Bill opened the show by crediting the Toronto Blue Jays for bouncing back to beat the Dodgers in Game 4 of the World Series. Bill and Ryan then discussed their Halloween costumes before Bill criticized the Steelers defense for severely underperforming this season. Start/Bench/Cut was next as Bill ranked whether Shohei Ohtani, Victor Wembanyama or Patrick Mahomes will be the best athlete three years from now and which holiday tradition is the best. Hour two opened with Mike Florio joining the show to discuss how the NBA betting scandal could impact the NFL and if the Steelers need to move on from Mike Tomlin. Buy or Sell was next as Bill answered if he's concerned about the Dodgers offense and if Thursday is a must-win game for the Ravens. The show ended with Bill taking a call and continuing to express his concern about the Steelers.