Return on Reputation by Justin Obey

March 12, 2026 Ep. 4 | Burned at Age 8, Told He’d Never Compete Again — Now a Top 1% IRONMAN Athlete | Shay Eskew | Return on Reputation

Join over 500 others and receive the Friday Briefing (free newsletter): https://get.obeycreative.com/newsletter

Download the Authority Media Engine Blueprint: https://get.obeycreative.com/authority-media-engine-blueprint

How do you pick yourself up when your life changes forever in just three minutes? And more importantly, how do you transform your scars—both physical and emotional—into the foundation of an unbreakable reputation that inspires thousands? This episode is a deep dive into the heart of true resilience and the "competitor" identity.

I’m Justin Obey, and on Return on Reputation, we talk to leaders who understand that character isn’t built when things are easy; it’s forged when you decide not to quit during your darkest hours.

My guest today is Shay Eskew. Shay’s story is, quite simply, a miracle of willpower. At eight years old, a horrific accident left him with burns over 65% of his body and a medical prognosis that said he’d never compete in sports again.

Today, Shay is not only a highly successful sales executive and author, but a world-ranked Ironman triathlete in the top 1%. He has turned what many would see as a tragedy into his greatest asset: a personal brand built on radical authenticity and a refusal to be a victim.

Shay breaks down why being "memorable" is far more powerful than being perfect, and how pain, when embraced with gratitude, becomes the fuel for a life without limits.

What we unpack in this conversation:

Competitor vs. Finisher: Why Shay refuses to just "get through" a task and how the mentality of going all-in separates exceptional leaders from the average.

The Vulnerability Advantage: How sharing your rawest failures—from grueling surgeries to forgetting your family’s passports—builds a level of trust with clients that traditional marketing can’t touch.

Choose Your Hard: The powerful philosophy of understanding that life will be difficult regardless, so you might as well choose the "hard" that leads to growth and discipline.

Reputation in the Boardroom: Shay’s secret to walking into a room and being the person everyone remembers, using his unique story to break through the noise and close multi-million dollar deals.

The Legacy of Grit: How to balance the ambition of an Ironman with being the father and husband your family deserves, ensuring that success at the top isn't a lonely finish line.

If you’re a founder going through a season of loss, or if you feel like your "scars" are holding you back, Shay is here to remind you that you are uniquely adapted to handle adversity.

Because at the end of the day, your reputation isn’t about what happened to you—it’s about who you chose to become because of it. Greatness isn't given; it’s earned in the fire.

About Shay Eskew:

Shay Eskew is a world-ranked Ironman triathlete, a highly successful sales executive, and a burn survivor who has turned unimaginable adversity into a blueprint for peak performance. After an accident at age eight left him with burns over 65% of his body and 40+ surgeries to follow, Shay defied medical odds to become a top 1% Ironman competitor and a sought-after motivational speaker.

With a career built on the mantra that "anything worth doing is worth overdoing," Shay has mastered the art of Authentic Resilience. He leverages his unique story to build deep trust in the boardroom, proving that vulnerability and grit are a leader's most valuable assets. He is the author of the bestseller What the Fire Ignited, where he teaches others how to stop being victims of their circumstances and start being competitors in their lives.

About Return on Reputation:

Return on Reputation is the show for founder-led brands that are done flying under the radar. Every episode, host Justin Obey, founder of Obey Creative, sits down with experts, founders, and dealmakers to unpack how personal brand, trust, and authority compound into real business leverage. We talk strategy over shortcuts, substance over viral moments, and real frameworks for turning your reputation into revenue.

Connect with Shay Eskew:

Website: https://www.shayeskew.com/

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/shayeskew/

Instagram: @mr_shay_sq

Connect with Justin Obey:

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/justinobey/

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@JustinObey

CHAPTERS:

01:15 Choose Your Hard

03:11 The Burn Accident