In this episode, we dive into some of the most uncomfortable, outrageous, and emotionally charged stories from Reddit’s r/AmIOverreacting subreddit. From stolen underwear to recycled engagement rings, the drama is real—and so are the red flags.

Stories featured:

• My stepdad stole my dirty underwear

• My wife went out to lunch with a guy she just met at the gym

• Am I overreacting for walking out of a proposal when my boyfriend used the same ring he gave his ex?

• My boyfriend cheated on me during my birthday dinner

These stories raise serious questions about boundaries, trust, and whether these reactions were truly “overreactions”… or 100% justified.

Listen, react, and let us know: What would YOU have done?