Rebuilding Self-Trust After Betrayal: Empowerment, Group Healing, and Learning to Trust Yourself Again
Host: MaryAnn Michaelis, LCSW, CSAT, CPTT
Guest: Jennifer Johnson, CMHC, CSAT, CPTT
Episode Summary
Rebuilding trust after sexual betrayal begins not with your partner—but with yourself.
In this deeply meaningful episode of Rise: Hope and Healing After Sexual Betrayal, host MaryAnn Michaelis, LCSW, CSAT, CPTT, sits down with her longtime mentor, colleague, and friend Jennifer Johnson, CMHC, CSAT, CPTT, for a powerful conversation on self-trust, group healing, and empowerment after betrayal trauma.
Jennifer—who has worked with betrayed partners for over 15 years—shares clinical wisdom, lived experience, and practical metaphors that have shaped an entire generation of betrayal trauma therapists, including MaryAnn herself. Together, they explore how betrayal erodes a person’s sense of reality, safety, and self-confidence—and how trust can be rebuilt through validation, embodiment, boundaries, and resourcing.
This episode is especially for listeners who feel confused, disconnected from their bodies, unsure of their reality, or afraid of their own reactions. Through stories, metaphors, and trauma-informed insight, MaryAnn and Jennifer offer a grounded path forward—one rooted in compassion, strength, and self-reliance.
Key Topics Discussed
Why sexual betrayal shatters self-trust and internal safety
The power of group work and the healing impact of “me too”
Why comparing betrayal stories minimizes pain—and why pain is pain
The “drowning in 5 feet vs. 20 feet of water” metaphor
How gaslighting and shame erode self-trust
Learning to trust your body after trauma responses and triggers
Why self-trust is independent of a partner’s recovery
The “Water Your Own Tree” analogy: differentiation and empowerment
Resourcing yourself for safety and stability
Trauma as powerlessness—and why action restores agency
The stages of healing: victim → survival → thriving
The “getting hit by a bus” metaphor for trauma, recovery, and relearning trust
Why healing does not mean abandoning the relationship
The role of therapy, groups, books, and community in rebuilding trust
Key Takeaways
Betrayal trauma disrupts your sense of reality—but you are not crazy
Self-trust is rebuilt through validation, embodiment, and action
Group healing reduces isolation and restores internal safety
You can strengthen yourself without moving away from your partner
Empowerment comes from recognizing your resources and choices
Healing is a process—and different stages require different care
Trusting yourself means learning what your body, emotions, and intuition need now
Metaphors & Frameworks Shared
Water Your Own Tree: Strengthening yourself without abandoning the relationship
Drowning Is Drowning: Pain does not need to be compared to be valid
Preparing resources for safety and self-reliance
Getting Hit by a Bus: Trauma recovery as stabilization, rehabilitation, and relearning trust
Victim → Survival → Thriving: Normal stages of betrayal trauma healing
Books Recommended in This Episode
Intimate Deception – Sheri Keffer, PhD
The Betrayal Bind – Michelle Mays, LPC
Ambushed by Betrayal Workbook
About the Guest
Jennifer Johnson, CMHC, CSAT and CPTT, is a Clinical Mental Health Counselor based in Farmington, Utah, specializing in betrayal trauma recovery for over 15 years. She is a mentor to clinicians, a trusted guide to betrayed partners, and a passionate advocate for trauma-informed, empowerment-based healing. Jennifer also brings lived experience as a betrayed partner, offering deep empathy and credibility to her work.
About the Host
MaryAnn Michaelis, LCSW, CSAT, CPTT is a Licensed Clinical Social Worker, Certified Sex Addiction Therapist, and Certified Partner Trauma Therapist. She is the founder of HART Recovery Institute (Healing Addiction, Relationships, Trauma) and the host of Rise: Hope and Healing After Sexual Betrayal. MaryAnn is also a recovering betrayed partner and a dedicated voice for compassionate, trauma-informed care.
Additional Support
If you are in the early days of betrayal or seeking structured guidance, explore:
Season 1 of Rise: Hope and Healing After Sexual Betrayal (Stabilization)
Therapist-led groups and the online course Rise: Hope and Healing After Betrayal
Resources available at humanintimacy.com
**You are not alone.
And learning to trust yourself again is possible.