There are times when obedience is deadly, when following the rules, sticking to the plan or hiding behind the institution means ignoring the subtleties of life as it unfolds in front of us.

Relational disobedience is the choice to refuse that deadening obedience. It is the courage to respond as a living sensing creative human being. It means listening more deeply than the policy allows. Caring when the system tells you to move on. Staying open to complexity when the institution demands a simple tick box. Choosing presence over prediction, relationship over regulation, creativity over compliance.

Relational disobedience is not rebellion for its own sake. It is fidelity to something more alive and more real than the machine logic of our institutions. It is a refusal to betray our own humanity and a commitment to the subtle harmony of the world we share. This is the call the invitation. Step out of the dinosaur logic of control and step into the living weave of relationship, become disobedient so that life, creativity, and care may flow again.

Institutions by their very nature are blunt instruments. They simplify complexity, reduce variety, and attempt to control what cannot be controlled. They lumber like dinosaurs in a living world that is always more subtle and more varied than the plans they impose upon it. The result is predictable, side effects, unintended consequences, harm to the very people and places we claim to serve.

Science, technology, computer models and policy studies, valuable though they are, cannot match the nuance of human life and ecological systems.

And yet there is hope. Institutions are not machines. They're made up of people. People who think, feel, imagine, and care. People with brains and bodies attuned to complexity. People with the capacity and the souls for unlimited creativity.

The invitation then is simple but profound. Stop trying to master life with plans that can never be subtle enough. Start creating conditions where human creativity, values and feelings can shape responses as they unfold. Replace control with care, prediction with presence, and compliance with creativity.

This is not the abandonment of institutions. It is their renewal. It is the way they might evolve from dinosaurs of control into hosts of possibility, capable not of domination, but of participation in the living systems of which we are part.

Of becoming places fit to house the human spirit.

Relational disobedience is the seed of this transformation. It begins in the choices of individuals, but it holds out a vision of institutions that are no longer at war with the world, but in harmony with it.

Relational Disobedience: A Way Beyond the Dinosaurs of Control.

How can any plan or policy meet the challenges of a system that is more subtle and varied than the institution that seeks to control it? We know the answer... it can't. Interventions that rely on control, prediction and standardisation are doomed to failure.

Science, technology, computer models, policy studies, they all fall short of the task. What is needed is something at least as subtle, as alive and as sensitive as the world itself.

That something is us.

Not our institutions, which lumber like dinosaurs, clumsy in their attempts to dominate complexity, but our living, sensing, feeling, creating selves.

Each one of us carries within us the tools to navigate complexity. A human brain, body, heart, and soul, attuned to relationship, alive to nuance, capable of creativity.

Relational disobedience is the name we give to this way of being. It's the refusal to collapse into the dead weight of prescribed systems. It's the choice to honour creativity over compliance, care over control, presence over prediction.

It's the practice of saying "I will not reduce life to categories and metrics. I will not let the logic of the institution override the reality of the relationship. I will respond as a human being, alive, feeling and creative."

This is not disobedience for its own sake. It is disobedience in service of a deeper obedience to the subtleties and beauty of life, to the coherence of our planet, and to the call of our shared humanity.

Institutions may lumber on, but when we choose relational disobedience, we remind ourselves and each other that harmony is not imposed from above. It is born in the living weave of human creativity, values, thoughts, and feelings. Relational disobedience is not a doctrine. It cannot be prescribed. It is ever changing and ever new because it arises from one place institutions cannot touch: our capacity to care, to love, to imagine, and to create together.

Thanks for reading Fresh Thinking! This post is public so feel free to share it.

If you would like to join our exploration of relational disobedience please do get in touch.

Get full access to Fresh Thinking at freshthinking.substack.com/subscribe