The sisters have officially descended on Nantucket for the summer, recording from bed on day four of commune life: 11 adults, six kids, and zero personal space. Clare has prepared Andrew a full orientation guide (no sleeping in, house chores mandatory), Erin woke up at 4am with her OCD reaching new heights, and Megan's camp counselor energy can't be contained. Also on the agenda: the crusty versus greasy personality debate, puka versus chain, a live CoStar reading under the Strawberry Moon, and a tick paranoia spiral that ends with Erin offering to check Clare's butt. That's what sisters are for.

Erin, Cat, and Clare are back in the chat this week, diving into the highs, lows, and absolute chaos of modern dating - and whether anyone should still be holding fish in their Hinge profile photos. The sisters swap stories about blind dates, debate relationship dealbreakers, and share the moments they knew they'd found their person (or at least stopped getting the ick). Plus: a debate on soulmates, internet dating culture, and the growing challenge of meeting people in real life. Along the way, they revisit Jesse McCartney nostalgia, discuss Cat's latest side-hustle ambitions, and relive Erin’s brief yet glamorous music video career. 

Erin, Megan, Cat, and Clare are in the chat this week. The sisters get into what it's actually been like climbing cringe mountain, early lessons from leaping before you're ready, and why they're still climbing anyway. Erin opens up about starting Pepper Home, experimenting in public, overcoming doubt, and why pushing through those early setbacks is a skill everyone needs to develop. Plus: the sisters find their Kardashian counterparts (Megan is absolutely Kim), a full sister fight club breakdown, and everything they're trying, buying, and loving this week.

All five sisters are in the chat for this one. We get into birth order, eldest daughter trauma (or lack thereof), and what growing up in a big family actually does to you — the roles you never asked for, the comparisons you couldn't avoid, and the siblings who shaped you before you even knew it was happening. Turns out the oldest got off easy, the middle child's therapist has notes, and the youngest has thoughts. Plus: relationship advice from the elders that actually worked and TBLs all around.

Fresh off a blepharoplasty (aka a bleph) and looking a little bit like Zorro, Erin arrives ready for a full show-and-tell. What starts as a reveal turns into a candid conversation about cosmetic procedures, body image, and whether Instagram has completely distorted the way we see ourselves. Clare finally tells the dog story — including Dad’s deal, the puppy that never came, and the negotiation tactic only an older sister could finagle. The May book lineup gets its moment, Clare’s LA trip is thoroughly dissected, and the shared-calendar phase of her relationship is officially confirmed. Plus: TBLs, side hustles, and an introvert identity crisis.

All our TBLs: https://shopmy.us/relativechaos/shelves

May Calendar:

Rivals Season 2 — TV show on Hulu/Disney+, premiered May 15. Based on Jilly Cooper's Rutshire Chronicles. 

Elsie Silver — Fever Dream — out May 19. 

Annabelle Monaghan — Dolly All the Time — May 2026.

R.S. Grey — Our Secret Summer — out May 5. 

Sisters on this Episode: Erin, Megan & Cat

Cat has some exciting news that's going to make our family a little bit bigger. She comes in with every burning question a first-time mom has, and Erin and Megan keep it completely real. Delivery stories, postpartum depression, losing yourself a little and finding your way back — no glossing over the hard parts, but plenty of the things that actually help and the moments that remind you why it's all worth it. With six kids under eight between them, they have a lot to say and hold nothing back: the joy, the overwhelm, and everything you wish someone had told you going in.

Plus all the things we're trying, buying and loving this week. Find them here

Books Recs: 

• The Deal (Off-Campus Book 1)
• Expecting Better by Emily Oster
• Mom's on Call 

Erin, Megan, Cat and Clare get into what it actually means to be a loving critic, and why the older you get, the fewer you have. When do you actually start feeling like an adult? (Spoiler: you don't.) Plus, we play the thought bubble game (three words that sum up each sister) and get into everything we're trying, buying, and loving this week.

Sisters on this episode: Erin, Megan, Cat

Erin comes back from vacation with a new concept to discuss — adult pro max. What does it actually mean to operate at the highest level of adulthood? How do you split that with a partner without losing your mind or your marriage? And what actually makes someone attractive in your 30s versus your 20s? Plus: what happens when your sister suggests hibachi for your 40th birthday, the inherent rizz of Harry Styles, and everything we're trying, buying, and loving.

Erin, Megan and Clare chat hot takes on the Love Story show (skip if you’re over it!), Clare's new relationship (total PGOM!), manifesting and why every woman needs a partner who will "yuck it up" with her. Plus: a detour into fairy smut and our current obsessions