation. I don’t know. There’s a lot of stuff to get to. The big theme in American media right now is MAGA rift. Apparently, war is not terribly important. The ostensible outcome of destabilizing the Middle East is not that important, but MAGA rift is very important, so we’re going to get to that. There’s a lot of amusing video on that score. But just to back up, for people who didn’t follow this story terribly closely, a week ago, at this time, Iran launched a series of coordinated attacks against-

    Walter Kirn: Israel did.

    Matt Taibbi: Sorry.

    Walter Kirn: I know. They all start with I, and they’re all equally far away.

    Matt Taibbi: You know what? Bud Trillin once wrote an article called Iran May Be Iraq. Did you read that?

    Walter Kirn: No.

    Matt Taibbi: I’ve done this ever since. Okay. So for those who haven’t followed the story, a week ago at this time, Israel launched a series of attacks, coordinated attacks against ostensibly Iran’s enrichment program, sites connected to it and ...

    Walter Kirn: And people connected to it.

    Matt Taibbi: And people connected to it. There was even a moment of what I would, I guess, call humor, although it’s very grim humor, where there was a television broadcast going on in an Iranian state TV in the middle of this, and right in the middle of proclaiming that bombs would never touch Iran because Allah is protecting them, the station got hit. So let’s take a look at that.

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah. I’m not sure that that’s the right translation. There’s one ... Apparently, what happened was that the anchor says bombs will not touch us because Allah is protecting us, and then 3.5 seconds later is when the bomb hits. I may have misunderstood that, but either way, that was part of what happened. Then there was the actual military operation, which apparently went rather well. Now this is important because the United States was hedging its bets publicly before the operation, and then there was this, sort of, wargasm that happened, similar to what happened after the shock and awe thing when suddenly there were people who thought, wow, that looks kind of awesome, and diplomats changed their mind. There was a lot of bomb cams from Israeli F-16s hitting targets. Can we take a look at those?

    Matt Taibbi: It’s got that, kind of, the ring feeling to it at the end with the static. And then, of course, Iran returned fire. There was carnage in Tel Aviv and Haifa, and quite a lot of footage going back and forth, and the exchanges have been going on ever since. Let’s take a look at some of the Israeli damage.

    Matt Taibbi: All right.

    Walter Kirn: Why was their music like that?

    Matt Taibbi: I don’t know. People on the internet, they want you to ... They’re multitasking. Maybe it’s like a rave, I don’t know, set to footage, war footage. Who knows?

    And then there was, on Monday ... Now, in between all this, there were various statements by Trump and by other people. Trump fully backed the Israeli action after those first four days then began speaking as if the United States would actually join in the attack. We had John Bolton rising from the dead to talk about how overthrowing the Ayatollahs was the only way out. He looked a little bit tumescent.

    And I don’t know, Walter, do you have any comment before we move on to the Tucker Carlson portion of the program? Because this was all touched off by an alleged real thing, which was, what was it, the international atomic energy ... or what’s the group? The IAEA basically said that Iran was in violation on ... I think it was last Thursday. So the Israelis attacked the next day.

    Walter Kirn: It was also the expiration of the 60-

    Matt Taibbi: Expiration of them.

    Walter Kirn: ... the 60-day deadline that Trump had given them to come to the negotiation table. I suppose he probably took that as a personal affront that they had blown him off for two months when he was offering them the olive branch, apparently.

    I think another thing we failed to mention was that it seems as though the general staff of Iran was wiped out in just a couple of days, including nuclear scientists, supposedly crucial to the program.

    So my impression after the first couple of days was that from the Israeli point of view, it had been a rousing success that they had ... The word decapitation kept being used, that-

    Matt Taibbi: Excellent word.

    Walter Kirn: Yeah, both literally and figuratively. It seemed the people behind the program, the top of the military, the head of the inner circle, Praetorian guard part of the government had been disposed of, and they had made great progress not just with the missile launchers but with various facilities.

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah, with three locations. Now there’s one they can’t get to without our help, and we’re going to get to that later.

    Walter Kirn: Right.

    Matt Taibbi: But apparently, they carried out an operation that they say was a big success. I think there were six top nuclear scientists that they were claiming were killed. If we could show number 18, which is Trump’s truth social, after this, basically saying Iran should have taken the deal. Now look at you. Look at you now. Right? This is his Tony Montana tweet. “Iran should have signed the deal I told them. What a shame and what a waste of human life. Simply stated, Iran cannot have a nuclear weapon. I said it over and over again. Everyone should immediately evacuate Tehran.” So now it’s essentially, we’re threatening to bomb Tehran, sort of, kind of, right?

    Walter Kirn: I didn’t necessarily read that as our threat to bomb Tehran, but his advice that Tehran was going to be bombed.

    Matt Taibbi: Okay. Yeah.

    Walter Kirn: This is a word to the wise and it has since been. Other facilities than nuclear, an oil refinery or an oil depot have been hit, and apparently, there’s no internet there and hasn’t been. I’m not sure if that’s because they turned it off or because Iran turned it off or because it’s been damaged.

    Matt Taibbi: There’s another report that the Iranian television has been taken over and that there is now something else being broadcast that maybe is being controlled by Israel. There are widespread reports of a big cyber attack. Okay. So this is all happening. It’s a revival of an issue that has come up periodically. Barack Obama, famously or infamously, depending on your point of view, came under tremendous criticism for making a deal with Iran once upon a time to, I guess, avoid the idea of Iran developing a nuclear bomb.

    Read more

    0 min
  • The Great Disappearing Trans Freakout

    From the New York Times, on the Supreme Court ruling affirming a Tennessee ban on surgeries or the prescription of puberty blockers for minors. Note the language:

    Here’s what else to know about the case, United States v. Skrmetti:

    The treatments: The law prohibits medical providers from prescribing puberty-delaying medication, offering hormone therapy or performing surgery to treat the psychological distress caused by incongruence between experienced gender and that assigned at birth.

    With the trans issue, even America’s ostensible paper of record has to speak in code, in its own pages. The Times couldn’t or wouldn’t use the word sex at the end of the above sentence, though it later used it appropriately when referring to a “federal policy requiring passports to reflect the sex on a person’s original birth certificate.” As if in protest, the paper swapped one preposterous bespoke language innovation (“sex assigned at birth”) for an even more nebulous and confusing one: “gender… assigned at birth.”

    I’m an aging cis male without gender-fluid children, so according to current formulas of mainstream discourse my opinion counts as about 1/19th of a person. Still, I’d like to offer a meager observation. No topic in recent history has been language-policed more thoroughly than this one (I have friends who still won’t return calls because I reviewed What is a Woman?). However, because the “Kamala is for They/Them, Trump is For You” commercial is widely credited with helping swing last year’s election, the usual Internet goon squads have gone mute of late, even after this week’s ruling. The Times even ran a think piece about the “new discomfort” yesterday.

    If we’re really at freakout’s end, let me be first to say, Ding, Dong, the Language-Policing Witch is Dead! This episode should be an object lesson in what happens when you try to tell people what they should think about things they can see with their own eyes, like a 6’4” biological male flashing the victory sign after double-lapping an NCAA pool full of bewildered young women. Awesome quantities of PR capital were expended denouncing those who booed as bigots. Still, the public wouldn’t budge, on that or related concerns, like the extant question of whether or not minors who can’t vote or drive have an absolute right to Lupron prescriptions. There were ways to talk sensibly and with sensitivity about all this, but no room was left to do so, and this is the result.

    Unfortunately, it’s already clear no lesson will be learned, as was also made clear in The Times this week:

    Subscribe now

    The modern version of the trans debate appeared as a scorching international controversy seemingly out of nowhere years ago. It was like opening your door to a seven foot stranger holding two huge theater trunks and asking to crash for a few years. Many in media were still in the not-wanting-to-be-rude phase of ideological engagement, and shrugged at a sudden cascade of op-eds and the addition of “T” at the end of LGB, assuming this was an extension of previous rainbow campaigns like gay marriage.

    I can’t have been alone in assuming I was (like Ice Cube) Down For Whatever, only to learn we were actually being asked to co-sign an extremely involved proposition built on stacks of extraordinary new assumptions. A 2018 directive by the American Academy of Pediatrics explained something called the Gender Affirming Care Model (GACM). At the time, my first child was five and probably would have identified as a brontosaurus if I’d asked (which I didn’t, in the apparently mistaken belief it was too early for that sort of thing). If you go to a pediatric dermatology conference, which by chance I did around that time, you’ll see slide after slide of retch-inducing skin conditions followed by doctor-lecturers shrugging and saying, “Eh, just do nothing” for initial treatment. The AAP however now said, seriously, that “watchful waiting” for gender-distressed children was the same thing as conversion therapy for gay adults! Waiting was called “reparative” therapy. The feelings of the six- or seven-year-old in distress were to be obeyed so absoutely that birth certificates were to be changed, to eliminate all bureaucratic memory of the assigned-at-birth ex-person. This all seemed pretty hardcore. Could we be reading it wrong?

    Nein! If you worked in media at this time you were constantly instructed not only in taxonomies of sexual identity more complex than German grammar, you were regularly told what parts of your vocabulary (and by extension, your being) were outdated and transphobic. Out of boredom years ago I started a bookmark folder called “Avoid the phrase…” to commemorate newly-exiled verbiage. It’s up to about sixty pages now. “Avoid the phrase sex change (see gender confirmation surgery below),” wrote GLAAD in one example, while the San Francisco Chronicle put readers in check with the headline, “Rejecting the use of ‘Latinx’ is Transphobic.” Another pamphlet helpfully advised, “Avoid the phrase ‘completed transition’ or any other language that implies that a transitioning person is ‘done,’ like a cinnamon roll in the oven.” Another suggested that in theoretical writing, “avoid only using old-fashioned ‘generic’ first names like Joe, Mary and Sue, which can sound singularly White.”

    All this was accompanied by a confident belief that sex “assigned at birth” could be unassigned through a combination of hormone therapy, surgery, and social encouragement, which sounded nice until a product of affirmation therapy competed on a track or in a pool against oldthinking anachronisms. Once they could see it, the American’s general tendency to want to be understanding, and live and let live, collapsed under the weight of so many radical asks.

    That should be clear by now, but isn’t. As the Court was preparing to hand down the ruling this week, the Times via Abundance author and podcaster Ezra Klein interviewed the “first openly trans member of Congress,” in a piece called, “Sarah McBride on Why the Left Lost on Trans Rights.” The discussion between Klein and the Delaware representative was jaw-dropping, both in its admissions about movement political tactics and the stance on Other People.

    In the most revealing exchange, Klein (in the tone of a person expecting to be hit with a rolled-up newspaper for asking) wondered about “re-thinking and self-recrimination,” in the context of the loss to Trump:

    I want to talk for a minute about the 2024 election and the aftermath. There’s been a lot of rethinking and self-recrimination among Democrats. One of the comments that got a lot of attention came right after the election when your colleague Seth Moulton, a Democratic congressman from Massachusetts, said: “Democrats spend way too much time trying not to offend anyone rather than being brutally honest about the challenges many Americans face. I have two little girls. I don’t want them getting run over on a playing field by a male or formerly male athlete, but as a Democrat I’m supposed to be afraid to say that.” What did you think when you heard that?

    Here, even Klein had to speak in code. By “got a lot of attention,” he meant, “Moulton was ruthlessly dogpiled as a Trump-loving Nazi bigot until he repented.” Moulton’s campaign manager Matt Chilliak resigned in protest after his remarks, adding on X, “Millions of Americans today showed that they hate immigrants and transgender people more than they fear fascism.” A Massachusetts Democrat vowed to put up a primary challenger to Moulton, calling him a “Nazi cooperator” in an email. Meanwhile, Moulton’s fellow Democrat Tom Suozzi was in the same boat after saying, “I don’t want to discriminate, but I don’t think biological boys should be playing in girls’ sports.” Left Voice denounced the “Democratic Transphobia” of both, writing, “One can see the cynical calculus: Would courting transphobic bigots yield more electoral victories than courting the exceedingly small transgender minority?”

    Moulton protested repeatedly that while “some of the, you know, woke left just wants to cancel me,” there was also “a good number of them who agree with me.” In the end, both members took so much flak for “transphobia” that they voted against a House measure barring the participation of biological men in women’s sports.

    This is what Klein really meant by “got a lot of attention.”

    McBride’s answer was wild:

    It wasn’t the language that I would use… The sports conversation is a good one because there is a big difference between banning trans young people from extracurricular programs consistent with their gender identity and recognizing that there’s room for nuance in this conversation. The notion that we created this “all-on” or “all-off” mentality, that you had to be perfect on trans rights across the board, use exactly the right language, and unless you do that, you are a bigot, you’re an enemy. When you create a binary all-on or all-off option for people, you’re going to have a lot of imperfect allies who are going to inevitably choose the all-off option.

    What ends up happening is the left excommunicates someone who not only — Seth voted against the ban on trans athletes, but we would excommunicate someone who uses imperfect language — yes, again, not language I would use. But we would excommunicate someone who’s saying that there’s nuance in this conversation and use this language that we don’t approve of — yet still votes “the right way”? That’s exactly what’s wrong with our approach.

    Translation: “So long as they bow to pressure on demand and ultimately vote the right way, we don’t have to excommunicate absolutely everyone guilty of ideological lapses.” When McBride said, “There’s room for nuance in this conversation,” what she meant, incredibly, is that a Democrat may temporarily express discomfort on the issue, provided he or she gets back in line in time to vote.

    Klein didn’t blink at the idea that people with a point of view differing from activists are “imperfect” human beings, nor was there any embarrassment or regret about the idea of “excommunicating” people from something other than a church. That means no apologies to Canadian Dr. Kenneth Zucker after he was fired and denounced as a conversion therapist for suggesting occasional “Watchful waiting,” or to biologist Colin Wright after he was tossed from PayPal or Etsy for selling “Reality’s Last Stand” merch, or to any of the folks who were dismissed or reprimanded for putting a signature on the Harper’s Free Speech Letter with J.K. Rowling and fifty other people. As for admitting the possibility of actual wrongness (as opposed to political error), on any of these issues, that remains competely and utterly excluded. I lost another friend over the Shrier review because I’d “fallen for” Shrier’s premise that this era saw an explosion of interest in transition among young girls. When the British government commissioned a study into the causes of this “surge,” Shrier should have been vindicated, but her “social contagion” thesis was considered so ideologically abhorrent it could not possibly be right, no matter what the numbers said.

    This issue from the start has been been presented as a single battle over “transgender rights” as opposed to what it was, a diverse list of wildly varying new demands. There’s a huge difference between denying an adult the right to transition and putting men with penises in women’s prisons. There’s also a big difference between opposing housing or employment discrimination against transgender adults and demanding the use of terms like “birthing persons.” Society was asked to accept all changes at once, and when voters said no to some, like eliminating the concept of “biological sex,” they were the ones deemed “imperfect,” not the activists who overshot the mark.

    The Boston Globe in March took the (for them) extraordinary step of asking if Moulton was owed an apology “now that so many publicly agree.” McBride and the Times got halfway to yes this week. The full concession, to Moulton, will come eventually. The rest of the country, meaning those who aren’t Democratic members of Congress, will have to wait longer. In a true culture war, it can take a long time to get to sorry, and an even longer time to take ownership of damage done to your own cause.

    0 min

About Racket News

From the publisher's feed

Regular news and features by award-winning author and investigative reporter, Matt Taibbi.