Racket News

Racket News

By Matt Taibbi
Download on the App Store

Racket News episodes

  • Listen to This Article - Take the NPR "That's Not Funny!" Challenge

    NPR's advice to parents concerned their children may become incel murderers? Keep them away from jokes

    Text published 04/08/25:

    Narrated by Jared Moore

    Art by Daniel Medina

    Listen to subscriber only audio in your podcast app

    Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts

    Read more

    3 min
  • Timeline: Panama Canal Politics, Policy, and Tensions
    Illustration by Daniel Medina

    While the trade war with China plays out, another war of political rhetoric is heating up again over the Panama Canal.

    Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth was in Panama this week, and pointed out America’s military presence and joint training exercises with Panamanians. Though he said the U.S. doesn’t seek war and that “war with China is certainly not inevitable,” he had a strong military message for the CCP:

    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    Our relationship is growing in part to meet communist China's rising challenge. China-based companies continue to control critical infrastructure in the canal area that gives China the potential to conduct surveillance activities across Panama. This makes Panama and the United States less secure, less prosperous, and less sovereign.

    He said “China will not weaponize this canal,” and it will stay that way “through the deterrent power of the strongest, most effective, and most lethal fighting force in the world.”

    Hegseth followed up Wednesday with a similar message to the Central American Security Conference.

    The era of capitulating to coercion by the communist Chinese is over. They're growing an adversarial control of strategic land and critical infrastructure in this hemisphere cannot and will not stand. To accomplish this, our countries cannot face these shared threats alone. We have to face them together. America will confront, will deter, and if necessary defeat these threats alongside all of you, our close and valued partners. Our mission is simple: achieve peace through strength through an America first approach. We're doing this by restoring the warrior ethos, rebuilding our military and reestablishing deterrence.

    Obviously, that didn’t go over well with China. Its embassy in Panama accuses the U.S. of hypocrisy as it “repeats ad nauseam the ‘Chinese interference and influence.’” It noted the U.S. invaded Panama in 1989 and asked: “Who represents the real threat to the Channel? People will make their own judgment.”

    (In making that judgment, a reminder that the U.S. still controlled the Panama Canal in 1989, and Panama was run by dictator Manuel Noriega who had been indicted in the U.S. on drug crimes. He was also a former CIA informant, and American officials knew about his crimes — which included helping Pablo Escobar — for years before doing anything about it).

    China’s influence over the Canal has grown since 2017, when Panama severed ties with Taiwan and established diplomatic relations with China. A Chinese company controls the largest port on the Atlantic side of the Canal, and a Hong Kong company, CK Hutchinson, controls ports on both ends of the Canal. Last month, BlackRock, an American investment firm, reached a deal to buy CK Hutchinson’s ports, but that deal could be in jeopardy of falling through. Chinese firms are also building a bridge across the Canal.

    President Trump has said the U.S. should have never given up the canal to Panama, which occurred on Dec. 31, 1999, as agreed to in treaties that President Carter signed in 1977 and won Senate approval the following year.

    While critics place a lot of blame on Carter, Presidents Nixon and Ford started the negotiations. There was bipartisan support to reach a deal (there was even a tentative deal in place in 1967, but a coup in Panama ended those negotiations) because there were tensions and sometimes violence between locals and Americans. The audio below is from a 1976 NBC story that describes life inside the barbed wire fence that surrounded the Canal Zone: “Its 40,000 American residents, both military and civilian, enjoy a suburban lifestyle.” Panamanians on the other side of the fence were resentful.

    Ronald Reagan changed the political debate over the Canal during his primary challenge to Ford in 1976. Opposition to any deal with Panama became the focus of his campaign. Reagan says in the ad below: “We bought it, we paid for it, and General Torrijos (Panama’s dictator) should be told we’re going to keep it.”

    The message was effective. Reagan won 24 states, and Ford didn’t secure the GOP nomination until the Republican National Convention.

    Today’s debate over the Panama Canal

    The Panama Canal was not a campaign issue in 2024. Trump first complained about passage rates charged to the Navy and U.S. shipping companies in two December 21 social media posts. Trump wrote that if the situation does not improve, “we will demand that the Panama Canal be returned to us, in full, and without question. To the Officials of Panama, please be guided accordingly!”

    He repeated those criticisms and threats in a speech the following day:

    It was not given for the benefit of others by a token of cooperation, but it was given to Panama and to the people of Panama, but it has provisions. You gotta treat us fairly, and they haven’t treated us fairly. If the principles, both moral and legal, of this magnanimous gesture of giving are not followed, then we demand that the Panama Canal be returned to the United States of America in full, quickly and without question.

    Congresswoman Debbie Wasserman Schultz called that “preposterous.” House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries also dismissed the idea of regaining control of the Panama Canal.

    But Democratic Congressman Jared Moskowitz said Trump has a point. He dismissed the idea of taking the Canal by force, but said “the United States reasserting its history in the Panama Canal is actually a good, important, strategic issue.”

    At a hearing in January, Senate Commerce Committee Chairman Ted Cruz voiced concern about the bridge that Chinese firms are building across the Canal.

    The partially-completed bridge gives China the ability to block the Canal without warning, and the ports give China ready observation posts to time that action. This situation poses acute risks to U.S. national security.

    A witness at that hearing, George Mason international law professor Eugene Kontorovich, testified that the presence of a Chinese company essentially means the Chinese military has a presence in the Canal.

    In a communist regime, distinctions between private and government-owned firms are not as absolute or clear-cut as in a Western liberal society. This is particularly the case for the People’s Republic of China (PRC), which has an official doctrine known as “Military-Civilian Fusion,” a top-level strategy of the CCP Central Committee since 2019.

    Here’s a timeline of key events in the history of the Panama Canal leading up to this week’s speeches from Hegseth.

    January 22, 1903

    The U.S. and Colombia, which controlled what is now Panama, agree to a treaty that gives the U.S. rights to the land to build the Canal in return for $10 million and $250,000 annually. However, Colombia’s congress rejects the deal.

    November 3, 1903

    With the backing of the U.S., Panama declares its independence from Colombia.

    November 18, 1903

    The U.S. and Panama sign the Hay-Bunau-Varilla Treaty, which establishes the Panama Canal Zone and “grants to the United States all the rights, power and authority within the zone.” The treaty has the same financial terms that Colombia’s Congress rejected. It’s ratified by the Senate and approved by President Theodore Roosevelt in February 1904.

    1903hay Bunau Varilla Treaty39.7KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload

    Construction begins in 1904. About 5,600 lives are lost by the time the Canal is completed a decade later.

    August 15, 1914

    The Panama Canal opens to shipping.

    January 9, 1964

    Panamanian rioters invade the Canal Zone and attempt to substitute the U.S. flag with a Panamanian one. The riots last three days, killing 22 Panamanians and four U.S. troops.

    September 7, 1977

    President Jimmy Carter and Panamanian dictator Omar Torrijos sign the Torrijos-Carter Treaties. Panama will take control of the Canal on Dec. 31, 1999. President Carter says:

    This agreement thus forms a new partnership to ensure that this vital waterway, so important to all of us, will continue to be well-operated, safe, and open to shipping by all nations now and in the future. Under these accords, Panama will play an increasingly important role in the operation and defense of the Canal during the next 23 years, and after that, the United States will still be able to counter any threat to the Canal’s neutrality and openness for use.

    Volume 1280 I 21086 English460KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadNeutrality Treaty17.8KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadDecember 31, 1999

    Panama gains control of the Canal. Army Secretary Louis Caldera, the head of the U.S. delegation at the handover ceremony, says:

    The United States could not aspire to be a good neighbor to Latin America and continue occupying and dividing the territory of a country considered a friend.


    December 21, 2024

    On Truth Social, President-elect Trump slams Panama for charging the United States “exorbitant prices and rates of passage” to use the Canal. He claims that China is influencing the canal’s management, before adding, “This complete ‘rip-off’ of our Country will immediately stop.”

    In a follow-up post, Trump adds:


    December 22, 2024

    While delivering a speech in Phoenix, Trump asks, “Has anyone ever heard of the Panama Canal? Because we're being ripped off at the Panama Canal like we're being ripped off everywhere else.”

    When an audience member suggests taking back the Canal, Trump responds, “That’s a good idea.”

    Panamanian President Jose Raul Mulino responds to Trump in a video he posts on X:

    Mulino also issues a written statement, citing the Torrijos-Carter Treaties: “Every square meter of the Panama Canal and its adjacent area belong to PANAMA, and will continue to be. The sovereignty and independence of our country are not negotiable.”

    He adds that passage rates are determined by “market conditions, international competition, operating costs and the maintenance and modernization needs of the interoceanic waterway,” and insists upon the Canal’s “permanent neutrality” and “open and safe operation for all nations.” He also rejects the notion that China wields any special influence over the Canal: “The Canal has no direct or indirect control from China, nor the European Union, nor the United States or any other power.”

    Trump’s response:

    Trump also shares an AI-generated image with the following caption:

    December 23, 2024

    Panamanian protesters gather outside the U.S. embassy to protest Trump.

    Among the chants: “Get out invading gringo” and “Trump, animal, leave the Canal alone.”

    They burn an American flag and set fire to an image of Trump.

    “Donald Trump and his imperial delusion cannot claim even a single centimeter of land in Panama,” says one protester.

    December 25, 2024

    Trump posts the following Christmas message:

    Minutes later, he announces that Miami-Dade County Commissioner Kevin Marino Cabrera will serve as the next U.S. ambassador to Panama, “a Country that is ripping us off on the Panama Canal, far beyond their wildest dreams.”

    December 26, 2024

    Panamian President Murino holds a press conference to send a message to Trump that the Canal is not for sale.

    The Canal is Panamanian and belongs to Panamanians. There's no possibility of opening any kind of conversation around this reality, which has cost the country blood, sweat and tears.

    He also denies Trump’s claim that the Chinese military has any presence in the Canal, saying, “There are no Chinese soldiers in the Canal, for the love of God.”

    January 7, 2025

    During a press conference at Mar-a-Lago, Trump refuses to rule out using military force to acquire the Panama Canal. He claims that it was “built for our military” and “is vital to our country.” He once again argues that the Canal is “being operated by China.”

    January 9, 2025

    Republican Congressman Dusty Johnson of South Dakota introduces the Panama Canal Repurchase Act of 2025, which authorizes the President and the Secretary of State to “initiate and conduct negotiations with appropriate counterparts of the Government of the Republic of Panama to reacquire the Panama Canal.”

    Bills 119hr283ih226KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadJanuary 10, 2025

    Panama Canal Administrator Ricaurte Vásquez tells the Associated Press that the Canal cannot charge lower rates to U.S. ships. He speaks of his desire to “maintain the established rules,” insists that the Canal is a neutral economic zone, and says that the Chinese companies operating in its ports have no special influence over how the Canal is run.

    January 20, 2025

    During his inauguration address, President Trump describes how “American ships [that use the Panama Canal] are being severely overcharged and not treated fairly in any way, shape, or form.” He repeats his assertion that China controls the Canal and closes with the following: “We gave it to Panama, and we’re taking it back.”

    Trump’s comments prompt another statement from Mulino in which he says, “The Canal was not a concession from anyone.”

    Panama also sends the statement to the U.N. Security Council.

    February 2, 2025

    Secretary of State Marco Rubio arrives in Panama City to meet with Mulino.

    Mulino attempts to assuage Rubio’s concerns about Chinese influence by announcing that Panama would allow its membership in China’s Belt and Road Initiative to expire. He also vows to allow more U.S. investments in Panama.

    Later that day, Trump reiterates his interest in obtaining the Canal. He tells reporters that “something very powerful is going to happen” if Panama does not cede control over the waterway.

    Secretary of State Rubio is in Panama right now, and we're talking about the Panama Canal. What they've done is terrible. They violated the agreement. They're not allowed to violate the agreement.

    China is running the Panama Canal. That was not given to China; that was given to Panama, foolishly. But they violated the agreement, and we're going to take it back, or something very powerful is going to happen.


    March 4, 2025

    A consortium led by BlackRock announces that it will purchase CK Hutchison’s holdings in the Panama Ports Company, which owns and operates two ports on each side of the canal. CK Hutchison is owned by Hong Kong billionaire Li Ka-shing, and it reportedly felt “political pressure to exit the ports business.” The deal is worth over $19 billion.

    Trump references the deal during his address to the joint session of Congress that evening (1:19:50 of the video below).

    [The Panama Canal] was given away by the Carter administration for one dollar, but that agreement has been violated very severely. We didn’t give it to China. We gave it to Panama, and we’re taking it back.

    March 5, 2025

    In an X post, Mulino denies Trump’s implication that the BlackRock deal lays the groundwork for a U.S. takeover of the Canal. He accuses Trump of lying.

    March 13, 2025

    NBC News reports that the Trump administration plans to bolster the U.S. military presence in Panama. Military officials tell NBC that, while the goal is to eventually reclaim control over the Canal, a U.S. invasion remains unlikely.

    March 20, 2025

    The Chinese government threatens to block CK Hutchison from selling its controlling interest in the two Panama Canal ports to BlackRock.

    April 7, 2025

    A Panamanian government investigation finds that CK Hutchison owes the country’s government over $300 million in fees because it did not properly renew its contract to operate its two ports along the Canal. This development has the potential to delay or even jeopardize the company’s deal with BlackRock.

    Later that night, Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth arrives in Panama. He will speak at the reopening of an American port and address the Central American Security Conference. He is the first secretary of defense to visit Panama in two decades.

    April 8, 2025

    Hegseth meets with Mulino and Panama Canal Authority Administrator Ricaurte Vazquez.

    They release a joint statement that says they agree to “strengthen bilateral Canal security cooperation,” guarantee “the expedited transit of warships and auxiliary vessels of the Republic of Panama and the United States, improve bilateral cyber cooperation,” and allocate Army Corps of Engineers resources towards ensuring the Canal’s sustainability. They also announce that they will move toward adopting a new mechanism for U.S. payment of Canal tolls and charges. The Defense Secretary praises Mulino for withdrawing Panama from the Belt and Road Initiative.

    Panama’s version of their joint statement includes an additional detail: It says that Hegseth “recognized Panama's leadership and inalienable sovereignty over the Panama Canal and its adjacent areas.”

    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    0 min
  • Take the NPR "That's Not Funny!" Challenge
    Keir Starmer wasn’t sure if “Adolescence” was a documentary, but wants all secondary school students to see whatever it is

    NPR, during a 23-minute piece about “What to Tell Your Kids About Online Extremism,” on learning “the signs of radicalization”:

    It’s really important to know when your kid might be falling down the rabbit hole… [“Radicalization” consultant Christine] Saxman told me to really keep an eye out for the kinds of jokes your kids are reacting to and making. Be particularly aware if they are beginning to engage with humor that dehumanizes others, in particular gay, transphobic and sexist jokes. Disguised as humor, it gives people with racist agendas plausible deniability, because it's “just” a joke.

    Originally published in 2022, the NPR story was just updated and pegged to news about the Netflix series Adolescence. It’s a spiffily-directed horror series starring the excellent Stephen Graham about an angelic British boy moved to savage knife crime by “violent misogyny” online. Adolescence is the 2020s version of The Day After, a scared-straight parable about the dangers of relaxed vigilance, though the enemy is Andrew Tate instead of Soviet bombers. A thrilled Keir Starmer not only launched an initiative to make the series free for every secondary school in the U.K., but put out a video endorsement that employs the signature one-shot technique of Adolescence as he brings the series creators on a tour through Downing Street. A spoof of the same technique using Martin Scorcese’s Copacabana scene and a Crystals soundtrack would have been much funnier (“Every time I come here, every time you two!” Starmer could have shouted at Morgan McSweeney and Rachel Reeves on the way in), but Starmer wouldn’t have seen the irony in the mafia-Downing street comp and was obviously more interested in a Fangrrling Adolescence tribute.

    The basic math of “dehumanizing” comedy has been proven a billion times over by now, but somehow it still needs to be said. If such humor is allowed to spread, it is true: Don Rickles or a modern equivalent will occasionally guest star on television and may even influence a few people to think ethnic jokes are funny. If on the other hand such material is suppressed, Don Rickles gets elected to the White House. It’s comedy’s iron law, but you’d never know it, listening to NPR extol the virtues of Keir Starmertainment:

    Subscribe now

    Adolescence is said to have amassed over 66 million views since it launched last month. It’s exceedingly well acted and choreographed, but the plot is a snuff film, in which you suffer the emotional torture of watching Parents Who Could Be You realize in slowest motion that their Beautiful Child Who Could Be Yours has ruined his own life and another’s, after being captured by online influence. The story moves like a thriller and the pace is electric, but there is no mystery to solve, nor is it pushing us toward emotional salvation in forgiveness or humility. The pain, and the avoidable nature of the crime, is the whole point. It’s inspired headlines about women being afraid to have kids, “especially boys,” along with numerous columns of the “As a Mum, Adolescence helped me see my son’s potential for knife murder” variety.

    This could be you is the series message, one NPR embraced by retooling a story they’d naturally already run about moms being afraid of their white sons. Remember Ruth Whippman, the involuntary humorist and New York Times columnist who penned the book-length woke-Rosemary’s Baby tale Boymom, complete with passages like, “I was frightened [for] the tiny piece of patriarchy growing inside me”? Whippman told New York Times readers last summer “We Can Do Better Than ‘Positive Masculinity,’” challenging parents of boys to “ditch the masculinity rhetoric altogether.” I thought she was one of a kind, but it turns out “Only Vigilance Stops My White Sons From Becoming Monsters” has been done more than once in American media. NPR reporter Hardymon works in this vein, describing the fear inherent in being the mom of two white boys:

    This is NPR’s LIFE KIT. I’m Barrie Hardymon… I am the parent of two kids, and there’s something that creeps into my consciousness every time I see another tragedy like the kind of racist shootings we’ve seen in El Paso, Christchurch, Buffalo. The criminal is almost always a young white man. I am raising two young white men. It’s a horror — right? — to think that your kid could be a victim. It's a whole different kind of fear to think that your kid could be — I almost don't want to say it out loud — a perpetrator, a racist, a sexist, a bigot, somebody who could even be susceptible to these ideas…

    There are many crazy things about this introduction, beginning with the premise that “the criminal is almost always a young white man.” That’s true if you’re describing that set of mass killings, meaning the type covered heavily in places like NPR. It should be a basic tenet of media that browsing choices (and strategies of algorithms designed to bullseye your fear centers) impact your perception of the frequency of social phenomena. It’s particularly weird for reporters to miss this given how much attention NPR has always paid to, say, “news media over-reporting violent crime.” Mass shooters are indeed almost exclusively male but not particularly distinguished by race, a bummer overall but reassuring if you believe people are pretty much the same across ethnicities. Some parents don’t seem anxious to be reassured on that front, however.

    Selecting media stories likely to upset you and then making political cause of your (predictably horrified) reaction isn’t limited to scared mothers. Starmer decided to proselytize the Adolescence message about the dangers of “Andrew Tate shite” across Albion while clearly conscious he was marketing drama as documentary. The PM would be a terrible poker player: he doubles and triples his umms and uhhs whenever he’s about to aggressively bullshit audiences. He twice broke out in tics and tells before saying things about Adolescence like “it’s a very very good uh uh documentary to watch, or drama,” or “the documentary, the drama umm umm”:

    He also talked about how boys are the culprit in “this particular instance,” as if it were a real story, adding, “This violence carried out by young men who are influenced by what they see online is a real problem, it’s abhorrent,” and “a matter of culture.” That last line is where he went off the rails. By culture, Starmer means the incel “shite” only. This is odd because no one should know better than American, French, and British citizens that violence carried out by “young men who are influenced by what they see online” is a universal problem, though this of course is a big reason Adolescence has become so controversial.

    When Islamists in 2015 shot up an office full of Charlie Hebdo cartoonists and journalists, Western intellectuals quickly bailed on Western speech values and turned to a “Je Ne Suis Pas Charlie” campaign, condemning French satirists for bringing the crime on themselves. The violence of those 17 murders too was “a matter of culture,” but neoliberal pols decided the guilty culture there was their own, and began moving toward anti-blasphemy laws of the type seen in Saudi Arabia and Bangladesh. Denmark banned desecration of the Koran in 2023, and Starmer two years ago supported a similar anti-blasphemy law in the runup to Britain’s Islamophobia Awareness Month.

    I don’t believe the state needs to intercede in the other direction, but the EU parliament long ago said Britain had the “greatest problem” with Islamist honor attacks and killings, with British police statistics showing the number of honor offenses has risen 81% since 2016. It’s still not clear what the motivation was of Southport attacker Axel Rudakubana, convicted of murdering three young girls with a knife last year, in assaults that started riots. It’s not hard to see why there might be an uproar about a Prime Minister suggesting a Netflix horror series about a fictional Tate-inspired crime spoke to the “real problem,” while other British officials cry out for more “guardrails” to protect their youth. It’s fully in character with a country that innovated the modern moral panic with the lunatic mod-rocker scare of the sixties.

    None of this is as idiotic as the American tendency to focus on humor as the gateway drug to violence, as exemplified by NPR. American liberalism was once adamant about the folly of blaming culture for crime. Republicans were ridiculed for pointing a finger at Marilyn Manson after the 1999 Columbine massacre. Michael Moore’s Bowling for Columbine interview of a Lockheed exec standing before a giant missile and saying “I don’t see that connection” when asked if a weapons-building culture might move kids toward violence more than a rock star in glam makeup, was typical of how the left once viewed the issue. The Harold and Kumar movies commemorated the eternal truth that nothing made you want to get high more than “gateway drug” commercials:

    This was the standard attitude among Boomer Dems for decades, but something around 2016 caused a mass permissiveness-pucker. In the NPR piece, Hardymon engages with Christine Saxman, who is introduced via the dulcet tones of an NPR saxophone riff as someone who’s been doing “social justice facilitation” for about 20 years, and will walk us through an episode about “preventing radicalization of white children.” Hoping the guest will agree, Hardymon tells Saxman “I’ve covered some extremism, and so I know that, like, humor is often a way that people are sort of sucked in.” Saxman concurs: yes, “honestly, some of the intro points are the joking around LGBT issues.”

    The two joke-phobics go on to speculate on when is the right moment to jump in when conducting surveillance of your nascent killer-spawn. Saxman warns against something she calls “the underreaction”:

    SAXMAN: I also don’t want to be like, if they’re starting to show overt hate, be like, “Boys will be boys. This is just them joking around, right?” That’s the underreaction.

    HARDYMON: Let’s say you — on that scale, right? — you had noticed that your kid has come to a place where he does have some harmful beliefs… Even if it’s not all the way at the scale of violence, but you notice that he thinks Hitler mustaches are funny. He thinks, you know, that he’s expressing himself. You see him slipping down that rabbit hole. What do you do?

    It’s universally acknowledged (there was a unanimous U.N. Security Council resolution about this in 1947) that Hitler mustaches are funny. It may be the only mandatory joke in the world, especially for Jewish comedians. The clear sign you have a young man on the wrong path is when he doesn’t find Hitler’s mustache funny, which probably can only happen in rare situations, one of which has to include a mother watching him constantly for signs of improper levity. I made this reel and couldn’t get through the first cut without laughing:

    Hardymon asks, “Is there a script I can give the kids that they can feel empowered to talk to [friends] about it? What are the actions we can help them take with their friends, with their peers?” Saxman initially answers, “I don’t think adults need to be policing every single problematic conversation that young people have,” which seems encouraging, but adds: “That’s part of being a young person, is learning how to do that yourself.” In other words, you can’t snitch out the bad influences in your child’s life, but with love and guidance, they’ll learn to do it themselves.

    Hardymon explains how torn she is about certain questions (“I hear, you are making a terrible decision about your young men,” she says, “Why are you letting them play with Nerf guns?”), while discussing proper “daily anti-radicalization hygiene” and how to avoid “normalizing” humor that acts as a rhetorical “stepping stone,” the new “gateway drug.” Neither seem to have a clue that one of the fastest ways to radicalize kids is to exaggerate danger. The Harold and Kumar scene above underscores another core truth: young people know the material you’re most worried about far better than you. In the case of weed, they all smoked it and knew it makes you want to eat Ho-Hos and watch Star Trek, not reach for a gun locker. Meaning, they know when you’re lying. It’s why we watched Reefer Madness for fun:

    Saxman tells Hardymon that off-color humor is sometimes successful because “it’s building up their sense of pride, their sense of, like, ‘I am a critical thinker. I am a good questioner.’” It never occurs to them that kids experience these feelings because parents have lied to them repeatedly on whole ranges of issues, from the dangers of marijuana to (more recently) a spate of wrong Covid dictates to platitudes about how “Trans women are women” (a theme that single-handedly birthed Dave Chappelle’s “beyond pussy” routines) and countless other dumb political saws. Comics become authorities to kids by telling them blunt truths their parents won’t.

    You can’t make funny jokes unfunny through “engagement.” I’m sure NPR would denounce as misogynistic Gilbert Gottfried’s panegyric on Joan Rivers’ vagina (“How old is it? How dry is it? How many men died during its construction?”) and would consider calling 911 if they heard a pre-teen listening to any of Sam Kinison’s routines. But you can’t make this not funny:

    On the other hand a lot of Kinison’s routines about gays from that era, like Eddie Murphy’s, come off as severely cringe-worthy. By raising our kids to love a good joke, we teach them to hear the difference. The riskiest, raunchiest humor was for decades at least allowed, and despite the fact that a generation of pre-teens grew up giggling to Richard Pryor or Bill Hicks or Kinison routines in defiance of their parents or listened to obscene punk or hip-hop with severely regressive themes, somehow that was the generation that pushed for gay marriage and affirmative action and prized tolerance above everything else.

    Only recently were young people re-introduced to taboos, and how’s that working out, NPR fans? Well, would you say? Or badly?

    0 min
  • Timeline: A Recent History of Tariffs
    Illustration by Daniel Medina

    Research assistance by James Rushmore

    Tariffs have always been controversial, but they use to be a bit simpler.

    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    There was the retaliatory chicken tax in 1964. West Germany placed tariffs on our poultry, so LBJ responded with a 25% tariff on light trucks.

    I don’t know anyone who questions Ronald Reagan’s free trade bonafides, yet he imposed a 45% tariff on imported motorcycles to protect Harley Davidson. Japanese bikes were overtaking the market. The motorcycle tariff, as it became known, expired in 1988. I should probably be thankful for that since I ride a Yamaha.

    My first experience dealing with tariffs as a journalist was in 2002. President George W. Bush imposed tariffs on steel because countries were “dumping” steel in the U.S. at below-market prices. Steel companies were filing bankruptcy and laying off workers. It seemed so obvious that something needed to be done.

    But it’s a little more complicated. I didn’t realize at the time that lots of people and companies really don’t care where their shit comes from. Companies that need steel were used to cheap prices, and they suddenly had to pay higher prices. There are plenty of studies that say those companies lost more jobs than the number of people employed in the steel-producing industry.

    The World Trade Organization, formed in 1995, eventually ruled the Bush tariffs were illegal. It’s ruled against America a lot, leading to accusations of anti-American bias. The Trump Administration has suspended payments to the WTO.

    I don’t think Trump will care how the WTO rules on his “Liberation Day” tariffs, which hit the usual suspects (China) and the not-so-usual. Lesotho, a country in Africa that I suspect many Americans cannot locate on a map, topped Trump’s list at 50%.

    My former colleague, Peter Savodnik, wrote about The Great Scramble in American politics — and that seems to be playing out when it comes to tariffs. A Wall Street Journal poll found that 77% of Republicans have a positive view of them, while 93% of Democrats have a negative view. The poll was taken shortly before Trump announced his tariffs last week.

    It’s interesting to see attitudes shift on Capitol Hill, too. Sen. Jon Cornyn, R-Texas, is one who stands out. Back in 2018, he voiced concern about Trump’s tariffs against China, calling them a “mixed message” and saying it’s not a given that automobile companies like Toyota will “continue to build cars in the United States if that were to change, the rules of origin.”

    Today, he’s on board with Trump’s tariffs.

    In the video above, Cornyn says:

    Part of the problem is we’ve sort of become accustomed to other countries treating us differently that we treat them. Part of the reuslt of that is we’ve offshored a lot of manufacturing outside of the United States. Part of President Trump’s, what’s he’s hoping for, is we can attract more businesses to come back and manufacture goods in the United States.

    In 2023, Cornyn said it was time to move on from Trump. Not anymore:

    On the Democratic side, there’s Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer. In 2009, he supported President Obama’s 35% tariffs on Chinese tires. At the time, Goodyear had tire plants in Buffalo and Niagara Falls. The plant in Buffalo has since shut down.

    Schumer also supported President Trump’s 2018 tariffs on Chinese steel and aluminum.

    “Today he is doing the right thing,” Schumer said the day Trump announced the tariffs. Schumer said something needed to be done to respond to China stealing U.S. intellectual property.

    In 2024, he sang the same tune when President Biden expanded Trump’s tariffs:

    Fighting the CCP’s unfair trade practices is something I have cared about for a very long time. It was one of the very first issues I focused on when I first visited upstate New York as a Senator and saw for myself jobs leaving our shores. The CCP has shown they will stop at nothing to steal our intellectual property and undermine our economy.

    In the last week, “grandma” has been in a lot of his anti-tariff talking points:

    He also says tariffs should have been “pinpointed and targeted” instead of a “massive assault on American families.”

    I don’t think it’s so simple. There are certainly a lot of people who feel they’ve been under assault by the status quo.

    Below is a list of tariffs that America has imposed since 2002 leading up to President Trump’s second term.

    March 5, 2002

    President George W. Bush imposes tariffs on steel, targeting China, Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, Germany and Brazil. They are to last for three years, starting at 30% and tapering to 18% in the third year.

    Sen. Jay Rockefeller, D-W.Va., praised the action but added: “I am not confident that the problems of the steel industry are on their way to being solved” in part because the 30% rate only lasts for one year.

    03 05 2002 Components Of The President's Decision162KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload03 05 2002 President Announces Temporary Safeguards For Steel Industry172KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload03 05 2002 Steel Products Proclamation152KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload07 04 2002 USTR Proclamation136KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadDec. 4, 2003

    Bush rescinds the steel tariffs. The decision comes nearly a month after the World Trade Organization rules the tariffs were illegal, and gives countries they targeted the right to impose $2.2 billion in retaliatory tariffs.

    “The President's complete lack of mettle in calling the W.T.O.'s bluff ignores the continuing damage being done," said Leo Gerard, the president of the United Steelworkers of America.

    12 04 2003 President's Statement On Steel149KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload12 04 2003 To Provide For The Termination Of Action Taken With Regard To Imports Of Certain Steel Products By The President Of The United States Of America A Proclamation145KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadSeptember 11, 2009

    President Obama imposes a three-year tariff on Chinese tires that had been flooding the market since 2004. The tariffs start at 35% and go down to 25% by the third year.

    The New York Times reports that four tire plants have shut down and more are scheduled to close.

    The United Steelworkers Union says the tariffs stabilized the American tire industry. Chinese imports dropped significantly, but tires from South Korea, Taiwan and Indonesia took their place, the Los Angeles Times reports in this 2016 story, which was pegged to Trump talking about tariffs on the campaign trail.

    09 11 2009 Memorandum For Secretary Of Commerce, Secretary Of Labor, United State Trade Representative200KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload09 11 2009 Proclamation To Address Market Disruption From Imports Of Certain Passenger Vehicle And Light Truck Tires202KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload02 2016 Standing Up For American Workers And Businesses The Obama Administration's Trade Enforcement Record498KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadJanuary 22, 2018

    Trump announces tariffs of 20 to 50% on washing machines and parts that decrease over three years, and 30% on solar panels and cells. The tariffs apply to any country, but are directed at China.

    March 8, 2018

    Trump announces tariffs of 25% on steel and 10% on aluminum, but temporarily excludes Canada and Mexico. He later excludes Argentina, Brazil, Australia and South Korea, and the European Union.

    05 31 2018 President Donald J129KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadSection 301 Final2.88MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadMay 31, 2018

    Trump announces the steel and aluminum tariffs will apply to Canada, Mexico and the EU.

    05 31 2018 President Donald J129KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload

    June 15, 2018

    Trump announces 25% tariffs on $50 billion in Chinese technology products “in light of China’s theft of intellectual property and technology and its other unfair trade practices.”

    Trump adds another $200 billion in Chinese products at 10% after China imposes retaliatory retaliatory tariffs on $50 billion in American products.

    06 15 2018 Statement By The President Regarding Trade With China131KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload06 18 2018 Statement From The President Regarding Trade With China130KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadMay 17, 2019

    Trump removes tariffs he imposed on Mexico and Canada nearly a year earlier, but then nearly two weeks later imposes a 5% tariff on all products from Mexico because of illegal immigration at the southern border. Trump says:

    Mexico’s passive cooperation in allowing this mass incursion constitutes an emergency and extraordinary threat to the national security and economy of the United States.

    Trump says the tariffs will escalate to 25% and remain “until Mexico substantially stops the illegal inflow of aliens coming through its territory.”

    05 19 2019 Proclamation On Adjusting Imports Of Aluminum Into The United States146KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload05 30 2019 Statement From The President Regarding Emergency Measures To Address The Border Crisis148KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadSeptember 2, 2022

    President Biden continues Trump’s tariffs against China.

    May 14, 2024

    Biden increases tariffs on $18 billion in Chinese products. They include:

    • A 100% tariff on electric vehicles

    • A 50% tariff on solar products

    • A 25% tariff on other products such as steel and EV batteries.

    Biden has strong words for China in making the announcement:

    Sometimes they just outright steal through cyber espionage and other means. And it’s been a well-documented inter- — and internationally recognized. When you make tactics like these, they are — they’re — you’re not competing. It’s not competition. It’s cheating. And we’ve seen the damage here in America.

    05 14 2024 Remarks By President Biden On His Actions To Protect American Workers And Businesses From China’s Unfair Trade Practices109KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload


    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    0 min
  • Do Your Own Research: The Economy

    Nearly two decades ago, when charged to cover an apparent Depression-level event in the 2008 crash, I was stunned to discover how few resources were available to ordinary people hoping to make sense of the economy. The financial press was written by and for financial professionals, and every time I thought I’d found an analyst who made sense, I’d discover shortly after he or she was funded by banks or hedge funds incentivized to put lipsticks on pigs.

    It also turned out that most of the statistics politicians used to represent the relative fitness or unfitness of the economy were and are weighted at best, and outright bull at worst, from the Consumer Price Index to the Unemployment Rate. Even LIBOR, the interbank lending rate that supposedly represented how finance companies thought about the economy, turned out to be a monstrous scam. The habit of tweaking stats became so ingrained, even Nobel laureates like Paul Krugman could unashamedly declare “the war on inflation is over” and “we won, at very little cost” using a graph that charted price growth excluding “food, energy, shelter, and used cars,” i.e. everything:

    We’re again in panic mode, with front page charts full of down-pointing arrows, and the word “plummets” suddenly a ubiquitous headline term. However you feel about the new “reciprocal tariffs” program, we’re again entering a time in which most news consumers will need to know where to search for de-politicized answers to economic questions. I polled finance professionals, contributors like Eric Salzman, and reporters who cover economics to ask which sources are most accessible. Then I spoke at length with fellow Substacker Chris Irons of Quoth the Raven about the broader problems with finding reliable economic info, and some sites that short-cut the obstacles.

    One quick note up front. Many respondents pointed out that a neophyte beginning a journey into sorting out what’s what in the economy may want to begin by familiarizing himself or herself with each of the twelve Federal Reserve banks. “They all pretty much report on different things,” says Salzman. “If you want to know what’s going on in the oil and gas business, the Dallas Fed issues a lot of research.” Irons pointed to FRED, or Federal Reserve Economic Data, put out by the St. Louis Fed. “It’s all there,” he says, noting for instance the multiple official unemployment rates that are often cherry-picked by financial media depending on the situation. “It’s just not what’s in the news.”

    Data about Wall Street is found throughout the Fed system, but the New York and Boston Feds put out some of the most interesting numbers and surveys on financial markets. The Atlanta Fed prides itself on forecasting numbers like GDP growth, San Francisco is good for labor markets and Pacific Rim issues, and so on. You can find each bank’s site here, and all of them will have a notation reading “research” or “what we study” at the top.

    From top left: The national Fed system interactive map, a San Francisco Fed paper on housing inventory, the New York Fed’s corporate bond distress index, and the Atlanta Fed graphing its own GDP forecasts

    A key thing to understand about economic searches is that governmental agencies (and quasi-governmental agencies, like the Fed) generally have a fair portion of the raw, unmanipulated data you’re looking for, both for macroeconomics and individual companies. The problem is learning to interpret the numbers, and finding convenient ways to locate everything you need in one place. If you’re following economic developments through the courts, costs can be a limiting factor, but as Matt Stoller points out, sites like CourtListener.Com can give you free updates about developments in antitrust cases or other lawsuits.

    www.courtlistener.com

    “If you want to understand important corporate economics,” Stoller says, “the place you understand them is when they’re fighting with each other.”

    It’s a big topic, and future entries will probably feature separate articles for independent investors and people simply interested in learning what kind of shape the global or national economy is in from places other than newspapers proven to be unreliable. I asked Irons, whose “The Inevitable, Just Sooner” piece about Donald Trump’s tariff war expresses a lot of my own beliefs about the subject, how and where he goes to evaluate companies and the economy in general:

    MT: Putting off macroeconomics for a moment, where do you start when you’re looking at a company?

    Chris Irons: Well, the nice thing about Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) reporting is that if you strip away all of the financial media, the sell-side analyst reports, and what everybody is saying about a given company, at the end of the day, everybody’s beholden to the same disclosure requirements. So there is always a way to make an apples-to-apples comparison of companies.

    One company may be earning $20 million a year and be very pissed off about it, and Goldman Sachs might hate ‘em, and another company may be making $20 million a year, and it might be the hottest thing ever, all over CNBC, because they’re in AI or whatever. At the end of the day, if you’re just looking at each company’s 10-Ks.

    MT: The annual reports required by the SEC.

    Chris Irons: Right. So you’re looking at $20 million on either one, and then it’s up to you to determine where that sits within the industry that the company’s in. So one thing you can do is compare companies to their peers, obviously, which is what everybody on Wall Street does, and then kind of work your way out to the overall sector in general: “Okay, is this an auto stock? How is the whole industry doing?” Then work your way out even a little bit more to the macroeconomy.

    MT: All of this is searchable at SEC.gov, right?

    Chris Irons: Yes. You can go in there, there’s a search filings page, and just enter any company, if you want to use the official sites.

    MT: There’s a nice clip-art picture of “you” frowning a little as you tackle the page:

    MT: Anyway, there are all sorts of mandated disclosures in these documents. What are some of the most important?

    Chris Irons: Literally reading a 10-K from start to finish is the best way to learn about a firm, especially if it’s just fresh off the press and you’re not two months into a new quarter. But when a 10-K or even a 10-Q [eds. note: the quarterly version] drops, that is really the best way to familiarize yourself with the basics of a company. They all start with, “What does the business do? What’s the name of the business? What’s the address? Where are they headquartered? Here’s the business that we’re in. Here’s the industry that we’re in, and here’s what the segments of our company are, so here’s where revenue is coming in.” So we may be Disney and we may have theme park revenue, video content, revenue, licensing revenue.

    MT: They’re telling a story about how they make money.

    From the latest Tesla 10-K

    Chris Irons: Right. How they make money, and if they don’t make money, how they expect to make money.

    Now, the best way to cheat if you don’t even want to look at the financials, say you don’t know anything about accounting, is every company has a risk factor section. The rule of thumb with risk factors is you always put the most materially important risk at the top.

    So if you have a “key man” risk where one guy knows the secret sauce and if he dies, you’re completely fucked, that’ll be up top. Or if it’s that you’re losing money as a cash burning biotech company that’s trying to push one drug through phase three, the first thing that they’re going to say is, our ability to operate is contingent upon our ability to raise capital. And that business could fail or be adversely affected if the phase three drug doesn’t go through or it doesn’t meet its primary endpoints. So the risk factors are often kind of overlooked as boilerplate, but they’re there for a reason.

    I’ve been in the room with securities lawyers and executives as they write them, they’re worded purposefully and they’re written with great care because in essence, that is a way for the company to disclaim itself from future risk that an investor may say, “I didn’t see this coming.” So they do want to be forthcoming.

    The problem is that nobody reads the 10-K. Everybody glances over it and they just say, okay, well this is just boilerplate lawyer bullshit. Well, it’s actually not. It’s actually the worst case scenarios that you can find. So that’s a great spot in an annual report to look at that. Most companies don’t look at that. If you turn on CNBC or you read a sell-side analyst report, they’re not going to go into depth about the risk factors.

    MT: It’s one of the few places in America where people are required to be at least somewhat painfully honest in advance.

    Pfizer risk factors.

    Chris Irons: Yeah. And some sites actually make it even a little bit easier. There’s a site that I really like that I’ve used for the last 10 years. It’s called BamSEC.

    MT: Okay. Never heard of that. And it’s going to give you access to the same filings.

    Chris Irons: It just organizes them a little bit. The SEC site is a bit convoluted, it’ll kind of give you a list of everything. In BAM SEC, you put the ticker in and immediately in one section of the screen you have your 8-Ks and your 10-Qs. Mostly they’re material events that occur to the business in between the periods of 10-Q. So if you just filed your quarterly and two weeks later your CEO resigns, that goes out in an 8-K, for foreign filers.

    Then one section has insider buys and sells, which will be on Form-4s and Form-3s. Form-3s are your initial statement of beneficial ownership and Form-4s are when insiders transact in the stock. I think they’ll put the 13-G and D filings in there too, which is when you have outside investors come in and acquire a big enough stake in the company, where they have to disclose, “Hey, I’m a 5% owner.” This is actually what the SEC is going after Musk for right now.

    They’re saying he didn’t file that when he needed to on Twitter. And then there’s another section of the page where you have the proxy statements and some other stuff. You’ll get a lot of the same information that you get in the annual reports, but you’re also going to get a lot of detail about the board of directors, the biographies of the people that are on the board of directors, the different committees within the board of directors.

    So BAM SEC just lays that shit out. Everything’s dated, so you know what the most recent filing is.

    BAM SEC’s page collecting Lockheed Martin filings.

    Chris Irons: There are a lot of really nice features on this site. You have correspondence. These are comment letters going back and forth to the SEC. So you can read those and see kind of what the SEC is asking them about.

    MT: Cool.

    Chris Irons: Yeah, ownership, which is your Form-4s, and again, your 13 Ds and Gs, and then prospectuses and registrations, which are documents related to selling stock to raise capital generally.

    MT: Like securities or bonds or anything of that sort?

    Chris Irons: Yeah, exactly. If they’re going to go out and sell convertible bonds or they’re going to sell stock, some administrative stuff, prospectuses - also, proxies will have an immense amount of information in them. A lot of the information will be repetitive, so you’ll see stuff that is in the 10-K, but say two months later, a company wants to go sell a million shares to raise 50 million, they have to once again disclose all that shit so that people that are participating in the purchase of the securities are aware of everything that was in the 10-K. So you’ll get a lot of redundant information. But for example, if you have a prospectus that was filed yesterday and the 10-K was filed two months ago, you may get more updated information in the prospectus.

    MT: So the average person, if they pick up the newspaper, the information they get about whether we have a good economy or not is going to be unemployment rate, inflation, where the stock market is, and maybe something like the consumer price index. What other things should people be looking at?

    Chris Irons: Well, I think people at first need to understand that those statistics in and of themselves are gamed.

    For example, the CPI uses things like owner’s equivalent rent and hedonic adjustments where they game the numbers to be significantly lower than they are, which is why you kind of notice things going up 10% a year price-wise, while they’re telling you they’re only going up 3% a year.

    There used to be a great site called the CHAPWOOD Index, which looks like they may have stopped in 2023, but the idea here is to kind of show you the true cost of living increases. And what they do is they take a basket of items similar to the way that CPI does it, but they include items that CPI strategically excludes and they don’t make adjustments. CPI makes an adjustment like this: if the price of TVs goes up year over year by 10%, but your TV can now stream video when it not used to not be able to do that, they will go in and discretionarily edit the true cost of what a TV costs because you’re theoretically getting more than what you would’ve gotten last year.

    MT: Because it’s more awesome now!

    Chris Irons: Yeah, exactly. Those are the kind of bullshit games that are in these numbers. There’s a cool little link on this site that just says problems with CPI. It’s on the CHAPWOOD index site, and it just says the government’s been artificially deflating CPI to keep figures as low as possible.

    And that’s because things like social security are all earmarked to the rate of inflation. So people would be shitting a brick if they knew inflation was 10% and the government’s cost of living increase for social services was trying to meet this 3% CPI number. And it’s the same with unemployment. There are huge differences in the way unemployment numbers used to be reported, versus now.

    Unemployment used to just mean people who were out of work. Now the unemployment numbers are excluding the people who are actively looking for a job. They do shit like this. Peter Schiff has a great series on problems with the unemployment number. I’m going to see if I can find it. The U-6 rate is what? Prior to 1994, the U-6 rate was the official rate, and that’s what you should get in there because they don’t use the U-6 rate, they use a different rate now, the U-3 rate.

    MT: So they went from a higher calculation to a lower one in 1994?

    Chris Irons: Yes. It’s the Bureau of Labor Statistics. This is how they fucking release the numbers. U-1 is people unemployed 15 weeks or longer as a percent of the civilian labor force. U-2 is job losers and people who completed temporary jobs. U-3, total unemployed as a percent of the civilian labor force, which is the official unemployment rate. And U-6, which is total unemployed plus all people marginally attached to the labor force plus total employed part-time for economic reasons as a percent of the civilian labor force, plus all people marginally attached to labor force.

    From the Bureau of Labor Statistics

    So just cast the net a little bit wider, and it used to be the employment number that they use. Now they use the U-3 rate, which is a smaller pot of people. So they’re data-mining essentially.

    MT: Gotcha. What other data might be of interest to an ordinary person? The Fed obviously puts out all kinds of papers.

    Chris Irons: The size of their balance sheet. I find it fascinating.

    The size of the Federal Reserve balance sheet, now down to almost $6 trillion. Since 2008, the Fed has been propping up the economy with its purchases.

    When they started quantitative easing, the idea was they were going to buy some bonds and then they were going to sell ‘em back into the market. And that never happened. They just started buying bonds and now the Fed balance sheet is whatever, seven or 8 trillion, and at some point something’s going to give because they have 7 trillion worth of - I don’t know if they’re subprime assets - but they’re assets that if they went to go find a market to buy them now wouldn’t be there.

    Monetary policy, the way that we’ve run it really since the 2000s, is just kind of this big unprecedented experiment and nobody really knows how it’s going to end. You have financial PhDs basically claiming that we’ve figured out the secret sauce, that we can twist and distort and micromanage the economy to get it to do whatever we want at any point that we want, and that this is the path to utopia. And then you have the free market people that say maybe it’s working now, but every day you fiddle around with this bullshit more, the worse it’s going to be when the reckoning comes. I actually just wrote an article about this last week that shows that one of the negative consequences of monetary policy now is this widening inequality gap. So if you go to my substack and you look at the dark secret behind Democrats’ economic policy, which should be the pinned number one, and just scroll down to the chart that says net personal wealth.

    MT: Okay.

    Chris Irons: So both parties are guilty of this, but I’m writing specifically about Democrats because they’re the party that sells equity and equality and not just equality of opportunity, but equality of outcome. This is the result of the monetary policy that this country has, which is not that the gap between the top 10% and the bottom 90% is widening, but it’s accelerated. And so it’s not just all of this wealth that they’re accruing, because with wealth comes power and influence. It’s within this very same system that Ben Bernanke once said we can print money at no cost, meaning it doesn’t cost anything to run the fucking printer. It costs 2 cents of electricity, but the long and short of it is there’s real cost and this is what the real cost looks like.

    Looks like the fucking ultra rich that these dildos are railing against on a daily basis getting exponentially richer and at the same time bringing with them a quality of life by virtue of osmosis. Because as this is occurring, inflation is worsening. And so these people in the top 10%, they don’t feel anything. The people in the bottom 90% are being brutalized, brutalized because the people on a shoestring budget are going to the store. And when they used to get 16 ounces of Fruity Pebbles for $4, now it’s $8 and they only get 10 ounces.

    That is a fucking big deal for some people. You know what I mean?

    MT: Sure.

    Chris Irons: That multiplied across all discretionary spending and especially consumer staples is where it hits these people. And so it’s no surprise to me that Nancy Pelosi thinks that the economy’s working fine or that any of these rich fucks throw a dart. They all think everything’s working. But that is this chart. If everybody understood what was in this chart, people would be raising a lot of serious fucking questions about monetary policy because this takes everything the Democrats talk about and all the virtue signaling bullshit about equity and bringing people together and we’re all going to sing Kumbaya and everybody gets a chance - and refutes it directly. And this happened under both parties.

    MT: Alright, are there other sites like that that you can think of that might not be known to the average person?

    Chris Irons: Another great site that I really like is called currentmarketvaluation.com.

    MT: Sounds self-explanatory.

    Chris Irons: It’s super easy. If you look at something like a price-to-earnings ratio, that’s essentially the most commonly used way to determine whether stocks are expensive or cheap. You have to compare them to something, whether that’s the historical average or the industry or whatever. But this gives you that in a couple of different ways to value to market.

    Chris Irons: So if you scroll down, you see where it says market valuation models?

    MT: Yes.

    Chris Irons: This makes things super simple because it’s telling you right up top that things are strongly overvalued.

    Irons: What it’s showing you there is how many sigma deviations it is away from the historical trend line. The Buffet indicator is market cap to GDP, which is what Warren Buffet has said in the past. It’s his favorite indicator, which is hilarious because three or four weeks ago, there was a big mystery, like, oh, why is Warren Buffet in all this cash? Why does Berkshire Hathaway have all this cash? It’s like the fucking indicator is called the Buffett indicator, and it’s two sigma deviations above the trend line. So his favorite indicator is screaming that the market is overvalued, and then you have your price-to-earnings model. You don’t even have to look at the rest. Those are two great ways to value the market. Market cap to GDP is perfect for the overall market. Price-to-earnings can be used for companies as well, and what I think is really important is that people see a stock go from 200 to a hundred. So they think it’s cheap because it’s 50% less than it was. Price means almost nothing. I mean, it’s a function of a company’s valuation, but when you’re trying to determine whether or not a company is cheap or it’s expensive, what you should be looking at is the multiple.

    And the multiple is how many times the current or next year’s earnings does the market trade at. Now when we’ve been in very deep recessions, that number’s gone as low as, I think, somewhere eight to 12 times earnings for the S&P. It may have even gotten lower than that before when a market traditionally is fair to a little bit more aggressively valued. You’re talking 12 to 20, 12 to 22. And we’re talking about basic stocks here. Certain industries have different PEs. Companies that grow a lot will have higher PEs. But this is all just very broad generalization. When you look at the market now and you see that the S&P, which is a collection of all different industries, is trading above 30 times earnings, to me that says that the stock market is overvalued.

    MT: Severely, right?

    Chris Irons: Yes. Because in essence, when you buy a stock at a multiple, what you’re doing is you’re betting if a company trades 10 times earnings and it earns $2 a share this year, it’d be trading at $20 a share, take your full year EPS, and you divide that into the share price and that’s your price-to-earnings multiple, give or take some other bullshit. That’s not really important. That number, what you’re doing is you’re buying 10 years of forward earnings under the assumption that the company is going to either be enough or last long enough that it’s going to pay you more than 10 years worth of earnings because you’re paying upfront 10 years worth of earnings. The market’s a forward looking indicator.

    So when you’re buying the S&P today, you’re buying 35 years of what the S&P is set to earn this year or next year. Now, because of inflation and because of earnings growth, that number usually does move higher. But if you get into a situation where, and that’s in general X-ing out individual company performance, but if you get into a situation where earnings start to stagnate or decline, that 35 multiple can become a 40 multiple or can become a 45 multiple, and you don’t have a lot of leeway there. Now you’ve paid for 45 years worth of earnings that at least now in the short to midterm may not be coming to fruition. You may have to wait significantly longer than you thought. So that’s why you always hear companies talk about price-to-earnings multiples. Tesla’s a stock that everybody talks about, right?

    The debate on Tesla, which trades right now at something over a hundred times earnings, which is extreme, that’s very aggressive even for a technology company. Microsoft, Apple, Nvidia, they’re between 30 and 45 times earnings because they’re expected to grow significantly. They’re branching out into other businesses. Tesla is trading at over a hundred times earnings. And the debate is whether or not the new shit that they’re going to bring to market, things that they claim that they’re working on, Robotaxis and the Optimist Robot and the AI and whatever other shit they say they’re working on, whether that is going to fill in the gap of these significantly aggressive expectations that the market is pricing into the stock now, because traditional automakers, people that are skeptics, say if you look at Ford, if you look at General Motors, if you look at Volkswagen, if you look at Stellantis and you go overseas, look at Renault, these companies are trading between five and 15 times earnings.

    So somebody’s wrong: either the people that think it’s a car company are wrong because they have this aggressive new technology that’s going to earn them so much more money in the future. Or the people that are paying a hundred times earnings now are wrong because at its core, it’s really a car company and it’s aggressively overvalued. And so the question is, especially with all the volatility from Tesla, whether their legacy auto business, which generates their revenue and cash flow, will begin to decline. If that happens, that 100 becomes 150 times earnings very quickly. And so that’s a good example of how you could see people arguing over multiples, because I’ve seen people this week say, oh, it came from 400 to 200, so it’s cheap.

    Well, if you believe it should be valued like a traditional automaker, it isn’t cheap. It’s 10 times more expensive than it should be. But if you believe it’s going to be the first company of its kind to have taxis all over the nation and it’s barely tapping into a hundred trillion dollars industry, well then it’s incredibly undervalued. So the multiple tells you how aggressive the market is being on a particular company or on the stock based on their forward-looking expectations.

    MT: So everybody’s being too bullish.

    [Eds note: this interview was conducted before the recent price drops]

    Chris Irons: If you ask my opinion, I would say that’s a gross understatement. I would say that we are in a period of insane euphoria driven by a significant amount of liquidity that was put into the market during Covid. I mean, the speculation that’s out there is not like anything I’ve ever seen. You have entire industries, something like Fartcoin had billions in market cap at one time. What does that mean? That means there’s billions floating around out there in this asset that for all intents and purposes, everybody knows is a joke. It’s worth nothing. It serves no purpose. It’s not a product, it’s not a service. That’s how aggressive people are being. So in a recessionary environment or an environment where the market starts to cascade lower, all of that, what they call malinvestment dog shit, all of that has to come in. All of that money has to evaporate. All of that speculation has to evaporate.

    So if you look historically where the market’s multiple is now, if you look at the Schiller PE, which is just a way to adjust the PE for growth, look at something like the Schiller PE of the overall market. There’s only been one time in history where it’s as high as it is now. And that was right before the 2000 bubble. So that’s the level of aggressive valuation we’re at right now. We’re at about year 2000 bubble aggressiveness.

    MT: Back in a new paradigm.

    Chris Irons: Exactly. This time it’s different.

    MT: Thanks, Chris.

    Chris Irons: Thank you.

    0 min
  • ATW Livestream Tonight at 8 PM ET/7 PM CT

    On tonight’s episode of America This Week, Matt and Walter will discuss the anti-Trump protests that took place across the United States and around the world on Saturday. According to The Washington Post, about 100,000 people attended the rally in Washington, D.C. Do the Hands Off demonstrations suggest that the Resistance movement will successfully renew its efforts during the second Trump presidency, or do these protests represent a more scattershot phenomenon? They’ll also take a look at the global economic fallout from the sweeping reciprocal tariffs that Trump announced during his “Liberation Day” speech on Wednesday, and they’ll explore the media’s coverage of his controversial new trade polices.

    Please tune in at 8:00 PM ET on Substack, Rumble, and YouTube:

    Or follow @mtaibbi or @walterkirn on Twitter. See you soon!

    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    0 min
  • There Are Signs of a Category 5 Housing Crisis Forming and Coming Straight For Us
    Illustration by Daniel Medina

    If there was ever a “canary in the coal mine” moment for the next housing crisis, it’s that mortgage and insurance giant Fannie Mae maintains a secret mortgage blacklist.

    The Wall Street Journal broke the news on March 17 that Fannie Mae keeps a blacklist that includes condo associations it believes have too little property insurance or need to make critical building repairs. According to the Journal, it’s a list that every major lender pays attention to.

    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    In other words, if you’re buying a condo in a building on that list, you’re likely not going to get a loan. However, the insurance “canary” isn’t just about condo buildings.

    If you think homeowners insurance has already skyrocketed — and it has — hold on because you’re likely about to get screwed even more. First, some background:

    The power of Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, and Ginnie Mae

    These three agencies insure against losses on about 90% of all residential mortgage loans. These loans end up as mortgage-backed securities (MBS), which amount to more than $9 trillion.

    The liquidity of the MBS market is the main reason getting a home mortgage in the U.S. is relatively easy. Without agencies like Fannie Mae, our housing market would be a fraction of what it is today. When borrowers make the monthly payment on their loans — usually to a loan servicer — the monthly payment goes through the agencies and makes its way to the MBS market.

    The agencies guarantee against principal losses and collect a monthly fee called a “Guarantor Fee.” In this case, they’re acting like an insurance company to MBS bond holders by collecting premiums and paying out any losses due to borrower default. MBS are collateralized by the borrower’s home.

    Therefore, if the homeowner’s insurance isn’t paid, then the collateral (ie: the home) backing the loan is at risk. If a home that’s collateralizing a mortgage that the agencies guarantee is without insurance, and the home is destroyed, the agencies would take the loss.

    A lapsed insurance policy can be considered a default and lead to foreclosure.

    Insurance and mortgage rates are connected

    Homeowners insurance is going up. A Treasury Department report released in January found that, nationally, insurance rates rose 8.7% faster than the rate of inflation from 2018-2022.

    Of course, the agencies can’t guarantee large swaths of homes in securities unless they are insured.

    Most people’s mortgage payment includes their insurance premiums and real estate taxes. Those premiums and taxes go into an escrow account from which the loan servicer pays those bills when they are due. So, as your insurance premiums and real estate taxes go up, so does your mortgage payment.

    This is where the rubber meets the road. While the average price of insurance went up 8.7% more than inflation from 2018-2022, it went up 14.7% more than inflation in the 20 highest-risk zip codes. The consumer price index rose 20% during that period. That means a $1,500 insurance policy in those top 20 zip codes increased an average of $344, raising a monthly $3,000 payment to $3,029. Another study from S&P Global found that premium increased an average of 34% from 2017-2023:

    If you can still only pay the $3,000 a month, you’re delinquent even if you covered your principal and interest in your payment. That means you’re on the path to foreclosure.

    Often, homeowners in this situation get introduced to a dark corner of the financial world: Forced Place Insurance (FPI). When closing on a home, the borrower signs loan documents agreeing to maintain continuous homeowners insurance coverage. If the insurance policy lapses or gets canceled, the lender or servicer steps in and obtains FPI — also known as lender-placed insurance — to safeguard the property.

    FPI premiums are usually four to 10 times more — meaning even higher monthly mortgage payments and an increased likelihood of default. That’s starting to happen in the commercial real estate market.

    FPI played a big role in the 2007-2008 mortgage crises, as Rohit Chopra, the former director of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, noted in this 2023 speech:

    There have been numerous lawsuits against mortgage servicers and insurance companies alleging that these entities, or an allegedly captive reinsurance company, were paid kickbacks. Even if the mortgage servicer doesn’t profit from the force-placed insurance, the mortgage servicer has limited incentives to minimize the cost of the force-placed insurance or avoid the placement. The entire price of the force-placed insurance is then passed on to the borrower.

    Foreclosures

    Look what’s happening so far in 2025:

    Foreclosures 2025
    January: +8% from previous month
    February: +5% from previous month

    While foreclosure numbers year-over-year are still below 2024, and the rate has remained relatively unchanged the previous three years, I’m concerned the uptick could become a trend because we know insurance rates have been going up since 2022, the last year covered in that Treasury Department report. The average premium jumped nearly $200 in 2023 and jumped again last year, according to this report from Harvard’s Joint Center for Housing Studies.

    With premiums rising faster than inflation, something’s got to give. I’ll be keeping a close eye on the foreclosure report for March later this week.

    Higher insurance premiums = higher mortgage rates

    Most of the media’s attention focuses on the Fed when it comes to mortgage rates. But insurance premiums can also affect rates for a new loan.

    Any loan provider is going to look at where the agencies’ securities are trading. If they are yielding 6%, the loan provider can’t just sell the loan at that rate. They also have to add on that guarantor fee I mentioned earlier that guarantees investors won’t lose money on the loan’s principal. There’s also the loan servicing fee. That 6% rate is likely to become a 6.75% rate for the customer. The higher the guarantor fee — which is in this case affected by soaring insurance premiums — the higher the interest rates. This FHFA report released last May shows that Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae guarantor fees are going up.

    Of course, insurance premiums are on the rise in large part because of natural disasters. Let’s face it: these days it seems like most of the country is increasingly prone to fires, hurricanes, or tornadoes. If you’re in California — which has been dealing with an insurance crisis for several years — your rates are already going up because of January’s fires in the LA area.

    I don’t need to tell you that disasters increase insurance premiums no matter where you live.

    But not to worry. The Treasury Department had a remedy in that January report:

    State and federal regulators and policymakers should continue their efforts to improve public awareness about the importance of adequate homeowners insurance.

    To quote Steven Wright, “I couldn’t repair your brakes, so I fixed your horn instead.”

    Correction: This story has been updated to correct an error we made in calculating an increase in monthly mortgage payments resulting form higher homeowners insurance premiums. We also added additional information from a study that the Minneapolis Fed wrote about last year.

    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    0 min

About Racket News

From the publisher's feed

Regular news and features by award-winning author and investigative reporter, Matt Taibbi.