Emcee, Andie, David, Jan and Logan get genuinely creeped out at this scary and sad episode. They say a fond farewell to a beloved teacher and again marvel at David Boreanaz’s improved acting chops.

The We Hate Xander club is out in full force with this episode. Emcee, Andie, David, Jan and Logan take a good hard look at the consent issue of love spells, the confusion the most basic of Greco-Roman deities, how lovely Buffy’s raincoats is and Shooty Eye-Beam Magic.

The We Hate Xander club is out in full force with this episode. Emcee, Andie, David, Jan and Logan take a good hard look at the consent issue of love spells, the confusion the most basic of Greco-Roman deities, how lovely Buffy's raincoats is and Shooty Eye-Beam Magic.

David puts up with Emcee, Andie, Jan and Logan as they swoon over Oz. But as much as they love this for being one of his only spotlight episodes, they criticize the misogyny and blatant homophobia. Fun all around!

David puts up with Emcee, Andie, Jan and Logan as they swoon over Oz. But as much as they love this for being one of his only spotlight episodes, they criticize the misogyny and blatant homophobia. Fun all around!

Emcee, Andie, David, Jan and Logan talk about the elevated performance of David Boreanaz as Angelus, the sexual violence inherent to his character and whether or not tropes were subverted or re-enforced.

Emcee, Andie, David, Jan and Logan talk about the elevated performance of David Boreanaz as Angelus, the sexual violence inherent to his character and whether or not tropes were subverted or re-enforced.

Emcee, Andie, David, Jan and Logan talk about very special episodes, if Buffy is really ready and why people thought Spike and Drusilla were dead.

Emcee, Andie, David, Jan and Logan talk about very special episodes, if Buffy is really ready and why people thought Spike and Drusilla were dead.

Emcee, Andie, David, Jan and Logan force themselves to watch Bad Eggs. That was… An episode.