Respectfully, You're Wrong

Send us Fan Mail

Some wrestling moments don’t just miss, they change how you watch the product. We sit down and build our Top 10 list of the most disappointing moments in wrestling history, digging into WWE and WCW booking decisions that killed momentum, wasted years of buildup, or left fans staring at the screen asking, “For who and for what?”

We jump from legendary what-ifs like Scott Hall never getting a world title run to modern frustrations like uneven WrestleMania builds and endings that feel rushed. We also get into the moments that still make people mad decades later: The Undertaker streak ending and what it meant once the streak was gone, Starrcade 1997’s bungled finish, the failed promise of the Invasion angle, and the Fingerpoke of Doom as the symbol of creative freefall. Along the way we talk presentation problems, including why a debut can fall flat even when the talent is money, and why exposing the “behind the curtain” side of wrestling can make it harder to buy into anything.

We don’t dodge the uncomfortable parts either. We discuss racially tone-deaf angles, how lazy “heat” damages careers, and why it feels like certain wrestlers get protected while others get sacrificed, including the lasting debate around Brock Lesnar squashing Kofi Kingston. If you love pro wrestling, this is part rant, part history lesson, and part group therapy.

Listen, then tell us what we got wrong. Subscribe, share the show with a wrestling friend, and leave a review so more fans can jump into the argument.

Send us Fan Mail

You can tell a lot about a wrestling fan by what they value most at WrestleMania: clean workrate, big moments, surprise returns, or an ending that flips a character’s whole direction. We bring Respectfully Wrong together with From My Perspective to rank the top 10 matches from WrestleMania, starting with our personal lists and then negotiating one collective list the hard way.

We get into the messy middle where the arguments live: why the women’s tag match lands on the board because of the Paige return, how Finn Balor bringing back The Demon changes the stakes of a street fight, and why Cody Rhodes vs Randy Orton feels like it’s begging for a heel turn that never happens. We also talk pacing, celebrity involvement, and how a crowd’s reaction can elevate a match even when the build is shaky.

Then we climb into the top tier: why Gunther vs Seth Rollins delivers on in-ring quality even when you can see the late booking, why Rhea Ripley vs Jade sparks a real split in expectations, and how Oba Femi vs Brock Lesnar works by doing exactly what it needs to do and then landing an emotional post-match beat. We close it out with the ladder match as pure WrestleMania chaos and our unanimous number one, CM Punk vs Roman Reigns, for storytelling that keeps you guessing.

If you’ve got your own top 10, you’re invited to argue with us. Subscribe, share this with a wrestling friend, and leave a review with your match of the night and the one finish you’d change.

Send us Fan Mail

One decision can change an entire era, and wrestling has more butterfly effects than almost any other entertainment world. We sit down and rank our top 10 “what if” moments that could have rewritten WWE and WCW history, then argue which ones are truly industry-changing versus just career-changing. If you love wrestling history, alternate timelines, and honest barbershop-style debate, this one is built for you.

Send us Fan Mail

We kick off Respectful, Your Wrong by explaining why we built a ranking show and why wrestling is the first season. We trade our Attitude Era histories, argue what “Attitude Era” even means across WWF, WCW, and ECW, then put our names on a Top 10 that ends with a wild number one pick. 
• why in-person pods feel like real conversation 
• the ranking format and why debate is the point 
• why wrestling is the first season theme 
• WCW roots, family introductions, and first live events 
• defining the Attitude Era beyond just WWE 
• tape trading culture and discovering regional and Japanese wrestling 
• how we watch wrestling now through clips, PLEs, and dirt sheets 
• our personal Top 10 picks and the logic behind them 
• Chyna’s role in DX and why recognition matters 
• Kane’s debut and why presentation sticks 
• Mick Foley’s characters and why he elevates everyone 
• The Rock, Stone Cold, and Undertaker as era-defining forces 
• the Steve Blackman number one reveal and why vibes count 
• building a shared “collective” Top 10 and who gets cut 

4400 Shelbyville Road come there every Thursday. It’s actually 6 p.m. If you get there at 6 p.m., you can see the pre-show Overdrive that’s being taped for next week on YouTube. $10 general admission.