At its founding, the Czech Pirate Party was meant to offer a center-left, progressive alternative in Czech politics, which has been mostly dominated by centrist and center-right views. But after a series of setbacks, from mismanaging building permit digitization efforts to failing to secure enough seats in the 2024 European Parliament elections, the Pirates reshuffled their leadership and distanced themselves from traditional progressive campaign topics like tax reform, environmental policy, and broader social equity concerns. Was that a worthwhile gamble? I spoke with Klára Votavová, research fellow at the Europeum Institute of Foreign Policy, about the current state of the left in Czechia. We discuss why, despite growing dissatisfaction with the status quo, the Pirates are hesitant to tackle progressive policies head-on, and why their role in the opposition might boost their popularity in the country.