Reimagining Us

Reimagining Us

Download on the App Store

All Reimagining Us episodes

  • Season 2 - Episode 6 - Reviving the Exhausted Majority

    The election is behind us, but the patterns that wear us down haven’t gone anywhere: the outrage, the scorekeeping, the feeling of watching from the sidelines. Nearly two-thirds of Americans report feeling exhausted when they think about politics. But exhaustion isn’t apathy. People can care deeply about their communities while feeling worn down by the constant conflict and the doubt that anything they do will matter. And the people who could change those patterns often aren’t the loudest voices. They’re the ones who’ve quietly stepped back.

    In this episode of Reimagining Us, Dr. Nichole Argo and Scott Hutcheson explore the distance between wanting things to get better and believing we can help make it happen. Stephen Hawkins, Global Director of Research at More in Common and lead author of Hidden Tribes, the study that coined the term “the exhausted majority,” explains why politics has become the hardest divide for Americans to cross. People see the value in connecting, but often feel they lack the energy, or the opportunity, to try. He shares his own journey from College Republican to progressive activist to feeling “a little bit politically homeless.”

    Part of the answer may be in the invitation. Few people are eager to sit down and discuss group tensions. Many more would welcome the chance to work with someone different on something that improves their community. As Scott puts it, people will help after a hurricane more readily than they’ll attend a polarization workshop.

    And sometimes, stepping back has more to do with exclusion than exhaustion. People can experience the same city differently. For instance, in Lexington, Kentucky, about half of white residents say they truly belong, compared with 1 in 5 residents of color. And nearly 8 in 10 residents, across demographic groups, believe some voices count more than others. Addressing those inequalities and helping people understand one another are both essential parts of building a community people want to join.

    What can that look like? John Sarrouf of Essential Partners recalls sitting down with members of a local Rod and Gun Club who walked in deeply suspicious. He brought pizza and asked them to tell him about their first gun. An hour in, a woman who had insisted you can’t talk to the other side asked whether they could do this with people who disagree. She was tired, she said, of walking around her own town feeling misunderstood. Nobody asked her to give up what she believed. What changed was the invitation: someone asked real questions and listened.

    Future Caucus’s Layla Zaidane shares the story of two young Oklahoma legislators who disagreed about abortion but had built a real relationship. By getting curious, they discovered a shared concern about mothers dying in their state—and passed a bipartisan bill together. And john a. powell of UC Berkeley’s Othering and Belonging Institute asks the question underneath it all: whose future are you helping to create?

    The thread through it all: hope often begins with an experience. You show up, someone takes you seriously, and together you change something that matters. You don’t have to save the country by yourself, but you can become a builder by working on one relationship, one place, one chance to shape what happens next.

    Key discussion points

    • Exhaustion isn’t apathy: Why people who care deeply step back from civic life, and how fewer people participating can leave the loudest voices shaping the conversation.

    • The perception gap: How Americans overestimate the other side’s extreme views—and often assume those people dislike them, too.

    • Politics as the hardest divide: Stephen Hawkins on why connecting across political differences feels harder than connecting across race, class, or religion, and what holds people back.

    • A more inviting way in: Why working on a shared local problem can feel more welcoming than starting with a conversation about what divides us, and why people want a process that treats them with dignity and shows their participation can make a difference, even when they don’t get the outcome they wanted.

    • Feeling worn out, feeling shut out: What local research reveals about unequal belonging, trust, and influence—and the assumptions people make about whose voice counts.

    • Who has a way in: How education, income, age, and race shape people’s connections to community life and their opportunities to influence local decisions.

    • An invitation worth accepting: John Sarrouf on the Rod and Gun Club member who arrived skeptical and left wanting to talk with people on the other side, and why connection and belonging can be stronger motivators than fear and animosity.

    • Whose future are we creating? john a. powell on the anxiety of a changing world and the invitation to help shape what comes next.

    • The relationship before the breakthrough: How two Oklahoma legislators found common cause on maternal health, and what their example offers teachers, parents, community leaders, and others who want to build together.

    • Practical takeaways

      1. Give yourself room to rest. Taking a break from the news can protect your energy. But stepping away from community life altogether leaves the conversation to the loudest voices, so consider which relationships and parts of community life still feel worth staying connected to.

      2. Check your picture of the other side. We often imagine people we disagree with holding more extreme views, and feeling more hostility toward us, than they actually do.

      3. Start somewhere familiar. Your library, place of worship, kid’s soccer field, or the coffee shop where someone knows your name can offer a foothold. Invest a little more time there.

      4. Widen the circle. Look for a small way to connect with someone whose experiences or beliefs differ from yours, perhaps through a place or activity you already enjoy.

      5. Invite people into shared work. Give people a reason to come together around something they care about. The relationships they build can help them navigate harder conversations later.

      6. Make the invitation feel different. People who expect a fight will stay away. Ask real questions, listen to the answers, and make it clear that no one has to give up what they believe to take part.

      7. Ask who’s missing, and why. If you lead or organize, learn who feels shut out, what gets in the way, and what would make participation feel worthwhile.

      8. Build relationships before you need them. Knowing someone beyond a position or disagreement can open possibilities when a difficult issue arises.

      9. Make one meaningful contribution. Strengthen a relationship, support a local effort, or care for a place in your community. A manageable beginning can give you and someone else  a reason to keep showing up.

      10. Hosts

        Nichole Argo is the Founder and Executive Director of TogetherUp Institute.

        Scott Hutcheson is the Executive Director of E Pluribus Unum.

        Produced by Next Chapter Podcasts.

        27 min
      11. Season 2 - Episode 5 - The Courage to Listen

        No matter how you feel about last week’s shifts in national leadership, the deeper patterns that divide Americans haven’t changed: systems that reward confrontation, people who profit from our anger, the feeling that nobody’s listening. Those patterns show up in our communities, and with Thanksgiving coming, many of us will soon sit at a table with people who see this moment very differently. That makes now the time to invest in understanding each other.

        This season of Reimagining Us has asked what makes belonging possible—and what we can build together. Here, Dr. Nichole Argo and Scott Hutcheson turn to its most basic and potentially most powerful building block: listening deeply and being heard. Nichole and Scott explore research showing that nonjudgmental listening can reduce defensiveness and help people think more openly. They also discuss a brain-imaging study linking feeling understood with activity in the brain’s reward regions and a stronger sense of connection.

        But listening well isn’t always easy. Many of us avoid hard conversations because we fear being judged or misunderstood. And although we all have innate abilities when it comes to listening, John Sarrouf of Essential Partners reminds us that pressure and fear can make us lose touch with our best selves. The good news: with practice, we can find our way back.

        Melissa Weintraub of Resetting the Table explains why real connection requires that we address our differences, with care. One building block is an exercise called “getting to bullseye,” where people take turns showing that they understood exactly what someone else meant. And Mónica Guzmán shows that when mistakes happen, repair is possible. Those small acts help us come to know each other better and build trust.

        Relationships built over time can also help people stay engaged when conversations get hard. Nichole shares how those bonds kept people at the table when a difficult community conversation ended without resolution.

        Planning a conversation you’re nervous about? The Conversation Coach, a free online tool developed by E Pluribus Unum and TogetherUp Institute, can help you think it through before you have it. [www.conversationcoach.app]

        Next week: The Exhausted Majority—the many people who care but have stepped back, and what it would take to bring them back. In the meantime, who can you build with locally—and what might become possible if you understood each other better?

        •    Why now: what a change in leadership can't fix, and why the weeks before Thanksgiving are a good time to practice listening.

        •    Listening to understand: why fear of being judged keeps people quiet, and the difference between waiting for your turn and trying to understand.

        •    Co-regulation, and what the research shows: how two people's bodies and emotions respond to each other, how feeling understood activates the brain's reward and social-connection regions, and why being heard helps people see more sides of an issue.

        •    Room for strong convictions. Why people need to know that connecting across differences leaves room for their deepest values and real disagreements.

        •    Safe enough, and brave: John Sarrouf and Melissa Weintraub on why meaningful conversations need care and structure, but also the willingness to address what actually divides us.

        •    Rupture and repair: Mónica Guzmán on the importance of repairing relationships, alongside a community example of staying connected through unresolved disagreement.

        1.    Notice when you're coming in hot. Recognize when you’re already defensive or “coming in hot,” and give yourself time to settle before continuing.

        2.    Listen to understand, not to win. Set aside your next point and focus on what the other person is trying to say.

        3.    Ask a question that makes room. Try: “What do you wish I understood better?” Then give the person time to answer.

        4.    Reflect back what you heard. Then ask: “Have I got that right?”

        5.    Don't stay only on safe topics. Real understanding grows when you address what matters, with care.

        6.    Pair candor with care. Give difficult topics enough time and agree on how you’ll handle disagreement. In groups, structure and facilitation matter.

        7.    Return and repair. Follow up when a conversation goes badly. Clarify misunderstandings, apologize where needed, and keep tending the relationship.

        8.    Remember there's always next Friday. A conversation that goes badly doesn't have to be the last one. Come back to it, and repair what you can.

        9.    Prepare with the Conversation Coach. Use the free online tool developed by E Pluribus Unum and TogetherUp Institute to think through a potentially difficult conversation you’d like to have and how you want to approach it.

        Nichole Argo is the Founder and Executive Director of TogetherUp Institute.

        Scott Hutcheson is the Executive Director of E Pluribus Unum.

        Produced by Next Chapter Podcasts.

        •    John Sarrouf, Co-Executive Director and Director of Program Development, Essential Partners. https://whatisessential.org

        •    Rabbi Melissa Weintraub, Co-Founder and Co-CEO, Resetting the Table. https://resettingthetable.org

        •    Mónica Guzmán, Senior Fellow for Public Practice, Braver Angels; author of I Never Thought of It That Way: How to Have Fearlessly Curious Conversations in Dangerously Divided Times (BenBella Books, 2022). https://benbellabooks.com/shop/i-never-thought-of-it-that-way/

        •    Feeling understood. Morelli, Sylvia A., Jared B. Torre, and Naomi I. Eisenberger. “The Neural Bases of Feeling Understood and Not Understood.” Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience 9, no. 12 (2014): 1890–1896. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24396002/

        •    Listening and defensiveness. Itzchakov, Guy, Avraham N. Kluger, and Dotan R. Castro. “I Am Aware of My Inconsistencies but Can Tolerate Them: The Effect of High Quality Listening on Speakers’ Attitude Ambivalence.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 43, no. 1 (2017). https://cris.huji.ac.il/en/publications/i-am-aware-of-my-inconsistencies-but-can-tolerate-them-the-effect/

        •    Itzchakov, Guy, Kenneth G. DeMarree, Avraham N. Kluger, and Yaara Turjeman-Levi. “The Listener Sets the Tone: High-Quality Listening Increases Attitude Clarity and Behavior-Intention Consequences.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 44, no. 5 (2018): 762–778. https://doi.org/10.1177/0146167217747874

        •    Arao, Brian, and Kristi Clemens. “From Safe Spaces to Brave Spaces: A New Way to Frame Dialogue Around Diversity and Social Justice.” In The Art of Effective Facilitation, edited by Lisa M. Landreman, 135–150. Stylus Publishing, 2013.

        •    More in Common. The Connection Opportunity (2025). About 7 in 10 people who often connect across difference want to do so again, compared with fewer than 3 in 10 of those who rarely do. https://moreincommonus.com/publication/the-connection-opportunity

        •    [The article on co-regulated apologies, if you can find it.]

        •    The Conversation Coach, a free online tool developed by E Pluribus Unum and TogetherUp Institute. www.conversationcoach.app

        TitleShort descriptionLong descriptionKey discussion pointsPractical takeawaysHostsSources & further readingVoices in this episodeResearch cited in this episodeFurther readingTools

        25 min
      12. Season 2 - Episode 4 - Power as Care: Designing Civic Life People Want to Join

        People want to contribute to their communities. So why do so many feel disconnected from the places where decisions get made?

        This episode opens in a room Scott has sat in more times than he can count: smart, caring leaders who understand the data, nod at every point, and conclude they can’t act. But the world outside that room has changed. A rising tide of disconnection and division has altered the environment every community lives in, and that changes what’s being asked of the institutions that organize everyday life: schools and libraries, churches and nonprofits, foundations, municipal staff, and local leaders. In this episode of Reimagining Us, Nichole and Scott ask whether this moment hands those institutions a new responsibility, and opportunity: nurturing connection and collaboration within the community, e.g., the health of civic life itself.

        Institutions inherit routines, norms, and ways of engaging the public that can persist long after they stop working well — and organizationally, changing course can feel risky. Nichole and Scott make an honest case for operating as usual — for institutional neutrality — but also examine the consequences of letting inaction become the default. They even find, inside the most famous defense of institutional neutrality ever written — the University of Chicago’s 1967 Kalven Report — the exception that changes everything: when something threatens an institution’s very mission, neutrality is no longer an option. And for community institutions, that exception is the point. Their mission is community — its connection, its trust, its capacity to solve problems together. When those fray, engaging isn’t a departure from the mission. It is the mission. The question, in other words, is mission-critical.

        Featuring Kristen Scott Kennedy, Executive Vice President of the Council on Foundations, and Daniel Stid, board chair of More in Common and author of The Art of Association, the episode moves from bridging and belonging to a deeper question of agency: Do people have meaningful opportunities to speak, contribute, deliberate, and shape the communities they live in?

        Drawing on their own and others’ local-level research, the hosts argue that the answer is less about convincing people to care and more about redesigning the containers we ask them to enter. Stid tells the story of a beautiful park near his home, fenced off for eighteen months, and the contentious public meeting that showed him why participation has to feel like something worth returning to. A public meeting, a community dinner, a library, or a grantmaking process can either make civic life feel aversive….or create an experience people want to come back to.

        The episode ultimately offers a different way to think about institutional power: power as care. Not simply delivering services, but stewarding the norms, spaces, and processes that help communities build relationships, exercise voice, and solve problems together.

        The takeaway? If people are willing to participate but lack meaningful opportunities to do so, disconnection is not simply a personal problem. It is a design problem, and we need our institutions to help solve it.

        Key Discussion Points

        • Why Institutions Hold Back: Familiar routines, perceived risk, and institutional inertia can make inaction feel safer than change.

        • When Neutrality Serves a Purpose: Neutrality can protect trust, pluralism, and institutional mission, but it should be chosen deliberately, not by default.

        • Connection Needs Agency: Bridging relationships matter, but belonging is incomplete if people still lack meaningful voice in decisions that affect them.

        • Participation Is Designed: The norms and processes surrounding civic engagement help determine whether people return, or walk away.

        • The Opportunity Gap: Many Americans say they want to connect and contribute but lack clear opportunities to do so.

        • Power as Care: Institutions can use their freedom and resources to create durable civic infrastructure that strengthens community over time.

        • Practical Takeaways


          • Look at the container, not just the participant. If people are disengaging, examine whether the experience of participation is welcoming, meaningful, and consequential.

          • Create real pathways to agency. Give people opportunities not only to attend or speak, but to influence what happens next.

          • Treat neutrality as a choice. Ask what your institution exists to protect, and what action or inaction means for that mission.

          • Design for return. Build civic experiences people want to come back to, not ones that require extraordinary willpower to endure.

          • Invest for the long term. Connection, trust, and civic capacity grow through sustained institutions, relationships, and spaces, not one-off programs.

          • Use power as care. Ask how your institution’s authority, resources, and convening power can help a community participate, connect, and shape its future.

          • 40 min
          • Season 2 - Episode 3 - What Makes Civic Life Sacred?

            What makes a group of strangers become the kind of people who visit one another in the hospital, check on an elderly neighbor, or come together when their community is in crisis?

            In this episode of Reimagining Us, Dr. Nichole Argo and Scott Hutcheson explore what makes civic life feel not merely obligatory, but meaningful—even sacred. Drawing on stories from communities across the country and insights from Sam Pressler, john a. powell, Seth Kaplan, and Dan Gutekanst, they examine what happens when people repeatedly experience being seen, valued, and needed by one another.

            The answer is about more than participation. It is about relationship.

            From an arts class where strangers became a community of care, to the Zulu concept of Sawubona—“I see you”—Nichole and Scott explore how recognition and shared experience can transform the way we understand our responsibility to one another. Relationships can widen our “circle of concern,” turning people who once seemed distant or abstract into people whose lives and well-being matter to us.

            But belonging also has a shadow side. History shows that tightly connected communities can still exclude, segregate, and reinforce inequality. The challenge, then, is not simply to create more belonging, but to intentionally build opportunities for people across race, class, age, identity, and experience to encounter one another, develop relationships, and shape community life together.

            The episode ultimately asks us to reconsider what civic infrastructure is for. It isn’t simply about meetings, programs, or institutions. At its best, civic life creates repeated opportunities for people to show up, be seen, contribute, experience joy, and build the reserve of relationships and trust that communities can draw upon when times get hard.

            The takeaway? Civic life becomes powerful when people experience themselves as part of something larger—and when we intentionally design that sense of belonging to include everyone.

            Key Discussion Points

            • Why Joy Matters in Civic Life: Sam Pressler challenges the idea that civic participation should feel like “eating your spinach.” If we want people to participate, community life has to offer meaning, connection, fun, and a genuine sense that showing up is worthwhile.

            • The Power of Being Seen: john a. powell introduces Sawubona, a Zulu expression meaning “I see you.” Recognition, dignity, and compassionate presence are not small gestures; they are fundamental human needs and building blocks of belonging.

            • Expanding the Circle of Concern: Relationships with people whose identities, experiences, or beliefs differ from our own can change who we consider part of “us.” We may still disagree, but we begin to account for one another’s humanity when we make decisions.

            • The Double Edge of Belonging: America’s history of local civic associations demonstrates the tremendous power of community institutions—but also their capacity to exclude. Civic renewal without attention to equity can strengthen belonging for some while leaving others outside the circle.

            • Designing a Bigger “Us”: Strong civic infrastructure creates repeated opportunities for people across differences to build relationships, work together, and have a meaningful voice in shaping their community. The goal is not simply participation, but belonging that crosses social and economic lines.

            • Relationships as Community Resilience: The relationships communities build during ordinary times become especially valuable during moments of conflict or crisis. The experience of Needham, Massachusetts, shows why trust and relationships are far easier to draw upon in an emergency when they have already been built beforehand.

            • Practical Takeaways

              1. Make participation worth showing up for. Joy, meaning, relationships, and shared purpose are not extras; they are part of what keeps people engaged.

              2. Practice seeing people fully. Move beyond roles, labels, and demographics toward genuine recognition and curiosity about another person’s experience.

              3. Ask who is missing. A connected community is not necessarily an inclusive one. Pay attention to whose voices, relationships, and experiences are absent.

              4. Create repeated contact across differences. One-off encounters matter, but belonging grows through recurring opportunities to work, create, celebrate, and solve problems together.

              5. Build relationships before you need them. Trust is infrastructure. Communities are more resilient when people and institutions already know how to reach one another before conflict or crisis arrives.

              6. Hosts:

                Nichole Argo is the Founder and Executive Director of⁠ TogetherUp Institute⁠

                Scott Hutcheson is the Executive Director of⁠ E Pluribus Unum⁠

                Produced by⁠ Next Chapter Podcasts⁠


                Sources cited in the episode

                • Pressler, Sam. Founder, Armed Services Arts Partnership; author of Connective Tissue (newsletter and policy framework). (the arts class; "eating your spinach"; embedding connection in housing)

                • Cox, Daniel A., and Sam Pressler. Disconnected: The Growing Class Divide in American Civic Life. Survey Center on American Life, American Enterprise Institute, August 22, 2024; survey of 6,597 adults. (the education divide in civic life)

                • powell, john a. Director, Othering and Belonging Institute, UC Berkeley. (Sawubona; being seen; the circle of concern)

                • Ellison, Ralph. Invisible Man. Random House, 1952. (named by powell)

                • Brooks, Arthur C. Love Your Enemies: How Decent People Can Save America from the Culture of Contempt.Broadside Books, 2019. (powell's friendship with Brooks)

                • Kaplan, Seth D. Fragile Neighborhoods: Repairing American Society, One Zip Code at a Time. Little, Brown Spark, 2023. (the woman at 903; the Great Quieting)

                • National Women's History Museum. "National Association of Colored Women." (founded 1896; Mary Church Terrell)

                • National Park Service. "Maggie L. Walker." (St. Luke Penny Savings Bank, Richmond)

                • Center for Inclusion and Belonging, American Immigration Council. Understanding Belonging Where It Is Lived.2026 research brief on the 2025 Belonging Mixed Methods Study, using the Belonging Barometer developed with Over Zero. (older adults report stronger local belonging)

                • TogetherUp Institute. CivicWorks, Needham, MA; with Dan Gutekanst, Needham Superintendent of Schools (Season 1, Episode 8). (relationships built before a crisis)

                • Background research

                  • Crimston, Daniel, Paul G. Bain, Matthew J. Hornsey, and Brock Bastian. "Moral Expansiveness: Examining Variability in the Extension of the Moral World." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 111, no. 4 (2016): 636–653. (the circle of moral concern)

                  • Singer, Peter. The Expanding Circle: Ethics and Sociobiology. Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1981. (origin of the expanding-circle idea)

                  • Holt-Lunstad, Julianne, et al. Social Connection in America. Barnes Family Foundation, 2025. (community ties, health and wellbeing)

                  • Office of the U.S. Surgeon General. Our Epidemic of Loneliness and Isolation. 2023. (connection and community health, cohesion and resilience)

                  • Skocpol, Theda, Marshall Ganz, and Ziad Munson. "A Nation of Organizers: The Institutional Origins of Civic Voluntarism in the United States." American Political Science Review 94, no. 3 (2000): 527–546. (late-19th-century boom in chapter-based associations)

                  • Putnam, Robert D., with Shaylyn Romney Garrett. The Upswing: How America Came Together a Century Ago and How We Can Do It Again. Simon & Schuster, 2020. (Gilded Age to Progressive Era civic revival)

                  • Skocpol, Theda, Ariane Liazos, and Marshall Ganz. What a Mighty Power We Can Be: African American Fraternal Groups and the Struggle for Racial Equality. Princeton University Press, 2006. (Black Americans building their own institutions)

                  • Cox, Karen L. Dixie's Daughters: The United Daughters of the Confederacy and the Preservation of Confederate Culture. University Press of Florida, 2003. (Scott on the Daughters of the Confederacy and the Lost Cause)

                  • Aldrich, Daniel P. Building Resilience: Social Capital in Post-Disaster Recovery. University of Chicago Press, 2012. (relationships as crisis infrastructure)

                  • TogetherUp Institute. Pleasanton Community Connection Survey. 2025. (belonging accumulates with time and tenure)


                  • 31 min
                  • Season 2 - Episode 2 - Embracing Complexity, Letting Go of Control

                    Why do so many well-intentioned efforts to bridge our political and social divides struggle to create lasting change?

                    In this episode of Reimagining Us, Dr. Nichole Argo and Scott Hutcheson explore why even promising efforts to bridge political and social divides can struggle to produce lasting change. Moving beyond the assumption that bringing people together for conversation is enough, they examine the psychological and systemic forces that sustain polarization and what it takes to counter them.

                    Their central insight? **Lasting change requires both a shift in how we relate to one another and structures that make those relationships possible to sustain. That means cultivating curiosity rather than defensiveness, embracing complexity rather than reaching for simple solutions, and investing in civic infrastructure that brings people across identities and sectors into lasting relationship and shared action.


                    Key Discussion Points

                    • Clock Problems vs. Cloud Problems: Columbia University conflict researcher Peter Coleman draws on philosopher Karl Popper to distinguish between mechanical "clock problems" (fixable, single-point breakdowns) and complex "cloud problems" (self-reinforcing, multi-layered system failures like toxic polarization). Coleman and the hosts discuss how treating polarization as a simple clock problem often backfires because social systems naturally compensate and resist simple fixes.

                    • How Polarization Flattens Communities: John Sarrouf (Co-Executive Director of Essential Partners) explains how contentious local issues can transform neighbors into opposing camps, reducing complex people to one-dimensional adversaries. As conflict intensifies, moderate voices withdraw and the loudest dominate. Nichole and Scott explore how overlapping relationships and shared institutions can help buffer communities against these dynamics.

                    • Building Civic Infrastructure for Lasting Connection: Curiosity is essential, but individual conversations alone cannot overcome the structural forces that keep us divided. Nichole and Scott explore the need to build lasting civic infrastructure that creates opportunities for sustained relationships across identities, communities, and sectors. Through initiatives like TogetherUp's CivicWorks, locally representative networks bring residents, community leaders, and institutions together to build trust, develop skills, and work collectively on shared challenges. The goal isn't simply more dialogue, but stronger relationships and greater capacity to act together over time.

                    • The Intolerance of Uncertainty: Nichole and Scott explore why uncertainty can feel so threatening, and how our brains and bodies respond when the world feels unpredictable or beyond our control. When uncertainty triggers fear or anxiety, we may gravitate toward simplified, binary narratives and quick fixes that promise certainty and control. But what if we could learn to embrace complexity rather than retreat from it?

                    • The "Toggle" Between Curiosity and Defense: Journalist and author Mónica Guzmán (I Never Thought of It That Way) explains how difficult conversations can shift us from wanting to understand to wanting to defend ourselves or win, often without our realizing it. By noticing physical signs of tension, we can recognize that shift and choose how to respond, whether by pausing, acknowledging our discomfort, or stepping away until we're ready to reengage with curiosity.

                    • Curiosity as a Form of Care: In conversation with peacebuilding expert John Paul Lederach and author Scott Shigeoka (Seek), Nichole and Scott explore how curiosity can help us move toward people we fear or disagree with, rather than retreating into judgment. By asking genuine questions and recognizing our shared humanity and interdependence, we create space for understanding and connection, even when we disagree.

                    • Practical Takeaways

                      1. Notice the Physical Radar: Pay attention to bodily sensations (gut, throat, chest) that signal you've moved from curiosity to defensive mode.

                      2. Ask One Real Question: Instead of setting a trap to win an argument, ask a genuine question about how the other person came to hold their perspective.

                      3. Show Your Math: Walk others through your thought process and life experiences rather than just stating and defending a rigid conclusion.

                      4. Start Close to Home: Practice holding space and being curious with family or neighbors before tackling intense public or political arenas.

                      5. Name the Feeling Underneath: Recognize that hostility and anger are often armor for underlying fear, anxiety, or vulnerability.


                      6. HOSTS:

                        Nichole Argo is the Founder and Executive Director of TogetherUp Institute

                        Scott Hutcheson is the Executive Director of E Pluribus Unum

                        Produced by Next Chapter Podcasts

                        42 min
                      7. Season 2 - Episode 1 - The Architecture of Belonging

                        What if belonging isn't something we find, but something we can intentionally create?

                        In the Season 2 premiere of Reimagining Us, hosts Nichole Argo and Scott Hutcheson shift the conversation from what's pulling us apart to what we can build together. Drawing on insights from social psychology, community-based research, and conversations with leading thinkers, they explore the hidden architecture of belonging: the everyday interactions, shared spaces, and local institutions that shape whether we feel connected, valued, and able to make a difference.

                        From the science of belonging to the surprising power of libraries, front porches, neighborhood gatherings, and even a simple smile, this episode reveals how our environments can either bring us together or keep us apart. Featuring insights from Peter Coleman, Seth Kaplan, Daniel Stid, and Sam Pressler, Nichole and Scott consider what it takes to design communities where people don't just live alongside one another, but genuinely feel part of something larger.


                        The takeaway? Connection doesn't happen by accident. And if we've designed a world that too often keeps us apart, we can begin designing one that brings us back together.


                        Nichole Argo is the Founder and Executive Director of TogetherUp Institute


                        Scott Hutcheson is the Executive Director of E Pluribus Unum


                        Produced by Next Chapter Podcasts

                        39 min
                      8. Introducing...Season 2 of Reimagining Us

                        In Season 2 of Reimagining Us, we go deeper...


                        If you care about connection, community and real change, this season is for you!


                        Reimagining Us is a podcast series that "lifts the hood" to uncover what's behind our feelings of division today, identify how we can rebuild connection and collaboration across differences in communities. The show is hosted by behavioral scientist Nichole Argo, the Founder and Executive Director of the TogetherUp Institute & Scott Hutcheson, Executive Director of E Pluribus Unum.

                        • Nichole Argo, Ph.D.: A behavioral scientist and Founder/Executive Director of the TogetherUp Institute, Nichole brings cutting-edge insights from the psychology of human conflict and connection to understand why we feel divided, and what we can do about it.

                        • Scott Hutcheson: Executive Director of E Pluribus Unum, Scott offers a wealth of experience addressing systemic inequities and fostering meaningful collaboration across race, class, and culture in the Deep South and beyond. As a region often at the epicenter of racial, political, and economic divides, the Deep South offers a powerful lens for exploring and addressing these issues nationwide.

                        • Together, Nichole and Scott create a dynamic, solutions-oriented conversation that engages listeners with authenticity, curiosity, and expertise.

                          For more information or to share your stories and feedback, email [email protected], or comment on YouTube and Social Media @togetherupinstitute

                          Reimagining Us is produced by Next Chapter Podcasts


                          2 min
                        • Episode 8 - "Bright Spots: The Needham Resilience Network”

                          In this episode, Nichole and Scott explore how philanthropy is getting behind work to connect and collaborate across differences at the local level with Kristen Scott Kennedy of the Council on Foundations. They then highlight a scalable example of this work: The Needham Resilience Network (NRN) brings town officials, diverse residents, and key stakeholders together to build relationships, anchor in the concept of belonging, learn skills in communicating across differences, and co-create solutions to local problems.

                          This episode opens with Kristen Scott Kennedy discussing how philanthropy can play a critical role in place-based work to connect across differences by acting as norm-shapers, modeling collaborative strategies, and supporting nonprofits.

                          Then, Needham Resilience Network members Bala Venkat, John Schlittler, Rabbi Jay Perlman, Marcus Nelson, Dan Gutekanst, and Beth Pinals talk about how the NRN has influenced their lives and transformed their community. The NRN was founded in response to significant challenges faced by the Needham community in Massachusetts, including demographic shifts, increased hate incidents, and distrust between groups. 


                          Actionable Takeaways:


                          For Individuals, Nonprofits, and Municipal Officials:

                          • Adopt the Long View: Recognize that meaningful cultural and social change will require ongoing commitment and care.
                          • Emphasize Collaboration Amongst Diverse Stakeholders for Greater Impact: Cultivate broad partnerships and coalitions across organizations, community leaders, and residents to co-create impactful events and initiatives. Involve both formal and informal leaders who represent different parts of the community, including marginalized groups.
                          • Invest in Relationships: Develop protocols and nurture relationships in stable times to prepare for future challenges. 
                          • Encourage Diverse Voices: Actively invite underrepresented groups to participate in community dialogues and leadership.
                          • Elevate Belonging: Incorporate narratives and activities that foster a sense of belonging and shared purpose.
                          • Employ Evidence-Based Design, & Do No Harm: Prioritize evidence-based approaches to programming; design with an eye towards “Do No Harm”; and begin initiatives with a "listening tour" to understand community needs and build trust .
                          • Center on Skill-Building: Train participants in listening to understand vs. persuade and conflict transformation skills
                          • Leverage Local Data for Reflection & Relationship-Building: Incorporate local data to ground discussions in shared realities and enable storytelling around lived experiences.
                          • Foster Community Co-Governance: Create channels for community involvement in governance, focusing on shared values and co-creation.
                          • Utilize Networks During Crises: Maintain open communication channels with diverse groups to resolve conflicts with sensitivity.
                          • Engage Local Foundations: Identify and partner with local or regional foundations that are invested in the community.


                            For Philanthropic Organizations:

                            • Model Best Practices in Pluralism: Use your freedom to showcase innovative approaches to collaboration, influencing broader societal norms.
                            • Invest in Local Partners: Strengthen community-based nonprofits that are on the frontlines of building connection and resilience.


                              Resources:

                              • READ: “Coming Together, Not Apart: How Philanthropy Supports Connection in a Time of Dangerous Division,” and “Coming Together, Not Apart: Inside the Work of Turning Conflict Into Cooperation,” by the Council on Foundations
                              • WATCH: The Needham Resilience Network information video
                              • VISIT: The NRN website
                              • READ: “My Parting Prescription for America,” by former Surgeon General Vivek Murthy, Jan 7, 2025. Community as the formula for fulfillment.

                              • HOSTS:

                                Nichole Argo is the Founder and Executive Director of TogetherUp Institute

                                Scott Hutcheson is the Executive Director of E Pluribus Unum

                                Produced by Next Chapter Podcasts

                                52 min
                              • Episode 7 - "Transforming Our Communities"

                                In this episode, Nichole and Scott talk about how individual and group efforts to revitalize connection in communities are necessary---but may not be sufficient for sustained change. Once we have the mindset and skills of pluralism, we need spaces and institutions that enable us to practice them. We need local governments and community stakeholders to invest in policies that foster “civic infrastructure.” Special guests Sam Pressler and Layla Zaidane help us explore the role of policy and institutions in fostering this kind of connection.

                                In order to thrive, Sam Pressler argues that local governments and community leaders should refocus on building civic life, prioritizing relationships and belonging as part of their policies and initiatives. Sam introduces the Connective Tissue Framework, which identifies over 150 policy opportunities to strengthen community connections, and highlights examples of this work, like Boston's Office of Civic Organizing (which fosters neighborhood interactions through block party grants and cleanup events) and citizen-government partnerships to create welcoming materials for newcomers, or “Old Home Weeks” to bring former residents back for community-building activities.

                                Layla Zaidane, the President and CEO of Future Caucus, describes how organizations focused on relationship building can promote collaboration across differences, just as Future Caucus does with young elected officials, regardless of political affiliation—by leveraging a shared, third identity (for Future Caucus, generation). While receiving training in leadership, communication, negotiation and bridge-building, young lawmakers build personal relationships, allowing them to see beyond polarization and find common ground across the aisle. Layla emphasizes the importance of “institutionalizing relationships across differences” in order to ensure continued contact and support.


                                Actionable Steps For Communities:
                                • Create Inclusive Spaces:
                                • Develop public parks, libraries, and community centers as hubs for connection.
                                • Design accessible spaces that encourage diverse groups to gather and interact.
                                • Promote Civic Engagement:
                                • Organize town-wide events like block parties, festivals, or cultural celebrations.
                                • Start initiatives like "Neighborhood Watch" or "Adopt-a-Street" programs to foster collaboration.
                                • Develop Welcome Initiatives:
                                • Create welcome kits for newcomers with resources about local services and groups and host orientation meet-and-greets to integrate new residents.
                                • Support Bridging Activities:
                                • Provide micro-grants for projects that bring different groups together, such as intergenerational programs or cross-cultural events.
                                • Encourage shared-use facilities for meetings, classes, or celebrations.
                                • Use a Connection Lens in Policy:
                                • Embed policies that strengthen social capital into housing, education, and transportation planning.
                                • Incentivize participatory design in public projects to ensure residents feel a sense of ownership.

                                • HOSTS:

                                  Nichole Argo is the Founder and Executive Director of TogetherUp Institute

                                  Scott Hutcheson is the Executive Director of E Pluribus Unum

                                  Produced by Next Chapter Podcasts

                                  47 min
                                • Episode 6 - "Be The Change - Part II - Tool Chest"

                                  Imagine that four experts on bridging divides came together to advise you on how to handle your next challenging conversation…Voila! Meet the “Be The Change” tool chest! On this episode of Reimagining Us, hosts Nichole Argo and Scott Hutcheson ask questions such as:

                                  • What strategies can I use to build my curiosity muscle?
                                  • How do I prepare for a conversation across differences?
                                  • Do I need to bridge with everyone?
                                  • How do you engage with someone who isn’t interested in being curious?
                                  • What do you do in a conversation where you think, “This person is crazy!”
                                  • What do you do when someone says something offensive, or harmful?
                                  • What’s a good dialogue strategy for sharing my position?

                                  • John Sarrouf, Melissa Weintraub, Monica Guzman, and Scott Shigeoka share actionable tools and strategies for fostering curiosity, connection and understanding that can help listeners engage effectively in conversations across differences. 

                                    Use this tool chest as a foundation that you can return to again and again as you connect across differences! 


                                    Actionable Takeaways:


                                    Prepare for Conversations

                                    1. Challenge Your Echo Chambers: Write down whose perspectives you’re not exposed to, or haven’t considered. Plan to engage with at least one new source of information or person this week.
                                    2. Reflect on Your Motivation. Approach each conversation as an opportunity to learn, understand others, and uncover the complexity of an issue. 
                                    3. Question “single story” narratives that depict individuals or groups as “just one thing.” 
                                    4. Name and Check Your Assumptions. Write down your assumptions (e.g., “They think I’m lazy”) and test them by seeking direct feedback when appropriate.
                                    5. Consider Your Bridging Boundaries. We don’t have to bridge with everyone – it’s okay to opt out if engagement feels too costly. That said, reflect on whether your "red lines" stem from a lack of understanding or genuine need for emotional safety.
                                    6. Practice Mental Preparation: Rehearse your approach before your next challenging conversation. Visualize questions, reactions, and ways to stay curious.

                                    7. During Engagement

                                      1. Move Divisive Conversations Off Social Media to encourage richer dialogue. Consider calling or meeting in person.
                                      2. Use “Splitting”: Start conversations by clarifying what you don’t mean to address potential misunderstandings and ease the other person’s concerns. Then focus on explaining your position in a way that opens space for understanding rather than entrenching divides.
                                      3. Recognize When You’re Feeling Triggered as this often shifts your motives from understanding to self-defense or domination. Take proactive steps—pause, reframe, or share your feelings calmly.
                                      4. Approach Offensive or Harmful Remarks with honesty about your feelings. Avoid shaming or dominating; instead, seek to understand the deeper values behind others’ perspectives.


                                        After Engagement

                                        1. Question Your Priors on Success and Failure. Success is not about changing minds but about fostering understanding and maintaining or repairing relationships. Conversations that allow for moments of discovery, even if minor, are inherently successful.
                                        2. Trust Curiosity and Be Patient. Curiosity and openness can build understanding over time. 


                                          Resources

                                          • Read I NEVER THOUGHT OF IT THAT WAY: How to Have Fearlessly Curious Conversations in Dangerously Divided Times by Monica Guzman
                                          • Read SEEK: How Curiosity Can Transform Your Life and Change the World, by Scott Shigeoka  
                                          • Visit Essential Partners at www.whatisessential.org
                                          • Visit Resetting the Table at www.resettingthetable.org

                                          • For more information or to share your stories and feedback, email [email protected], or comment on YouTube and Social Media @togetherupinstitute


                                            HOSTS:

                                            Nichole Argo is the Founder and Executive Director of TogetherUp Institute

                                            Scott Hutcheson is the Executive Director of E Pluribus Unum

                                            Produced by Next Chapter Podcasts

                                            52 min