Recipe Challenge

Recipe Challenge

By Rebecca Collins and Katie LailLeisure
Download on the App Store

Recipe Challenge episodes

  • Holiday Cookie Exchange

    Are you headed to a holiday cookie exchange or swap this season? What cookies are you going to bring? We tried out two cookie recipes to see which one is most exchange worthy—Soft Gingerbread with Maple Glaze or Pistachio Pinecones. Which one could we not stop eating?

    Links for the episode:

    Soft Gingerbread Cookies with Maple Glaze
    Pistachio Pinecones
    When in doubt, go Peanut Butter Blossoms

    To see photos of our cookies and to share what you're bringing to your cookie exchange this year, follow us on Instagram: @recipechallengepod

    Want to talk recipes or have suggestions for future themes? Email us:

    39 min
  • Halloween Treat Boards

    Charcuterie, cheese, and butter boards got nothin' on the Halloween treat board! This month, we each chose a scary movie and constructed a treat board to go with it for a maximized Halloween experience. Required: three kinds of candy, a baked good (sweet or savory), a fruit, and a cheese. Best of all, we both won just for embracing The Spirit of Halloween. Listen to find out which movies and treats we chose.

    Links for the episode:

    Rebecca's board:
    Gummy eyeballz
    Devil's Food Cookies
    Perfect chocolate pudding from Cooking in Real Life by Lidey Heuck
    Chocolate-covered peanuts
    Dark chocolate and white chocolate Kit Kats
    Candied pecans
    Petit Boo Brie
    Hammond's Caramel Pumpkin Marshmallows
    Katie's board:
    Fruit Spiders
    Buttered Popcorn Sugar Cookies
    Reese’s Take 5
    Kit Kat
    Gummy spiders
    Ellsworth Creamery smoked cheddar

    To see photos of our treat boards, follow us on Instagram:

    @recipechallengepod Want to talk recipes or have suggestions for future themes? Email us:

    36 min
  • After-School Apples

    It's September and time to say goodbye to summer fruits—the berries! the peaches! the cherries!—and embrace fall. This episode our challenge was apples as after-school snacks. We both looked for healthy options... with mixed results on taste. But which one comes closest to being a winner? Grab a bag of cacao nibs and listen.

    Links for the episode:

    Healthy Caramel Apple Salad from Snacking in Sneakers
    Apple Salsa from Astonishing Apples by Joan Donatelle
    Podcast episode: Bea Ojakangas, From Finnish Food To Pizza Rolls
    Kale Salad with Gouda, Honeycrisp & Walnuts from Cooking in Real Life by Lidey Heuck

    To see photos of our apple snacks, follow us on Instagram:

    @recipechallengepod

    Want to talk recipes or have suggestions for future themes? Email us:

    38 min
  • MN State Fair Dupes

    We're back and ready to talk fair food! This month we celebrate the Minnesota State Fair (second largest state fair in the U.S. behind Texas). It's the Great Minnesota Get Together AND the Great Minnesota Eat Together. We each selected a food you can buy at the fair and found recipes to duplicate them at home. One of us went classic and one went brand new for 2024. Which treat gets the blue ribbon?

    Links from the episode:

    Fried Pickles w/ Ranch Dipping Sauce
    New MN State Fair food: PB Bacon Cakes
    Martha Stewart's Bacon Pancakes
    Homemade In the Kitchen Peanut Butter Whipped Cream

    To see photos of our MN State Fair dupes, follow us on Instagram:

    @recipechallengepod

    Want to talk recipes or have suggestions for future themes? Email us:

    39 min
  • Picnic (Savory)

    It's full-on summer and that means more meals eaten al fresco. And while you may want to grab some takeout and head lakeside, sometimes it's fun to make your own picnic. This episode, we went head-to-head with some delicious sandwich recipes you could make for an outdoor dining experience. Will we be putting the burrata caprese or the chicken salad in our picnic basket this summer? Savor this episode - we're on summer break and will be back in August!

    Links from the episode:

    Burrata Caprese Sandwich with Cherry Tomato Confit from Bread Bake Beyond
    Green Goddess Chicken Salad Sandwich from New York Times Cooking
    Consider a picnic backpack
    Cuisinart 14-Cup 50th Anniversary Edition Food Processor
    Oofos recovery slides (Not a sponsor! We just like them!)
    To see photos of these amazing sandwiches, follow us on Instagram:
    @recipechallengepod

    Want to talk recipes or have suggestions for future themes? Email us:

    39 min
  • Birthday Cake

    Happy birthday to YOU! Happy birthday to ME! Whenever your birthday happens to fall, you may want to celebrate with a delicious homemade cake. In honor of Rebecca's birthday month, we each made a cake - one is a traditional yellow cake/chocolate frosting and the other is a Dairy Queen dupe ice cream cake. Which one takes the cake challenge?

    Links from the episode:

    King Arthur Baking Co. Classic Birthday Cake
    Copycat Dairy Queen Ice Cream Cake
    King Arthur Baking School
    To see photos of our gorgeous birthday cakes, follow us on Instagram:
    @recipechallengepod

    Want to talk recipes or have suggestions for future themes? Email us:

    44 min
  • Honey

    This month we honored our first listener request! We each chose a honey-forward dessert, but instead of sweet treats we got dryness and gumminess. Oh my. Which is the lesser of two evils? Find out in this episode + flashback to last month's cottage cheese episode with some cottage cheese ice cream.

    Links from the episode:

    Cottage cheese ice cream
    Gingerbee Cookies (scroll all the way down the page)
    The Imploding Honey Custard Cake

    To see photos of our honey-infused desserts, follow us on Instagram:

    @recipechallengepod

    Want to talk recipes or have suggestions for future themes? Email us:

    34 min
  • Cottage Cheese

    Love it or despise it, cottage cheese is back, baby! In this challenge, a TikTok cottage cheese recipe goes curd-to-curd with an old school cottage cheese salad. Or is it dip? Find out which one was a more satisfying snack. And we got our first-ever request for a challenge and it's a sweet one!

    Links from the episode:
    Healthy Viral TikTok Cottage Cheese Queso Recipe
    Nixon's last White House lunch
    lainiecooks cottage cheese ice cream
    Cottage cheese ice cream (multiple mix-in ideas!)
    10 Viral Cottage Cheese Recipes for Boost of Protein
    To see photos of our cottage cheese concoctions and to get the recipe for Cottage Cheese-Cucumber Cooler, follow us on Instagram:
    @recipechallengepod

    Want to talk recipes or have suggestions for future themes? Email us:

    43 min
  • Awards Season Cocktails

    'Tis the season for Grammys, BAFTAs, Golden Globes and Oscars. For this challenge, we exchanged recipes for cocktails to serve at your next awards show viewing party. One of us tried to bring the glitz and shimmer while the other uncovered the Official Cocktail of Summer 2024. Find out if we greenlit the Gold Rush or the Starlight just in time for the 96th Academy Awards.

    Links from the episode:
    Sparkly Gold Rush cocktail recipe
    Starlight cocktail recipe

    Follow us on Instagram:

    @recipechallengepod

    Want to talk recipes or have suggestions for future themes? Email us:

    37 min
  • Celebrity Cookbooks

    For our first challenge of 2024 we exchanged recipes from celebrity cookbooks. One of us went high and the other went low. Find out whether pasta casserole from The Tucci Cookbook by Stanley Tucci (friend of the pod) (not really) or Barry's (Greg Brady) Showstopper Zucchini and Swiss Pie from Alice's Brady Bunch Cookbook earned a repeat cook.

    Links from the episode:
    The Tucci Cookbook by Stanley Tucci, 2012
    Stanley Tucci: Searching For Italy
    Alice's Brady Bunch Cookbook, 1994
    To see a photo of The Hairy Chef, follow us on Instagram:
    @recipechallengepod

    Want to talk recipes or have suggestions for future themes? Email us:

    50 min

About Recipe Challenge

From the publisher's feed

Recipe Challenge is the podcast that turns cooking into a friendly and fun game. Once a month, hosts Katie and Rebecca each choose a recipe for the other to cook based on a theme and then come…